The War on Drugs is Useless

what do you mean with , we are doing it already with pharmaceuticals?

Most medicines that get developed aren't permitted to be sold as such, because of side effects. And yet, we still permit some medicines, even though they too have some side effects.

McHrozni
 
Most medicines that get developed aren't permitted to be sold as such, because of side effects. And yet, we still permit some medicines, even though they too have some side effects.

McHrozni

i dont think that is correct, i had the impression that most developed medicine get permitted. but dont have numbers, maybe im wrong.
 
You already did that with the question which had nothing to do with the war on drugs. You asked about a substance that would change a persons' behavior, assumed it would be illegal and asked who would take it anyway.

I imagine some would take it, but your assumption that it would be illegal is unfounded. It might be, if the changes in behavior would change the person to the point he or she would be unrecognizable, or it might be heavily controlled. If it was highly addictive or it had other nefarious side effects, it could also be illegal.
Heroin isn't illegal because it gives you a rush, it's illegal because it's highly addictive and has other negative impacts on your health.

McHrozni


My bad. It was an obnoxious post.
 
i dont think that is correct, i had the impression that most developed medicine get permitted. but dont have numbers, maybe im wrong.

If by "most developed" you mean "the ones with the lest side effects" then sure, although this is a major simplification.
The main sticking point is do the risks posed by the drug outweigh the benefits? That's why you have outright dangerous drugs being administered to caner patients, because there is no better way to cure an otherwise lethal disease, but you can't get heroin as a cough drop any more.

High standards in medicine regulation are one of the main reasons why medicine research is so expensive - much of it will result in dead ends.

McHrozni
 
If by "most developed" you mean "the ones with the lest side effects" then sure, although this is a major simplification.
The main sticking point is do the risks posed by the drug outweigh the benefits? That's why you have outright dangerous drugs being administered to caner patients, because there is no better way to cure an otherwise lethal disease, but you can't get heroin as a cough drop any more.

High standards in medicine regulation are one of the main reasons why medicine research is so expensive - much of it will result in dead ends.

McHrozni

no, i think most medicines in developement will get permission.

but how would you do that with drugs like Heroine or crack? have big studies with propants on drugs for a long time?
 
no, i think most medicines in developement will get permission.

You might be of that opinion. That opinion is wrong. An average of 1 out of 1000 newly developed drugs will reach clinical trial stage, and around 60% (a very rough estimate) of those are removed in each of the three steps of clinical trials. This gives you a grant total of approximately 1 in 5000 developed medicines getting approved, not counting the ones that get withdrawn after being approved (which are few).

but how would you do that with drugs like Heroine or crack? have big studies with propants on drugs for a long time?

Clearly, no. The studies that have been already performed would suffice to ensure neither could be sold as a medicine.

McHrozni
 
You might be of that opinion. That opinion is wrong. An average of 1 out of 1000 newly developed drugs will reach clinical trial stage, and around 60% (a very rough estimate) of those are removed in each of the three steps of clinical trials. This gives you a grant total of approximately 1 in 5000 developed medicines getting approved, not counting the ones that get withdrawn after being approved (which are few).



Clearly, no. The studies that have been already performed would suffice to ensure neither could be sold as a medicine.

McHrozni

source for your numbers?

and the idea was never to sell drugs as medicine :s how did you come there?
 
source for your numbers?

Ever heard of Wikipedia?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clinical_trial#Length
I also found this on Google:
http://bmartinmd.com/2008/03/clinical-trial-phases-what-are.html

and the idea was never to sell drugs as medicine :s how did you come there?

Well, aside from that heroin was initially marketed as a cough drop, there is a very good argument against legalization of narcotics right here: how do you maintain some medicines are illegal because of side effects, if you're permitting the sales of narcotics with far worse side effects, who also don't have any noteworthy medical benefits?

McHrozni
 
The non-medical "benefits" of drugs are so big that it is impossible to enforce a ban.
And the attempts of enforcements gives worse side effects than the drugs themselves.
 
This is a complete lie. Your source cites this report which only states "More than 132,000 persons died as a consequence of alcohol and drug problems in 1992. Of these deaths, 107,400 were related to alcohol abuse and 25,500 were related to drug abuse."

"Related to"... you know what that includes? AIDS deaths if the infection was from sharing an infected needle, likewise tuberculosis and hepatitis, suicides by overdosing on either legal or illegal drugs, and other such factors.

In fact, the single greatest contributors to that number are hepatitis (8,000 to 12,000 annually) and AIDS deaths, which accounted for over 10,000 cases per year at the time of the study.

These deaths would not be happening if the drug use was legalized and regulated. Your "fact" is bogus.

Goalpost shift. You said "The people who sell them are more dangerous than the drugs themselves." Your fact was bogus.
 
i dont think that is correct, i had the impression that most developed medicine get permitted. but dont have numbers, maybe im wrong.

21.5% of drugs actually make it to market, with billions and billions spent on researching drugs that don't make it to market.

http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php?record_id=11975&page=1
In recent years, the costs of new drug development have skyrocketed. The average cost of developing a new approved drug is now estimated to be $1.3 billion (DiMasi and Grabowski, 2007). At the same time, each year fewer new molecular entities (NMEs) are approved. DiMasi and Grabowski report that only 21.5 percent of the candidate drugs that enter phase I clinical testing actually make it to market.

My emphasis.
 
Goalpost shift. You said "The people who sell them are more dangerous than the drugs themselves." Your fact was bogus.

Actually, his fact was that legalization could save lives. Your stats helped him with that argument by pointing out all the ills caused by prohibition. It isn't just the murders. Thanks for the additional statistical backup.

I think the larger point is that prohibition causes more problems than it solves. Our drug policy needs reform. I guess some here would like to just open the gates, but I think most would be happy if we just took steps to a more rational policy. If we could just move away from the Reefer Madness mentality I think most people would be happy.

As McH has conceded, marijuana should be legalized, there is simply not rational drug policy that allows for smoking tobacco and alcohol use, but not pot. Most of the pot heads I know make more money than me and would be happy not to expose themselves to the criminal element to get their pot. A higher price would be fine if they could get legalization and quality assurance. That is your window for regulation. Replace the violence with oversight. There is room there for a tax that would pay for oversight and health care aspects.

When you get to harder drugs there will be more resistance, even from me. I understand that coke can be safer if you have more quality control. Still, I would something more than an age restriction. Maybe a registration system along the lines of handgun licenses. I'm just riffing here, but something that keeps track of who can buy and who can't, what they are buying and how often. Sure, there would be a gray market, but nothing like the black market we have now.

Heroin and crack are far harder for me. Over time I would be open to reasonably regulated markets for each, but I would require stricter regulation for more dangerous drugs. It is what we do with pharmaceuticals and we should find a way to do this for recreational drugs.

But really, once you start heading down this road you cut the legs off the the gangs. Sure they will still exist, but you would diminish their power. How much money can you really make off of a protection racket in this day and age? That sort of thing requires a lot more work per dollar than illegal drugs.

Once again, I would point you to Law Enforcement Against Prohibition. They are far more eloquent than I.

"Drug Abuse is bad. The Drug War is worse." - LEAP
 
I was told that there used to be a police sergeant here who would sell it in the park late at night out of the trunk of his patrol car.

The only people that have better drugs than cops are the people the cops stole the drugs from. Christ, I hope that isn't an upsetting bit of the math.

In small town Appalachia, you tend to know who your daddy is and such.
I am fortunate to live in a part of the U.S. that is protected by "big government", even as we complain about their abortion campaign thingy; garf; Sarah P." barf; teabagger-babtists, creationist cousin-****ers, to put it bluntly.

Th National guard spends enormous $ to train helicopter pilots to fly over my land...twice a year; every year...looking for pot.

I got so bored with their ineptitude, I left easy to get plants out for them.
They landed; on my land; several times.
They took the puny bait I left for them, god bless us all.

And they waived at us! And flew off, into the wild-blue yonder!

Pictures of the pathetic plants show up on the cover of the local right wing rag of a newspaper. Like a body count.

Like we may be winning the war on drugs; you bastards.
Church ladies give their blessings.

No one on earth is strong enough to go up against the church ladies of Appalachia.

I don't even bother growing pot anymore. I don't need the money, and I don't like being stoned.

Can you big city slickers even grasp this phenomena?

Small town Appalachia.
Forced to grow pot for the war effort, against their will.
Navy needed rope.

My farm was one of these experiments, way back.
Meanwhile, Kentucky gets all holy. You can't buy liquor where I live. Nor in any of the surrounding counties.

But dig this, good people:

What do we do here in this rand paul, bible thumping state?

We do whiskey and bourbon, in vast quantitie; even in dry counties.
We do world class pot growing, which supports the local economies, and all the wannabe-sheriffs know this. Their daddies were major bootleggers.

We do gambling. Horse racing, to be specific.
We're all holy about the other forms of gambling, which take place in your face, at any and every convenience store in my county.

We make meth here, too....lots of it. Horrible meth. Lots of busts; lots of dumb-ass chemists; amazing propaganda about the toxic threat that, frankly, is coming from the farm supply store.

We also buy oxycontin from slease-bag md's from florida.
We are also obese.

Its truly pathetic people.
I've done time in a federal pen.

I've never met anything more evil than the church ladies that run the mill of repressed sin in Appalachia.



(Whoo, boy...I hope I don't regret this tomorrow..)


Its just that hypocrisy wrankles my ass worster than anythingy.
 
Seeing the massacre on Jamaica, another issue rises up: even if drugs were legalized, would that affect the drug war fought in the drug-providing countries at all? That's where most of the deaths take place.

I for one am not convinced it would even help, let alone solve the problem. There is no reason to expect it would. For example, African diamond mines have been known to support various rebel groups in the past, even using slave labor. It's not the only example by any means.
Why should we expect the drug lords to suddenly act any different?

McHrozni
 
Seeing the massacre on Jamaica, another issue rises up: even if drugs were legalized, would that affect the drug war fought in the drug-providing countries at all? That's where most of the deaths take place.

I for one am not convinced it would even help, let alone solve the problem. There is no reason to expect it would. For example, African diamond mines have been known to support various rebel groups in the past, even using slave labor. It's not the only example by any means.
Why should we expect the drug lords to suddenly act any different?

McHrozni

i dont know, but could it be that the criminality and especially violence comes from the whole bussines already beeing illegal. with that i mena, this bussines atracts violent criminals.

why would it be diffrent from Alcohol or Tabaco factories?
why do tabaco factoires fight no bloody wars? or Whiskey producers?
 
i dont know, but could it be that the criminality and especially violence comes from the whole bussines already beeing illegal. with that i mena, this bussines atracts violent criminals.

Perhaps. The said violent criminals already own the business. What reason is there to believe they would become law-abiding citizens?

why would it be diffrent from Alcohol or Tabaco factories?
why do tabaco factoires fight no bloody wars? or Whiskey producers?

For one, because all of the raw material production is already presided over by criminals. In the case of cocaine, this is in no small part because the production is limited by climate, much more so than tobacco or grains and fruit used to produce alcohol.

I'm sure the Taliban would suffer from competition, though if they could provide the opium at a lower price, much less so.

McHrozni
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom