Are we speaking at cross-purposes here? My hypothetical did not suggest that middle knowledge allows God to force a choice without affecting free will. In fact, the reason I excluded middle knowledge from the hypothetical is because I suspect that if it could exist, it might very well be incompatible with free will (although I am not certain). To that extent, at least for the purposes of the argument as it currently stands, we are basically in agreement. So why do you keep bringing up the hypothetical existence of middle knowledge, when I am clearly trying to explore the hypothetical consequences for free will of the non-existence of middle knowledge?
Without middle knowledge, God could not be said to be omniscient. "To know all that it is possible to know" is not omniscience; "to know everything" is.
Look at it this way:
Interviewer: "So, God, let's talk about free will, for a moment."
GOD: "Sure, Johnny."
Interviewer: "It's awful nice that you've given us the ability to make our own choices."
GOD: "Well, Johnny, I'm a nice Deity; go fig."
Interviewer: "Say, what will Ed over there answer his girlfriend about getting married tonight?"
--scenario 1--
GOD: "Ed has free will - I cannot possibly know what Ed will decide."
Interviewer: "But aren't you omniscient?"
GOD: "I can only know what it is possible to know. Since Ed is a free agent, I cannot know what choices he will make in every scenario."
Interviewer: "But don't you know the future, too? Didn't you create time itself?"
GOD: "I'm sorry, Johnny, could you rephrase the question?"
Interviewer: "God, your followers believe that you created time and space itself. If you don't know what Ed over there is going to say tonight, that means you don't have intimate knowledge of future events?"
GOD: "Yes, Johnny, that's right..."
--conclusion--
God is either non-omniscient, or is not the creator of time itself and, therefore, non-omnipotent.
--scenario 2--
GOD: "Ed's going to agree to marry her tonight."
Interviewer: "Oh, that's great! Because her family was really getting antsy on the subject... Old Italian 'Family', if you know what I mean..."
GOD: "Of course I know what you mean."
Interviewer: "Really? Say, tell us what would happen if Ed refused the marriage proposal?"
GOD: "Don't be ridiculous - Ed is going to marry that girl."
Interviewer: "But he COULD choose not to... right?"
GOD: "He could, but he won't. There is no reason to consider any alternatives."
Interviewer: "Wait a minute... he could but he won't? Um... am I missing something here, Ed?"
Ed: (off camera) "Hyuk hyuk hyuk... Maybe I'll refuse just to exercise my 'free will'."
GOD: "Don't be a putz, Edward. I am the Lord thy God, and I have said you will accept that marriage proposal."
Interviewer: "Then Ed really doesn't have free will, does he?"
GOD: "What? No, I... er... well, he
could choose otherwise, but he WON'T."
--conclusion: free will is just an illusion--
These are the only two scenarios I can imagine, try as I might, where so-called 'middle knowledge' is excluded, and as far as I can tell, doing so either precludes free will or precludes certain deific qualities.
As for using depleted definitions of omni____, such a depleted definition further requires a supreme being to be subordinate to or bound by one of its creations. This is the opposing extreme to lifegazer's view that omni____ must necessarily include the ability to generate and actualize paradox, but it should be noted that there is something to what ol' singularity had to say about omni_____ - his use of the term was more conceptually coherent for what we should expect of a deific creator than one that limits and warps this deity to fit within the boundaries and rules of his creation. Of course, his use of the term also means that meaningful logical discussion of God becomes next to impossible, but them's the breaks.