The IDF Now Has A YouTube Channel

As I said, prayer times are well known. It would be just as easy to bomb it outside prayer times. If you want to say that Israel is no worse than Hamas, go ahead.
Sure it would. it's also possible that it wasn't a prayer time, or that there aren't just as many people in it outside of prayer time. Or that all the people "praying" were actually Hamas going into the mosque to retrieve their weapons.

Fact is, you don't know the facts. You only know what Hamas wants you to know, as they control the information coming out of Gaza.
 
If people were launching rockets at me every day, I'd blow up anything that remotely looked like one and tell everyone else to F-off.

Intel-"Look, tube shaped objects. Could be rockets or gas canisters"

Me-"blow it up"

One of my family is worth all of yours. Sad but true.
 
Last edited:
If people were launching rockets at me every day, I'd blow up anything that remotely looked like one and tell everyone else to F-off.

Intel-"Look, tube shaped objects. Could be rockets or gas canisters"

Me-"blow it up"

One of my family is worth all of yours. Sad but true.

+1
 
Sure it would. it's also possible that it wasn't a prayer time, or that there aren't just as many people in it outside of prayer time. Or that all the people "praying" were actually Hamas going into the mosque to retrieve their weapons.

Fact is, you don't know the facts. You only know what Hamas wants you to know, as they control the information coming out of Gaza.

It's all the fault of Hamas, I forgot :rolleyes:

http://feeds.bignewsnetwork.com/index.php?sid=431362
 
Perhaps you should admit you lack the expertise to actually make any judgment on the nature of the objects being loaded onto the truck.

On what basis do you judge me to have lack of expertise ? I can tell the difference between a gas bottle and a grad rocket.

I would think the IDF can as well. But unlike me they could care less, and fired anyway.
 
Fact is, you don't know the facts. You only know what Hamas wants you to know, as they control the information coming out of Gaza.

Fact is, you don't know the facts. You only know what Israel wants you to know, as they control the information coming out of Israel.
 
Oh and Israel play a big part ion the information coming out of Gaza as it's disallowed foreign journalists from entering Gaza.

Something to hide Israel? Like the truth?

Of course if Israel and it's apologists are claiming Hamas are distorting the truth ( which like Israel they probably are ) then why not allow journalists in.
 
Of course if Israel and it's apologists are claiming Hamas are distorting the truth ( which like Israel they probably are ) then why not allow journalists in.

What truths are Hamas distorting and what truths are Israel distorting?
 
It says the mosque was full, that wasn't just a few people deciding to drop by and pray.
A weapons cache is a target 24/7. LOAC is silent on wheather or not prayer time makes a weapons cache holy ground.

AUP, may I comment on the irony of a Skeptic choosing this venue to get touchy about prayer time to Allah? On this set of forums?

Appreciate the laugh. Cheers.

DR
 
A weapons cache is a target 24/7. LOAC is silent on wheather or not prayer time makes a weapons cache holy ground.

AUP, may I comment on the irony of a Skeptic choosing this venue to get touchy about prayer time to Allah? On this set of forums?

Appreciate the laugh. Cheers.

DR

You logic makes no sense. If they had thought this was a valid target, it was still a valid target a few hours either side of prayer time. If they were praying to an imaginary being or not is irrelvant.
 
On what basis do you judge me to have lack of expertise ?

Because if you had any expertise you wouldn't be so quick to make definitive statements about the nature of the materials. These sorts of determinations are never made based on imagery alone.



I can tell the difference between a gas bottle and a grad rocket.

No, you think you can. Such absolute claims are usually a sure sign of a lack of expertise. How many gas bottles and how many grad rockets have you previously observed in IR video? I'm going to take a wild guess here and suggest none. In fact I'm going to suggest before you watched this video you actually had no frikken idea what a grad rocket looked like.
 
You logic makes no sense. If they had thought this was a valid target, it was still a valid target a few hours either side of prayer time. If they were praying to an imaginary being or not is irrelvant.

You're making a pretty large assumption here that the decision to attack during prayers was made because it was during prayer time. A myriad of factors contribute to determine the best time to strike a particular target. The impact on civilians is only one of many factors, and once it is decided the target needs to be hit, it is actually the least important factor.
 
You logic makes no sense. If they had thought this was a valid target, it was still a valid target a few hours either side of prayer time. If they were praying to an imaginary being or not is irrelvant.

What if the target wasn't going to be there in a few hours time, or if Israel wasn't going to be able to hit it in a few hours time? Do we even know that more people were going to be there during prayer time than before or after?
 
What if the target wasn't going to be there in a few hours time, or if Israel wasn't going to be able to hit it in a few hours time? Do we even know that more people were going to be there during prayer time than before or after?

Do you really think they didn't have this lined up as a target months or even years ago?
 
Do you really think they didn't have this lined up as a target months or even years ago?
Why do you think that you know everything that IDF knows/has/wants/does?
In war there are strategic targets and there are dynamic targets.
Things progress and change as the war continues and new targets pop up or disappear.
All the targets that are aimed at go through many chains of command including the legal department that checks if hitting that target is in no violation of international laws.
Could it be that some weapons were starting to be removed from there?
Maybe at the time there were Hamas soldiers hiding there?
Maybe...maybe...maybe....
You don't know everything so how can you be so sure in your judgments?
 
Last edited:
Do you really think they didn't have this lined up as a target months or even years ago?

You are assuming that the mosque was the target. Do we know that this was the target? Could they have been targetting a person or an arms cache or something else that was movable?

I don't see how I can speculate for how long it was targetted.
 
But wait, there's more. Is it Hamas who controls the information getting out, or Israel?

We have been trying to report as accurately as possible on the fighting in Gaza.
But that is without question a challenge when we do not have reporters on the ground who can bring you first-hand information about what is taking place.
The reason we have no reporters on the ground in Gaza is because Israel will not allow foreign journalists into Gaza.
Tuesday night, we call for Israel to open the borders to allow journalists in, to allow them to do their jobs, to witness first-hand what is happening on the ground.


http://edition.cnn.com/2009/WORLD/meast/01/06/campbell.brown.gaza/index.html


The IDF is allowed to put up it's version of events, but it won't let reporters present an independent version of events.
 
But wait, there's more. Is it Hamas who controls the information getting out, or Israel?




http://edition.cnn.com/2009/WORLD/meast/01/06/campbell.brown.gaza/index.html


The IDF is allowed to put up it's version of events, but it won't let reporters present an independent version of events.
In Lebanon in 2006 the reporters were were tipping off Hezbollah as to what Israel was going to do next. They didn't want that to happen this time around.

There were also many examples of "independent" reporters being used as stooges by Hezbollah to spread Hezbollah misinformation, which they surely must have known about at the time.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom