But making money is the entire reason for the existence of these Mexican cartels. They aren't ideologically motivated and thus it makes no sense for to fight the government for kicks.
Unless, of course, they find another source of illicit money. Eventually yes, they could weaken, but not in the short to medium term.
Your regular organized crime comes to mind, as do what they're doing now: drug exports.
Several reasons, in your personal opinion.
If you can point to me why each of them is invalid, you're free to do so. But I suspect you can't.
The demand is not always elastic. And it turns out that I am not the only one who believes this is the case for drugs. Nobel laureate Gary Becker thinks the same thing.
See this paper.
An interesting read. A pity you stated earlier you agreed earlier that the high level of correlation isn't a coincidence.
Just which version do you believe now? That the demand is inelastic, and the reduction of usage corresponding to higher prices is a fluke, or that of Gary Becker, who says there is no significant correlation?
His case isn't the strongest, either.
There are no reliable estimates of the price elasticity of demand for illegal drugs, mainly because data on prices and quantities consumed of illegal goods are scarce. However, estimates for different drugs generally indicate an elasticity of less than one in absolute value, with a central tendency of about 1/2 (see Cicala, 2005), although one or two studies estimate a larger elasticity (see Caulkins, 1995, van Ours, 1995) and the variability in these estimates is sizeable. Moreover, only a few studies of drugs have utilized the theory of rational addiction, which implies that long run elasticities exceed short run elasticities for addictive goods (see Becker and Murphy, 1988).
One thing I couldn't find is why he thinks the demand is inelastic. He states it "appears to be" several times and builds the document on that assumption, but I can't find any reasoning behind the assumption. I've already shown why I think he's wrong with his initial assumption in the study above. You actually agreed his entire premise wrong before citing him. Good job.
I very clearly said before that it can cause temporary shortages. Do you not remember, or you being dishonest?
I honestly don't remember you saying that, but I'm talking to about 5 different people, so I think that's understandable. That said, the period in which the price rose and usage dropped was over 5 years. Just where do you put a limit on "temporary"? You also stated several times that there is no shortage of drugs, and yet the price rose and the usage dropped. Which one is it, then? A temporary cocaine shortage spanning at least five years, or something else entirely?
Assuming you're telling the truth, you're in the small minority. Nobody else I have asked the question has said anything but no. That's the point.
Have you tried asking why not?
Hm. According to you heroin and cocaine are dangerous and highly addictive compounds, that can easily be used in moderation.
I'm sorry, but this just doesn't make sense. On what basis are they dangerous, if they can be easily and safely used in moderation?
And you ignore the second half of the sentence. Dishonest much?
I'm sorry, how did the second half of sentence affect that you admitted that the war on drugs was having a strong positive effect?
Not to ignore it completely, you're claiming that labels on packaging would be sufficient, right? If so, why are there at least two habitual smokers for each occasional or habitual illicit drug user of any kind? Drugs don't have warnings on packages, but tobacco products have had those for almost 45 years now.
Before you begin ranting "it's because drugs are dangerous and everybody knows it", please explain how that is not a result of the war on drugs and the vilification that follows. I've raised this point several times now, you ignored it and now call me dishonest over ... what, exactly? That packaging with warning labels would be sufficient when it was already demonstrated not to be very effective?
McHrozni