So it would seem that the legal drugs present a much more of a health hazzard than illegal drugs.
Yes, they do. Many more people use them, after all. Your argument is that this has nothing at all to do with the illegality, or the actual physical harm they do, which makes me wonder what indeed causes it, in your opinion.
Or drug over doses due to illegal drugs
I seriously doubt an explosion of drug use would result. There would certainly be an initial increase as those who are curious would try them. But there would be an inevitable fall off. This was the case with alcohol use after prohibition. If the Texas report is any indication those who do not use drugs presently will not do so if drugs were made legal. Even the impromptu poll taken here seems to lend a very small support to that notion.
I think alcohol and tobacco would still retain its status as the number one killer drug conbination.
Of course they would, at least for a long while. But we should be comparing the damage the drug war and war on drugs do to the society, not the damage caused by the already legal drugs.
According to this site from the CDC,
http://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/alcoholdrug/index.htm , Alcohol use amoungs teens remained steady at 50% amoung teens from 1991 to 1999 and then decreased to 42% percent in 2009. Now this is a decreased use of a legal drug amoung teens. And the use of illegal drugsalso decreased amoung teens also. It would seem that education is a bit more effective than the war on drugs. It would also appear that amoung teens, the use of drugs would not increase significantly if made legal.
If you look at other portions of the same source:
Current marijuana use decreased from 27% in 1999 to 21% in 2009.
Lifetime inhalant use decreased from 20% in 1995 to 12% in 2003 and then remained steady from 2003 (12%) to 2009
Lifetime use of ecstasy among high school students decreased from 11% in 2003 to 7% in 2009.
Lifetime use of methamphetamines was steady from 1999 (9%) to 2001 (10%) and then decreased to 4% in 2009.
Hallucinogenic drug use decreased from 13% in 2001 to 8% in 2007 and then remained steady from 2007 (8%) to 2009 (8%).
Alcohol was a following trend towards using less drugs in general. The relative drop in alcohol use was significantly smaller than the drops in other drugs, however. Notice, however, how high alcohol use was compared to any other drug.
Education is a significant
part of the war on drugs. It's probably the most effective part of the war on drugs, but don't pretend it's not a part of it. Many, many more people use legal drugs than they use illegal ones. To show this is not in part because of their illegality is a major uphill battle.
I never said the war on drugs was a social ill. I am arguing that the war on drug is not effective in stopping or preventing the use and sale of drugs. The illegality of drugs is indirectly resopnsible for much of the crime and violence associated with drugs.
This makes the war on drugs a social ill. I certainly agree with that, even if you don't. However I remain completely unconvinced this ill is anywhere near as bad as the ill that could (and probably would) befall a country that would legalize some of the currently illicit drugs. Note again, I would consider legalizing marijuana. It's not that bad as far as intoxicants go, and it's one of the most profitable illegal drugs around.
No, I said that the stigma had more to do with health issues and the social classes associated with the type of drugs than the illegality. I never said there no connection at all. The wide spread use of illegal drigs and the ease at which they can be obtained indicated that people have little respect for the laws in general.
But you also said that health issues of heroin and cocaine are comparable to the health issues of alcohol and tobacco. Yet that doesn't seem to be nearly as big factor in their use. Explain, please.
These articles refrence reports indicating that nicotine is at least as addictive as cocaine and heroin. The others articles I linked to in the previous post also make the same claims.
http://www.frostillustrated.com/full.php?sid=1256
http://www.libraryindex.com/pages/21...-NICOTINE.html
The first article is rather weak. Is there a scientific study that would show something to that effect, or just a story, anecdotal evidence?
Note this list in the article:
* The lack of availability of smoking cessation programs in the black community.
*
The fact that three out of four African Americans smoke mentholated cigarettes, which smokers tend to inhale more deeply and therefore breath in more chemicals.
*
The fact that mentholated cigarettes are marketed in the black community, purposely targeting blacks.
* The fact that, until recently, few organizations that normally defend the rights of African Americans have stood up to say that targeting blacks for the addiction of cigarettes is wrong.
I bolded two parts which are directly tied to cigarettes being legal. According to the article, there are at least two significant reasons the problem is in the drug being legal, easily available and marketed, not it being addictive.
Another thing, you should be citing this report, which was the source for the article:
http://profiles.nlm.nih.gov/NN/B/B/Z/D/_/nnbbzd.pdf
Now to see what the report really says - it does not once state heroin and cocaine are comparably addictive as nicotine. It states the process of addiction is biochemically similar:
The pharmacologic and behavioral processes that determine tobacco addiction are similar to those that determine addiction to drugs such as heroin and cocaine.
But not that the nicotine is as addictive as heroin or cocaine. The article was saying that cigarettes are addictive, not that they're as bad as heroin and cocaine. It just compared them to known addictive drugs to get his point across. Get your sources straight.
The second article basically just states nicotine is addictive, which we covered already. It is addictive, but it's addictiveness and much more importantly, withdrawal effects are nowhere near cocaine and heroin.
Prohibition is the only other incident in America where a drug was made illegal and a crime syndicate arose around the illicit sale and use of the illegal drug. The general conditions are the same.
In any stiuation you can only go by a precident event to help make predictions on any other subsequent or similar events. It's called refering to history. It is something that is common to do. Obviously there would some differences but the general conditions are similar.
Please explain why prohibition would not make a valid correlary to the present day situation?
I actually made this point several times in this thread already, I'll just make a summary.
- marketing for various alcoholic beverages prior to prohibition was still on the minds of the people
- various alcoholic beverages played and still play significant forms of national identity: French are proud of their wines, Germans of their beer etc, the affinity towards national drinks didn't disappear when people came to America
- alcohol at the time was the only strong intoxicant (getting a high dose of nicotine from smoking is impossible, it's eliminated too quickly from the body), and the society unfortunately needs a strong intoxicant
- alcohol is easy to produce, needs no special equipment or chemicals, and there were thousand upon thousands of people who knew just how to do it
- there are plentiful legitimate uses for alcohol, meaning it was still produced and sold, and thus available to anyone desperate enough to get his hands on it
- I could go on, the list is far from exhaustive.
Most importantly, alcohol use was deeply rooted in culture on all levels, from the lowest tramp to the highest of social strata, it's obvious banning it was an exercise in futility. In contrast, currently illegal drugs are limited to the marginal parts of society, and remain a taboo just about everywhere else.
What I've been arguing for a while now, and you might have missed it, is that by making the currently illegal drugs legal, we risk making them acceptable to society. That would certainly lead to greater usage, and it would lead into a situation where backtracking was impossible. That would take time, of course, I'm not arguing demand would jump significantly immediately and remain on high level ever since.
This is the power of education i mentioned earlier. I think that is far more successful than making the drugs illegal. (It could also be due to a convergance of eduacation and the growing interest in health)
Education is not mutually exclusive to illegality. In fact, it's mutually supportive with it. I'd also say education is much more effective if the drugs are also illegal, for many reasons: you can tell kids (who are the most effective target) that these things are bad, and that anyone selling them is a bad man and a criminal. You can't do that if they're sold by a legal vendor. Marketing is another significant factor, it's much easier to enforce a ban on advertising if the drugs are illegal.
I think this indicates a possible growing disinterest with drugs. Considering technology is giving us more and more distractions than drugs do.
Which is good. But again, this is mutually supportive with illegality.
And then more than likely decline to 3% or 4%
Perhaps, but the same drop would occur if the drugs remained illegal during this time, and would more than likely be greater. I covered the other concerns above.
I doubt If the numbers would be "millions upon millions", but the increased tax revenue could be used to rehabilitate the new addicts. Not to mention increase education efforts to disuade the use of recreational drugs.
Doubt it all you want, your personal opinion is no better as evidence than mine is.
As for drug rehabilitation, did you ever look up costs of those? Treating a drug (heroin) addiction costs a few thousand dollars a month (up to $30,000 a month) and can take a long while - up to 6 months. It's expensive and doesn't have an exactly superb track record.
A major problem in any rehab is the risk of relapse. That is easier to control if the drugs aren't offered to the patient whenever he buys groceries, which is a major problem in treating tobacco and alcohol addictions.
McHrozni