There is No God (And You Know It)

Argument from ignorance.

From Wikipedia:

The argument from ignorance, also known as argumentum ad ignorantiam or argument by lack of imagination, is the assertion that if something is currently inexplicable to some people, then it did not (or could not) happen, or that if evidence of something has not been scientifically proven to their satisfaction, then it cannot exist. "Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence" is an adage used to explain that one's own "ignorance" (or, one's "absence of evidence") does not disprove anything (or, "is not absence of evidence"). In other words, mere personal belief, poor logic, or closed-mindedness masquerading as certainty is not logical.

To say that God might serve the purpose of creating life is not an argument from ignorance. I never said that this was God's purpose, only that it might be God's purpose. This was in direct response to Belz's request that I speculate on what God's purpose might be. I wasn't using the fact that we have yet to create life to support my speculation, I was simply stating that as a fact, in response to Belz's claim that our current understanding of how life is created somehow precludes the possibility of God creating life.

Yet it remains a claim set forth by yourself. Which places the burden of proof squarely on your shoulders.
Just claiming a possibility is tantamount to just shrugging your shoulders and going ‘I don’t know.’

EXACTLY. I don't know. I made no other claim than that. If you wish to claim that it is impossible for God to exist, or even that God doesn't exist, you will have to provide evidence.

No it wouldn’t be on Belz. Since you can’t disprove a general negative, only specifics it is up to the ones proclaiming the existence of a soul to define it. (Actually it’s up to them to provide evidence for it’s existence as well.)

Correct, it is up to the ones proclaiming the existence of a soul to define it. But nobody is making such a proclamation. Belz was making the opposite claim (that no souls exist) and therefore the burden of proof is on him.

-Bri
 
This doesn't demonstrate free will or not - it says nothing about why they made the choice to intervene at all. In this situation, they probably had 'a very strong feeling' that this vision was true. This feeling compelled them, as well as their apparently moral nature, their stubbornness, etc. These factors all came into play - unless you are claiming these factors did not exist at all.

In other words, not enough info provided to judge whether or not this was an act of 'free will'.

Zaay - free will doesn't require an analysis of motivation. Motivation may define what range of choices we make; however, the ability to make choices defines the existence of free will. A range of choices are available and they can potentially choose any of them

Your argument is tantamount to saying that someone will make a choice based on their beliefs, views, morality, ethics, personality, etc... to which I say "Sure. Their decision will be influenced by those factors. That does NOT predetermine their choice; it simply increases the likelyhood that they'll make a decision in line with their beliefs."

Your argument is tantamount to saying that since someone can be influenced, free will is an illusion. That's not an argument against free will, it's an argument against objective decision making.

You failed to demonstrate whether they were compelled to make these decisions or not.

Did they choose this? Or has their life's experience taught them that such 'visions' are merely dreams? Are they hard-core skeptics, prone to dismissing the unusual and bizarre as merely intense dreaming? You don't discuss the underlying factors between these two scenarios, so you don't truly discuss 'free will' here at all.

The underlying factors, as I have said, aren't germane to a contextual discussion of free will. The motivation behind the decision-making is irrelevant; what is relevant is the fact that they could have made other choices - it was not impossible for them to do so. By definition, they must make some choice - even if they make nodecision, that's still a choice.

The problem is, jmercer, that you're approaching this from the point of view that all decisions are made in a vacuum, or at best, that 'all else being the same' that these are the choices offered. Yet you've neither stated this as a premise, nor implied it in the scenarios. These are incomplete examples at best. They don't prove nor disprove free will.

Actually, I've simply not defined the circumstances beyond the bare necessity of demonstrating that other choices are possible, and by the same individual, in fact. And they are possible, and they can be made by the same individual involved. Granted, the choices made will be influenced by that person's emotions, experiences, information made available to them, etc.

The reason that the sociopath example is different is because they are victims of their own compulsory behavior, so they really don't have a choice. So-called "normal" people have a range of behaviors to choose from; they are not compelled to react in a specific manner.
 
Your argument is tantamount to saying that someone will make a choice based on their beliefs, views, morality, ethics, personality, etc... to which I say "Sure. Their decision will be influenced by those factors. That does NOT predetermine their choice; it simply increases the likelyhood that they'll make a decision in line with their beliefs."

Your argument is tantamount to saying that since someone can be influenced, free will is an illusion. That's not an argument against free will, it's an argument against objective decision making.

This is what I was trying to explain to Zaay in an earlier post when he was trying to distinguish between "absolute" and "practical" free will, but you did a better job of it. The central issue is the difference between the word "influence" and the word "cause." Nearly all decisions have external influences, but if free will is true, then there is an internal cause. An internal cause is a cause that is not itself entirely caused by external causes, at least part of which originates internally. If there is no free will, then all decisions are ultimately caused by external causes.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Occam's Razor states that when two theories are equal we should choose the simpler. In practice, Occam's Razor is often wrong (the more complex theory is often the correct one). In this case, the two theories are not equal anyway.

Indeed they're not. One is supported by evidence.

Oh yes, you did later comment on that one, but it was not in response to this discussion (it was in response to a discussion specifically about the classic deist God). Even if we take your premise to be true that no souls means no judgement, you cannot prove that there are no souls. Unless you can provide evidence that we have no souls you are not any closer to disproving that God's purpose is to judge us.

Somehow, I don't think the burden of THAT proof is on my shoulders.

There are four possibilities: a universe in which there is no God but there is free will, a universe in which there is a God and there is free will, a universe in which there is no God and no free will, and a universe in which there is a God but no free will. You claim that these might actually all be the same, or at least we don't know what the differences would be. If I agree that this is true, then any of the four possibilities could be true, there is no way for us to know which is true, and you have successfully proven my point that it is possible that God's purpose is to provide free will.

Nice try. The point is that, a priori, there is no way to know what the differences may be. However, evidence tips our "belief" onr way or the other. Without evidence, the other possibilities are discarded.

Three answers. First, a God that isn't required might be useless, but that doesn't mean that he doesn't exist.

No, but it's an important step.

Second, you are incorrect if you believe that we have a good understanding of how life forms and how it is different from non-life.

Please provide specific examples.

Third, and more importantly, God's purpose might have been to create the first humans, and might still be to create life (until we humans learn how to do it). God would perhaps become useless if and when we actually do create life, but you cannot prove that we ever will. Even if he becomes useless in the future, he isn't useless now.

Assume that he is. Then what ?

Actually, you should elaborate on what we DO know about them. We actually know surprisingly little about the causes of these kinds of phenomena. If we knew all the factors that create them, we would be able to predict them with certainty.

Really ? I'm pretty sure you can know all the factors that come into play during a lottery pick, but could you predict it if you didn't know the value of each variable ?

You might say that earthquakes are caused by the plates of the earth causing friction against one another, but we don't know what causes the plates to move as they do when they do.

Magma movement, I believe.

To your next question: heat.

Do you want me to explain where the heat comes from ?

I don't agree with your definition of "reasonable doubt" in this case. You haven't provided a shred of evidence that God doesn't exist, much less that it is impossible for God to exist.

Which brings about an interesting question: what would you ACCEPT as evidence ?

Actually, the God that you are least likely to be able to disprove is the one who is beyond logic. You simply cannot touch that definition of God at all since all arguments you can make are limited by logic. The best you can hope for is to try to disprove the notions of God that are limited by logic, but you have yet to do that either.

How could something do the illogical ?
 
This is what I was trying to explain to Zaay in an earlier post when he was trying to distinguish between "absolute" and "practical" free will, but you did a better job of it. The central issue is the difference between the word "influence" and the word "cause." Nearly all decisions have external influences, but if free will is true, then there is an internal cause. An internal cause is a cause that is not itself entirely caused by external causes, at least part of which originates internally. If there is no free will, then all decisions are ultimately caused by external causes.

-Bri

And by proposing an 'internal cause', you are in effect highlighting a 'ghost in the machine'.

jmercer:

free will doesn't require an analysis of motivation. Motivation may define what range of choices we make; however, the ability to make choices defines the existence of free will. A range of choices are available and they can potentially choose any of them

I disagree entirely. The ability to make choices only defines practical free will; the motivations behind choices is what helps determine if absolute free will exists. A range of choices are available, and you say they could potentially choose any of them - but that's not really true either, is it? No person can choose other than that which they have chosen, ultimately, no matter how much they think they could have gone back and made different changes.

That is an assertion, true; but I think it's a reasonable one. We make the choices we do because of factors both conscious and subconscious; and I don't see how we could make a decision any other way at all. It's like digging a trench and claiming that water has some decision over which course it will run; it doesn't, really. Or by digging a trench with three apparently equal branches - is the water deciding which way to run, or are there factors at work forcing the water's choice?

The only way I could see 'free will' being verified is IFF you could establish an experiment with numerous absolutely identical choices being offered to a number of absolutely identical people, studied the brain activity during the choice, and determined, truly, that no conscious or subconscious decision-making process occurs. However, the parameters of such an experiment are so tight as to be impossible, IMHO.

If, on the other hand, 'motivations' have nothing to do with the issue of 'free will', then free will means something absolutely different from what I've always been led to believe it means, and exists even in a purely deterministic, automated universe.
 
Without middle knowledge, God could not be said to be omniscient. "To know all that it is possible to know" is not omniscience; "to know everything" is.
Philosophers disagree on what is intrinsically capable of being known, but I never read one who asserted that omniscience meant knowing more than it is possible to know. If you really insist on formulating the definition as "to know everything", I am compelled to point out that "the truth of propositions without truth-value" is, in that sense, not really a thing. It is nothing.

As for using depleted definitions of omni____, such a depleted definition further requires a supreme being to be subordinate to or bound by one of its creations.
I do not consider the definition I've employed to be "depleted"; nothing is depleted by the exclusion or removal of that which has no substance.

Imagine a being one of whose innate qualities is being a perfect bowler. Let us further imagine that we observe this being, whom we will nickname the Omnibowler, bowl one game (assume the standard definition of bowling a game). What do you suppose is the Omnibowler's score? I hope you answered the same as I: 300. Although 300 is a lower number than 400 or 500, it can't, after all, fairly be characterized as a "depleted" bowling score. It hardly detracts from the Omnibowler's bowling perfection that he scores 300 rather than some higher number. On the contrary, the fact that he always bowls 300 is precisely what establishes the Omnibowler's perfection as a bowler, because 300 is the highest bowling score it is possible to get.

If the perfect bowler always scores the maximum possible number of points, why are you so reluctant to accept the notion that the perfect knower always possesses the maximum possible amount of knowledge?
 
Indeed they're not. One is supported by evidence.

Both are supported by evidence, even if one is supported by more evidence than the other. Even if a scientific theory completely explains the origins of the universe (which is debatable), it is still theory (one of many possible explanations). Likewise, the God-theory of the origins of the universe is a possible explanation and possibly not incompatible with current scientific theory, I might add.

Somehow, I don't think the burden of THAT proof is on my shoulders.

Of course it is. If you want to use a lack of souls as a basis to prove that God cannot judge us after we die, then you must first prove the lack of souls.

Nice try. The point is that, a priori, there is no way to know what the differences may be. However, evidence tips our "belief" onr way or the other. Without evidence, the other possibilities are discarded.

No evidence presented thus far proves that it is IMPOSSIBLE for God's purpose to be to create free will. One way to prove this would be to disprove free will beyond any doubt. Even if the evidence is against free will (which it is) you haven't proven that it's IMPOSSIBLE for God's purpose to create free will, because it is still POSSIBLE that free will exists. In order to prove an impossibility, you have to disprove the possibility beyond any doubt, which is an extremely high burden of proof.

No, but it's an important step.

If you say so. It's an important step if you want to prove that God is useless, but it doesn't advance your argument that God is nonexistant.

Please provide specific examples.

Examples of how we don't fully understand something? Why don't you explain how life forms, and then list the differences between life and non-life? Then show how it would be impossible for God to be involved in the process.

At any rate, it's irrelevent to your argument, as I pointed out.

Assume that he is. Then what ?

Assume that he is what?

Really ? I'm pretty sure you can know all the factors that come into play during a lottery pick, but could you predict it if you didn't know the value of each variable ?

OK, let's suppose for a moment that we know every variable that goes into making an earthquake or tornado (we don't, but let's suppose that we do). We certainly don't know the value of those variables, so why couldn't God be responsible for setting the values?

Even if I knew all of the factors that came into play during a lottery pick, I cannot prove that God had no hand in any of them!

Magma movement, I believe.

OK, so prove that God doesn't cause the magma to move in order to create earthquakes.

To your next question: heat.

Do you want me to explain where the heat comes from ?

Yup! Prove that it isn't caused by God. If you're going to say that the heat is caused by the sun, prove that God didn't cause the sun to produce heat at the proper place and time to cause the tornado.

Which brings about an interesting question: what would you ACCEPT as evidence ?

Any evidence at all that God cannot possibly have any of the functions that I suggested would be a start. If you're claiming that they are all possible (even if they are not probable), then you have conceded my argument, which is that they are possible.

How could something do the illogical ?

Something that created logic and is beyond logic could do the illogical. It might be the case that other universes utilize a different logic than ours, and to us, those universes would seem illogical. If God created logic, he can define any system of logic as he sees fit, and could make any illogical situation you can pose logical (such as the "square circle" thing).

-Bri
 
Philosophers disagree on what is intrinsically capable of being known, but I never read one who asserted that omniscience meant knowing more than it is possible to know. If you really insist on formulating the definition as "to know everything", I am compelled to point out that "the truth of propositions without truth-value" is, in that sense, not really a thing. It is nothing.


I do not consider the definition I've employed to be "depleted"; nothing is depleted by the exclusion or removal of that which has no substance.

Imagine a being one of whose innate qualities is being a perfect bowler. Let us further imagine that we observe this being, whom we will nickname the Omnibowler, bowl one game (assume the standard definition of bowling a game). What do you suppose is the Omnibowler's score? I hope you answered the same as I: 300. Although 300 is a lower number than 400 or 500, it can't, after all, fairly be characterized as a "depleted" bowling score. It hardly detracts from the Omnibowler's bowling perfection that he scores 300 rather than some higher number. On the contrary, the fact that he always bowls 300 is precisely what establishes the Omnibowler's perfection as a bowler, because 300 is the highest bowling score it is possible to get.

If the perfect bowler always scores the maximum possible number of points, why are you so reluctant to accept the notion that the perfect knower always possesses the maximum possible amount of knowledge?

If I roll a ball downhill, and place a rock in its path, I know what will happen (assuming I know enough physics to account for what will happen). I also know what will happen if I remove the rock, whether or not I do so. If God fails to know what any human being will do in any given circumstance, then God is not omniscient. It's not a matter of there being a limited 'maximum amount of knowledge', because we are accusing this 'God' of not possessing such knowledge at all.

Let me put it this way: if God is omniscient, then this also means God knows the future - yes or no? If yes, then God can instantly know what each and every human being does under each and every future circumstance instantly - and being omnipotent, could change any circumstance in which man fails to make a desirable choice, and instead forces him to make a new choice - the outcome of which God knows instantly. In short, unlike man, who is limited in time and resources, God could test every possible hypothesis INSTANTLY - and therefore would know beyond a shadow of doubt which choice every being would make, no matter what the condition was. Hence, 'maximum knowledge' takes this into account - God knows not only the maximum knowledge for this created universe, but for all possible created universes simultaneously. Otherwise - God is not Omniscient.

The 'omnibowler' was a pretty poor scenario. Much better to compare it to a game of 'Scrabble' with an infinite tile set and infinite space on the board. What is the 'perfect score' then? Only the omniscient one would know for sure.

In simplest possible terms: if free will exists, God cannot know what a free agent will choose in any situation, because that choice can be freely changed at the will of the agent, without regard to the situation, environmental influences, etc. God can, at best, only make an educated guess. Further, this means God is only omniscient up to the point, in time, where a free agent makes a free decision; all points in time beyond it would necessarily be obscured to this God. However, if God knows what every agent will do in any given circumstance, being that agent's creator, free will cannot exist.

Still unconvinced, CEO - now more so than ever.

ZD
 
And by proposing an 'internal cause', you are in effect highlighting a 'ghost in the machine'.

Yes, correct. Which might possibly be the case whether or not God exists. God might allow such a ghost in the machine, or it may be something completely natural that we simply don't understand yet (although I would guess that someone would term it "God" if it were proven to exist). Then again, it might not exist at all, and we might not have free will.

-Bri
 
Yes, correct. Which might possibly be the case whether or not God exists. God might allow such a ghost in the machine, or it may be something completely natural that we simply don't understand yet (although I would guess that someone would term it "God" if it were proven to exist). Then again, it might not exist at all, and we might not have free will.

-Bri

Therefore, 'free will' can only exist under idealism or dualism, because if this 'ghost' is a natural cause that we don't understand yet, then it becomes part of the mechanistic process once we do understand it - and 'free will' vanishes.

Nevertheless - it causes human decision to become unpredictable and, therefore, causes any such deity to lose omniscience as a result.
 
I disagree entirely. The ability to make choices only defines practical free will; the motivations behind choices is what helps determine if absolute free will exists. A range of choices are available, and you say they could potentially choose any of them - but that's not really true either, is it? No person can choose other than that which they have chosen, ultimately, no matter how much they think they could have gone back and made different changes.

That is an assertion, true; but I think it's a reasonable one. We make the choices we do because of factors both conscious and subconscious; and I don't see how we could make a decision any other way at all. It's like digging a trench and claiming that water has some decision over which course it will run; it doesn't, really. Or by digging a trench with three apparently equal branches - is the water deciding which way to run, or are there factors at work forcing the water's choice?

Zaay - I know we respect each other, so I don't have the slightest problem with you disagreeing with my views at all. (Even though I'm right! ;))

Your above assertion is a bit confusing. First you speak of making choices in the future tense, then you speak of choices made being unchangeable even if the person could go back (in time, I assume.) No one can change a choice they've made; they can only make another one.

Your viewpoint means that everyone who ever existed had no choice in any decision they made, and that everything that ever happened - and will happen - is predestined by our programming. The concept of responsiblity for one's actions (or inactions) becomes meaningless - up to and including murder, rape, robbery, child molestation, producing child pornography and so forth... because the people involved don't really have a choice in their behavior. The same is true at the opposite end of the spectrum, of course - people who exemplify the best that humanity has to offer shouldn't be honored for their actions, because they also had no choice.

We will, I guess, continue to disagree on this if for no other reason than I will not excuse humanity from responsiblity for it's own actions. :)

The only way I could see 'free will' being verified is IFF you could establish an experiment with numerous absolutely identical choices being offered to a number of absolutely identical people, studied the brain activity during the choice, and determined, truly, that no conscious or subconscious decision-making process occurs. However, the parameters of such an experiment are so tight as to be impossible, IMHO.

If, on the other hand, 'motivations' have nothing to do with the issue of 'free will', then free will means something absolutely different from what I've always been led to believe it means, and exists even in a purely deterministic, automated universe.

Zaay - I'm not saying that motivation has nothing to do with free will; I'm saying that the existence of free will is independent of motivation. Moreover, I will state that while it's impossible to group a series of identical people as you've described, you can take the same person and apply the same choice options to them during different time periods in their life, and some of them will make different choices.

Case in point; if my current circumstances were identical to when I was 18 and I were presented with the same set of options, I would never marry my ex-wife again.
 
Zaay - I know we respect each other, so I don't have the slightest problem with you disagreeing with my views at all. (Even though I'm right! ;))

Your above assertion is a bit confusing. First you speak of making choices in the future tense, then you speak of choices made being unchangeable even if the person could go back (in time, I assume.) No one can change a choice they've made; they can only make another one.

Your viewpoint means that everyone who ever existed had no choice in any decision they made, and that everything that ever happened - and will happen - is predestined by our programming. The concept of responsiblity for one's actions (or inactions) becomes meaningless - up to and including murder, rape, robbery, child molestation, producing child pornography and so forth... because the people involved don't really have a choice in their behavior. The same is true at the opposite end of the spectrum, of course - people who exemplify the best that humanity has to offer shouldn't be honored for their actions, because they also had no choice.

We will, I guess, continue to disagree on this if for no other reason than I will not excuse humanity from responsiblity for it's own actions. :)

And this is precisely why practical free will is still important, whereas absolute free will does not exist. Further, though I do think people are not 'absolutely' responsible for either their crimes or their honors, I think that the practical notion of crime or honor is vital as another contribuiting environmental factor in the decision-making process. By publicly rewarding those who make a positive contribution and publicly punishing those who make negative contributions, we increase or decrease the potentials of certain behaviors for future generations. Surely you're not going to tell me that you've never been in a situation where the only thing preventing you from taking a certain action was concern about the consequences of that action?

Zaay - I'm not saying that motivation has nothing to do with free will; I'm saying that the existence of free will is independent of motivation. Moreover, I will state that while it's impossible to group a series of identical people as you've described, you can take the same person and apply the same choice options to them during different time periods in their life, and some of them will make different choices.

Which means that the exact decision environment is different, isn't it? That's like saying you can take the exact same ball and drop it at the exact same rock on another part of the hill, and it might roll a different direction. Still constrained, my friend.

Case in point; if my current circumstances were identical to when I was 18 and I were presented with the same set of options, I would never marry my ex-wife again.

That is because of the experience of having married her in the first place, existing to alter your decision-making processes - i.e. you got some stinking sense in ya, now. :D

I think what you are battling for, above, is what I call 'practical' free will - which, yes, is an illusion, in the absolute sense; but which is sufficient to allow us just cause for punishment and reward, gratification, selfless acts, etc. In the end, however, it's going to be very important to recognise practical free will as an illusion, for the simple fact that, I believe, the time will come when we will be able to artificially constrain any decision we desire, as a society, without affecting 'practical free will'. We already do, to some extent, but I think the idea of independence is so absolutely ingrained in some people, that they must rail against the idea that their decisions are not purely their own.
 
P.S.: I do respect the point of view you are taking, jmercer. However, I don't think we're talking about the same thing at all.
 
Nice conversation all!

But, alas, I have to chime in on this free will question.

Question for all: Does God have free will?

If God has free will and knowledge of the future, than (s)he knows what (s)he is going to do. If this is the case, God would never make a mistake because (s)he can know what consequences will occur for his/her actions. That includes knowing that Adam and Eve would falter, Jesus would be crucified, when the world will end, etc.. If God knows what future events are, then (s)he has no free will because (s)he has a template to follow.
 
The best evidence of free will is that most of us "feel" that we have it and act as though we have it. We get angry at people for harming us (even though if they didn't have free will they would have had no choice but to harm us). Our judicial system also assumes that we have free will. Of course, this isn't proof that we have free will, and there is little scientific evidence in support of free will. That doesn't mean we don't have it though.

No offense, but that's ridiculous. We have free will because we "feel" it ? You call that evidence ? I call that a subjective assumption. That's no evidence at all. Your example about getting angry is ludicrous. They might not have any choice but to harm us, but you don't have a choice about getting angry, either. Your anger isn't caused by their choice, per se, but by the effect of their action.
 
Both are supported by evidence, even if one is supported by more evidence than the other. Even if a scientific theory completely explains the origins of the universe (which is debatable), it is still theory (one of many possible explanations). Likewise, the God-theory of the origins of the universe is a possible explanation and possibly not incompatible with current scientific theory, I might add.

Name ONE piece of evidence that supports the God-theory.

Of course it is. If you want to use a lack of souls as a basis to prove that God cannot judge us after we die, then you must first prove the lack of souls.

Oh, no. Your example of a function for God, in this case, is entirely dependent upon another theory that is completely unsupported by evidence. I don't have to lift a finger, here.

Even if the evidence is against free will (which it is) you haven't proven that it's IMPOSSIBLE for God's purpose to create free will, because it is still POSSIBLE that free will exists. In order to prove an impossibility, you have to disprove the possibility beyond any doubt, which is an extremely high burden of proof.

You see ? You've moved again beyond reasonable doubt to beyond any doubt. I'm certainly not going to entertain you if you keep moving from one side of the fence to the other. We are talking about reasonable doubt, here, and you're constantly placing unreasonable doubt upon everything I say.

If you say so. It's an important step if you want to prove that God is useless, but it doesn't advance your argument that God is nonexistant.

If God is useless, it would be a good starting point to argue that he doesn't exist.

Examples of how we don't fully understand something? Why don't you explain how life forms, and then list the differences between life and non-life? Then show how it would be impossible for God to be involved in the process.

Dodge noted, as some would say.

We understand the formation of life sufficiently as to NOT attribute it to the action of an extra-cosmic God (directly, anyway.)

Assume that he is what?

Assume that God IS useless. Then what ?

OK, let's suppose for a moment that we know every variable that goes into making an earthquake or tornado (we don't, but let's suppose that we do). We certainly don't know the value of those variables, so why couldn't God be responsible for setting the values?

See ? Unreasonable doubt mode.

Yup! Prove that it isn't caused by God. If you're going to say that the heat is caused by the sun, prove that God didn't cause the sun to produce heat at the proper place and time to cause the tornado.

Let's skip forward in this line of argument to my final claim and your final question, namely:

- We have a very good idea of how the universe was formed in the first place.

And:

- Prove that God didn't cause the universe.

To which I answer that God isn't necessary to the creation of the universe, and therefore pretty much useless. We're right back where we started: if God IS useless, then what ?

Any evidence at all that God cannot possibly have any of the functions that I suggested would be a start.

Second dodge noted. This time, however, I won't let you slip away so easily:

Name at least one piece of evidence that would confirm that God cannot have one of those functions.

Something that created logic and is beyond logic could do the illogical. It might be the case that other universes utilize a different logic than ours, and to us, those universes would seem illogical. If God created logic, he can define any system of logic as he sees fit, and could make any illogical situation you can pose logical (such as the "square circle" thing).

That doesn't make any sense. Please explain how something could be "beyond" logic.
 
If God has free will and knowledge of the future, than (s)he knows what (s)he is going to do. If this is the case, God would never make a mistake because (s)he can know what consequences will occur for his/her actions. That includes knowing that Adam and Eve would falter, Jesus would be crucified, when the world will end, etc.. If God knows what future events are, then (s)he has no free will because (s)he has a template to follow.

You forgot the "/It" possibility !
 
P.S.: I do respect the point of view you are taking, jmercer. However, I don't think we're talking about the same thing at all.

Well - you've given me something to ponder with the concept of practical free will vs. absolute free will, so you may be right about us not talking about the same thing. There's something appealing about the idea of duality in free will the way you describe it; I find it logical and esthetically pleasing. I'm not sure it's true, but heck, it's worth a good look. :)

One possible caveat that I'll be considering, though, is the thought that "A difference that makes no difference is no difference", if you catch my meaning. :)
 
Nice conversation all!

But, alas, I have to chime in on this free will question.

Question for all: Does God have free will?

If God has free will and knowledge of the future, than (s)he knows what (s)he is going to do. If this is the case, God would never make a mistake because (s)he can know what consequences will occur for his/her actions. That includes knowing that Adam and Eve would falter, Jesus would be crucified, when the world will end, etc.. If God knows what future events are, then (s)he has no free will because (s)he has a template to follow.

FWIW - here's one (totally speculative) explanation:

1) God abhors paradoxes. In fact, God created the universe in such a way that paradoxes are impossible. Therefore, God will not act in such a way that a paradox will be created, because that would violate His own "law".

2) God has a goal.

3) God has free will and full knowledge of how each action He takes will affect reaching His goal.

4) Since God desires to reach the goal, He won't take any action that will prevent that even though he is capable of taking that action.

5) Some actions will not prevent God from reaching the goal; it may make it more difficult, or may make the process longer. Where God can act without concern over failing to reach His goal, God is free to do so. (Unless such action would result in a paradox, as stated in item 1)

I'm not saying any of this is true; I'm simply pointing out that there could be possible logical constraints, even on a God. An omnipotent God wouldn't necessarily be free to exercise His/Her power without consequences... unless S/He was willing to create a paradox. As long as S/He is willing to accept those consequences (or a paradox), well and good; otherwise, S/He won't act in a way contrary to His/Her own plan.
 
That, of course, jmercer, is one of the valid explanations available.

It could also be that God, having created this universe, simply no longer exists - that God died in the birth of the Universe. Since we're discussing a God who also creates time, logic, etc. we're talking about a God who sacrifices itself, utterly, to initialize a Universe in which Man has some mystical free will - sparks of the Divine, perhaps - but where omniscience and omnipotency are no longer an issue.

Of course, such a theology, again, reduces any need for morality or order from a deific imperative to a social one... but it's still something to ponder, as well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom