The War on Drugs is Useless

What makes you think this hasn't already been tried?
The guy is still alive.
And if you do take out such a kingpin, so what? Another one will simply be ready to take their place. There's just too much damn money involved in the black-market drug trade to realistically expect that by "taking out the kingpins" everything will just get better.
Probably true.
 
Probably true.

I red that conversation a bit, and I disagree with one thing - that removing a technically replaceable man is useless.

It's not. The man in power is the most knowledgeable and possibly the most capable man in the operation. Removing him will temporarily reduce the effectiveness of the business, and it will leave the cartel one brain weaker in their operations. If several (3-4) were assassinated in a relatively short succession (one per 6 months or so), a crisis of leadership is certain. There can be a few men capable of replacing the top dog, but they aren't trivial to replace. A small succession war within the cartel is not out of the question either.

All of these will deplete their power, at least in the short to medium term.

McHrozni
 
Yet despite the fact that there are already many, many, many Mexicans dying in such drug-related violence every year (and it's getting way worse), the coke still makes its way here (we haven't put a dent in it)... and American kids still are dying.

So, explain to me exactly how this Prohibition is working out?

Do you need another 40 years to see how stupid this is?

I think Wildcat is on your side.



My point was that drug users simply don't care about their health, what's yours?

Nice generalization, there. I guess people who use alcohol or tobacco also don't care about their health? Who else? People who eat fast food? Race car drivers?
 
Nice generalization, there. I guess people who use alcohol or tobacco also don't care about their health? Who else? People who eat fast food? Race car drivers?

Okay, fine. If you think this will help the argument in any way ...

I think that many of the intravenous drug users simply don't care about their health enough to ensure their needles are safe.

This brings up an interesting point, for those that weren't able to see it before: how would legalizing drugs change that?

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Okay, fine. If you think this will help the argument in any way ...

I think that many of the intravenous drug users simply don't care about their health enough to ensure their needles are safe.

This brings up an interesting point, for those that weren't able to see it before: how would legalizing drugs change that?
McHrozni
You don't need to legalize drugs for this -- simply setting up a building where users can get free needles, instructions and health care, and a seat where they inject their shots, goes a long way towards making drug use safer. In cities where this has been tried, death toll from overdoses has, to my knowledge, plummeted.
 
Last edited:
You don't need to legalize drugs for this -- simply setting up a building where users can get free needles, instructions and health care, and a seat where they inject their shots, goes a long way towards making drug use safer. In cities where this has been tried, death toll from overdoses has, to my knowledge, plummeted.
Why not charge them for needles, at cost?
 
You don't need to legalize drugs for this -- simply setting up a building where users can get free needles, instructions and health care, and a seat where they inject their shots, goes a long way towards making drug use safer. In cities where this has been tried, death toll from overdoses has, to my knowledge, plummeted.

That I agree with. Still, this discussion has been mainly about legalizing drugs in general, not about altering certain aspects of the war on drugs. I still stand by my statement, though, that if the drug addicts wanted to obtain safe needles for themselves, they could.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
I would love to.
But it would de-rail this thread.

You already did that with the question which had nothing to do with the war on drugs. You asked about a substance that would change a persons' behavior, assumed it would be illegal and asked who would take it anyway.

I imagine some would take it, but your assumption that it would be illegal is unfounded. It might be, if the changes in behavior would change the person to the point he or she would be unrecognizable, or it might be heavily controlled. If it was highly addictive or it had other nefarious side effects, it could also be illegal.
Heroin isn't illegal because it gives you a rush, it's illegal because it's highly addictive and has other negative impacts on your health.

McHrozni
 
You already did that with the question which had nothing to do with the war on drugs. You asked about a substance that would change a persons' behavior, assumed it would be illegal and asked who would take it anyway.

I imagine some would take it, but your assumption that it would be illegal is unfounded. It might be, if the changes in behavior would change the person to the point he or she would be unrecognizable, or it might be heavily controlled. If it was highly addictive or it had other nefarious side effects, it could also be illegal.
Heroin isn't illegal because it gives you a rush, it's illegal because it's highly addictive and has other negative impacts on your health.
McHrozni

with that reasoning we would have to bann Alcohol.

Tetrahydrocannabinol is less addictive than alcohol, it also does change your behavior less than alcohol.
 
Last edited:
with that reasoning we would have to bann Alcohol.

Tetrahydrocannabinol is less addictive than alcohol, it also does change your behavior less than alcohol.

I explained my reasoning for the differences between marijuana and alcohol earlier, explicitly to you. I see no reason to argue that again. I have also stated, in this thread, that I consider marijuana a drug that could be legalized, therefore I really don't consider this 'argument' of yours to have any merit whatsoever.

Do try to pay attention, and if you have a memory of a goldfish, consider writing things down. Dropping marijuana may help in that regard as well.

McHrozni
 
The following pictures are taken from a park called Platzspitz, previously known as "Needle Park" in Switzerland. One of the pictures was taken when drug use was virtually legalized in the park. One of the was taken after the experiment was shut down. Try and guess which is which:

[qimg]http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_dmDHh7gwpa4/SdSfis20SQI/AAAAAAAABr8/0mAWo8ATyuU/s800/AAAA.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/ca/Z%C3%BCrich_-_Platzspitzpark_IMG_0374.jpg/800px-Z%C3%BCrich_-_Platzspitzpark_IMG_0374.jpg[/qimg]

oh i missed that one, very missleading, yes there was a huge problem there. but the clean parc has nothing to do with drugs beeing legalized.
the government just choosed to have one place where drug addicts can do their thing. in all other places the police drove them away.

but that changed and the police made huge razias there to clean the parc.
but actually this exactly showed that only reactionary police driving away the addicts is no solution to the problem.
now they get free needles, methadone, even heroine etc.....
 
I explained my reasoning for the differences between marijuana and alcohol earlier, explicitly to you. I see no reason to argue that again. I have also stated, in this thread, that I consider marijuana a drug that could be legalized, therefore I really don't consider this 'argument' of yours to have any merit whatsoever.

Do try to pay attention, and if you have a memory of a goldfish, consider writing things down. Dropping marijuana may help in that regard as well.

McHrozni

but your reasoning for legalizing or criminalizing drugs doesnt make sence. the reasoning is far to easy.
 
oh i missed that one, very missleading, yes there was a huge problem there. but the clean parc has nothing to do with drugs beeing legalized.

I think the implication was that if drugs were as freely available as alcohol, many more parks would look like the one on top.

I can't say I agree with that, but I consider that a possibility.

McHrozni
 
I think the implication was that if drugs were as freely available as alcohol, many more parks would look like the one on top.

I can't say I agree with that, but I consider that a possibility.

McHrozni

i dont think so, that parc was a concentration from addicts from all over the world, not only swiss addicts, from across europe people came to that parc. and they were driven away from all other places. Now they are more spread among the "needle-houses" were you can get free needles and have a place to give yourself a shot. But there is not only 1 place in switzerland, there are now many places in all cities, but none of them looks like that parc anymore.
 
because it needs alot exceptions, like for alcohol, and THC, and other stuff.

It needs a few exceptions, certainly. So? We're already doing the same with pharmaceuticals.

McHrozni
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom