The War on Drugs is Useless

Seeing the massacre on Jamaica, another issue rises up: even if drugs were legalized, would that affect the drug war fought in the drug-providing countries at all? That's where most of the deaths take place.

I for one am not convinced it would even help, let alone solve the problem. There is no reason to expect it would. For example, African diamond mines have been known to support various rebel groups in the past, even using slave labor. It's not the only example by any means.
Why should we expect the drug lords to suddenly act any different?

McHrozni

It is clear that we could end the drug wars completely with the end of prohibition. These thugs aren't killing people for the fun of it, they are doing it to protect the huge profits they are making. And with drugs legal, the profit margins would be much less. Even given the unlikely event that these people would want to stay in the drug business, it would be trivial to make it so they couldn't sell their product. The US government, for example, could make it so the drugs only come from approved sources, none of which would be violent gangs. Hell, except for cocaine, they could all be cheaply produced in the US.

And the diamond mines are a ridiculous analogy. Diamonds don't grow on trees (marijuana, coca, opium poppy), nor can they be easily and cheaply synthesized (methamphetamine, MDMA, LSD, ect).
 
Perhaps. The said violent criminals already own the business. What reason is there to believe they would become law-abiding citizens?



For one, because all of the raw material production is already presided over by criminals. In the case of cocaine, this is in no small part because the production is limited by climate, much more so than tobacco or grains and fruit used to produce alcohol.

I'm sure the Taliban would suffer from competition, though if they could provide the opium at a lower price, much less so.

McHrozni

mmhh thats indeed a very good point.
 
The non-medical "benefits" of drugs are so big that it is impossible to enforce a ban.
And the attempts of enforcements gives worse side effects than the drugs themselves.

Exactly the point.

If we want to MAGNIFY the harm they do to society, we increase the enforcement... Its a paradoxical effect.

Harm reduction consists of decriminalization and education.
 
It is clear that we could end the drug wars completely with the end of prohibition. These thugs aren't killing people for the fun of it, they are doing it to protect the huge profits they are making. And with drugs legal, the profit margins would be much less. Even given the unlikely event that these people would want to stay in the drug business, it would be trivial to make it so they couldn't sell their product. The US government, for example, could make it so the drugs only come from approved sources, none of which would be violent gangs. Hell, except for cocaine, they could all be cheaply produced in the US.

So you're essentially saying the drug lords would become regular law-abiding citizens. Okay. I choose not to take your word for it. At the very least, there is plentiful room for a substantial illegal market, albeit at reduced profit margins. Sure, maybe not for the first couple of fixes or for recreational use, so the illegal market would reduce somewhat.
It is likely it would get plentiful traffic. Heroin habit is a bit hard to kick, or just to reduce, and if you can get two fixes for the price of one ...

And the diamond mines are a ridiculous analogy. Diamonds don't grow on trees (marijuana, coca, opium poppy), nor can they be easily and cheaply synthesized (methamphetamine, MDMA, LSD, ect).

Perhaps. But if you can get it significantly cheaper if it's imported, it's fairly likely it will still be traded, albeit under fake papers. If this could be controlled, controlling drug flow in the first place should be outright trivial.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Exactly the point.

If we want to MAGNIFY the harm they do to society, we increase the enforcement... Its a paradoxical effect.

Harm reduction consists of decriminalization and education.

If, and only if, the prohibition doesn't notably reduce the usage. Thus far I don't see anything more than fairly empty claims that drug usage isn't affected by prohibition at all. I'm sorry, but unless one of those claiming it is the God (not a god, the God) or something, I'm not buying that claim.

McHrozni
 
If, and only if, the prohibition doesn't notably reduce the usage.
So it's worth the thousands being killed every year in the drug wars if it keeps one single American from snorting a line of coke?
 
If, and only if, the prohibition doesn't notably reduce the usage. Thus far I don't see anything more than fairly empty claims that drug usage isn't affected by prohibition at all. I'm sorry, but unless one of those claiming it is the God (not a god, the God) or something, I'm not buying that claim.

McHrozni

Total logical fail.

You have to compare the excess deaths.

MUCH lower if drug users can just get product at the pharmacy than when you provide the incentive for criminals to profit from it.

You also have to compare the excess deaths to passers-by.

I have not heard of a Drug Armageddon in the Netherlands, have you?

I have not heard of a Drug Armageddon in Portugal, have you?
 
It is clear that we could end the drug wars completely with the end of prohibition. These thugs aren't killing people for the fun of it, they are doing it to protect the huge profits they are making. And with drugs legal, the profit margins would be much less. Even given the unlikely event that these people would want to stay in the drug business, it would be trivial to make it so they couldn't sell their product. The US government, for example, could make it so the drugs only come from approved sources, none of which would be violent gangs. Hell, except for cocaine, they could all be cheaply produced in the US.

And the diamond mines are a ridiculous analogy. Diamonds don't grow on trees (marijuana, coca, opium poppy), nor can they be easily and cheaply synthesized (methamphetamine, MDMA, LSD, ect).

So you're essentially saying the drug lords would become regular law-abiding citizens. (snip)
McHrozni

How did you get this from dtugg's comment?
 
The only people that have better drugs than cops are the people the cops stole the drugs from. Christ, I hope that isn't an upsetting bit of the math.

In small town Appalachia, you tend to know who your daddy is and such.
I am fortunate to live in a part of the U.S. that is protected by "big government", even as we complain about their abortion campaign thingy; garf; Sarah P." barf; teabagger-babtists, creationist cousin-****ers, to put it bluntly.

Th National guard spends enormous $ to train helicopter pilots to fly over my land...twice a year; every year...looking for pot.

I got so bored with their ineptitude, I left easy to get plants out for them.
They landed; on my land; several times.
They took the puny bait I left for them, god bless us all.

And they waived at us! And flew off, into the wild-blue yonder!

Pictures of the pathetic plants show up on the cover of the local right wing rag of a newspaper. Like a body count.

Like we may be winning the war on drugs; you bastards.
Church ladies give their blessings.

No one on earth is strong enough to go up against the church ladies of Appalachia.

I don't even bother growing pot anymore. I don't need the money, and I don't like being stoned.

Can you big city slickers even grasp this phenomena?

Small town Appalachia.
Forced to grow pot for the war effort, against their will.
Navy needed rope.

My farm was one of these experiments, way back.
Meanwhile, Kentucky gets all holy. You can't buy liquor where I live. Nor in any of the surrounding counties.

But dig this, good people:

What do we do here in this rand paul, bible thumping state?

We do whiskey and bourbon, in vast quantitie; even in dry counties.
We do world class pot growing, which supports the local economies, and all the wannabe-sheriffs know this. Their daddies were major bootleggers.

We do gambling. Horse racing, to be specific.
We're all holy about the other forms of gambling, which take place in your face, at any and every convenience store in my county.

We make meth here, too....lots of it. Horrible meth. Lots of busts; lots of dumb-ass chemists; amazing propaganda about the toxic threat that, frankly, is coming from the farm supply store.

We also buy oxycontin from slease-bag md's from florida.
We are also obese.

Its truly pathetic people.
I've done time in a federal pen.

I've never met anything more evil than the church ladies that run the mill of repressed sin in Appalachia.



(Whoo, boy...I hope I don't regret this tomorrow..)


Its just that hypocrisy wrankles my ass worster than anythingy.



Damn, quarky. How could you forget to mention tobacco?
The tax value of your own land is rated by how much tobacco it can grow.
I'm ashamed of you.

Again.
 
mmhh thats indeed a very good point.

No, it isn't.

As has already been noted by others, most drugs could be grown or produced in the US without the involvement of criminals. Both alcohol and tobacco have shown this to be true.

The existing criminals will no longer have a market for their product. At the least, we will diminish their market significantly, something we have never done under the current system. So, they will no longer make as much money and no longer have power. Without cash flow they are just thugs.

We will never rid the world of thugs, but there is no reason we should help them gain power.
 
So it's worth the thousands being killed every year in the drug wars if it keeps one single American from snorting a line of coke?

No, but if it keeps several million from doing so (saving thousands of lives in the process), that might be the case.

McHrozni
 
Total logical fail.

You have to compare the excess deaths.

I covered that earlier. I don't consider someone who is living from one drug dose to the next to be living a worthwhile life. He is surviving. That's it.
Death toll is a useful statistic, but far from sufficiently informative to be the only statistic we should use.

I have not heard of a Drug Armageddon in the Netherlands, have you?

I have not heard of a Drug Armageddon in Portugal, have you?

Nor have I heard of either of the two countries giving up prohibition. Have you?

That said, the Netherlands experienced approximately 300% increase in the number of people using pot a decade or so after they permitted sales in "coffee shops". I'm sure you'll claim this was completely unconnected to the decriminalization. You might be right, but your point fails rather miserably, all things considered.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
How did you get this from dtugg's comment?

This part:
It is clear that we could end the drug wars completely with the end of prohibition. These thugs aren't killing people for the fun of it, they are doing it to protect the huge profits they are making.

Hm. I guess they are protecting the huge profits they're making now, but if we were to try to remove those profits they wouldn't be inclined to protect them. Or something. Great logic.

McHrozni
 
At the least, we will diminish their market significantly, something we have never done under the current system.

I'm sorry, but just what is the founding of this assumption?

64% of adults in the US used alcohol in the past year, 50% of whom would be likely to report "used it in past month" (over 12 drinks in a year)
http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/alcohol.htm

For smoking:
http://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/adult_data/cig_smoking/index.htm#national
About 20% of adults in the US smoke, give or take some.

For illicit drugs, I found this survey:
http://www.oas.samhsa.gov/nsduh/2k8nsduh/2k8Results.cfm#Ch2

Which has 20 million Americans above the age of 12 using illicit drugs in the past month, including controlled pharmaceuticals. That's about 8% of the population, according to the survey. You'll notice the majority of those come from "soft" drugs, like marijuana.
The alcohol statistic is for the past year, whereas illicit drugs is for past month, but we're still looking at a roughly four to five fold difference, possibly as much as eight fold difference compared to alcohol and a two to three fold difference compared to tobacco. That's quite significant, don't you think?

Now please explain your reasoning why this is in no way the result of the war on drugs.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
So you're essentially saying the drug lords would become regular law-abiding citizens. Okay. I choose not to take your word for it.

I am saying that they wouldn't be selling drugs and killing people over the sale of drugs because there would be no money in it. People like you are giving them a very easy way to make billions of dollars a year. Without this easy money, they would have less money to pay henchman, buy guns, bribe cops, ect.

At the very least, there is plentiful room for a substantial illegal market, albeit at reduced profit margins.

Not if the legal market were priced correctly. And even if some black market existed they would be making much, much less money. Meaning, as I said before, less money for henchman, guns, and bribes.

Sure, maybe not for the first couple of fixes or for recreational use, so the illegal market would reduce somewhat.
It is likely it would get plentiful traffic. Heroin habit is a bit hard to kick, or just to reduce, and if you can get two fixes for the price of one ...

Not if it were priced correctly. At a certain price no junkie is going to buy crap of questionable quality off the street when he can get some of guaranteed quality from the store. And even given the unlikely event that some junkies would be willing to get heroin of questionable quality to save a few bucks, this would only be a small percentage of users rather than 100% of them as now. So black market heroin dealers would have much less customers and be making much less money per customer. I doubt many would find it worth the risk. And even if they did, they would have much less money for guns, henchman, and bribes.


Perhaps. But if you can get it significantly cheaper if it's imported, it's fairly likely it will still be traded, albeit under fake papers. If this could be controlled, controlling drug flow in the first place should be outright trivial.

McHrozni

Solution: Price the legal drugs accordingly. And even these thugs still wanted to sell drugs at much, much, much lower profit margins then they do now, they would have a small portion of them market rather than 100% of it. And they would make less money per customer. And as I have said repeatedly, this means much less money for henchman, guns, and bribes.
 
Last edited:
I am saying that they wouldn't be selling drugs and killing people over the sale of drugs because there would be no money in it. People like you are giving them a very easy way to make billions of dollars a year. Without this easy money, they would have less money to pay henchman, buy guns, bribe cops, ect.

Even without drugs, there is still plentiful money in organized crime. They would have to do more to get it, that is true. In the short to medium term, I would expect a rise in other forms of organized crime, because they already have henchmen, bribed cops, guns and a stock of money to run this for a while. In the long run, organized crime might be reduced.

On the other hand, in the medium to long term, a significant rise in drug use is also possible, if not likely. If that does more damage than the gang violence, who are you to say that option is the better one?

Not if it were priced correctly. At a certain price no junkie is going to buy crap of questionable quality off the street when he can get some of guaranteed quality from the store.

By priced correctly, you mean cheap, right?

McHrozni
 
yep seems so, i thought that atleast more than 50% would make it.
didnt know so many dont make it.

And what's even worse is that now the majority of the new drugs that are even researched are derivative drugs because the cost of researching a brand new class of drugs is so expensive and the chance of getting past initial trials is so low.

But that's off-topic.
 
This part:
It is clear that we could end the drug wars completely with the end of prohibition. These thugs aren't killing people for the fun of it, they are doing it to protect the huge profits they are making.

Hm. I guess they are protecting the huge profits they're making now, but if we were to try to remove those profits they wouldn't be inclined to protect them. Or something. Great logic.

McHrozni

Let's see, affect thier profits by destroying thier fields, supply lines, and distribution system which serves to drive up the price of thier commodity. Protecting thier profits is rather easy. Bribery, assainations, very little competition due to the violent nature of the system. Targets are few and easy to reach.


Now attacking thier profits by swamping the market with a multitude of producers and vendors in countries where they have no influence. The increase of product in the market and the competition of the free market would drop the price of the commodity.

Exactly how would they protect thier profit in that system using violence and coersion?

Except maybe bribeing, I mean, providing campaign contributions to, U.S. congressmen to keep the drug war going. Lord knows there's a whole bunch of money to be made there.
 
Last edited:
~snip~
On the other hand, in the medium to long term, a significant rise in drug use is also possible, if not likely. If that does more damage than the gang violence, who are you to say that option is the better one?
McHrozni

So you're saying the situation we have right now is the better choice?

It wasn't all that good back in the 20s
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom