The IDF Now Has A YouTube Channel

Muslims pray at fixed times in Mosques, the times are well known. The mosque was attacked at prayer time. It wouldn't have taken too much work to attack the mosque when it wan't prayer time, if it was thought to be a legitimate target.
What is the basis for your claim that it was struck during one of the fixed prayer times? People pray in mosques outside of those prayer times, just as people pray in churches on days other than Sunday.
 
It says the mosque was full, that wasn't just a few people deciding to drop by and pray.
How do you know? Do you know what time it was hit? Do you know it wasn't an all-day "pray for Israel's destruction" special? Do you know the people weren't there 24/7 to act as human shields?
 
Last edited:
And your hyperbole about "tens of missiles are falling everywhere trying deliberately to kill as many civilians as possible." is nonsense. Very few Israeli's have been killed because of the missiles compared to the huge amount of Palestinians killed in the last 60 years due to Israel's behavior.

Most of the Missiles fall on dead ground.

Interestingly at least two notable human rights groups does not share your view on the rocket attacks against Israel:

This is what the Israeli human rights watch group B´Tselem has to say about the rocket attacks on Israeli:
Qassam rocket fire into Israel
Israel’s obligations in responding to Qassam rocket fire

And this what the Human Rights Watch have to say about the rocket attacks on Israel:
Letter to Hamas to Stop Rocket Attacks
Israel/Gaza Strip: Rockets and Shelling Violate Laws of War
The Human Rights Watch report found that Palestinian armed groups have deliberately targeted and launched indiscriminate attacks against Israeli civilians in violation of the laws of war. In addition to inflicting scores of casualties, the attacks have caused property damage and created a pervasive climate of fear in affected Israeli communities.
 
I do admit that "arm-chair general" seems to work here. At the very least, "arm-chair intelligence officers".

I especially like the 100% sure postings that you're dealing with gas cannisters that couldn't POSSIBLY be missiles at all...

_45342917_gas226.jpg


http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/7809371.stm

look like gas canisters to me.

But those IDF terrorist apologists will never admit it. I mean Israel could never make a mistake could it?
 
Last edited:
How do you know? Do you know what time it was hit? Do you know it wasn't an all-day "pray for Israel's destruction" special? Do you know the people weren't there 24/7 to act as human shields?

To you Israel is always right, always honest, always morally good isn't it?

I notice you NEVER condemn anything Israel does.
 

Yes. At this angle, with this color photograph, this close up, yes, they look like gas cannisters.

But those IDF terrorist apologists will never admit it. I mean Israel could never make a mistake could it?

blah blah blah apologist blah blah blah.

I swear, I could make some of you people into chatbots. It would look up random websites at random intervals for something involving the words "Israel" and "Gaza" and "Palestine" and "Violence", and then link to it while saying "Let's see the apologists question this!"

I, personally, wouldn't see the difference.
 
And I notice that you're trigger happy TO condemn it.

As far as I'm concerned, you're both silly.


Yes I do readily condemn Israel but I also condemn the killing of Israeli citizens by Hamas.

My bias is towards humanity whatever the race/ethnicity of people.

I condemn Israel a lot more because Israel is by far the worst culprit.
 
a_unique_person said:
There's more, if you want me to look. Once again, everything was denied, till people who were outside could tell the rest of the world what was happening.
http://www.kibush.co.il/show_file.asp?num=19030

On the local radio a few days ago, a known Israeli journalist who is known to be major left winged has said that he has many times been against IDF actions in the occupied territories because he has always read in Bets'elem reports how the IDF killed this 16 year old kid or that 13 year old etc. But now, he continued, after doing some research on the subject and filling in those reports with all other information he could find on these cases, he said he is changing his mind on the whole Bets'elem reports. He says that for some reason there have always been important details left out of those reports. Which details you ask? well for example that these boys were hanging around rocket launchers. He said he has been embarrased several times when giving these cases as proof of IDF unjustice (based on Bets'elem reports) and then been proven back that these reports were telling only half truths.

When you give proof of your point of view try to give neutral reports and not major left or right winged views.
The link you gave is a major left winged point of view similar to Bets'elem so anything they say, I would take with great caution.
 
How do you know? Do you know what time it was hit? Do you know it wasn't an all-day "pray for Israel's destruction" special? Do you know the people weren't there 24/7 to act as human shields?

A mosque in northern Gaza was also hit, during evening prayer time, in what witnesses said was an Israeli airstrike. At least 11 worshipers were killed and about 30 wounded, according to Palestinian hospital officials. The Israeli military had no immediate comment.
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/04/world/middleeast/04mideast.html
 
Look a_u_p, even if it was during a designated prayer time (and there is still no evidence it was other than the word of Hamas) it was a legitimate target if there were weapons being stored inside. Here's another mosque in Gaza making more booms than there were bombs dropped on it:



Your outrage would be better directed at Hamas for storing weapons amongst civilians, but I know that for you it's always Israel's fault.
 
On the local radio a few days ago, a known Israeli journalist who is known to be major left winged has said that he has many times been against IDF actions in the occupied territories because he has always read in Bets'elem reports how the IDF killed this 16 year old kid or that 13 year old etc. But now, he continued, after doing some research on the subject and filling in those reports with all other information he could find on these cases, he said he is changing his mind on the whole Bets'elem reports. He says that for some reason there have always been important details left out of those reports. Which details you ask? well for example that these boys were hanging around rocket launchers. He said he has been embarrased several times when giving these cases as proof of IDF unjustice (based on Bets'elem reports) and then been proven back that these reports were telling only half truths.

When you give proof of your point of view try to give neutral reports and not major left or right winged views.
The link you gave is a major left winged point of view similar to Bets'elem so anything they say, I would take with great caution.

this guy said ...

I will believe almost anything the IDF says because in Israel everything is outrageously open for scrutiny by the media. It's gotten so out of hand that reporters are telling the whole world what the next moves of the army will be. If the IDF put a video up for everyone to see you can bet your life that they KNOW FOR CERTAIN that those were rockets. You have to remember that Israel has recruiters on the Palestinian side that report about what activities are being done and where.

He believes almost anything the IDF says.

They knew for certain those gas cannisters were rockets? They never looked like rockets to me. Of course they could have guided that drone to follow the journey of the gas cannisters to see if they were being set up to be launched as rockets before murdering the people handling them.
 
Look a_u_p, even if it was during a designated prayer time (and there is still no evidence it was other than the word of Hamas) it was a legitimate target if there were weapons being stored inside. Here's another mosque in Gaza making more booms than there were bombs dropped on it:



Your outrage would be better directed at Hamas for storing weapons amongst civilians, but I know that for you it's always Israel's fault.

As I said, prayer times are well known. It would be just as easy to bomb it outside prayer times. If you want to say that Israel is no worse than Hamas, go ahead.
 
Yep, WildCat did concede his interpretation was likely to be wrong.


After looking at the pics Norseman linked to I will concede that this very likely was a bad mistake.

But I doubt that the IAF was looking for random targets of opportunity when it struck the truck, probably they knew rockets were being stored in that area and he was in the wrong place at the wrong time to be loading things on to a truck that look like missiles from several miles up in the sky.

But sheesh, one of the tanks had a regulator attached and they were letting it roll around in the back of the truck!
 
TFT said:
They never looked like rockets to me.

Oh well then they must not have been rockets.
I'll tell the IDF to cosult with you next time.
Please give me your telephone number.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom