Okay, how were my counter-arguments to your examples inadequate ?
OK, my suit of armor is on, and I'm ready to answer.
I said that you failed to show why God couldn't serve any of the functions I listed. So, to answer your question...
Short answer: Because you never showed that my examples were not possible functions of God.
Long answer: Off the top of my head, at your request, I gave six possible functions that God might serve:
1. He might be the creator of the universe. You said that current theory explain the origins of the universe without God. True enough, but that doesn't mean that the current theory is correct (which is why it's still called a "theory.") You have offered no evidence at all that God couldn't have created the universe.
2. He might judge us after we die. You didn't comment on this one at all.
3. He might be the catalyst for free will. You asked me to further explain, and I said that current scientific theory suggests that there is no free will because of determinism. God might exist in order to allow us to have free will, perhaps by providing an exception to determinism by allowing us to have free will in an otherwise deterministic universe. You then asked "By doing what that would be different from a godless universe ?" which wasn't an argument against God's purpose being to provide free will at all.
4. He might provide consciousness. You didn't comment on this one at all.
5. He might endow the raw materials for life with life. You claimed that science can explain life and that we know how cells and genes work and why. I pointed out that, no, science cannot fully explain life much less create life, and furthermore even if science could do either, that wouldn't preclude God from creating life (or having created life).
6. He might make tornados and earthquakes. You said that we know how tornadoes and earthquakes happen, implying that God couldn't possibly cause them. I pointed out that this is not true, that not only do we not know all the factors that cause tornadoes and earthquakes, we cannot prove that God isn't the cause of those factors.
So, no, you haven't provided any evidence that God couldn't serve any of those functions.
Of course, and I wouldn't claim that lack of forseeable function alone would prove that God cannot exist, but it's a step in that direction, which is why I'd like you to answer my above question.
I understand the purpose of your questioning, but it cannot be used to show that God cannot exist. You cannot prove that God has no function. Even if you somehow disproved all of the functions I listed (you didn't actually disprove even one of them) I could always make up more possible functions, or better yet say that we don't know his function but he might still have one. Even if you could somehow prove that God has no function, that doesn't mean that God doesn't exist (just that God is useless).
Again, if the existence of God goes against our knowledge of the laws of physics (or logic, of course,) and if we can't think of a function (cause or effect) that God could have in existence, then would you agree that we can say that God cannot exist within reasonable doubt unless further evidence is presented ?
Not at all. God's function has nothing to do with his existance. However, I will grant you that there is no reason to care about something that serves no function and doesn't affect us in any way, so if you can somehow prove that (you can't, but if you could) then I would agree that God is a useless concept. In other words, I would agree that a concept of God existing but not affecting us in any way at all is a useless concept (at least to us).
That has nothing to do with God going against the laws of physics/nature or logic. There is no reason to think that God wouldn't be able to disobey the laws of nature. To the contrary, I would say that a God that
couldn't disobey the laws of nature might disprove some concepts of God (but perhaps not all). If you could only prove that God can't disobey the laws of logic, that might disprove certain other concepts of God (but definitely not all and probably not even most).
-Bri