The War on Drugs is Useless

Unless, of course, they find another source of illicit money.

None of which would be as easy and as profitable as drugs.

Your regular organized crime comes to mind,

Not nearly as profitable.

as do what they're doing now: drug exports.

But selling drugs is only so profitable because they are illegal.

If you can point to me why each of them is invalid, you're free to do so. But I suspect you can't.

The burden is not on me to invalidate your personal opinions.

An interesting read. A pity you stated earlier you agreed earlier that the high level of correlation isn't a coincidence.
Just which version do you believe now? That the demand is inelastic, and the reduction of usage corresponding to higher prices is a fluke, or that of Gary Becker, who says there is no significant correlation?


It seems like you are being intentionally dishonest. Yes, I said it wasn't a coincidence, but I also said that the correlation was more likely due to decreased supply which would cause a price increase. That has nothing to do with whether the demand is inelastic or not.


His case isn't the strongest, either.

One thing I couldn't find is why he thinks the demand is inelastic. He states it "appears to be" several times and builds the document on that assumption, but I can't find any reasoning behind the assumption. I've already shown why I think he's wrong with his initial assumption in the study above.

Who to believe, a Nobel Prize winning economist or some guy on the Internet?

You actually agreed his entire premise wrong before citing him. Good job.

That's a lie.

I honestly don't remember you saying that, but I'm talking to about 5 different people, so I think that's understandable. That said, the period in which the price rose and usage dropped was over 5 years. Just where do you put a limit on "temporary"? You also stated several times that there is no shortage of drugs, and yet the price rose and the usage dropped. Which one is it, then? A temporary cocaine shortage spanning at least five years, or something else entirely?

I can't really say without reading the paper (and I am not going to pay to read it), as I have no idea how these statistic were arrived at. Perhaps there many temporary shortages in the five year span.

Have you tried asking why not?

Yeah, most say because it is dangerous.

Hm. According to you heroin and cocaine are dangerous and highly addictive compounds, that can easily be used in moderation.

I'm sorry, but this just doesn't make sense. On what basis are they dangerous, if they can be easily and safely used in moderation?

Because not everybody uses them safely and in moderation. Would it make you happy if I rephrased it to say "can be dangerous and highly addictive"?

I'm sorry, how did the second half of sentence affect that you admitted that the war on drugs was having a strong positive effect?

It doesn't. But I find it dishonest how you ignored the part where I argued that prohibition isn't necessary to give this effect.

Not to ignore it completely, you're claiming that labels on packaging would be sufficient, right?

Not on its own, but it could help.

If so, why are there at least two habitual smokers for each occasional or habitual illicit drug user of any kind? Drugs don't have warnings on packages, but tobacco products have had those for almost 45 years now.

Probably because tobacco use is deeply ingrained in our society and has been for centuries. Of course, smoking is also down significantly since the 1960s....

Before you begin ranting "it's because drugs are dangerous and everybody knows it", please explain how that is not a result of the war on drugs and the vilification that follows. I've raised this point several times now, you ignored it and now call me dishonest over ... what, exactly? That packaging with warning labels would be sufficient when it was already demonstrated not to be very effective?

McHrozni

Yes I suppose you could say that it is due in part to the war on drugs. Everybody knows that they can be dangerous because they are taught at home, at school, ect. that they are. But my point was that there is no reason that we couldn't keep doing that part without the prohibition. And warning labels were only one example of what could be done in addition to the general drug education that is already being done and which should still be done in the event that they are legal.
 
Last edited:
None of which would be as easy and as profitable as drugs.
(...)
Not nearly as profitable.
(...)
But selling drugs is only so profitable because they are illegal.

I addressed this earlier, I see no reason to do so again.

The burden is not on me to invalidate your personal opinions.

It is if I support them, as I have. You can concede I have a valid point, though.

It seems like you are being intentionally dishonest. Yes, I said it wasn't a coincidence, but I also said that the correlation was more likely due to decreased supply which would cause a price increase. That has nothing to do with whether the demand is inelastic or not.

So ... the price is inelastic, but there was a shortage, which resulted in an increased price. But you also said the war on drugs is very ineffective and can't produce a substantial medium to long term shortage ... which is what would be necessary for the observed effect to be seen. You also claimed earlier there was no current shortage

Who to believe, a Nobel Prize winning economist or some guy on the Internet?

Oh, I agree with his analysis, which hinges on his premise. I just think he got the initial premise wrong, and have submitted the reasons why that is. He admitted the premise wasn't at all proven in the article.

I can't really say without reading the paper (and I am not going to pay to read it), as I have no idea how these statistic were arrived at. Perhaps there many temporary shortages in the five year span.

Which averages to one long shortage, or an effective war on drugs if you so desire.

Yeah, most say because it is dangerous.

And this is not a result of the war on drugs?

Because not everybody uses them safely and in moderation. Would it make you happy if I rephrased it to say "can be dangerous and highly addictive"?

Obviously. The issue is that most illicit drugs are so harmful and addictive safe usage is difficult, not easy as you said earlier, and that it turns to abuse far too often. Approximately 0,5% of all illicit drug users turn drug abusers, but approximately 23% of individuals using heroin become addicted to it.

It doesn't. But I find it dishonest how you ignored the part where I argued that prohibition isn't necessary to give this effect.

Whereas I've been arguing the whole time that it is a significant factor. I pointed out you ignored this by now, you know. And no, "packaging warning labels" don't even approach the problem.

Not on its own, but it could help.

More than being repeatedly told drugs are dangerous and constant vilification of them? Anywhere comparably?

Probably because tobacco use is deeply ingrained in our society and has been for centuries. Of course, smoking is also down significantly since the 1960s....

And if currently illicit drugs became legal and accepted in a society, the effect where they're used more often wouldn't show? Why not?

Yes I suppose you could say that it is due in part to the war on drugs. Everybody knows that they can be dangerous because they are taught at home, at school, ect. that they are. But my point was that there is no reason that we couldn't keep doing that part without the prohibition. And warning labels were only one example of what could be done in addition to the general drug education that is already being done and which should still be done in the event that they are legal.

This is precisely what is being done with alcohol and tobacco to, at best, a mediocre effect. If those comparisons are of any use, currently illicit drug use would significantly increase. Not immediately, perhaps, but over a decade or two, that's almost a given. You said earlier that alcohol and tobacco are more accepted in our society, whereas illicit drugs are not. If they were legal and available at low prices, wouldn't that improve their acceptability and increase usage? If no, why not? It's a very reasonable expectation. True, I can't prove it, because there is no usable working model, but expecting that similar conditions will produce similar results is logical and rational.

McHrozni
 
I covered that earlier. I don't consider someone who is living from one drug dose to the next to be living a worthwhile life. He is surviving. That's it.

...

Pardon me for saying so, but what self-righteous garbage. Its up to you to determine whose life is worth living?

How many heroin addicts have you personally known? I have known several. And I think they had worthwhile lives, and so did they (probably still do, but I am not in contact with them any more.) You probably think they had worthwhile lives too, as you have no doubt personally enjoyed their art. Now, they had a privileged position with respect to smack addicts; they had far more than enough money to afford it, were able to get it any time they needed it and it was the best in quality, and they never had to share needles with anybody in their lives. Pretty much the situation that would pertain under decriminalization.

So we should just have pulled the plug on them right after their first use of the drug as they instantly became worthless bits of human refuse? Is that what you are telling me?

What sanctimonious crap.
 
21 more gang shootings here last night, brought to you by the War on Drugs.

But it's all worth it if it keeps one kid from getting high. Gonna be a long summer.

Setting up a straw man usually shows your argument is weak. Setting it up anew after being explicitly told it is one probably proves that. See post #392, in case you genuinely missed it.

Pardon me for saying so, but what self-righteous garbage. Its up to you to determine whose life is worth living?

I didn't say that, nor did I mean to imply that. I do consider a life of a junkie wasted and only marginally better than a life lost to a shooting incident however. And no, your fallacious argument outlined below still has no merit whatsoever.

So we should just have pulled the plug on them right after their first use of the drug as they instantly became worthless bits of human refuse? Is that what you are telling me?

You know what? You really shouldn't be lecturing me on what's sanctimonious refuse. And no, this is not what I've been telling you, and yes, if you had tried to find out what I was telling you, you really could do that through the magic of reading. But jumping to conclusions and using logical fallacies makes a much more persuasive argument, doesn't it.

I'll refer you to the post you quoted. You quoted my first part, read the seventh. I'll also refer you to post #414 of this thread, last part.
In fact you could try to read the thread as a whole first and make smart sounding slippery slope fallacies afterward, if it'll still seem smart to you. It probably won't though.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
How do you know these shootings were drug related? Doesn't mention it in the article. How do you know the War on Drugs made them do it?

Pretend for a moment that you live on the same planet as the rest of us, OK?

Nobody else doubts that the majority of the violence in our major cities is drug related. Just like nobody doubted it when that little incident took place inside of the SMC Cartage Company that it was related to alcohol prohibition. So, knock off the pretense, you aren't scoring any points with it.
 
The argument was that most drugs would be produced in the US. There are narco cartels in the US, aren't there? They would be quite interested in keeping the business.
Again, the number of people and corporations wanting to get in on the market will represent too many targets for the cartels. They would not be able to threaten the competition via violence. They could try but they wouldn't be able to keep it up for very long considering thier rapidly dwindling resources. This is exactly what happend to the Mafia after prohibition was repealed. The black market could not compete with the low priced alcohol from legal sources. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibition_in_the_United_States)

The drug cartels would be reduced to what the mafia does now. Hijack the odd local shipment. They would become a dim shadow of thier former selves against the huge corporate light.


True. There will also be the beforementioned church groups, which would support them, plus many people who aren't members of either of the two, but strongly disagree with your simplistic view and consequently with your conclusions (like me).
It would be an odd paring. Church groups do not usually associate themselves with murdering drug cartels. It's bad for public image and the whole sin thing.

Church and advocate groups pretty much have accepted the repeal of prohibition. They mainly busy themselves with "just say no" campaigns these days. If congress manages to decriminalize drugs I do not see these groups banding together with drug cartels to spread fear and death amoung the new producers. Protest rallies is more to thier form.

That should be a concern. Drugs would be more accepted in a society, and significantly wider usage is highly likely. That could easily lead to a significantly more damage to society than drug cartels could ever do.

McHrozni
Wasn't that the same argument against the repeal of prohibition? Alcohol, nicotene, and caffiene are presently socialy acceptable and yet society is still intact for the most part.

The majority of the people are not obssesed with drugs or alcohol. I think the pathological addict represents a small fraction of our society. Most are casual users with the odd teen age binge drinker/user.

The statistics you've shown show that more people use alcohol more than drugs and yet there are billions of dollars of drug that are moved into the U.S. That means that there are billions of dollars of drugs available in the U.S. now and yet the number of people who use those drugs is still less than the people who use alcohol. I think this shows that drug use would not increase significantly. There would an increase to be sure, but I do not think it would be to devestating levels.

The repeal of Prohibition showed that there was an initial short term increase of alcohol use per capita that later declined. (http://eh.net/encyclopedia/article/miron.prohibition.alcohol)

Social programs are already in place to deal with addicts. The initial increase in addiction will no doubt place an increased strain on social programs, but this can be offset by the increased tax revenue of drug sales. Drug interdiction resource could be restructured to deal the increased number of drug related incidents. Ex-DEA agents could be reassigned to local law enforcement to provide increased vilgialnce aginst DWIs and drug related domestic incidents.
Street gangs would also loose the resources that were provided by the black market distribution of drugs. Law enforcement would have an oppurtunity to take advantage of as the gangs would try to reorganize.
 
If the increased amount of drug use is significant enough, then yes, certainly.
Human nature not withstanding, history has shown that if drug use is left up to voluntary use, and not advocated or forced, it remained a social ill rather than a devestating plague. I think education would reduce usage more than prohibition ever could.

I agree, stigma plays a significant role. So what is the source of this stigma?
You're saying it's not illegality and it's not persecution. It was stated earlier it's not physical harm either. So what is it?
As I mention before, the stigma brought on by which social class used which drug and the observation of the effects of the abuse of the drug.
http://opioids.com/images/opium-den.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_den
http://www.nceta.flinders.edu.au/events/documents/Room2005.pdf

Not to mention the religious ferverance that has prevaded this country since it's inception.
Religious and temperance groups were also keen to capitalize and increase the social stigma of drug use. It was religious temperance groups that got prohibition passed.

The media of the time also pushed the social stigma, even if it was to increase movie ticket sales by cranking out puriant, voyeristic, two reelers promoting the social ills of drug use by scantily clad women of questionable moral compass. The movie "Reefer Maddness" comes to mind as an example.

Wait. You're saying that the stigma comes from the fact that decades ago, the said drugs were part of society that was looked down upon, and that at the same time a significant number of people were using cocaine. That's usually called a contradiction you know.
Hint for you, look at why Coca Cola was developed in the first place. People used to drink cocaine-fortified wine, you see, and alternative to wine was sought. Cocaine use used to be fairly common, and not associated with any stigma whatsoever.

Heroin was initially marketed as a cough drop by Bayer.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:BayerHeroin.png
No, that is a contradiction of society. That was to show that there was wide spread use of certain drugs without the social effect, as it is today.


Today alcohol, caffene and nicotine are socialy acceptable. Nicotine is every bit as addictive and cocaine, morphine and heroine. Alcohol is every bit as debilitaing to mental faculties as morphine and heroine. Alcohol is also very deadly, as in overdose and DWI. Caffiene and nicotine are also deadly in the long use/term. But yet they are socialy acceptable.

Do you see a contradiction there?

No stigma there. It came later. Where from?
As I mentioned before certain drug use was associated with certain classes of society.
Cocaine, laudinum (morphine) were the prefered drugs of use by high society. Addiction was a subject to be avoided amoung the leaders (rich) of society.

It wasn't untill the large scale use by the lower classes and immigrants did the stigma start to form. And religious groups had always been against the use of inebriants in this country, so they were happy to push the stigma.

Precisely. It's most certainly has nothing to do with how drugs were accepted decades ago. It's something more recent. I have an idea what that could be. Do you?
Now days it is about health and the strain on social services.

The illegality of drugs is still a social non-issue. That is because drug use has become so widespread and previlent that law enforcement do not really go after the user (except when another crime has been committed in association with drug use, i.e. DWI, PI, theft and prostitution to get drug monies, etc...).

Heck, I personaly know law enforcement officials who occasionaly use marijuana.

There were even campaigns about how using drugs supports terrorist activities. That idea flopped very quickly.

Back it the sixties the fact that drugs were illegal actually boosted it's use because it was a "fun" form of protesting and rebelling against the establishment. In the seventies drug use actually momentarily became socialy acceptable. Particularly Marijuana and cocaine use.

Not very many people still respect the anti-drug laws.

And, according to you, none of that is because of the war on drugs, but because of ... what, exactly?

McHrozni
The majority of Americans think that the war on drugs is futile. Or at least that the present policies are not effective.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_on_Drugs
http://www.cato.org/drug-war
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2009/06/23/opinion/main5106252.shtml

Call it liberal media if you want, but the fact remains that people do not really respect the drug laws. Drug use is prevalent dispite the laws.

Those who do not use drugs do so not so much because of the laws but because of the health and social effects. Or they simply choose not to.
And drug use is still seen as the affliction of the lower classes. You normaly associate drug use with a low income hispanic or African American inner city gang member or a Caucasion trailer home dweller. You see it in our media

That is the social stigma that surrounds drug use today, dispite the fact that drugs are used by a broad spectrum of society.
 
Human nature not withstanding, history has shown that if drug use is left up to voluntary use, and not advocated or forced, it remained a social ill rather than a devestating plague. I think education would reduce usage more than prohibition ever could.

Prohibition and education are not mutually exclusive. In fact permitting drugs to be sold freely and education against them are far less compatible.

As I mention before, the stigma brought on by which social class used which drug and the observation of the effects of the abuse of the drug.
http://opioids.com/images/opium-den.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_den
http://www.nceta.flinders.edu.au/events/documents/Room2005.pdf

Wait, you're again claiming that the current drug perceptions are more shaped by how drugs were used 80 or more years ago than the past 40 years of policy?
That's not just false, it's ridiculous.

Today alcohol, caffene and nicotine are socialy acceptable. Nicotine is every bit as addictive and cocaine, morphine and heroine. Alcohol is every bit as debilitaing to mental faculties as morphine and heroine. Alcohol is also very deadly, as in overdose and DWI. Caffiene and nicotine are also deadly in the long use/term. But yet they are socialy acceptable.

Really. Would you care to publish sources that show this?

Do you see a contradiction there?

Even if you were correct (you aren't), this just shows one thing: prohibition eventually causes a stigma in the usage of a certain drug, reducing it's use in the long term. Some of the currently illegal drugs are less harmful than the legal ones (but not the ones you mentioned), and far less popular. Why is that, if not because of stigma brought by prohibition?

The illegality of drugs is still a social non-issue.

No, it's not. You just turn away from every evidence that points to the fact that illegality reduces usage and claim something ridiculous to "show" that's not the case.

The majority of Americans think that the war on drugs is futile. Or at least that the present policies are not effective.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_on_Drugs
http://www.cato.org/drug-war
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2009/06/23/opinion/main5106252.shtml

If the majority of Americans thought the Earth was hollow on the inside, would that make Earth hollow on the inside?

Again, the number of people and corporations wanting to get in on the market will represent too many targets for the cartels. They would not be able to threaten the competition via violence. They could try but they wouldn't be able to keep it up for very long considering thier rapidly dwindling resources. This is exactly what happend to the Mafia after prohibition was repealed. The black market could not compete with the low priced alcohol from legal sources. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibi..._United_States)

The drug cartels would be reduced to what the mafia does now. Hijack the odd local shipment. They would become a dim shadow of thier former selves against the huge corporate light.

Perhaps. Perhaps not. Saying this would happen with certainty is unfounded. It could be that the drug cartels would be severely impacted and reduced to a meager existence, it could also be they would find something else to trade in.
In the short to medium term, I'd expect extraordinary chaos, which would make the current drug war seem like a pleasant stroll in a park, as they would fight tooth and nail over the few remaining sources of income (like sales in countries with prohibition). In the long term, this may subside, it depends on the end results of the chaos.

I also believe the comparison to the alcohol prohibition is rather unfounded. That was a policy which ran for a total of 14 years, and prohibited an intoxicant which was widely available and used since the dawn of western civilization. The attitudes obviously stayed the same as the prohibition began, they can't be changed overnight. As I have pointed out earlier, the intoxicant is also very easy to produce using perfectly legitimate groceries. Moreover, thousands upon thousands had all the necessary skills to produce it, having been employed by legitimate industries for their entire lives in some cases. Alcohol was also legally and widely available just across borders. There already were untold millions of regular users, who had their supply cut and sought an alternative, sometimes any alternative would do.
There are also many non-intoxicating uses for alcohol, it's a highly useful solvent and a cleaning agent and a highly effective disinfectant.

None of this can be compared to heroin (heroine is a female hero, heroin is a drug), cocaine or any other currently illegal drug, not at the start of prohibition and in all likelihood not now either.

It would be an odd paring. Church groups do not usually associate themselves with murdering drug cartels. It's bad for public image and the whole sin thing.

So? I didn't say the actions would have to be coordinated. They would each work towards the same goal, each in their own way and for their own reasons. It's odd, yes, but not unprecedented.

Wasn't that the same argument against the repeal of prohibition? Alcohol, nicotene, and caffiene are presently socialy acceptable and yet society is still intact for the most part.

Depending on what you mean by "intact", but yes, none of them are crippling to the society.
That said:
http://www.drugwarfacts.org/cms/?q=node/30

Complications arising from tobacco use are the leading cause of death in the US, with complications arising from alcohol use being third.
You might say the article is from a biased site, and I agree it's not a site I'd like to rely upon, but the general gist is correct: tobacco is a major killer, and so is alcohol. Together they kill over 25 people for each homicide victim in the US, according to this site.

Even assuming these numbers were off by an order of magnitude - which is reducing the argument to absurdity - alcohol and tobacco combined kill way more people than all violence put together.
Compared to this, the war on drugs is truly just a mild ill of the society. But eliminating it risks an explosion of abuse of far more drugs by far more people, leading to even worse results than we currently have.

The majority of the people are not obssesed with drugs or alcohol. I think the pathological addict represents a small fraction of our society. Most are casual users with the odd teen age binge drinker/user.

We have statistics that tell us those, I cited them earlier.
Approximately 0,5% of all illicit drug users turn drug abusers. Approximately 23% of all heroin users turn addicts. Approximately 4% of alcohol users become alcoholics (according to http://www.enotalone.com/article/5540.html at least, I don't know how accurate it is). Obviously heroin is more dangerous than alcohol, but combined to soft illicit drugs, it's worse.
However, the numbers are not really comparable, since alcohol is much more socially acceptable and legal, which make alcohol addiction far more likely.

That said, a drug war victim represents a far, far, far smaller fraction of society. An innocent drug war victim represents an even tinier subset of that small fraction of society.

http://www.alcoholalert.com/drunk-driving-statistics.html

There were about 13,000 people killed due to drunken driving in the US in 2008. Unfortunately I don't know how many of those were people who drank and drove and how many were people who were a victim of a drunken driver. Still, it's fairly likely the number of people killed by drunken drivers dwarfs the number of innocent victims in the drug war.

If the damage steaming from use of alcohol and tobacco isn't a major ill of the society, then neither is the drug war.

Note: I said earlier that the death toll is not a sufficient statistic, but also that it's still a useful statistic. I've also ignored other ills to society, like passive smoking and violence from using alcohol, people crippled by drunken drivers and such, so I think the end results would not be significantly different in favor of the war on drugs.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Prohibition and education are not mutually exclusive. In fact permitting drugs to be sold freely and education against them are far less compatible.


Wait, you're again claiming that the current drug perceptions are more shaped by how drugs were used 80 or more years ago than the past 40 years of policy?
That's not just false, it's ridiculous.
No, I am saying that drug use comes with a stigma even back when they were legal to use. Today the stigma is based on health issues and, still to a degree, the social classes that are perceivced to use them. Certain types of drug use are associated with certain groups in our society.

Really. Would you care to publish sources that show this?
Alcohol:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-term_effects_of_alcohol
http://www.cdc.gov/alcohol/
http://pubs.niaaa.nih.gov/publications/aa63/aa63.htm
http://www.about-alcohol.com/Alcohol_Overdose.html
http://moms.gather.com/viewArticle.action?articleId=281474978271291
http://cdc.gov/MotorVehicleSafety/Impaired_Driving/impaired-drv_factsheet.html
Nicotine:
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/nicotine-dependence/ds00307
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicotine
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_effects_of_tobacco
http://www.helpwithsmoking.com/effects-of-nicotine.php
http://www.drugs.com/sfx/nicotine-side-effects.html
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/287555-overview
http://student.biology.arizona.edu/honors96/group7/studies.htm
caffiene:
http://www.medicinenet.com/caffeine/page2.htm
http://www.benbest.com/health/caffeine.html
There is no conclusive evidence that caffiene is linked to cardiovascular desease but there is evidence that caffiene causes mutation in cells and a possibility for cancer.


Even if you were correct (you aren't), this just shows one thing: prohibition eventually causes a stigma in the usage of a certain drug, reducing it's use in the long term.
Prohibition did not create any new stigma that alcohol didn't already have. (which was religious based). In a past post I linked to a chart that showed that alcohol use actually started to increase in the few months before the repeal of the 8th admendment.

Some of the currently illegal drugs are less harmful than the legal ones (but not the ones you mentioned), and far less popular. Why is that, if not because of stigma brought by prohibition?
Illicit drug use has decreased because people are more concerned with health these days. It's become a fad.
Thanks to the baby boomers people have seen the effects of the use and abuse of illegal drugs and most are turned off to them. I would venture to bet that if you were to run a poll that asked people who do not use illegal drugs why they do not use them that the illegality of the drug as a reason is not way up on the list.

There is a poll on this forum asking if the people who frequent this forum would use "hard drugs" if they were made legal. So far @78% said no. And 19% of the respondents who said no had used "hard drugs" in the past. (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/poll.php?do=showresults&pollid=61773)
I would say that the illegality of the drugs has no bearing on the respondent's decision to not use of the illicit drugs.



No, it's not. You just turn away from every evidence that points to the fact that illegality reduces usage and claim something ridiculous to "show" that's not the case.
If anything "llegality" affects the price and, in some cases, the availability of the drug. In these days it is concerns for health and addiction that reduces the usage of illicit drugs.

And here is a report written in 1990 by the Texas Commission on Alcohol and Drug abuse asking people who refuse to use illicit drugs the reason why they do not use them.
http://www.dshs.state.tx.us/sa/research/adult/Notuse.pdf

Take particular note of the number one reason why people do not use illict drugs. The largest response based on users and non users both exposed and not exposed is "personal choice". Health and ethical reasons come in at a close second and third. depending on the group. The illegality of drugs is not the primary reason for non use.

If the majority of Americans thought the Earth was hollow on the inside, would that make Earth hollow on the inside?
I think the recent statistics supports thier belief.
http://www.drugpolicy.org/library/factsheets/effectivenes/index.cfm
http://reason.com/archives/2002/01/01/statistics-from-the-war-on-dru
See if you find any statistcs that support the opposite of my claim.

Perhaps. Perhaps not. Saying this would happen with certainty is unfounded. It could be that the drug cartels would be severely impacted and reduced to a meager existence, it could also be they would find something else to trade in.
Prohibition is a possible model or example. Certainly the Cartel would look for other means of income. Gun running perhaps?

In the short to medium term, I'd expect extraordinary chaos, which would make the current drug war seem like a pleasant stroll in a park, as they would fight tooth and nail over the few remaining sources of income (like sales in countries with prohibition). In the long term, this may subside, it depends on the end results of the chaos.
I would agree to a certain extent. The chaos could present an opportunity to reduce the influence of the cartels. But the U.S. was a huge source of income (as well as guns) for the cartels. The lose of the U.S. market would be a huge, possibly crippleing, loss for the cartels.

I also believe the comparison to the alcohol prohibition is rather unfounded. That was a policy which ran for a total of 14 years, and prohibited an intoxicant which was widely available and used since the dawn of western civilization. The attitudes obviously stayed the same as the prohibition began, they can't be changed overnight. As I have pointed out earlier, the intoxicant is also very easy to produce using perfectly legitimate groceries. Moreover, thousands upon thousands had all the necessary skills to produce it, having been employed by legitimate industries for their entire lives in some cases. Alcohol was also legally and widely available just across borders. There already were untold millions of regular users, who had their supply cut and sought an alternative, sometimes any alternative would do.
Any body can grow marijuana. It grows just about anywhere. There is a reason the call it "weed". Cocain and heroin are a bit harder to produce. Getting and growing Coca plants and poppies are a bit harder to obtain. But if you can manage extracting the drug is not difficult. Heck people are smoking salvia these days. Salvia is basicaly the herb sage. And all those drugs have been with man kind since the beggining to. It's just that certain drugs started with different civilization other than the western civilization. They were imported at later times.
But this is beside the point of prohibition. The point of prohibition was that people wanted an inebriant. the government made it illegal and a powerfull crime syndicate evolved around the drug. Sounds familiar, right?

There are also many non-intoxicating uses for alcohol, it's a highly useful solvent and a cleaning agent and a highly effective disinfectant.
There are non-intoxicating uses for THC, cocaine, and opiates today.

Sorry, but the wife is hungry and attempting to tear me away as i type. I will respond to the rest of the post later in the day.
 
No, I am saying that drug use comes with a stigma even back when they were legal to use. Today the stigma is based on health issues and, still to a degree, the social classes that are perceivced to use them. Certain types of drug use are associated with certain groups in our society.

And you also claim the stigma is in no way connected with the crime?
I find that very far-fetched.


Do any of these show a comparison between the nicotine, alcohol and caffeine on one side, and heroin and cocaine on the other? This is what you claimed, that they're absolutely no better than heroin and cocaine.

Prohibition did not create any new stigma that alcohol didn't already have. (which was religious based). In a past post I linked to a chart that showed that alcohol use actually started to increase in the few months before the repeal of the 8th admendment.

I pointed out why comparison to alcohol prohibition is unfounded. Please explain why you think that is false before making further comparisons to alcohol prohibition.

Illicit drug use has decreased because people are more concerned with health these days. It's become a fad.

And yet you claim alcohol is no better. But the usage of alcohol isn't declining anywhere near as significantly. Isn't that a contradiction?

There is a poll on this forum asking if the people who frequent this forum would use "hard drugs" if they were made legal. So far @78% said no. And 19% of the respondents who said no had used "hard drugs" in the past. (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/poll.php?do=showresults&pollid=61773)
I would say that the illegality of the drugs has no bearing on the respondent's decision to not use of the illicit drugs.

Perhaps, but keep in mind this is after 40 or so years of intensive conditioning and being spoon-fed that drugs are bad from practically all sources. Making them legal could (and probably would) change this is medium to long term.
I wouldn't expect a swift change. I said this several times now.

And here is a report written in 1990 by the Texas Commission on Alcohol and Drug abuse asking people who refuse to use illicit drugs the reason why they do not use them.
http://www.dshs.state.tx.us/sa/research/adult/Notuse.pdf

Take particular note of the number one reason why people do not use illict drugs. The largest response based on users and non users both exposed and not exposed is "personal choice". Health and ethical reasons come in at a close second and third. depending on the group. The illegality of drugs is not the primary reason for non use.

Well, you have "upbringing" at 3,5%, "fear what will happen" at 2,5%, "they're wrong, stupid" at 2,3%, "heard about on TV, read about it" at 2%, "illegal" at 1,7%, "socially unacceptable" at 0,8%, "substance not available" at 0,3%, "too expensive" at 0,3%, "job security" at 0,3%, can't afford at 0,2%, "fear of arrest" at 0,1%, "penalties you pay" at 0,1% and "alcohol drug testing" at just under 0,05%. This is a total of over 13% who are at least linked to the war on drugs, if not a direct result of it.

This is quite telling, especially since the primary reason, standing at almost 25%, is "I don't know".

Comparing this study to the poll we had, it's quite possible that an extra 5% of population would use hard drugs, if they were legal.

I think the recent statistics supports thier belief.
http://www.drugpolicy.org/library/factsheets/effectivenes/index.cfm
http://reason.com/archives/2002/01/01/statistics-from-the-war-on-dru
See if you find any statistcs that support the opposite of my claim.

We'll let's see, from the second link:

923,000 Number of heroin addicts in the U.S. in 1988
977,000 Number of heroin addicts in 2000

In 1989, USA had approximately 244 million people, and the 2000 census counted 281 million people. In 1988 0,378% of people in the US were addicts, whereas in 2000, 0,348% were addicts. That's a decline as far as I'm concerned.

Funnily enough, all other relevant statistics the link uses are percentages, and none show a trend.

Drug use statistics show that the efforts were fairly effective until about 1991-92, when usage increased again, though not to the same extent as in 1970s:
http://www.whitehousedrugpolicy.gov/publications/factsht/druguse/

Prohibition is a possible model or example. Certainly the Cartel would look for other means of income. Gun running perhaps?

Perhaps, yes.

I would agree to a certain extent. The chaos could present an opportunity to reduce the influence of the cartels. But the U.S. was a huge source of income (as well as guns) for the cartels. The lose of the U.S. market would be a huge, possibly crippleing, loss for the cartels.

Eventually, yes, that is a possibility. But as we discussed earlier, it's quite possible the number of addicts would increase by so much - by about 1% of population, if our poll is to be believed, as about 20% of hard drug users turn abusers - that damage to society would outstrip the damage done by cartels in the long run. In the short term we'd be worse off because the cartels would fight over the few remaining niche markets, and in the long run we could still be worse off by having millions upon millions of new addicts.

Another catch, there would be no way back. With addiction rates three times they are now, enforcing the prohibition would be that much harder.

Any body can grow marijuana. It grows just about anywhere. There is a reason the call it "weed". Cocain and heroin are a bit harder to produce. Getting and growing Coca plants and poppies are a bit harder to obtain. But if you can manage extracting the drug is not difficult. Heck people are smoking salvia these days. Salvia is basicaly the herb sage. And all those drugs have been with man kind since the beggining to. It's just that certain drugs started with different civilization other than the western civilization. They were imported at later times.

And I have stated that I would consider legalizing marijuana.

There are non-intoxicating uses for THC, cocaine, and opiates today.

None of which are remotely comparable to the usefulness of alcohol, especially in 1920s and 30s. I also don't object to using them to produce medicines.

I'd just ask of you to respond to both posts in one post, if you can. It's easier to follow discussion that way :)

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Depending on what you mean by "intact", but yes, none of them are crippling to the society.
That said:
http://www.drugwarfacts.org/cms/?q=node/30

Complications arising from tobacco use are the leading cause of death in the US, with complications arising from alcohol use being third.
You might say the article is from a biased site, and I agree it's not a site I'd like to rely upon, but the general gist is correct: tobacco is a major killer, and so is alcohol. Together they kill over 25 people for each homicide victim in the US, according to this site.
So it would seem that the legal drugs present a much more of a health hazzard than illegal drugs.

Even assuming these numbers were off by an order of magnitude - which is reducing the argument to absurdity - alcohol and tobacco combined kill way more people than all violence put together.
Or drug over doses due to illegal drugs
Compared to this, the war on drugs is truly just a mild ill of the society. But eliminating it risks an explosion of abuse of far more drugs by far more people, leading to even worse results than we currently have.
I seriously doubt an explosion of drug use would result. There would certainly be an initial increase as those who are curious would try them. But there would be an inevitable fall off. This was the case with alcohol use after prohibition. If the Texas report is any indication those who do not use drugs presently will not do so if drugs were made legal. Even the impromptu poll taken here seems to lend a very small support to that notion.
I think alcohol and tobacco would still retain its status as the number one killer drug conbination.


We have statistics that tell us those, I cited them earlier.
Approximately 0,5% of all illicit drug users turn drug abusers. Approximately 23% of all heroin users turn addicts. Approximately 4% of alcohol users become alcoholics (according to http://www.enotalone.com/article/5540.html at least, I don't know how accurate it is). Obviously heroin is more dangerous than alcohol, but combined to soft illicit drugs, it's worse.
However, the numbers are not really comparable, since alcohol is much more socially acceptable and legal, which make alcohol addiction far more likely.
According to this site from the CDC, http://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/alcoholdrug/index.htm , Alcohol use amoungs teens remained steady at 50% amoung teens from 1991 to 1999 and then decreased to 42% percent in 2009. Now this is a decreased use of a legal drug amoung teens. And the use of illegal drugsalso decreased amoung teens also. It would seem that education is a bit more effective than the war on drugs. It would also appear that amoung teens, the use of drugs would not increase significantly if made legal.


That said, a drug war victim represents a far, far, far smaller fraction of society. An innocent drug war victim represents an even tinier subset of that small fraction of society.

http://www.alcoholalert.com/drunk-driving-statistics.html

There were about 13,000 people killed due to drunken driving in the US in 2008. Unfortunately I don't know how many of those were people who drank and drove and how many were people who were a victim of a drunken driver. Still, it's fairly likely the number of people killed by drunken drivers dwarfs the number of innocent victims in the drug war.

If the damage steaming from use of alcohol and tobacco isn't a major ill of the society, then neither is the drug war.
.
I never said the war on drugs was a social ill. I am arguing that the war on drug is not effective in stopping or preventing the use and sale of drugs. The illegality of drugs is indirectly resopnsible for much of the crime and violence associated with drugs.
 
And you also claim the stigma is in no way connected with the crime?
I find that very far-fetched.
No, I said that the stigma had more to do with health issues and the social classes associated with the type of drugs than the illegality. I never said there no connection at all. The wide spread use of illegal drigs and the ease at which they can be obtained indicated that people have little respect for the laws in general.


Do any of these show a comparison between the nicotine, alcohol and caffeine on one side, and heroin and cocaine on the other? This is what you claimed, that they're absolutely no better than heroin and cocaine.
These articles refrence reports indicating that nicotine is at least as addictive as cocaine and heroin. The others articles I linked to in the previous post also make the same claims.
http://www.frostillustrated.com/full.php?sid=1256
http://www.libraryindex.com/pages/2111/Tobacco-What-What-Does-ADDICTIVE-NATURE-NICOTINE.html



ed out why comparison to alcohol prohibition is unfounded. Please explain why you think that is false before making further comparisons to alcohol prohibition.
Prohibition is the only other incident in America where a drug was made illegal and a crime syndicate arose around the illicit sale and use of the illegal drug. The general conditions are the same.

In any stiuation you can only go by a precident event to help make predictions on any other subsequent or similar events. It's called refering to history. It is something that is common to do. Obviously there would some differences but the general conditions are similar.

Please explain why prohibition would not make a valid correlary to the present day situation?



And yet you claim alcohol is no better. But the usage of alcohol isn't declining anywhere near as significantly. Isn't that a contradiction?
I just presented a link that alcohol and illicit drug use has been declining over the years amoung teens.



Perhaps, but keep in mind this is after 40 or so years of intensive conditioning and being spoon-fed that drugs are bad from practically all sources. Making them legal could (and probably would) change this is medium to long term.
I wouldn't expect a swift change. I said this several times now.
This is the power of education i mentioned earlier. I think that is far more successful than making the drugs illegal. (It could also be due to a convergance of eduacation and the growing interest in health)

I think there would be an initial increase followed by a steady decline with occasional spikes. Kind of what's happening now.



Well, you have "upbringing" at 3,5%, "fear what will happen" at 2,5%, "they're wrong, stupid" at 2,3%, "heard about on TV, read about it" at 2%, "illegal" at 1,7%, "socially unacceptable" at 0,8%, "substance not available" at 0,3%, "too expensive" at 0,3%, "job security" at 0,3%, can't afford at 0,2%, "fear of arrest" at 0,1%, "penalties you pay" at 0,1% and "alcohol drug testing" at just under 0,05%. This is a total of over 13% who are at least linked to the war on drugs, if not a direct result of it.

This is quite telling, especially since the primary reason, standing at almost 25%, is "I don't know".
I think this indicates a possible growing disinterest with drugs. Considering technology is giving us more and more distractions than drugs do.

Comparing this study to the poll we had, it's quite possible that an extra 5% of population would use hard drugs, if they were legal.
And then more than likely decline to 3% or 4%



We'll let's see, from the second link:

923,000 Number of heroin addicts in the U.S. in 1988
977,000 Number of heroin addicts in 2000

In 1989, USA had approximately 244 million people, and the 2000 census counted 281 million people. In 1988 0,378% of people in the US were addicts, whereas in 2000, 0,348% were addicts. That's a decline as far as I'm concerned.

Funnily enough, all other relevant statistics the link uses are percentages, and none show a trend.

Drug use statistics show that the efforts were fairly effective until about 1991-92, when usage increased again, though not to the same extent as in 1970s:
http://www.whitehousedrugpolicy.gov/publications/factsht/druguse/
The CDC shows a steady decrease since the 90s.



Eventually, yes, that is a possibility. But as we discussed earlier, it's quite possible the number of addicts would increase by so much - by about 1% of population, if our poll is to be believed, as about 20% of hard drug users turn abusers - that damage to society would outstrip the damage done by cartels in the long run. In the short term we'd be worse off because the cartels would fight over the few remaining niche markets, and in the long run we could still be worse off by having millions upon millions of new addicts.
I doubt If the numbers would be "millions upon millions", but the increased tax revenue could be used to rehabilitate the new addicts. Not to mention increase education efforts to disuade the use of recreational drugs.
 
So it would seem that the legal drugs present a much more of a health hazzard than illegal drugs.

Yes, they do. Many more people use them, after all. Your argument is that this has nothing at all to do with the illegality, or the actual physical harm they do, which makes me wonder what indeed causes it, in your opinion.

Or drug over doses due to illegal drugs
I seriously doubt an explosion of drug use would result. There would certainly be an initial increase as those who are curious would try them. But there would be an inevitable fall off. This was the case with alcohol use after prohibition. If the Texas report is any indication those who do not use drugs presently will not do so if drugs were made legal. Even the impromptu poll taken here seems to lend a very small support to that notion.
I think alcohol and tobacco would still retain its status as the number one killer drug conbination.

Of course they would, at least for a long while. But we should be comparing the damage the drug war and war on drugs do to the society, not the damage caused by the already legal drugs.

According to this site from the CDC, http://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/alcoholdrug/index.htm , Alcohol use amoungs teens remained steady at 50% amoung teens from 1991 to 1999 and then decreased to 42% percent in 2009. Now this is a decreased use of a legal drug amoung teens. And the use of illegal drugsalso decreased amoung teens also. It would seem that education is a bit more effective than the war on drugs. It would also appear that amoung teens, the use of drugs would not increase significantly if made legal.

If you look at other portions of the same source:
Current marijuana use decreased from 27% in 1999 to 21% in 2009.
Lifetime inhalant use decreased from 20% in 1995 to 12% in 2003 and then remained steady from 2003 (12%) to 2009
Lifetime use of ecstasy among high school students decreased from 11% in 2003 to 7% in 2009.
Lifetime use of methamphetamines was steady from 1999 (9%) to 2001 (10%) and then decreased to 4% in 2009.
Hallucinogenic drug use decreased from 13% in 2001 to 8% in 2007 and then remained steady from 2007 (8%) to 2009 (8%).

Alcohol was a following trend towards using less drugs in general. The relative drop in alcohol use was significantly smaller than the drops in other drugs, however. Notice, however, how high alcohol use was compared to any other drug.

Education is a significant part of the war on drugs. It's probably the most effective part of the war on drugs, but don't pretend it's not a part of it. Many, many more people use legal drugs than they use illegal ones. To show this is not in part because of their illegality is a major uphill battle.

I never said the war on drugs was a social ill. I am arguing that the war on drug is not effective in stopping or preventing the use and sale of drugs. The illegality of drugs is indirectly resopnsible for much of the crime and violence associated with drugs.

This makes the war on drugs a social ill. I certainly agree with that, even if you don't. However I remain completely unconvinced this ill is anywhere near as bad as the ill that could (and probably would) befall a country that would legalize some of the currently illicit drugs. Note again, I would consider legalizing marijuana. It's not that bad as far as intoxicants go, and it's one of the most profitable illegal drugs around.

No, I said that the stigma had more to do with health issues and the social classes associated with the type of drugs than the illegality. I never said there no connection at all. The wide spread use of illegal drigs and the ease at which they can be obtained indicated that people have little respect for the laws in general.

But you also said that health issues of heroin and cocaine are comparable to the health issues of alcohol and tobacco. Yet that doesn't seem to be nearly as big factor in their use. Explain, please.

These articles refrence reports indicating that nicotine is at least as addictive as cocaine and heroin. The others articles I linked to in the previous post also make the same claims.
http://www.frostillustrated.com/full.php?sid=1256
http://www.libraryindex.com/pages/21...-NICOTINE.html

The first article is rather weak. Is there a scientific study that would show something to that effect, or just a story, anecdotal evidence?

Note this list in the article:
* The lack of availability of smoking cessation programs in the black community.
* The fact that three out of four African Americans smoke mentholated cigarettes, which smokers tend to inhale more deeply and therefore breath in more chemicals.
* The fact that mentholated cigarettes are marketed in the black community, purposely targeting blacks.
* The fact that, until recently, few organizations that normally defend the rights of African Americans have stood up to say that targeting blacks for the addiction of cigarettes is wrong.

I bolded two parts which are directly tied to cigarettes being legal. According to the article, there are at least two significant reasons the problem is in the drug being legal, easily available and marketed, not it being addictive.

Another thing, you should be citing this report, which was the source for the article:
http://profiles.nlm.nih.gov/NN/B/B/Z/D/_/nnbbzd.pdf

Now to see what the report really says - it does not once state heroin and cocaine are comparably addictive as nicotine. It states the process of addiction is biochemically similar:

The pharmacologic and behavioral processes that determine tobacco addiction are similar to those that determine addiction to drugs such as heroin and cocaine.

But not that the nicotine is as addictive as heroin or cocaine. The article was saying that cigarettes are addictive, not that they're as bad as heroin and cocaine. It just compared them to known addictive drugs to get his point across. Get your sources straight.

The second article basically just states nicotine is addictive, which we covered already. It is addictive, but it's addictiveness and much more importantly, withdrawal effects are nowhere near cocaine and heroin.

Prohibition is the only other incident in America where a drug was made illegal and a crime syndicate arose around the illicit sale and use of the illegal drug. The general conditions are the same.

In any stiuation you can only go by a precident event to help make predictions on any other subsequent or similar events. It's called refering to history. It is something that is common to do. Obviously there would some differences but the general conditions are similar.

Please explain why prohibition would not make a valid correlary to the present day situation?

I actually made this point several times in this thread already, I'll just make a summary.
- marketing for various alcoholic beverages prior to prohibition was still on the minds of the people
- various alcoholic beverages played and still play significant forms of national identity: French are proud of their wines, Germans of their beer etc, the affinity towards national drinks didn't disappear when people came to America
- alcohol at the time was the only strong intoxicant (getting a high dose of nicotine from smoking is impossible, it's eliminated too quickly from the body), and the society unfortunately needs a strong intoxicant
- alcohol is easy to produce, needs no special equipment or chemicals, and there were thousand upon thousands of people who knew just how to do it
- there are plentiful legitimate uses for alcohol, meaning it was still produced and sold, and thus available to anyone desperate enough to get his hands on it
- I could go on, the list is far from exhaustive.

Most importantly, alcohol use was deeply rooted in culture on all levels, from the lowest tramp to the highest of social strata, it's obvious banning it was an exercise in futility. In contrast, currently illegal drugs are limited to the marginal parts of society, and remain a taboo just about everywhere else.

What I've been arguing for a while now, and you might have missed it, is that by making the currently illegal drugs legal, we risk making them acceptable to society. That would certainly lead to greater usage, and it would lead into a situation where backtracking was impossible. That would take time, of course, I'm not arguing demand would jump significantly immediately and remain on high level ever since.

This is the power of education i mentioned earlier. I think that is far more successful than making the drugs illegal. (It could also be due to a convergance of eduacation and the growing interest in health)

Education is not mutually exclusive to illegality. In fact, it's mutually supportive with it. I'd also say education is much more effective if the drugs are also illegal, for many reasons: you can tell kids (who are the most effective target) that these things are bad, and that anyone selling them is a bad man and a criminal. You can't do that if they're sold by a legal vendor. Marketing is another significant factor, it's much easier to enforce a ban on advertising if the drugs are illegal.

I think this indicates a possible growing disinterest with drugs. Considering technology is giving us more and more distractions than drugs do.

Which is good. But again, this is mutually supportive with illegality.

And then more than likely decline to 3% or 4%

Perhaps, but the same drop would occur if the drugs remained illegal during this time, and would more than likely be greater. I covered the other concerns above.

I doubt If the numbers would be "millions upon millions", but the increased tax revenue could be used to rehabilitate the new addicts. Not to mention increase education efforts to disuade the use of recreational drugs.

Doubt it all you want, your personal opinion is no better as evidence than mine is.

As for drug rehabilitation, did you ever look up costs of those? Treating a drug (heroin) addiction costs a few thousand dollars a month (up to $30,000 a month) and can take a long while - up to 6 months. It's expensive and doesn't have an exactly superb track record.

A major problem in any rehab is the risk of relapse. That is easier to control if the drugs aren't offered to the patient whenever he buys groceries, which is a major problem in treating tobacco and alcohol addictions.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
It's worth 100 Mexican lives if one American kid doesn't take that first line of coke.

Haha, so you're not just an ultra-nationalist pro Israeli extremist, it extends to all avenues of life.

1000's of Mexican, Jamaican's, Colombian's etc die as a result of America's multi-trillion dollar drug war, yet those kids are STILL getting that first line of coke, and it cheaper, purer and more readily available than ever before. What does that tell you? Tells me that waging a war against chemical compounds is utter fail.
 
At least 40 people shot here in Chicago over the weekend, most of it because of street gangs fighting over drug turf.

This is far worse than mafia wars during Prohibition ever was, and yet we continue the same stupid drug prohibition policies.


No one is in custody for any of the shootings.
Par for the course in gang shootings. Not like domestic disputes, or other crimes of passion where there's an instant and obvious suspect.
 
Last edited:
At least 40 people shot here in Chicago over the weekend, most of it because of street gangs fighting over drug turf.

Imagine that turf would become a lot smaller overnight. What would you expect to happen?

This is far worse than mafia wars during Prohibition ever was, and yet we continue the same stupid drug prohibition policies.

Yes, repeating the same mantra over and over again and not addressing the points made against it is a very good way of making your point :rolleyes:

McHrozni
 
Unfortunately the war on drugs gives the government way too much money and way too much power. That's why they continue to pursue the war on drugs.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom