The War on Drugs is Useless

Even without drugs, there is still plentiful money in organized crime. They would have to do more to get it, that is true. In the short to medium term, I would expect a rise in other forms of organized crime, because they already have henchmen, bribed cops, guns and a stock of money to run this for a while. In the long run, organized crime might be reduced.

Sure organized crime will always be around, but there is far more money in drugs than there is in anything else. Do you honestly think that these drug gangs would have the money and power to threaten governments if not for drug prohibition?

On the other hand, in the medium to long term, a significant rise in drug use is also possible, if not likely. If that does more damage than the gang violence, who are you to say that option is the better one?

Easy. One can choose to not ruining one's life with drugs by not doing them or doing them in moderation. It's not hard to do even heroin or cocaine in moderation. One can't choose to not be murdered by a drug dealer.


By priced correctly, you mean cheap, right?

Yeah.
 
So you're saying the situation we have right now is the better choice?

It wasn't all that good back in the 20s

There are at least 4 people using alcohol for each person using illicit drugs of any kind. Why are so few people using illicit drugs compared to legal ones, if not because of the war on drugs?

McHrozni
 
Sure organized crime will always be around, but there is far more money in drugs than there is in anything else. Do you honestly think that these drug gangs would have the money and power to threaten governments if not for drug prohibition?

They might, it depends on how strong the national police force would be and so on. Probably not in the US, but in central and south America, they might.

Easy. One can choose to not ruining one's life with drugs by not doing them or doing them in moderation. It's not hard to do even heroin or cocaine in moderation. One can't choose to not be murdered by a drug dealer.

One can't choose not to be murdered by a drug addict out for drug money, either. I said if the damage to the society were greater from a greater number of drug users, who are you to say this situation is better, didn't I?

I also find it funny how you're able to claim drug dealers don't murder people for the fun of it, but also claim one can't choose not to be murdered by a drug dealer. Sure you can. Don't deal with them.


Cool.

McHrozni
 
Let's see, affect thier profits by destroying thier fields, supply lines, and distribution system which serves to drive up the price of thier commodity. Protecting thier profits is rather easy. Bribery, assainations, very little competition due to the violent nature of the system. Targets are few and easy to reach.


Now attacking thier profits by swamping the market with a multitude of producers and vendors in countries where they have no influence. The increase of product in the market and the competition of the free market would drop the price of the commodity.

Exactly how would they protect thier profit in that system using violence and coersion?

Except maybe bribeing, I mean, providing campaign contributions to, U.S. congressmen to keep the drug war going. Lord knows there's a whole bunch of money to be made there.

I suppose they couldn't coerce farmers not to produce the necessary crops, then. I'm sure various church groups would help with that, wittingly or not. Lobbying could play a part as well, especially on the state level, banning or regulating some crops to the point farmers would just produce something else and so on. It could also be done on the federal level, as you said.

Why do you assume none of the current problems with, well, everything somehow wouldn't apply to drugs?

Mchrozni
 
They might, it depends on how strong the national police force would be and so on. Probably not in the US, but in central and south America, they might.

I don't see how they possibly could. The only reason these gangs have so much power is because they have a lot of money. Money that comes from richer countries, like the USA. With drugs legal they wouldn't have this money and thus not the power.

One can't choose not to be murdered by a drug addict out for drug money, either. I said if the damage to the society were greater from a greater number of drug users, who are you to say this situation is better, didn't I?

Hmmm, I wonder in which system this is more likely to happen. One where a drug habit can be very expensive because they are illegal? Or one where an addict can fund his addiction cheaply and legally?


I also find it funny how you're able to claim drug dealers don't murder people for the fun of it, but also claim one can't choose not to be murdered by a drug dealer. Sure you can. Don't deal with them.

I take it you believe that innocent people never get killed in the crossfire?
 
There are at least 4 people using alcohol for each person using illicit drugs of any kind. Why are so few people using illicit drugs compared to legal ones, if not because of the war on drugs?

McHrozni

Different question. Are you saying the growing violence and governmental unrest in a niegboring country, not to mention the gang violence and turf wars on this side of the border, is better than an increased amount of drug use?

But to answer you question, I don't think the war on drugs has as big an effect on the amount of drug used today as you think. Drugs are easily available on the street dispite the war on drugs.
I know exactly where to go to get a bag of dope right now, if I were still a user. I don't use illict drugs today, not because it is illegal or the fear of getting caught by the law, but because I choose not to use them any more. I no longer have any interest in them anymore. I don't even drink alcohol or smoke tobacco either.

I think a significant reason that illicit drug use is not as high as tobacco or alcohol use is because there is a certain amount of social stigma associated with drug use that has nothing to do with the legality or illegality of recreational drugs.

This goes back to the days before recreational drugs like opium, cocaine and marijuana were considered controlled substances. Opium den patrons and "rope smokers" were not looked too highly upon in those days because of the effect the drugs had on the users and that these particular types of drugs were associated with immigrants and "inferior" cultures.

Alcohol and tobacco were more socialbly acceptable. I would venture that this is because of the history that alcohol has with mainstream (or western) civilization. And Tobacco was a huge (still is) source of income for America

It is a fact that a large number of the populace were once unwitting cocaine users. Cocaine was an ingrediant in Coca Cola. Poppy seeds also contain an insignificant amounnt of opiates in them.

And today, dispite Americas love affair with drug use during the 60s and 70s, drug use still carries with it a social stigma.

Drug use has lost it's cache with the general public. People don't bat an eye any more when they see a character in a movie smoke a joint (usually the "good guy"). The" bad guys" are usually seen snorting a line. ( can think of two movies off the top of my head. Marijuana use by the good guys in Zombie land and cocaine use by the bad guy in Kick Ass.)

Some of the social associations are still there.
 
Last edited:
I suppose they couldn't coerce farmers not to produce the necessary crops, then.
Not in a country where they have no influence. I don't think the Mexican or South American cartels have any say over what crop a Taliban farmer grows in Afghanistan, do you?
I'm sure various church groups would help with that, wittingly or not.
Well, church groups did manage to get prohibition passed....for a short time.
Lobbying could play a part as well, especially on the state level, banning or regulating some crops to the point farmers would just produce something else and so on. It could also be done on the federal level, as you said.
True, But the drug cartels won't be the only lobbists competeing for the congressman's favors.


Why do you assume none of the current problems with, well, everything somehow wouldn't apply to drugs?

Mchrozni
The playing field would change significantly. There would be more players that are more image friendy, less criminaly associated, and have better marketing strategies than say an "evil" drug cartel.

Drug cartels make good drug cartels, I don't know how well they would manage in today's image concious free market system.
 
I don't see how they possibly could. The only reason these gangs have so much power is because they have a lot of money. Money that comes from richer countries, like the USA. With drugs legal they wouldn't have this money and thus not the power.

Perhaps. Or perhaps they could put their money not in gold-plated guns and such, but into something more sinister, like a coup. Do you deny that is a possibility in many countries in Latin America?

Hmmm, I wonder in which system this is more likely to happen. One where a drug habit can be very expensive because they are illegal? Or one where an addict can fund his addiction cheaply and legally?

Since there are at least four alcohol users for each drug user, I'd say it's the latter.

I take it you believe that innocent people never get killed in the crossfire?

Rarely. But would the several times higher addiction levels lead to a lower number of innocent deaths? I don't think so.

McHrozni
 
Perhaps. Or perhaps they could put their money not in gold-plated guns and such, but into something more sinister, like a coup. Do you deny that is a possibility in many countries in Latin America?

FARC, for example is already trying to overthrow the government. So is the Taliban. And it is a fact that they would have less money and thus less power if prohibitionists didn't give them such an easy way to gain it.

Since there are at least four alcohol users for each drug user, I'd say it's the latter.

Non sequitur.

Rarely. But would the several times higher addiction levels lead to a lower number of innocent deaths? I don't think so.

"Several time higher addiction rates" is completely unfounded. In any case, you wouldn't have addicts committing crimes to get money for drugs if they were legal (and cheap).
 
FARC, for example is already trying to overthrow the government. So is the Taliban. And it is a fact that they would have less money and thus less power if prohibitionists didn't give them such an easy way to gain it.

I'm having my doubts about FARC's sincerity. They might be just in for the easy money. But I was more thinking along the likes of Bolivia, Chile, Nicaragua perhaps even Mexico ...

"Several time higher addiction rates" is completely unfounded. In any case, you wouldn't have addicts committing crimes to get money for drugs if they were legal (and cheap).

There are at least four times as many alcohol users as there are illicit drug users. You also advocate a substantial drop in drug prices. Why are substantially higher addiction rates completely unfounded?

Doesn't a lower price mean at least a good possibility more people would use (currently) illicit drugs in your world? Why not, explain please, as it goes against virtually all our economic models and experience.

Why doesn't a working model of alcohol work for (currently) illicit drugs? What are the key differences? Unless you can explain, thoroughly and in detail, why this can't be reasonably used as a model, we can't carry on the discussion.

McHrozni
 
Not in a country where they have no influence. I don't think the Mexican or South American cartels have any say over what crop a Taliban farmer grows in Afghanistan, do you?

The argument was that most drugs would be produced in the US. There are narco cartels in the US, aren't there? They would be quite interested in keeping the business.

Well, church groups did manage to get prohibition passed....for a short time. True, But the drug cartels won't be the only lobbists competeing for the congressman's favors.

True. There will also be the beforementioned church groups, which would support them, plus many people who aren't members of either of the two, but strongly disagree with your simplistic view and consequently with your conclusions (like me).

The playing field would change significantly. There would be more players that are more image friendy, less criminaly associated, and have better marketing strategies than say an "evil" drug cartel.

That should be a concern. Drugs would be more accepted in a society, and significantly wider usage is highly likely. That could easily lead to a significantly more damage to society than drug cartels could ever do.

McHrozni
 
Different question. Are you saying the growing violence and governmental unrest in a niegboring country, not to mention the gang violence and turf wars on this side of the border, is better than an increased amount of drug use?

If the increased amount of drug use is significant enough, then yes, certainly.

I think a significant reason that illicit drug use is not as high as tobacco or alcohol use is because there is a certain amount of social stigma associated with drug use that has nothing to do with the legality or illegality of recreational drugs.

I agree, stigma plays a significant role. So what is the source of this stigma?
You're saying it's not illegality and it's not persecution. It was stated earlier it's not physical harm either. So what is it?

This goes back to the days before recreational drugs like opium, cocaine and marijuana were considered controlled substances. Opium den patrons and "rope smokers" were not looked too highly upon in those days because of the effect the drugs had on the users and that these particular types of drugs were associated with immigrants and "inferior" cultures.

Alcohol and tobacco were more socialbly acceptable. I would venture that this is because of the history that alcohol has with mainstream (or western) civilization. And Tobacco was a huge (still is) source of income for America

It is a fact that a large number of the populace were once unwitting cocaine users. Cocaine was an ingrediant in Coca Cola. Poppy seeds also contain an insignificant amounnt of opiates in them.

Wait. You're saying that the stigma comes from the fact that decades ago, the said drugs were part of society that was looked down upon, and that at the same time a significant number of people were using cocaine. That's usually called a contradiction you know.

Hint for you, look at why Coca Cola was developed in the first place. People used to drink cocaine-fortified wine, you see, and alternative to wine was sought. Cocaine use used to be fairly common, and not associated with any stigma whatsoever.

Heroin was initially marketed as a cough drop by Bayer.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:BayerHeroin.png

No stigma there. It came later. Where from?

And today, dispite Americas love affair with drug use during the 60s and 70s, drug use still carries with it a social stigma.

Precisely. It's most certainly has nothing to do with how drugs were accepted decades ago. It's something more recent. I have an idea what that could be. Do you?

Drug use has lost it's cache with the general public. People don't bat an eye any more when they see a character in a movie smoke a joint (usually the "good guy"). The" bad guys" are usually seen snorting a line. ( can think of two movies off the top of my head. Marijuana use by the good guys in Zombie land and cocaine use by the bad guy in Kick Ass.)

Some of the social associations are still there.

And, according to you, none of that is because of the war on drugs, but because of ... what, exactly?

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
I'm having my doubts about FARC's sincerity. They might be just in for the easy money. But I was more thinking along the likes of Bolivia, Chile, Nicaragua perhaps even Mexico ...

And where would these people get the money for these supposed coups if they couldn't sell the drugs on the black market? Sure the cartels probably have money laying around, but it wouldn't last forever. Then what? And really, of the countries that you mentioned, only the cartels in Mexico have any real money and power. And they are already fighting the government. And while the government has been unable to defeat them, it certainly doesn't seem as though the cartels are in an position to actually overthrow the government. How would it be more likely that this would happen if their money supply was completely cut off?

There are at least four times as many alcohol users as there are illicit drug users. You also advocate a substantial drop in drug prices. Why are substantially higher addiction rates completely unfounded?

Because you have no evidence that it would happen.

Doesn't a lower price mean at least a good possibility more people would use (currently) illicit drugs in your world? Why not, explain please, as it goes against virtually all our economic models and experience.

You're assuming that the current prices keeps people from using drugs. But there is no evidence this is true, and I know from experience that it is not. In fact, using drugs recreationally isn't prohibitively expensive for the vast majority of people. One can easily get high on any number of illegal drugs including heroin and cocaine for cheaper than a night out drinking at bars. Sure once you are addicted, it can become a very expensive habit, but no drug addicts I know really care about that.

Why doesn't a working model of alcohol work for (currently) illicit drugs? What are the key differences? Unless you can explain, thoroughly and in detail, why this can't be reasonably used as a model, we can't carry on the discussion.

McHrozni

Do you or have you ever drank alcohol? Would you start using heroin if you could legally do so? I am assuming the answer is no? Why not?
 
And where would these people get the money for these supposed coups if they couldn't sell the drugs on the black market? Sure the cartels probably have money laying around, but it wouldn't last forever. Then what? And really, of the countries that you mentioned, only the cartels in Mexico have any real money and power. And they are already fighting the government. And while the government has been unable to defeat them, it certainly doesn't seem as though the cartels are in an position to actually overthrow the government. How would it be more likely that this would happen if their money supply was completely cut off?

Immediately after it was cut off, trouble could flare up. In the long run, the results might or might not be better, depends on what else they would begin to do to bring in money.

Because you have no evidence that it would happen.

I have presented evidence it would happen. It's not proof, and it's possible events would take a different turn, but what is there to believe I'm wrong, beyond your personal opinion?

You're assuming that the current prices keeps people from using drugs.

And you're assuming it has no bearing whatsoever on it. That would be fairly rare in the world of economics.

But there is no evidence this is true, and I know from experience that it is not. In fact, using drugs recreationally isn't prohibitively expensive for the vast majority of people. One can easily get high on any number of illegal drugs including heroin and cocaine for cheaper than a night out drinking at bars. Sure once you are addicted, it can become a very expensive habit, but no drug addicts I know really care about that.

Oh, anecdotal evidence is useful evidence now? Can I cite stories of people saying "I'd try it, but it was too expensive" as well?

Nah, let's try to get something which can count as useful evidence, if not outright proof.
http://www.nber.org/papers/w10619.pdf

The striking point is that the series of cocaine and
heroin mentions [in ED episodes] are virtual mirror images of the price series.

A 10% increase in prices can prevent 10,723 cocaine and heroin-related ED visits

Sure, correlation doesn't necessarily equal causation. They write something to that effect in the article as well. But I'd say it's up to you to show it was other effects and that price was irrelevant, and the strong correlation nothing but a pure coincidence.

Do you or have you ever drank alcohol? Would you start using heroin if you could legally do so? I am assuming the answer is no? Why not?

I think that there is a possibility I'd try heroin (or something else) if it were legal, if not now then perhaps when I was younger and stupider. I can't say for certain about the people I know, but I'm quite sure more would try it.
We have discussed earlier that there is a certain stigma attached to using drugs, which is a significant factor (possibly the most significant factor) in turning people away from using drugs. What is the cause of this stigma? If it's war on drugs, you have a major benefit right there. If not, what is causing it?

McHrozni
 
There are at least 4 people using alcohol for each person using illicit drugs of any kind. Why are so few people using illicit drugs compared to legal ones, if not because of the war on drugs?

McHrozni

Perhaps the relative advertising.marketing spend has an influence?
 
Immediately after it was cut off, trouble could flare up. In the long run, the results might or might not be better, depends on what else they would begin to do to bring in money.

What else could they possibly do to bring in nearly as much money. I can't think of a single thing.

I have presented evidence it would happen. It's not proof, and it's possible events would take a different turn, but what is there to believe I'm wrong, beyond your personal opinion?

You've presented nothing more than your personal opinion that addiction rates would be several times higher.

And you're assuming it has no bearing whatsoever on it. That would be fairly rare in the world of economics.

I just know that using drugs is not expensive unless you have a habit.

Oh, anecdotal evidence is useful evidence now? Can I cite stories of people saying "I'd try it, but it was too expensive" as well?

Sure. I doubt you'll find anybody who never tried heroin because they thought $10/bag (or less) is too expensive though.

Nah, let's try to get something which can count as useful evidence, if not outright proof.
http://www.nber.org/papers/w10619.pdf

Sure, correlation doesn't necessarily equal causation. They write something to that effect in the article as well. But I'd say it's up to you to show it was other effects and that price was irrelevant, and the strong correlation nothing but a pure coincidence.

If the statistics are true, it is of course not a coincidence. But the increase in price was certainly due to a decrease in supply. And that is the likely reason for less people overdosing. Not because people suddenly thought that $50/g for cocaine was fine but $55/g was too much. And before you say that reducing supply can save lives, the fact that there is no quality control whatsoever plays a big role in overdoses in the first place.

I think that there is a possibility I'd try heroin (or something else) if it were legal, if not now then perhaps when I was younger and stupider. I can't say for certain about the people I know, but I'm quite sure more would try it.

Would it be heroin, or something else that is relatively safe like marijuana or MDMA? If it is the latter, so freaking what?

We have discussed earlier that there is a certain stigma attached to using drugs, which is a significant factor (possibly the most significant factor) in turning people away from using drugs. What is the cause of this stigma? If it's war on drugs, you have a major benefit right there. If not, what is causing it?

McHrozni

How about the fact that (some of them) are known to be highly addictive and dangerous? That's the reason that even most drug users I know wouldn't touch heroin, meth, or crack. Granted, the fact that this is known can be attributed at least partly to the war on drugs, but there is no reason we still couldn't tell people this with them legal. Hell it could be printed on the packaging.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps the relative advertising.marketing spend has an influence?

That's part of the reason, but doesn't account for the magnitude of the difference. It's also part of war on drugs, so it doesn't really weaken my argument.

McHrozni
 
What else could they possibly do to bring in nearly as much money. I can't think of a single thing.

Considering how much money they squander it wouldn't need to bring in that much for them to remain powerful. I imagine a whole host of illicit activities, probably mixed with some technically legal ones could perpetuate them.

You've presented nothing more than your personal opinion that addiction rates would be several times higher.

Excuse me? I presented several reasons why they would be. That's by any standard "something more".

I just know that using drugs is not expensive unless you have a habit.

And I know that the laws of economics dictate that a lower price will lead to greater usage. Why do you think drugs are special in this regard?

If the statistics are true, it is of course not a coincidence. But the increase in price was certainly due to a decrease in supply.

So the war on drugs decreased the supply? I thought you said earlier this didn't happen.
Which one is it, then?

Would it be heroin, or something else that is relatively safe like marijuana or MDMA? If it is the latter, so freaking what?

I never was in the situation, so I don't know. Heroin wouldn't be out of the question for me, were it legal. Is there a point to your question?

How about the fact that (some of them) are known to be highly addictive and dangerous? That's the reason that even most drug users I know wouldn't touch heroin, meth, or crack.

And yet you said earlier:

It's not hard to do even heroin or cocaine in moderation

So which one is it, then? Are these highly addictive and dangerous, or is it easy to do them in (relatively) harmless moderation?

Granted, the fact that this is known can be attributed at least partly to the war on drugs

Therefore the war on drugs is not useless. QED.

McHrozni
 
Considering how much money they squander it wouldn't need to bring in that much for them to remain powerful.

But making money is the entire reason for the existence of these Mexican cartels. They aren't ideologically motivated and thus it makes no sense for to fight the government for kicks.

I imagine a whole host of illicit activities, probably mixed with some technically legal ones could perpetuate them.

Like what.


Excuse me? I presented several reasons why they would be. That's by any standard "something more".

Several reasons, in your personal opinion.

And I know that the laws of economics dictate that a lower price will lead to greater usage. Why do you think drugs are special in this regard?

The demand is not always elastic. And it turns out that I am not the only one who believes this is the case for drugs. Nobel laureate Gary Becker thinks the same thing. See this paper.


So the war on drugs decreased the supply? I thought you said earlier this didn't happen.
Which one is it, then?

I very clearly said before that it can cause temporary shortages. Do you not remember, or you being dishonest?

I never was in the situation, so I don't know. Heroin wouldn't be out of the question for me, were it legal. Is there a point to your question?

Assuming you're telling the truth, you're in the small minority. Nobody else I have asked the question has said anything but no. That's the point.


And yet you said earlier:

So which one is it, then? Are these highly addictive and dangerous, or is it easy to do them in (relatively) harmless moderation?

Both.

Therefore the war on drugs is not useless. QED.

McHrozni

And you ignore the second half of the sentence. Dishonest much?
 
But making money is the entire reason for the existence of these Mexican cartels. They aren't ideologically motivated and thus it makes no sense for to fight the government for kicks.

Unless, of course, they find another source of illicit money. Eventually yes, they could weaken, but not in the short to medium term.

Like what.

Your regular organized crime comes to mind, as do what they're doing now: drug exports.

Several reasons, in your personal opinion.

If you can point to me why each of them is invalid, you're free to do so. But I suspect you can't.

The demand is not always elastic. And it turns out that I am not the only one who believes this is the case for drugs. Nobel laureate Gary Becker thinks the same thing. See this paper.

An interesting read. A pity you stated earlier you agreed earlier that the high level of correlation isn't a coincidence.
Just which version do you believe now? That the demand is inelastic, and the reduction of usage corresponding to higher prices is a fluke, or that of Gary Becker, who says there is no significant correlation?

His case isn't the strongest, either.

There are no reliable estimates of the price elasticity of demand for illegal drugs, mainly because data on prices and quantities consumed of illegal goods are scarce. However, estimates for different drugs generally indicate an elasticity of less than one in absolute value, with a central tendency of about 1/2 (see Cicala, 2005), although one or two studies estimate a larger elasticity (see Caulkins, 1995, van Ours, 1995) and the variability in these estimates is sizeable. Moreover, only a few studies of drugs have utilized the theory of rational addiction, which implies that long run elasticities exceed short run elasticities for addictive goods (see Becker and Murphy, 1988).

One thing I couldn't find is why he thinks the demand is inelastic. He states it "appears to be" several times and builds the document on that assumption, but I can't find any reasoning behind the assumption. I've already shown why I think he's wrong with his initial assumption in the study above. You actually agreed his entire premise wrong before citing him. Good job.

I very clearly said before that it can cause temporary shortages. Do you not remember, or you being dishonest?

I honestly don't remember you saying that, but I'm talking to about 5 different people, so I think that's understandable. That said, the period in which the price rose and usage dropped was over 5 years. Just where do you put a limit on "temporary"? You also stated several times that there is no shortage of drugs, and yet the price rose and the usage dropped. Which one is it, then? A temporary cocaine shortage spanning at least five years, or something else entirely?

Assuming you're telling the truth, you're in the small minority. Nobody else I have asked the question has said anything but no. That's the point.

Have you tried asking why not?


Hm. According to you heroin and cocaine are dangerous and highly addictive compounds, that can easily be used in moderation.

I'm sorry, but this just doesn't make sense. On what basis are they dangerous, if they can be easily and safely used in moderation?

And you ignore the second half of the sentence. Dishonest much?

I'm sorry, how did the second half of sentence affect that you admitted that the war on drugs was having a strong positive effect?

Not to ignore it completely, you're claiming that labels on packaging would be sufficient, right? If so, why are there at least two habitual smokers for each occasional or habitual illicit drug user of any kind? Drugs don't have warnings on packages, but tobacco products have had those for almost 45 years now.

Before you begin ranting "it's because drugs are dangerous and everybody knows it", please explain how that is not a result of the war on drugs and the vilification that follows. I've raised this point several times now, you ignored it and now call me dishonest over ... what, exactly? That packaging with warning labels would be sufficient when it was already demonstrated not to be very effective?

McHrozni
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom