The IDF Now Has A YouTube Channel

It seems based off of the information provided by Norseman that they were gas cyliniders and not grad rockets. It's sad to think that this man lost his son as a result of such an error.
 
What strikes me about the first video is the way they are treating the objects they are moving. I don't think I would be rolling / kicking rockets around like what is shown in the video. I know I would not be kicking or moving gas cylinders around like that. From my experience in using various types of compressed gas it does not look like they are moving gas cylinders. Those suckers are heavy, and I doubt that someone would be carrying one one-handed, as you can see in the video.

I don't know what is being loaded in the truck, and I hope that the people who pulled the trigger on this one had more then that video image to go on before doing so. It might be just as Wildcat said, but IMO it is not a very convincing piece of evidence on its own. The shots of the mortar shells are far more convincing.

I should point out, that when I see videos such as this what I mainly see is 8-10 people dying and I have a hard time getting excited about that. It might be that this action saves several more lives, and it might be that everyone in that last frame is a homicidal maniac bent on killing all Jews for the sake of them being Jewish and getting what they deserve. Some of them could also be desperate people in a desperate situation, trying to survive and lashing out they only way they can.

I am worried about the uneven floors in my house, the rotten wood, and the cracks in the brick facade. I am worried if my wife an I will both keep our jobs next year, if we will have access to health care and what my retirement account will look like. I would not want to walk a mile in the shoes of anyone living in that part of the world, and I cannot begin to think that I understand what motivates wither side to take the actions they do.

Daredelvis
 
wow, daredelvis. That was actually a thoughtful post, and one that doesn't quite seem as charged with emotion as most of the posts on this subject tend to be.
 
From the btsalem site link.

According to Sanur’s testimony, he and members of his family were trying to salvage material from a metal workshop he owns, which was next door to a bombed house, in order to prevent looting. He denies any connection to militants, or military activity, and is willing to talk to any journalist, or investigator.

I would be interested to know why his direct neighbour was targetted by the IDF, if you look at the photos of the aftermath, it doesnt look like a house thats been bombed, it looks like it was a makeshift industrial unit just like Sanurs.
Just the kind of place you would manufacture quassams.

Also what kind of missile is fired from the IDF drone, is it a hellfire?
 
Last edited:
After looking at the pics Norseman linked to I will concede that this very likely was a bad mistake.

But I doubt that the IAF was looking for random targets of opportunity when it struck the truck, probably they knew rockets were being stored in that area and he was in the wrong place at the wrong time to be loading things on to a truck that look like missiles from several miles up in the sky.

But sheesh, one of the tanks had a regulator attached and they were letting it roll around in the back of the truck!
 
But sheesh, one of the tanks had a regulator attached and they were letting it roll around in the back of the truck!
[derail]while in grad school, I knew a guy who completely disregarded safety for getting the job done fast. In our lab, I caught him moving a cylinder by grabbing the regulator head and dragging the whole cylider across the room.

I also saw him try to open a 2 L bottle of acetonitrile, which had a sureseal top (a crimped beer bottle like cap), by banging it against an opened metal drawer.[/derail]
 
I don't think I would be rolling / kicking rockets around like what is shown in the video. I know I would not be kicking or moving gas cylinders around like that. From my experience in using various types of compressed gas it does not look like they are moving gas cylinders. Those suckers are heavy, and I doubt that someone would be carrying one one-handed, as you can see in the video.
Would it not make a difference if they were empty gas cylinders?
 
I guess my question is why are there more than 10 people there just to remove gas cylinders?
 
Would it not make a difference if they were empty gas cylinders?
Some, but as others have pointed out the regulators were on them. I assume they wanted to move them out fast, and this would explain the guy carrying one with one hand. I could not fathom moving cylinders with the regulators on unless I knew they were empty, but my tolerance for a safe work environment is likely higher then someone living in Gaza, and I can't stand to see tools/equipment abused.

Daredelvis
 
The amateur Intelligence Specialist dialogue has been fascinating, folks. Some good questions were asked.

I do appreciate that impulse to Skeptical methods, in terms of "how do you know that?"

For a bit of context: from operations I've been involved with, it isn't just the overhead that cues one to what is being loaded on the truck. The sources and methods are not infrequently sensitive, and some come from deep cover.

By all means be skeptical. Whatever the IDF is releasing, they aren't releasing everything they know, for what is likely sound operational reasons. Or, for other reasons. As Norseman points out, it might have been a mistake. :(

Tim, your default "it's an obvious sham" is a bit transpartent. A bit of homework, like Norseman did, would have made your response stronger.

From what I see see here, it's hard to confirm what the guys on the IR film were loading onto the truck.
What strikes me about the first video is the way they are treating the objects they are moving. I don't think I would be rolling / kicking rockets around like what is shown in the video.
A good point. However, if rockets are habitually handled, and are handled in an unarmed configuration, I'd not be surprised that, absent professional organizational methods, people got a little "familiarity breeds contempt" in their habitual tasks. Heck, getting sloppy even happens in professional militaries now and again.

Your point is a good one. There may be other human factors involved.
I know I would not be kicking or moving gas cylinders around like that. From my experience in using various types of compressed gas it does not look like they are moving gas cylinders.
Shape and what you said has me nodding my head with you. I'd not kick a missile either, being paranoid.
Those suckers are heavy, and I doubt that someone would be carrying one one-handed, as you can see in the video.
Maybe these lads are on steroids or speed. *shrugs*
I don't know what is being loaded in the truck, and I hope that the people who pulled the trigger on this one had more then that video image to go on before doing so.
Me too.
It might be just as Wildcat said, but IMO it is not a very convincing piece of evidence on its own. The shots of the mortar shells are far more convincing.
Aye.
I should point out, that when I see videos such as this what I mainly see is 8-10 people dying and I have a hard time getting excited about that. It might be that this action saves several more lives, and it might be that everyone in that last frame is a homicidal maniac bent on killing all Jews for the sake of them being Jewish and getting what they deserve. Some of them could also be desperate people in a desperate situation, trying to survive and lashing out they only way they can.
Yes.
I am worried about the uneven floors in my house, the rotten wood, and the cracks in the brick facade. I am worried if my wife an I will both keep our jobs next year, if we will have access to health care and what my retirement account will look like. I would not want to walk a mile in the shoes of anyone living in that part of the world, and I cannot begin to think that I understand what motivates wither side to take the actions they do.
Nods.
wow, daredelvis. That was actually a thoughtful post, and one that doesn't quite seem as charged with emotion as most of the posts on this subject tend to be.
Agreed.
That's the width of the cab. You buy the bed seperately, but the bed is always wider than the cab is.
Also what kind of missile is fired from the IDF drone, is it a hellfire?
If it's a Predator equivalent, Hellfire is a likely payload. Their reliability is excellent.
After looking at the pics Norseman linked to I will concede that this very likely was a bad mistake. But I doubt that the IAF was looking for random targets of opportunity when it struck the truck, probably they knew rockets were being stored in that area and he was in the wrong place at the wrong time to be loading things on to a truck that look like missiles from several miles up in the sky.
Could be the case. The man's problem is that, unlike with a jet low over head, he has no idea a UAV is over head. None. First thing he'll know is "kaboom" and perhaps "Hi, my name is Allah, glad you made it."

Rather sudden. Welcome to the world of high tech warfare. Lethality comes at a premium.
But sheesh, one of the tanks had a regulator attached and they were letting it roll around in the back of the truck!
Hard to get the whole picture, even in operations, no less at our desks on the Itarwebs.
Would it not make a difference if they were empty gas cylinders?
Depends.
There was that incident in the Lebanon war when farm workers, near the Syrian border, were attacked and killed.
Yeah, in war, sometimes a target gets attacked when it looks like a target. Sometimes, in peace, a target gets hit when it looks like a target. See 2 Blackhawks downed over Northern Iraq by two F-15's.

It can happen.

DR
 
Last edited:
Shame that they censor all comments underneath every one of their videos.

Sort of "We report, You listen"?

Not allowing any comments on a Youtube video is "censorship" now? Gravy didn't allow comments on any of his debunking videos that he had on Youtube, either. The reason is obvious: the tenor of comments given by Youtube viewers is so mindless and mean-spirited that it leaves essentially no room for legitimate discussion at all. Given the number of comments controversial videos like these produce, policing them is nearly impossible and would only lead to the appearance of far worse censorship. Why should they provide an avenue for hate-speech, whether it be anti-Semitic, anti-Palestinian, or Islamophobic?
 
Not allowing any comments on a Youtube video is "censorship" now? Gravy didn't allow comments on any of his debunking videos that he had on Youtube, either. The reason is obvious: the tenor of comments given by Youtube viewers is so mindless and mean-spirited that it leaves essentially no room for legitimate discussion at all. Given the number of comments controversial videos like these produce, policing them is nearly impossible and would only lead to the appearance of far worse censorship. Why should they provide an avenue for hate-speech, whether it be anti-Semitic, anti-Palestinian, or Islamophobic?

Don't you get it?!111 Discussion on anything involving Israel or Palestine is totally cool on Youtube! Can't they see what they're missing?

From here:

RensedotCom
not jewNN or Foxkike jew news
hey look up Stern Gang
and Irgun Gang
you will see who is the world terrorists
who started this **** in `1948
Menachem begin was a wanted TERRORIST by the british and later became premier
go figure
kikestan the terror state
the source of all terror car bombs
and murders especially in Lebanon
to create anther vcivil war only it backfired
time to tell the kikes at mossad to make another plan
LOL
one that works
ugly parrot beeek kikes

Who started the war in the first place? Do ur history and you will find out that this land belonged to the Palestinians until those Jews (Zionists) took it by force

StinkFingerr: **** u u stupid mother****er, the Palestinians used to live there before the Israeli *****, Jews (Zionists) came to Palestine and took their land.

Before Israel, Palestine was a peaceful country for all religions

now it is colonized by extremists criminal Jews who commit genocide

against the Palestinians to evacuate a place for the new extremists

immigrants. The world has to stop the holocaust, FREE Palestine from

extremists, and destroy criminal cell Israel. Stop the new Nazi = Israel

Go the Palestinian resistance the Palestinian Heroes Stop the Apartheid

and yes i use linux, ubuntu 8.10 for more... hahahhahahaah



Don't you guys get it? We TOTALLY need this debate! How else are we going to get anywhere closer to the truth if we don't watch people yell at each other over the internet or talk about what OS they use?

TOTAL sign of bias!
 
One thing that is annoying me is the reference to "mortars" in the video of the school. They aren't mortars, they're clearly some sort of rocket. Mortars don't produce a trail of rocket exhaust and they aren't fired with a flat trajectory like that. I doubt you'd even be able to see a mortar shell being fired on a camera like that. I'd expect a flash and cloud of dust/heat at the mouth of the mortar tube, and that's all.
 
Depends.

Yeah, in war, sometimes a target gets attacked when it looks like a target. Sometimes, in peace, a target gets hit when it looks like a target. See 2 Blackhawks downed over Northern Iraq by two F-15's.

It can happen.

DR

Yep we wiped out Serbia's complete fleet of cardboard tanks a few years ago.
 
The woman bases her claim that they weren't rockets because "dozens" of rockets would have made a bigger explosion. In fact, there were only 4 in the truck.

You were one of the guys fooled by the famous Hezbollah ambulance, weren't you?

You can see they aren't rockets. rockets at least have some kind fins on them to stabalise flight. I can clearly see them rolling these tubes on the back of the truck. Look like gas bottles to me.
 
You can see they aren't rockets. rockets at least have some kind fins on them to stabalise flight. I can clearly see them rolling these tubes on the back of the truck. Look like gas bottles to me.

These could be the rocket launchers and not the rockets themselves.
terrorcivilians6.jpg

These are tubes that can be kicked around and are around 1 meter in length from what I can see in the picture.
 
After looking at the pics Norseman linked to I will concede that this very likely was a bad mistake.

But I doubt that the IAF was looking for random targets of opportunity when it struck the truck, probably they knew rockets were being stored in that area and he was in the wrong place at the wrong time to be loading things on to a truck that look like missiles from several miles up in the sky.

But sheesh, one of the tanks had a regulator attached and they were letting it roll around in the back of the truck!

yep, sometimes when you are a true believer...you get embarassed. Something tells me that this is not going to make you think about how you behave here and it will be straight back to accepting whatever the IDF say and slagging people who don't join you.
 
yep, sometimes when you are a true believer...you get embarassed. Something tells me that this is not going to make you think about how you behave here and it will be straight back to accepting whatever the IDF say and slagging people who don't join you.

I will believe almost anything the IDF says because in Israel everything is outrageously open for scrutiny by the media. It's gotten so out of hand that reporters are telling the whole world what the next moves of the army will be. If the IDF put a video up for everyone to see you can bet your life that they KNOW FOR CERTAIN that those were rockets. You have to remember that Israel has recruiters on the Palestinian side that report about what activities are being done and where.
I suggest you don't be so quick on your trigger finger and THINK you know everything just because in the video it may appear to be this or that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom