The War on Drugs is Useless

Imagine that turf would become a lot smaller overnight. What would you expect to happen?
I expect the street gangs would be far smaller and much much poorer, as they were before the War on Drugs.

Not nearly as much money running prostitution rings, legal casinos make the gambling houses not worthwhile any more.

Yes, repeating the same mantra over and over again and not addressing the points made against it is a very good way of making your point :rolleyes:

McHrozni
What point of yours wasn't addressed?
 
I expect the street gangs would be far smaller and much much poorer, as they were before the War on Drugs.

Not nearly as much money running prostitution rings, legal casinos make the gambling houses not worthwhile any more.

Overnight? No, that's rather absurd. Over a period of time, 10-20 years, maybe, perhaps even probably, yes. But not overnight, the only reasonable thing you'd expect in the short to medium term is a significant increase in violence.

What point of yours wasn't addressed?

The above, for one. And the one which claims that we should expect an increase in drug usage, which could easily be a worse social ill than the war on drugs is. And the one about legalization being a one way street. If I'm remotely correct about increased usage and the effects of the drugs on society, then there would be absolutely no way to come back from it. Alcohol prohibition proved that.

Certainly, gang violence is ugly, but that doesn't mean the alternative can't be even worse than that.

McHrozni
 
Overnight? No, that's rather absurd. Over a period of time, 10-20 years, maybe, perhaps even probably, yes. But not overnight, the only reasonable thing you'd expect in the short to medium term is a significant increase in violence.
Why do you think it would increase?

The above, for one. And the one which claims that we should expect an increase in drug usage, which could easily be a worse social ill than the war on drugs is. And the one about legalization being a one way street. If I'm remotely correct about increased usage and the effects of the drugs on society, then there would be absolutely no way to come back from it. Alcohol prohibition proved that.

Certainly, gang violence is ugly, but that doesn't mean the alternative can't be even worse than that.

McHrozni
Except that all the drugs of which you speak were once legal in the entire US, cocaine and heroin included. The problems you fear didn't materialize until after they were made illegal.
 
After 1933 the murder rate in the US fell sharply. Anybody want to guess what happened in 1933?
 
Why do you think it would increase?

Because the current thugs and gang members wouldn't become law-abiding citizens, but would seek out other means of illicit income. With the money and weapons already bought they could sustain a lot for a while. In the long run, their recruitment might be impacted by the lower revenues, but even that isn't certain.

Except that all the drugs of which you speak were once legal in the entire US, cocaine and heroin included. The problems you fear didn't materialize until after they were made illegal.

Or maybe they weren't made illegal until the problems I fear began to materialize?

After 1933 the murder rate in the US fell sharply. Anybody want to guess what happened in 1933?

Nazis came to power in Germany? :)

Seriously though if you want to keep arguing that we should only look at murders and ignore all other factors you might as well stop posting here. I made this point several times: the damage to society from cheaply and available intoxicants can be greater than the damage done by criminals running business from those intoxicants.

That doesn't mean we should ban all intoxicants any more than it means we should permit all of them. We need a reasonable policy, accept some damage from milder ones (like tobacco, alcohol, marijuana and maybe some others), but we're probably better off with fighting the more severe ones through a strict policy of banning them.

Near as I can tell, no one has attempted to even address that point.

McHrozni
 
That doesn't mean we should ban all intoxicants any more than it means we should permit all of them. We need a reasonable policy, accept some damage from milder ones (like tobacco, alcohol, marijuana and maybe some others), but we're probably better off with fighting the more severe ones through a strict policy of banning them.

Near as I can tell, no one has attempted to even address that point.


Every time someone asks if you have any more to offer than your unsubstantiated opinion and unsupported assertion, they're addressing your point. Your response is more unsubstantiated opinion and unsupported assertion.
 
Because the current thugs and gang members wouldn't become law-abiding citizens, but would seek out other means of illicit income. With the money and weapons already bought they could sustain a lot for a while. In the long run, their recruitment might be impacted by the lower revenues, but even that isn't certain.

Yet this didn't happen after Prohibition was repealed. In fact, the complete opposite did. Why is that? Why would it be different with drug prohibition?

Nazis came to power in Germany? :)

Seriously though if you want to keep arguing that we should only look at murders and ignore all other factors you might as well stop posting here. I made this point several times: the damage to society from cheaply and available intoxicants can be greater than the damage done by criminals running business from those intoxicants.

That doesn't mean we should ban all intoxicants any more than it means we should permit all of them. We need a reasonable policy, accept some damage from milder ones (like tobacco, alcohol, marijuana and maybe some others), but we're probably better off with fighting the more severe ones through a strict policy of banning them.

Near as I can tell, no one has attempted to even address that point.

McHrozni

I don't really feel like going over this again, it got boring the last time. But I will say this: Maybe significantly more people would use drugs if they became legal although its pretty much unknowable unless it happens. But I don't think it is any of my, or the state's business if people want to shoot up heroin or smoke meth, or whatever.
 
Last edited:
Yet this didn't happen after Prohibition was repealed. In fact, the complete opposite did. Why is that? Why would it be different with drug prohibition?

Besides the issues listed earlier (alcohol being very common before it, etc), there is also the fact that alcohol prohibition only lasted a short time: 13 years. The illegal cartels that were set up had much less time to build up a significant organized crime infrastructure, with far fewer people becoming career criminals. Moreover, virtually all of the illegal infrastructure was domestic, as opposed to much of it being abroad.

Secondly, the culture in 1933 was significantly different than the one we have today. Long term murder trend was rising from about 1910 to 1933, which indicates prohibition was not the only and perhaps not even the most important factor in overall murder rate peak in 1933, and consequently wasn't the only important factor for the drop.

Overall I think the comparisons you're making aren't as justified as you're making them to be.

I don't really feel like going over this again, it got boring the last time. But I will say this: Maybe significantly more people would use drugs if they became legal although its pretty much unknowable unless it happens. But I don't think it is any of my, or the state's business if people want to shoot up heroin or smoke meth, or whatever.

We're running in circles, I agree. It's a matter of opinion, really, if the state should allow potentially extremely dangerous intoxicants in the streets or not. I happen to think it shouldn't and that it's a matter of general well being that they don't.

I would like to ask you one question, however: would you consider a contract selling yourself into slavery in exchange for a desired object valid?
Why/why not?

McHrozni
 
Every time someone asks if you have any more to offer than your unsubstantiated opinion and unsupported assertion, they're addressing your point. Your response is more unsubstantiated opinion and unsupported assertion.

Funnily enough, you're the first person to mention that.

For the stuff you were quoting, I made a slight error in placement of paragraphs. It should go like this:

Seriously though if you want to keep arguing that we should only look at murders and ignore all other factors you might as well stop posting here. I made this point several times: the damage to society from cheaply and available intoxicants can be greater than the damage done by criminals running business from those intoxicants.

Near as I can tell, no one has attempted to even address that point.


If you want substantiations for that read the thread.

McHrozni
 
Besides the issues listed earlier (alcohol being very common before it, etc), there is also the fact that alcohol prohibition only lasted a short time: 13 years. The illegal cartels that were set up had much less time to build up a significant organized crime infrastructure, with far fewer people becoming career criminals. Moreover, virtually all of the illegal infrastructure was domestic, as opposed to much of it being abroad.

But in those 13 years these gangs became far more organized and powerful than any gang operating in the US today. It is believed that 50% of the police force in Chicago was on Al Capone's payroll. Can any gangster say that today?

Secondly, the culture in 1933 was significantly different than the one we have today. Long term murder trend was rising from about 1910 to 1933, which indicates prohibition was not the only and perhaps not even the most important factor in overall murder rate peak in 1933, and consequently wasn't the only important factor for the drop.

But it surely was a factor. In any case, murders didn't rise. It's as good a comparison as we can get.

I would like to ask you one question, however: would you consider a contract selling yourself into slavery in exchange for a desired object valid?
Why/why not?

McHrozni

Sure, as long as there is no coercion involved in the forming of the contract, the slave isn't forced to do anything illegal, and the owner doesn't physically abuse his slave. Both sides would benefit. And I don't think an agreement between two consenting adults is anybody's else's business. If it were possible, I might consider selling myself into slavery if the price were right. Say $1 million for a year.
 
Last edited:
But in those 13 years these gangs became far more organized and powerful than any gang operating in the US today. It is believed that 50% of the police force in Chicago was on Al Capone's payroll. Can any gangster say that today?

It's not an issue of organization, but of tradition so to speak. The organized crime wasn't this organized for more than a few years, at most. It's been organized for decades now. As with all things, exit is easier if you haven't been into it for so long.

It also shows alcohol prohibition resulted in a significantly worse social ill than the drug prohibition has. Something to ponder when you compare the two.

But it surely was a factor. In any case, murders didn't rise. It's as good a comparison as we can get.

And unfortunately it's fairly rubbish, for reasons I presented.

Sure, as long as there is no coercion involved in the forming of the contract, the slave isn't forced to do anything illegal, and the owner doesn't physically abuse his slave. Both sides would benefit. And I don't think an agreement between two consenting adults is anybody's else's business. If it were possible, I might consider selling myself into slavery if the price were right. Say $1 million for a year.

Hm, you didn't understand the question. By slave I mean a slave a slave, not a person laboring for you at miserable wage. You don't get to have property, you are property. You don't get paid $1 million a year, because that's employment, not slavery. He has the same rights to you as he has to his chair. You don't get to end the contract. If you disobey, he may whip you, and if you obey he may still torture you for the fun of it. He may be forced to do the illegal for his master.
The contract was freely entered into, with no coercion, but everything else is like a slave in the classical antiquity.

Would you hold such a treaty as legally binding? Would you consider the slave legally responsible for his actions during his slavery?

McHrozni
 
It's not an issue of organization, but of tradition so to speak. The organized crime wasn't this organized for more than a few years, at most. It's been organized for decades now. As with all things, exit is easier if you haven't been into it for so long.

It also shows alcohol prohibition resulted in a significantly worse social ill than the drug prohibition has. Something to ponder when you compare the two.



And unfortunately it's fairly rubbish, for reasons I presented.

Whatever you say. It is certainly better than what you what you base your idea that crime would actually rise in the event drugs were legal upon. Which is to say nothing whatsoever but your gut feeling.

Hm, you didn't understand the question. By slavee I mean a slave a slave, not a person laboring for you at miserable wage. You don't get to have property, you are property. You don't get paid $1 million a year, because that's employment, not slavery. He has the same rights to you as he has to his chair. You don't get to end the contract. If you disobey, he may whip you, and if you obey he may still torture you for the fun of it. He may be forced to do the illegal for his master.

The contract was freely entered into, with no coercion, but everything else is like a slave in the classical antiquity.


Would you hold such a treaty as legally binding? Would you consider the slave legally responsible for his actions during his slavery?

McHrozni

Don't own property? I thought I was doing it for a desired object. How could I have a desired object but not own property? And assault and forcing someone to commit a crime are crimes in and of themselves, so this obviously would not be allowed.

Anyway, your comparison is ridiculous. Nobody would voluntarily enter such a contract. Whereas, demonstrably, millions of people take drugs.
 
Whatever you say. It is certainly better than what you what you base your idea that crime would actually rise in the event drugs were legal upon. Which is to say nothing whatsoever but your gut feeling.

And a previously presented reasoning, which you ignore. Indeed aside from the prohibition example, there is no reason to expect otherwise. I have explained why I believe that equivalence is a false one.

Don't own property? I thought I was doing it for a desired object.

Yes. Either it's an object that would be quickly used up (like a snort of coke), an object for someone other than you, or something that becomes a part of you, like an organ transplant.
See? It works.

And assault and forcing someone to commit a crime are crimes in and of themselves, so this obviously would not be allowed.

So you wouldn't hold the treaty as valid, I take it?

Anyway, your comparison is ridiculous. Nobody would voluntarily enter such a contract. Whereas, demonstrably, millions of people take drugs.

And yet hundreds of thousands of them get enslaved by them and commit all sorts of criminal acts, including murder, in order to be able to buy more. That's why I presented this comparison. It's not completely equivalent, but it is fairly similar.

McHrozni
 
And a previously presented reasoning, which you ignore. Indeed aside from the prohibition example, there is no reason to expect otherwise. I have explained why I believe that equivalence is a false one.

There is no reason to believe it would rise other than your gut feeling. Sorry if I don't take that as gospel.

Yes. Either it's an object that would be quickly used up (like a snort of coke), an object for someone other than you, or something that becomes a part of you, like an organ transplant.
See? It works.

In fantasy land, I guess.

So you wouldn't hold the treaty as valid, I take it?

No, people can't commit crimes as part of a contract.

And yet hundreds of thousands of them get enslaved by them and commit all sorts of criminal acts, including murder, in order to be able to buy more. That's why I presented this comparison. It's not completely equivalent, but it is fairly similar.

McHrozni

Since they are free to quit, and any harm is entirely self-inflicted your comparison is rejected.

And the only reason that people commit all sorts of criminal acts, including murder, in order to buy some more is because people like you decided they should be the moral police, creating the black market which vastly inflates the price.
 
There is no reason to believe it would rise other than your gut feeling. Sorry if I don't take that as gospel.

No, I presented far more than my gut feeling, you're just ignoring it for whatever reason. It's inconvenient for you, I guess, because there is nothing but your gut feeling on your side either. Forgive me for not taking that as gospel either.

And the only reason that people commit all sorts of criminal acts, including murder, in order to buy some more is because people like you decided they should be the moral police, creating the black market which vastly inflates the price.

No, actually this is because it's very, very difficult to resist the urge to take a drug you've become addicted to. The inflated price and the persecution of the dealers, on the other hand, probably deters more people away from the drug in the first place.

But we're just running in circles.

No, people can't commit crimes as part of a contract.

So you wouldn't consider it legal after all. Thanks.

Slightly off-topic, but all recreational drugs are now legal in Mexico for personal use.

Hm, I checked and you're partially right, it's been decriminalized in 2006. The difference is that it's still illegal, but they don't persecute users.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
No, actually this is because it's very, very difficult to resist the urge to take a drug you've become addicted to. The inflated price and the persecution of the dealers, on the other hand, probably deters more people away from the drug in the first place.

People don't kill to buy tobacco or alcohol. I have never once heard of a pharmacist shooting another pharmacist to take over their territory. People don't break into Starbucks to get an espresso at 2:00 AM.
 
People don't kill to buy tobacco or alcohol. I have never once heard of a pharmacist shooting another pharmacist to take over their territory. People don't break into Starbucks to get an espresso at 2:00 AM.

Yes, the cravings for alcohol, tobacco and especially caffeine are much, much, much, MUCH less severe than those for, say, heroin. Which is one of the reasons why I think heroin should remain illegal, but alcohol, tobacco and caffeine should remain legal without me being inconsistent.

Using the same reasoning, I think buying a butter knife shouldn't be very difficult, but obtaining a 200-kiloton nuke should. Or do some of our "legalize it!" bunch disagree and call this inconsistent as well?

McHrozni
 
No, I presented far more than my gut feeling, you're just ignoring it for whatever reason. It's inconvenient for you, I guess, because there is nothing but your gut feeling on your side either. Forgive me for not taking that as gospel either.

You've provided nothing but your say so. I, on the other hand have historical precedent.


No, actually this is because it's very, very difficult to resist the urge to take a drug you've become addicted to.

But an addict can quit if he wants to. A slave can't quit being a slave.

The inflated price and the persecution of the dealers, on the other hand, probably deters more people away from the drug in the first place.

Unknowable. But it is a fact that the black market gets people killed.

Yes, the cravings for alcohol, tobacco and especially caffeine are much, much, much, MUCH less severe than those for, say, heroin. Which is one of the reasons why I think heroin should remain illegal, but alcohol, tobacco and caffeine should remain legal without me being inconsistent.

Actually, studies show that nicotine is as addictive as heroin. And there are many drunks who are just as addicted as any junkie. And alcohol withdrawal is probably worse than heroin. You can actually die.

I have not once heard of a smoker or a drunk killing anybody to feed his addiction.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom