The War on Drugs is Useless

You've provided nothing but your say so.

That's a lie. I'm sorry, I can't say anything else.

I, on the other hand have historical precedent.

For which I explained several times why it isn't a very good precedent to begin with.

But an addict can quit if he wants to. A slave can't quit being a slave.

Not true on both counts, I'm afraid. Quitting hard drugs is a very difficult and often very expensive process, with failure rates ranging from 80% to 98%.

Slave, on the other hand, can either escape or be bought by someone else and freed.

Unknowable. But it is a fact that the black market gets people killed.

If, and only if, you assume the criminals currently peddling drugs would be ordinary, law-abiding citizens otherwise. Obviously if you only count the bad sides of the war on drugs, ignore the positives and ignore the fact not all crime related to war on drugs is directly caused by it, drug legislation seems like a very good alternative.

But then again, this is a view which is so one-sided and so biased it really doesn't deserve a first glance, let alone a second one.

Actually, studies show that nicotine is as addictive as heroin.

No, they don't. A 1988 report by US Surgeon General states the process of nicotine addiction is biochemically similar to the process of heroin addiction, saying tobacco is addictive, not just a bad habit. It says nothing of potency of the addiction. This was pointed out before.

Secondly, you do realize there is a major difference between getting (easily) addicted to something (which is what the report was about) and the withdrawal symptoms of an addiction, right? If you don't please make a note of that first, because I was talking about the latter

And there are many drunks who are just as addicted as any junkie. And alcohol withdrawal is probably worse than heroin. You can actually die.

I have not once heard of a smoker or a drunk killing anybody to feed his addiction.

You do realize you're directly contradicting yourself here, right?

In regards to alcohol withdrawal, it can be treated effectively with various medicines and even alcohol itself.
Heroin withdrawal can be marginally treated with methadone, the efficiency being about 20-30% in most cases, and the treatment must be maintained indefinitely. You can't say alcohol is worse in this regard, destroying your point even further.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
People don't kill to buy tobacco or alcohol. I have never once heard of a pharmacist shooting another pharmacist to take over their territory. People don't break into Starbucks to get an espresso at 2:00 AM.

They certainly did in the 1920s when alcohol was illegal. It was called Prohibition...



Just proving a point :)
 
They certainly did in the 1920s when alcohol was illegal. It was called Prohibition...

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_77474bfd3c4158052.jpg[/qimg]

Just proving a point :)

An excellent demonstration.

Of course, people will correctly make the argument that we shouldn't legalize something simply because criminals kill over it. But when it come drugs, one of the arguments is that it should be illegal is because of all the violence. It gets a bit circular.

Another argument is that drugs are bad for you. I won't argue against the notion that drugs are generally unhealthy, but that's really not a justification for making them illegal. Driving without a seatbelt can get you killed, so I can see the justification for the law (may not agree even though I was a seat belt fanatic before the laws went into effect). Thing is, the penalty is not that severe. It's just a fine.

What's happened with drugs is that the penalties are far worse than the damage they cause. Geez, if you grow some pot in your back yard so you and your wife can get stoned and watch Benny Hill reruns, they want to throw you in jail and take away your house. I'm sorry, but that's just whacked.

There's a limit to how far the government should go to protect people from themselves. The war on drugs has far exceeded that limit. In the process they have created an associated climate of violence because the profits are so high. ****, meth is like $300 to $400 per gram on the street while the wholesale price is 1/10th that.

Think about the wholesalers. They are buying their ingredients and production materials at retail prices and working in makeshift, labor-intensive labs. This is horribly inefficient production. I bet Pfizer could make it a hell of a lot cheaper and Walgreens would have a much lower mark-up.

It costs, what, $18K per year to keep somebody in jail? How much do we spend on law enforcement? How much higher are insurance rates because of associated crimes? How many drug dealers in emergency rooms have health insurance to cover their surgeries to remove bullets? The costs for non-drug users are astounding, and the money drug users spend is not taxed.

The best argument against legalizing drugs is the concern over people with serious addiction problems. Well, let's spend some of the money we save on that. More addicts if it's legalized? Fine. We still have plenty of money to spend on education and support programs. It will be a helluva lot cheaper, and we can use the money from drug taxes to fund the programs.

But let's face it: This is a morality issue. It really does boil down to people just not liking the idea of people getting high just like we're not big on people getting drunk - we just have more tolerance for the latter. Everything else is a justification for the position that it's immoral. Pragmatically speaking, there would be far less actual harm with legalized drugs.

If it ever happens, I think it will come from the conservatives. The one thing that competes most heavily with their morality concerns is their fiscal concerns. If I were an activist, that's how I would sell it. I would concede the immoral issue or at least not argue against it. I would go full tilt on the fiscal concerns and try to get a companies like Pfizer and R.J. Reynolds to explain how they could make the stuff far cheaper and generate legitimate jobs and tax dollars.
 
Hm, something I missed, then. Do you have a link?

McHrozni

I should have included the link originally:

Mexico Legalizes Drug Possession
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/21/world/americas/21mexico.html

Mexico Decriminalizes Small-Scale Drug Possession
http://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory?id=8379990

Heroin and cocaine now legal in Mexico – in small doses
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/w...l-in-mexico-ndash-in-small-doses-1776792.html

'High'-minded Mexican Drug Laws
http://www.nypost.com/p/news/intern...N;jsessionid=6F063D0FA671E25A6E572526511271FA
 
Because the current thugs and gang members wouldn't become law-abiding citizens, but would seek out other means of illicit income.
Such as?

With the money and weapons already bought they could sustain a lot for a while. In the long run, their recruitment might be impacted by the lower revenues, but even that isn't certain.
Sustain a lot of what? Fighting for drug territory which doesn't exist?

Or maybe they weren't made illegal until the problems I fear began to materialize?
No, they wewre made illegal during the temperance movement which also banned alcohol.

Marijuana was made illegal primarily due to racism against blacks and Mexicans.

Seriously though if you want to keep arguing that we should only look at murders and ignore all other factors you might as well stop posting here. I made this point several times: the damage to society from cheaply and available intoxicants can be greater than the damage done by criminals running business from those intoxicants.
I suppose you could claim that in theory, but you'd be hard-pressed to show it in fact.

That doesn't mean we should ban all intoxicants any more than it means we should permit all of them. We need a reasonable policy, accept some damage from milder ones (like tobacco, alcohol, marijuana and maybe some others), but we're probably better off with fighting the more severe ones through a strict policy of banning them.

Near as I can tell, no one has attempted to even address that point.

McHrozni
If you ban something that's popular it's a losing battle for everyone.
 
A couple of years ago, one of the NPR programs I listened to cited a study of the greater Detroit area which found that enormous amounts of money moved through the vicinity due to the drug trade.
In this economically hard-hit area, it was the drug trade that was keeping the area running. The mom and pop stores, beauty parlors, barbers, fast-food joints, etc. were all being kept running as a result of the cash flow from drugs.
This is likely the case in a number of big-city and even rural areas, perhaps made even worse by widespread unemployment currently. (the study was some years old at the time I heard the program)
So...Perhaps the fears of increases in other forms of crime might well have some foundation. We are currently seeing a rather high incidence of what might be called "subsistence" crimes, intended to generate enough cash to keep things together.
Dumpster-diving for scrap and metals, stripping abandoned and foreclosed homes of copper tubing and electrical wire, breaking into cars for such items as might be found...
These are not lucrative crimes for the people committing them; they only get a tiny percentage of the value of the stolen items. Far less than the damage caused.
 

We covered that before. Certainly, racketeering, peddling drugs at a cheaper rate than official vendors, kidnappings, burglary, fraud, robbery, gun smuggling, etc don't fetch nearly as good income as drug smuggling currently does, but I would expect a rise in all of them.

This was pointed out to you before.

Sustain a lot of what? Fighting for drug territory which doesn't exist?

See above.

No, they wewre made illegal during the temperance movement which also banned alcohol.

A very, very rough estimate indeed. Not to mention most drugs were made illegal well before alcohol.

I suppose you could claim that in theory, but you'd be hard-pressed to show it in fact.

Actually I don't see why I should. Given the huge policy shift this would take, it could easily be argued the burden of proof is onto you to prove it won't result in much, much worse consequences.

If you ban something that's popular it's a losing battle for everyone.

Really. In Greece, not paying taxes is very popular, and look at where the non-enforcement of those laws brought them.

McHrozni
 
Name a country where money and connections don't influence the course of the law.

Maybe North Korea, there connections influence the course of money and maybe even law, but your money is irrelevant to your influence on law ;)

Grasping at straws, I know :)

McHrozni
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom