Argument from ignorance.
From Wikipedia:
The argument from ignorance, also known as argumentum ad ignorantiam or argument by lack of imagination, is the assertion that if something is currently inexplicable to some people, then it did not (or could not) happen, or that if evidence of something has not been scientifically proven to their satisfaction, then it cannot exist. "Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence" is an adage used to explain that one's own "ignorance" (or, one's "absence of evidence") does not disprove anything (or, "is not absence of evidence"). In other words, mere personal belief, poor logic, or closed-mindedness masquerading as certainty is not logical.
To say that God might serve the purpose of creating life is not an argument from ignorance. I never said that this was God's purpose, only that it might be God's purpose. This was in direct response to Belz's request that I speculate on what God's purpose might be. I wasn't using the fact that we have yet to create life to support my speculation, I was simply stating that as a fact, in response to Belz's claim that our current understanding of how life is created somehow precludes the possibility of God creating life.
Yet it remains a claim set forth by yourself. Which places the burden of proof squarely on your shoulders.
Just claiming a possibility is tantamount to just shrugging your shoulders and going ‘I don’t know.’
EXACTLY. I don't know. I made no other claim than that. If you wish to claim that it is impossible for God to exist, or even that God doesn't exist, you will have to provide evidence.
No it wouldn’t be on Belz. Since you can’t disprove a general negative, only specifics it is up to the ones proclaiming the existence of a soul to define it. (Actually it’s up to them to provide evidence for it’s existence as well.)
Correct, it is up to the ones proclaiming the existence of a soul to define it. But nobody is making such a proclamation. Belz was making the opposite claim (that no souls exist) and therefore the burden of proof is on him.
-Bri