The IDF Now Has A YouTube Channel

No, instead they steal land, and bulldoze homes, sometimes with families in them. Get some perspective.

I thought we were talking about Israeli military actions, not this garbage?

Oh please, don't try to impose Tin Foil Timmy's failed argument, on me. This notion of whether it's a law or not, is strawman, in order to hide behind the reality of the matter.

That's great. But do you think it would help your case if what Israel did was illegal? Then you could say, 'It's clearly illegal, as well, because X.' or whatever. Don't act like you wouldn't, pal!

Israel engages in some pretty brutal, indiscriminate, killing, too.

Killing is usually brutal. It's not pretty, certainly. And I suppose the burden of proof lies upon you to prove that it was indiscriminate. Sounds fancy, but can you convince someone who knows little of this argument that what Israel did was 'indiscriminate'?


It's amazing to me that we can find more moderates when it comes to dems versus republicans, on this forum.. but when it comes to the issue of Israel/Palestian, there is an overwhelming lack of moderates, or people that are willing to speak for the other side..

Parky is what I'd be willing to call a moderate when it comes to this topic. And did you not speak down to him for not being as 'extreme' in his view of the topic as you are?


Only??? ONLY??!! Are you ****ing joking??

It is certainly a big number, and an ugly one. Would you be willing to look at other, similar, aerial campaigns against a foe who is entrenched in a heavily populated ubran center? Just for comparisons sake?


Why do I need to compare/contrast to a different situation of your cherry picking?

Perspective?

A rational person never wants to limit reasonable inquiry.
(I like that quote)

Does that somehow negate your stated 1400 civilian palestinian deaths?

You are, of course, assuming all those who were killed were civilians. That is your first mistake. And you were complaining how there were so few moderates in this discussion!


Does that negate the thousands more civilian deaths that Israel's armed forces are responsible for, every single year?

Are you trying to poison the well there, Gang?

Why state that goal? They actively pursue it on a regular basis.

Yet the Palestinian population is growing, Israel is being pressured to turn control of land over the Palestinians, and a two-state option is becoming more and more likely. Their goal is within reaching distance, I just know it! :rolleyes:


God, this is why I try to avoid any threads that have to do with Israel, on this forum.. The Zionist vein, sickeningly, runs strong, through the JREF.


Because we do not see eye to eye, we sicken you? :D
 
Because we do not see eye to eye, we sicken you? :D

He doesn't seem to realize that "Zionism makes me sick!" is no argument at all -- and even if it were, it would at most be an argument in favor of Zionism...
 
Because we do not see eye to eye, we sicken you? :D

No, you sicken me because of your extremely pro-zionist bias, and the lack of fruitfulness that comes from discussing, or debating this topic with the majority of JREFers. It's sad that so called skeptics are given to such a propaganda driven bias, on such a critical issue. It blows my mind to think that anyone could support Israel, if you have a fair understanding in how it came to be. It's a complete waste of my time to go on about this topic. Tin Foil Timothy is a perfect example of what a waste of time it is.

Also, your smugness in your response, sickens me. You are a disgusting person to portray such a smug attitude on this issue (see smug green smiley grin, up above).

As I said above, I'm more than capable of acknowledging that Hamas is a shady organization that engages in indiscriminate killing, but a lot of you seem incapable of acknowledging the same about Israel, when it's true.
 
Last edited:
No, you sicken me because of your extremely pro-zionist bias

He thinks Jews have a right to fight back against those who call for their genocide and bomb their cities.

It blows my mind

Not much of a loss.
 
Last edited:
No, you sicken me because of your extremely pro-zionist bias

Well, since I am a pro-Zionist, I may have a bias. There's no question that exists. However, I'd like you to convince me that that bias is intefering with our discussion. You've made some pretty bold accustations, claiming what Israel did was indiscriminate (and routine). All I've asked for is some evidence of this. Since neither you or I can prove it WAS (or was not) indiscriminate, the best we can do is look at the evidence. Israel is using advanced technology and weapons that -should- minimize collateral damage. They have also dropped leaflets onto areas warning of the imminent airstrikes, and there have also been news reports of the IDF CALLING houses before they've been bombed. You have quite an uphill battle if you wish to convince someone (let alone my bias having self) that what Israel did was indiscriminate.


and the lack of fruitfulness that comes from discussing, or debating this topic with the majority of JREFers.

Gang, you are the one refusing to have a fruitful and productive discussion. You refuse to look at any other aerial campaign by a military against an enemy entrenched in a huge urban center because it's been 'cherry picked', whatever that means in that context. Grozny and Gaza bare quite a few similarities, not the least of which is that one side is vastly superior to the other and is determined to root out its enemies.

If you limit the scope of your discussions, you shouldn't be surprised at the results.

It's sad that so called skeptics are given to such a propaganda driven bias, on such a critical issue.

Propaganda such as?

It blows my mind to think that anyone could support Israel, if you have a fair understanding in how it came to be.

And you were complaining there are so few moderates in this discussion. WHERE IS THAT LAUGHING DOG ! ?
 
Many of my older (and some decased) relatives fought in Israel's war of independence. They told me quite a lot about it. I can't wait for Gangularis to explain to me how Israel "came into being", so as to explain to me how they've all lied to me all those years.

Not that he knows how one says "good morning" in Hebrew, or can name an Israeli city apart from Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, but hey, that's no obstacle to knowing the AWFUL TRUTH(tm) about Israel.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom