I assumed nothing of the sort and anyway it was not my conjecture, it was yours.
No, it was your conjecture, but no matter.
In which case any efforts would be worthless. They can't effect the greater good.
Bingo! But they can affect the good, which would be to help the man.
And as you have stated the bystanders can't affect the greater good at all then they can't affect the greater good by helping him. So why do anything? As you have said, God already did it.
I said that God did the greater good by proving the opportunity to help him. By helping him, the bystanders can do good.
But as you say it might not be. If we don't know what the greater good is then we have no basis for taking action at all. It works both ways.
Again, incorrect. God ensures that the good performed by humans is always for the greater good.
But of course in this case the doctor is aware of the situation, ready and able to take action but uncontactable
Then you should comfort the patient and assume the doctor knows what he's doing. But you already knew that. You do whatever is best for the patient.
So if you are aware of a competent ethical person who is aware of the situation and you are not qualified since you do not know the full story then you should do nothing. Which is of course what I have been saying all along.
I never disagreed. I said that you are ethically responsible for helping the person when it will do good.
I agree. So if the doctor's name is Yahweh and is the most competent ethical person possible then the situation would be no different.
If Yahweh is a person, yes. If Yahweh is God, then you must assume responsibility for helping him if you can because it's not God's responsibility to do so. God already did his responsibility, which was for the greater good, possibly by allowing you the opportunity to do yours, and possibly by allowing you to accept the consequences of your inaction if you choose not to help him.
You mean if I recognize a greater good I should just pretend it is not there?
You can't recognize the greater good. It's impossible.
And yet you agree, because you say that we are unable to affect the greater good or the greater evil - just what I said, our actions have no real moral consequences.
Huh? Where do you get this from? Good/evil
do have moral consequences! God ensures that the good done by humans IS for the greater good.
So if no evil has occurred, then you can simply do nothing and you will not have done any evil.
Again incorrect. The natural disaster is not evil (indeed, there is no such thing as "greater evil" since everything God does is for the greater good), but your helping or not helping is a separate event entirely. If a greater good has occurred by creating the disaster, you can still do
more good by helping, or do evil by doing nothing.
If it was not evil that the man is suffering, why would it then be good if his suffering was alleviated?
Because the man's suffering (if caused by God) is for the greater good. If caused by a person, it may not be for the greater good (and might in fact cause an incredible amount of harm since a person cannot determine what is for the greater good). It is for the good for a person to alleviate the suffering of another person.
Which is exactly what I said. If you can't affect the greater good and you can't affect the greater evil then your actions have no real moral consequences.
Still incorrect, no matter how many times you state it.
So why is the reverse not true? If it was for the greater good that the person survives God would make sure that the man survived even if you did not help. So you should just do nothing.
Because it is for the greater good for you to have the opportunity to help him. And it is for the greater good for there to be consequences for not helping him. But it is not for the good for you to not help him.
But there is somebody more qualified there to help him - God.
Again, God isn't responsible for helping him -- you are. God is doing the greater good by not helping him, therefore he can't be doing the greater good by helping him. You can do good by helping him though. You're not responsible for the greater good, only the good.
I can't pretend to be unaware of God any more than I can pretend to be unaware of the doctor. So if God is more qualified to help then doing nothing is good. You do not know that helping him will increase the good in the world since you can't predict the consequences of any action.
God cannot help in this case because the greater good is better served by him not helping. The greater good is served by allowing you to accept the consequences of your actions or lack thereof. Yes you do know that helping your fellow person is for the good, and yes you do know the consequences of your actions.
This is really not that difficult of a concept. Imagine that the good in the world increases by 100 points for God providing you the opportunity to do good and another 100 points for God allowing you to accept the consequences of the choice. If God makes a dude get hit by a bus in front of you -- 100 points for the world. Now you can help him (10 points) or not help him (-10 points). Whatever your choice is, if God doesn't intervene and help the dude, it's a bonus 100 points for the world for allowing your action to have consequences. God knows that pushing the dude in front of the bus will have no other affect on the net good in the world. What actions on God's part increases the net good in the world the most? What action on your part increases the net good in the world the most?
Now, imagine that you decide to play God, so you push someone in front of a bus in front of a third person. But alas, even though the third person saves him, he still ends up in the hospital, and you didn't realize that the person you pushed in front of the bus would have increased the good in the world by 1000 points that day if you hadn't sent him to the hospital. Furthermore, as you're placed into an overcrowded prison, another minor offender is released to make room for you, and ends up committing a murder of opportunity as he leaves the prison, reducing the good in the world by an additional 2000 points. The person murdered would have increased good in the world by 1,000,000 points during the rest of their life. You get the idea. This is why you cannot play God, because you cannot understand what is for the greater good and what isn't.
-Bri