The IDF Now Has A YouTube Channel

I will believe almost anything the IDF says because in Israel everything is outrageously open for scrutiny by the media. It's gotten so out of hand that reporters are telling the whole world what the next moves of the army will be. If the IDF put a video up for everyone to see you can bet your life that they KNOW FOR CERTAIN that those were rockets. You have to remember that Israel has recruiters on the Palestinian side that report about what activities are being done and where.
I suggest you don't be so quick on your trigger finger and THINK you know everything just because in the video it may appear to be this or that.

Believe it or not, the armed forces lie to their own people. I knew a WWII vet who fought in New Guinea. One night, he heard an attack at an airforce base. They went there in the morning, and it was a smoking ruin. The Australian public were told there was only minor damage. That's what happens in war.
 
The difference is that in Israel the reporters are everywhere and the soldiers themselves with all those cell phones with cameras are as good a source as any. picture filmed by a reporter. It is the people's army and the people know Everything that goes on. Heck, it's now at a miserable state where parents call their son's commanders giving them a hard time because their son was put on a long patrol or had to do long guard shifts in the middle of the night when it was raining.
The soldiers themselves go to the press (especially reserves) and tell them all that they've seen which is not right in the army.
These videos are authentic. That's all I can say. You can choose not to believe. I know my army, I know the mentality and I know the soldiers (I'm one of them) and I know that these videos are the real deal.
 
wow, daredelvis. That was actually a thoughtful post, and one that doesn't quite seem as charged with emotion as most of the posts on this subject tend to be.


I fully agree, and sometimes I feel like a bit of a jerk sitting here at my screen miles away from this conflict reading all these posts trying to pick a side, and pick an argument.

To me this is just another conflict in some part of the world I'm glad I don't live in and considering I have no "stake" in this conflict, I find it extremely difficult to identify "the greater evil"

So...who really broke the latest truce ? was it Israel when they went in and destroyed a tunnel under construction on November 4th, 2008, or the militants when they started constructing that tunnel ?

Where are the UN in all this mess ? I mean I'm reading about 1.4 million people in Gaza being subjected to inhumane conditions and the Security Council is where ? exactly ?

Was Hamas democratically elected ? Or did they seize Gaza by force ? How stupid could the people of Palestine be to elect a group that has the stated destruction of their far more powerful neighbour in their charter. They know they can't win this "war" with what they've got, and they have to be aware that these ineffectual rocket attacks are going to bring a response that Hamas is ill equipped to deal with. Maybe Hamas is using the people of Gaza as pawns for their own political ends.

It'll be interesting to see what comes out of this rockets in the back of the truck video. If Israel is proven to have made a mistake, what will they do ? Take it down and sweep it under the rug, or admit their error and apologise.
 
You can see they aren't rockets. rockets at least have some kind fins on them to stabalise flight. I can clearly see them rolling these tubes on the back of the truck.
Grad rockets have fins,, but they do not emerge until after they are fired. It would be hard to fit them iside the tube they are launched from if they had fins sticking out, don't you think? Prior to firing, they look like this: http://bsvt.net/gfx/photo/artboepripass/122.jpg

See any fins TFT?

yep, sometimes when you are a true believer...you get embarassed. Something tells me that this is not going to make you think about how you behave here and it will be straight back to accepting whatever the IDF say and slagging people who don't join you.
I'm not embarrassed at all Fool, but after seeing how Hezbollah pulled off hoax after hoax (Red Cross ambulance incident, unfired bullets claimed to have been shot at woman's house, etc) I take things with a grain of salt. You should try it sometime. I do think that Israel thought they were shooting at Grads, there is no evidence at all they were just shooting random Palestinians for fun.
 
Last edited:
To me this is just another conflict in some part of the world I'm glad I don't live in and considering I have no "stake" in this conflict, I find it extremely difficult to identify "the greater evil"
Really? If the firepower were suddenly reversed tomorrow, do you really think there would be an Israel that is 5/6 Jewish and a 100% Muslim PA next door?

So...who really broke the latest truce ? was it Israel when they went in and destroyed a tunnel under construction on November 4th, 2008, or the militants when they started constructing that tunnel ?
You really have to ask that question? Do you think there was a legitimate reason for Hamas to be digging a tunnel into Israel? That Israel should have just ignored it? Complained to the UN about it instead? If the latter, what do you think the UN would do, issue a strongly worded letter after months of debate?

Where are the UN in all this mess ? I mean I'm reading about 1.4 million people in Gaza being subjected to inhumane conditions and the Security Council is where ? exactly ?
Where is the UN in the Congo? In Darfur? In N. Korea? In Zimbabwe? In Burma? In Tibet? Etc etc.

Was Hamas democratically elected ?
Yes.

Or did they seize Gaza by force ?
After they were democratically elected in Gaza they proceeded to forcefully eliminate all their opposition.

How stupid could the people of Palestine be to elect a group that has the stated destruction of their far more powerful neighbour in their charter. They know they can't win this "war" with what they've got, and they have to be aware that these ineffectual rocket attacks are going to bring a response that Hamas is ill equipped to deal with. Maybe Hamas is using the people of Gaza as pawns for their own political ends.
Ya think?

It'll be interesting to see what comes out of this rockets in the back of the truck video. If Israel is proven to have made a mistake, what will they do ? Take it down and sweep it under the rug, or admit their error and apologise.
And what difference will it make? It's war, and this kind of thing is guaranteed to happen when you go to war.
 
Grad rockets have fins,, but they do not emerge until after they are fired. It would be hard to fit them iside the tube they are launched from if they had fins sticking out, don't you think? Prior to firing, they look like this: http://bsvt.net/gfx/photo/artboepripass/122.jpg

See any fins TFT?

.....


What you've just proved is that those cylinders of the back of that truck are not those Grad rockets you have linked a picture to.

Andy ouare the one who posted the video gloating ...


"Here's a video of Hamas asshats loading Grad missiles onto a truck Dec. 28, then they get blowed up real good:"


You didn't even know what grad rockets looked like back then did you? FOS
 
Last edited:
What you've just proved is that those cylinders of the back of that truck are not those rockets you have linked a picture to.
I think the only thing proven is that you had no idea what you were talking about. The rest is various degrees of likely or not likely.
 
Quoted for posterity.

Can we nominate that for a stundie? :boggled::boggled:
It is really amazing that we debate for 90 posts if those were or were not grad missiles or a mistake of identification by the IDF while on the other side of the border tens of missiles are falling everywhere trying deliberately to kill as many civilians as possible.
In my view this speaks highly of how people here see the moral of the IDF. It is so uncommon to see Palestinian civilians get killed (by mistake) by the IDF that if something like that happens we debate about it for 90 posts.
I'm glad that this is the situation.
 
Really? If the firepower were suddenly reversed tomorrow, do you really think there would be an Israel that is 5/6 Jewish and a 100% Muslim PA next door?
.

I don't know. Some things I'm reading suggest that Hamas is a radical organization that's not really supported by the Gazan populace. I'll raise the blockade of Gaza by Egypt in response to Hamas gaining power as part of my confusion. Is Egypt really worried about a radical Islamist state next door ? I'm thinking yes, based on this action.

If the Palestinian people really want the total destruction of Israel and a return to the diaspora, then I side Israel and their actions.

Yes, I have to ask the question about the tunnel. media reports are rather sketchy but seeing as how the IDF had to travel 250 meters into Gaza to halt the construction, IMO they could have waited until the tunnel hit the border ( seeing how there's a "truce' on ) and when it did , dig straight down then taken whatever action they deemed necessary. That would have disallowed any Palestinian "excuses" like they were building an air raid shelter.

Where is the UN in the Congo? In Darfur? In N. Korea? In Zimbabwe? In Burma? In Tibet? Etc etc.

Nowhere to be seen, but since there's calls from "the left" for this organization to get involved, I figured I'd raise it just to see what the counter was. I like your response, rather than the left's assertions.

Thanks for the clarification re the sequence of events regarding my confusion about the election and the seizing by force. This points to my accepting Israel's course of action even more in view of war being a representation of what the Palestinian people really want.

It just seems, to me at least, that spoiling for a war that you can't possibly win ( 'cept maybe with God's help ? ) is the epitome of stupid.

If Hamas is acting strictly on their own ideology and using the Palestinian people as pawns, then we have a different situation.

And what difference will it make? It's war, and this kind of thing is guaranteed to happen when you go to war

Yes of course. It's also a really slick PR campaign and this video was offered up by the IDF as "proof" of what they're doing is "right" and if, in the end, it does prove to be not what they originally intended and they are caught "making a mistake" just how they deal with this mistake will help ( or harm ) their cause in the theater of public opinion.

I have one "protester" type guy telling me that the IDF is using cluster munitions in this operation and dropping a load of them every 20 minutes. When I search for evidence of this, I find that although the IDF used them in Lebanon, the Israeli supreme court has banned their use. See what I mean when i say I'm feeling manipulated. Too bad i can't challenge that statement about the cluster munitions, as it's posted on a leftist forum, and any "questions" about things like that ( or Hamas rockets ) just result in ad homs and banning.
 
while on the other side of the border tens of missiles are falling everywhere trying deliberately to kill as many civilians as possible.
In my view this speaks highly of how people here see the moral of the IDF. It is so uncommon to see Palestinian civilians get killed (by mistake) by the IDF that if something like that happens we debate about it for 90 posts.
I'm glad that this is the situation.

Yes, exactly. Yet we have protesters screaming genocide whereas all the media reports ( well, MSM at least ) have reports differing numbers of dead militants vs dead civilians. I have no truck with the IDF taking out enemy combatants and it's a fact of war that some innocents are going to get caught in the crossfire, but when there's literally thousands of people "out in the streets" clamouring about civilian casualties, I just can't ignore them and wonder if they have some information that I 've either missed or don't have access to.
 
It is really amazing that we debate for 90 posts if those were or were not grad missiles or a mistake of identification by the IDF while on the other side of the border tens of missiles are falling everywhere trying deliberately to kill as many civilians as possible.
In my view this speaks highly of how people here see the moral of the IDF. It is so uncommon to see Palestinian civilians get killed (by mistake) by the IDF that if something like that happens we debate about it for 90 posts.
I'm glad that this is the situation.

The reason it's been debated is that there are those that will go to extraordinary lengths to absolve the IDF/israel/Zionist Movement of any crime.

And your hyperbole about "tens of missiles are falling everywhere trying deliberately to kill as many civilians as possible." is nonsense. Very few Israeli's have been killed because of the missiles compared to the huge amount of Palestinians killed in the last 60 years due to Israel's behavior.

Most of the Missiles fall on dead ground.
 
Most of the Missiles fall on dead ground.

Yes, but that's due to the limits of the weapons technology currently available to the Palestinians, no ? If they had access to bigger, longer range weapons, do you think they would use those instead ?
 
TFT said:
And your hyperbole about "tens of missiles are falling everywhere trying deliberately to kill as many civilians as possible." is nonsense. Very few Israeli's have been killed because of the missiles compared to the huge amount of Palestinians killed in the last 60 years due to Israel's behavior.

Most of the Missiles fall on dead ground.

Did you read what you quoted me saying?
"...trying deliberately to kill....". Trying...
The fact that Israel has many UAVs in the skies 24 hours a day helps immensly with the fact that they are mostly trying and not succeeding as much as they'd like to.
So nonsense it is not.

Israel's "behavior" as you put it is 95% due to retaliation against hostile activities of the terroristic organizations (they have several of those working against Israel simultanously). If you ask me, not enough has been done by Israel over the years in order to get rid of those terroristic organizations.

In this war it is not a simple body count as you are trying to make it. If they kill four of us that doesn't mean we should kill four of them. Israel cannot take terroristic acts on a daily basis as it has been doing for years. Ten rockets from the terrorists should mean hell to the people supporting them. Plain and simple.
 
Last edited:
The reason it's been debated is that there are those that will go to extraordinary lengths to absolve the IDF/israel/Zionist Movement of any crime.

And your hyperbole about "tens of missiles are falling everywhere trying deliberately to kill as many civilians as possible." is nonsense. Very few Israeli's have been killed because of the missiles compared to the huge amount of Palestinians killed in the last 60 years due to Israel's behavior.

Most of the Missiles fall on dead ground.

Please, next time we call you as terrorist apologist, please shut up about it, this post is proof that you are one.
 
Last edited:
Please, next time we call you as terrorist apologist, please shut up about it, this post is proof that you are one.

nonsense. I don't support the killing of civilians pardalis.


The next time you call me a terrorist apologist I shall call you out for the nonsense you spew.


The IDF are just as much terrorists as Hamas. Plenty of IDF apologists here.
 
Hamas is deliberately targeting civilians, whether or not they are successful at it is irrelevant.

So your "Most of the Missiles fall on dead ground" remark is spot-on apologism.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom