The IDF Now Has A YouTube Channel

Israel's "behavior" as you put it is 95% due to retaliation against hostile activities of the terroristic organizations (they have several of those working against Israel simultanously). If you ask me, not enough has been done by Israel over the years in order to get rid of those terroristic organizations.

What nonsense.

Most of Israel's overall behavior against the Palestinians is that of persecution, apartheid and ghettoization. Even this latest terrrorist attack against Gaza is a completely disproportionate response to the Hamas rockets.


The transparent agenda of Israel is to make life as hard as hell for the Palestinians in order to drive them out of Palestine forever.


And why should anyone take what you say seriously ... I nearly spat my coffee over the monitor reading the following ....

I will believe almost anything the IDF says because in Israel everything is outrageously open for scrutiny by the media. It's gotten so out of hand that reporters are telling the whole world what the next moves of the army will be. If the IDF put a video up for everyone to see you can bet your life that they KNOW FOR CERTAIN that those were rockets. You have to remember that Israel has recruiters on the Palestinian side that report about what activities are being done and where.
I suggest you don't be so quick on your trigger finger and THINK you know everything just because in the video it may appear to be this or that.


How absurdly naive and gullible can a person be?
 
You know what, I think I just understood where you get it wrong.

nonsense. I don't support the killing of civilians pardalis.

snip

The IDF are just as much terrorists as Hamas. Plenty of IDF apologists here.

In your mind, terrorism = killing civilians

But see, terrorism isn't necessarily about killing the innocent, and innocent people dying isn't always the result of terrorism.

You said you don't support the killing of civilians, but you don't seem to find a problem with the deliberate targeting of civilians. Hamas isn't targeting civilian areas to defend themselves, they are deliberately aiming at them to provoque and escalate the conflict. That is the definition of terrorism, an you're making excuses for it.
 
Last edited:
I'm starting to think it's actually impossible for a western country to effectively wage a war now. Every air strike, every skirmish, is analysed in real-time by ignorant arm-chair generals who swallow whatever propaganda is fed their way.

It's very visible with something like Israel, but the exact same thing happened with Afghanistan and Iraq, and Kosovo and Bosnia before that.
 
I do admit that "arm-chair general" seems to work here. At the very least, "arm-chair intelligence officers".

I especially like the 100% sure postings that you're dealing with gas cannisters that couldn't POSSIBLY be missiles at all...

Or the claim that not allowing people to comment on what obviously is causing a lot of emotion, on a website not exactly given to rational discussion even when you're talking about bowling balls, is somehow a sign of something...
 
Last edited:
I do admit that "arm-chair general" seems to work here. At the very least, "arm-chair intelligence officers".

I especially like the 100% sure postings that you're dealing with gas cannisters that couldn't POSSIBLY be missiles at all...

Or the claim that not allowing people to comment on what obviously is causing a lot of emotion, on a website not exactly given to rational discussion even when you're talking about bowling balls, is somehow a sign of something...



I went and read some of the editorials in the local Newspaper about this latest turn of events and it actually shocked me how the paper has finally abandoned even a semblance of balance.

Of course the fact that our new Jewish-ancestory Prime Minister hasn't come out and condemned the Israeli actions outright is now being ominously highlighted. Of course the reason the current government isn't condemning the attacks in harsh terms is because they're led by a filthy Jew, not because the previous government was led by a rabidly anti-Israeli meglomaniac. It's scary how quickly an extremist political world view can become considered "normal".
 
The latest video:



Is that an Australian accent I detect from the IDF spokesman?
 
Last edited:
I went and read some of the editorials in the local Newspaper about this latest turn of events and it actually shocked me how the paper has finally abandoned even a semblance of balance.

Of course the fact that our new Jewish-ancestory Prime Minister hasn't come out and condemned the Israeli actions outright is now being ominously highlighted. Of course the reason the current government isn't condemning the attacks in harsh terms is because they're led by a filthy Jew, not because the previous government was led by a rabidly anti-Israeli meglomaniac. It's scary how quickly an extremist political world view can become considered "normal".
Apparently, Obama is also controlled by the Jews.
 
Please, next time we call you as terrorist apologist, please shut up about it, this post is proof that you are one.

Notice how he also tried to again bring in the 'zionist movement'?

The reason it's been debated is that there are those that will go to extraordinary lengths to absolve the IDF/israel/Zionist Movement of any crime.

I went and read some of the editorials in the local Newspaper about this latest turn of events and it actually shocked me how the paper has finally abandoned even a semblance of balance.

Are you talking about the NZ Herald? I'll look it up.
 
Are you talking about the NZ Herald? I'll look it up.

It is indeed.

Palestinians' fight is a struggle against 'apartheid'

Godwinned in the second paragraph:

The pretext for this butchery is that some Gazans are firing home-made missiles into Israeli towns. As a result, the Israeli politicians insist the entire population of Gaza is to be punished. The Nazis used a similar policy during World War II in their occupied territories. The Israelis are getting the same results the Nazis got - their victims increase their hatred and determination to seek revenge.

Classy.
 
It is really amazing that we debate for 90 posts if those were or were not grad missiles or a mistake of identification by the IDF while on the other side of the border tens of missiles are falling everywhere trying deliberately to kill as many civilians as possible.
In my view this speaks highly of how people here see the moral of the IDF. It is so uncommon to see Palestinian civilians get killed (by mistake) by the IDF that if something like that happens we debate about it for 90 posts.
I'm glad that this is the situation.

Maybe you need to read Haaretz some more.

http://www.remembershaden.org/articles/Military_mumbo_jumbo.htm

His claim was debated in the courts until two weeks ago, when the High Court of Justice rejected his petition, but determined in principle that "during the execution of actions carried out among a civilian population, both inside and beyond the Green Line, IDF soldiers must exercise caution when using their weapons in regard to civilians who could be injured."

Different version

While this intifada is far more violent and deadly than the previous one, the outgoing chief of staff, Moshe Ya'alon, maintained that this should not justify the killing of a woman in the yard of her home. He was referring to Shadin Abu Hijla, a 60-year-old peace activist from the Rafidiya neighborhood of Nablus, who was hit by a volley of fire that came in her direction on October 11, 2002, during an army operation to impose a curfew. Her doctor husband and her son, a university lecturer, were injured.

At first, it was unofficially claimed that Abu Hijla unfortunately found herself in the path of a stray bullet, despite the fact that the walls of her house were scarred by over a dozen bullets. Her son, who lives in Chicago, and her daughter, a United Nations employee in Jerusalem, established an Internet site on which they have reported all the developments in the case. The affair went as far as the White House, and from there, via the Prime Minister's Office in Jerusalem, reached Ya'alon.

Last week, two and a half years after the event, the Military Advocate General, Brigadier General Avihai Mandelblitt, decided to bring Colonel Harel Knafo, who at the time was in command of the Samaria Brigade, and the commander of the company that had been operating in the area at the time before a disciplinary tribunal. The officers are being charged with overstepping their authority to the point of endangerment of life and welfare, "in light of the orders regarding the rules of engagement that were given by them and which overstepped the rules of engagement that applied in that area at the time."

Nevertheless, the two officers will not face criminal charges.

You can find several cases like this, where often the only reason the facts come out is that there are people outside the occupied territories who have the influence to do so.
 
It is indeed.

Palestinians' fight is a struggle against 'apartheid'

Godwinned in the second paragraph:



Classy.

Nelson Mandela fought against apartheid, that's what people do. Unfortunately for the Palestinians, someone of Mandela's stature and intelligence is very rare.

They did not compare the Israeli's to Nazi's, they pointed out that brutalising people will make them hate you. The 40 years of occupation has created a lot of hate. I don't know why that would surprise anyone.
 
I will believe almost anything the IDF says because in Israel everything is outrageously open for scrutiny by the media. It's gotten so out of hand that reporters are telling the whole world what the next moves of the army will be. If the IDF put a video up for everyone to see you can bet your life that they KNOW FOR CERTAIN that those were rockets. You have to remember that Israel has recruiters on the Palestinian side that report about what activities are being done and where.
I suggest you don't be so quick on your trigger finger and THINK you know everything just because in the video it may appear to be this or that.


http://www.kibush.co.il/show_file.asp?num=19030

It is one of the poignancies of Tom Hurndall`s short life that he had gone to Gaza in search of a story, and ended up becoming it. A 21-year-old photography student at Manchester Metropolitan University, he went to Baghdad in February 2003 to photograph human shields, activists who were trying to protect ordinary Iraqis from the threat of Anglo-American attack. While he was there he heard about Rachel Corrie, a 23-year-old American peace activist with the International Solidarity Movement (ISM), who had been protecting a Palestinian`s family`s house in Rafah, in the southern Gaza strip, when an Israeli bulldozer crushed her to death. Tom went to Gaza to find out what had happened.

All that is clear from the book his mother, Jocelyn, has written about Tom`s life, and about his family`s battle to bring the Israeli army to account for killing him. It`s not a political book, she stresses, though the anger, frustration and disappointment she feels towards the army, and the Israeli and British governments, is obvious.

Tom was in Rafah, in the Israeli-occupied Gaza strip, on April 11, at an ISM demonstration. Suddenly low shots were fired from an Israeli army watchtower in the direction of children playing on a mound of rubble. Most of them ran - but three froze. Tom, wearing a bright orange ISM jacket, ran to help them. He scooped up a boy and carried him to safety. He ran back for the two girls, bent down to put his arm round one of them and was shot in the head.

Jocelyn was at work, at a school in London where she was head of learning support, when she got a call from her daughter Sophie saying that Tom had been shot. It was the last day of the spring term. She calmly finished photocopying a report she had been working on and distributed it into pigeonholes, before setting off for home. It was as if she was trying to put off discovering the full horror of the story. `I think you do anything to delay the moment of impact,` she says in the bright sitting room of her north London home.

After nearly two months by his hospital bedside in Israel, the family - Hurndall, her former husband, Anthony, and their children Sophie, Billy and Fred - were allowed to bring Tom back to the UK. The brain injury had left him in a coma; his main organs working, but nothing else. Did she accept that Tom would die from the start? `I think I knew,` she says. `The pressure in Tom`s head had damaged other parts of his brain. I knew he would never recover.`

Tom eventually died nine months later on January 13 2004 - Jocelyn`s birthday - in hospital in London. Was it a relief, in a way? `It was, because he wasn`t in pain any more,` says Hurndall. `But it was also impossible when he died.` She is silent for a long time. `I still haven`t accepted it.`

There's more, if you want me to look. Once again, everything was denied, till people who were outside could tell the rest of the world what was happening.
 
They did not compare the Israeli's to Nazi's, they pointed out that brutalising people will make them hate you. The 40 years of occupation has created a lot of hate. I don't know why that would surprise anyone.


Are you for real? That's exactly what they did. They identified collective punishment as a Nazi tactic, used by Israel. Thus Israel are like the Nazis. Never mind that every military action ever undertaken in human history constitutes collective punishment according to this definition.

Also never mind that Nazi Germany invaded Europe without provocation for the purpose of conquest. It's not like Poland was lobbing rockets at them on a daily basis.
 
Another 60 people were wounded, 16 of them critically, in the strike on the Ibrahim al-Maqadna mosque, which was reduced to rubble, they said.
Two brothers, 10 and 12 years old, were among the dead, medics said.
More than 200 people were inside the mosque praying when it was struck, witnesses said.


The muslims have fixed times for praying. Was this attack on a mosque made at a time when it was known that people would be praying in it?


http://www.theage.com.au/world/child-first-victim-of-gaza-tank-battles-medics-20090104-79kv.html
 
Are you for real? That's exactly what they did. They identified collective punishment as a Nazi tactic, used by Israel. Thus Israel are like the Nazis. Never mind that every military action ever undertaken in human history constitutes collective punishment according to this definition.

Also never mind that Nazi Germany invaded Europe without provocation for the purpose of conquest. It's not like Poland was lobbing rockets at them on a daily basis.

They identified a mechanism. They did not say Israel was like the nazis, they said that when you oppress an occupied people they will hate you, as happened to the Nazis.
 
The muslims have fixed times for praying. Was this attack on a mosque made at a time when it was known that people would be praying in it?
I don't know, maybe you should find out? Or are you just going to make accusations disguised as questions?

Meanwhile, it is known that Hamas stores weapons in mosques. Just watch the secondary explosions in this video:



Maybe if Hamas didn't store weapons in mosques Israel wouldn't target them?
 
I don't know, maybe you should find out? Or are you just going to make accusations disguised as questions?

Meanwhile, it is known that Hamas stores weapons in mosques. Just watch the secondary explosions in this video:



Maybe if Hamas didn't store weapons in mosques Israel wouldn't target them?

Muslims pray at fixed times in Mosques, the times are well known. The mosque was attacked at prayer time. It wouldn't have taken too much work to attack the mosque when it wan't prayer time, if it was thought to be a legitimate target.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom