The IDF Now Has A YouTube Channel

In Lebanon in 2006 the reporters were were tipping off Hezbollah as to what Israel was going to do next. They didn't want that to happen this time around.

There were also many examples of "independent" reporters being used as stooges by Hezbollah to spread Hezbollah misinformation, which they surely must have known about at the time.

Damn, you're good.

I'd been suspicious as to why Israel wasn't letting any press into Gaza and I was tending towards the rather popular " they have something to hide" reasoning because I couldn't think of any "legitimate" reasons on my own.

I went asearchin'

And came up with this.
 
For those of us who participated in or followed the discussion related to the video in the OP, here is the conclusion of the IDF's own investigation into the incident:

• Truck apparently carrying oxygen tanks (December 29th, 2008) – the truck was targeted after the accumulation of information which indicated convincingly that it was carrying rockets between a known Hamas rocket manufacturing facility to a known rocket launching site. The attack was carried out near a known Hamas rocket manufacturing site and after a launch. It was only later discovered that the truck was carrying oxygen tanks (similar in appearance to Grad Missiles) and not rockets. The strike killed four Hamas operatives and four uninvolved civilians. It is important to note that the oxygen tanks being carried in the truck were likely to be used by Hamas for rocket manufacturing.
Source: Conclusion of Investigations into Central Claims and Issues in Operation Cast Lead
 
what is wrong with an international investigation into these things? made up of folks from the UN, EU, USA, and Russia.
 
What is your definition of terrorism?

Terrorism is when Hamas kills civilians, but not when Israel does it, of course! Everybody knows it's not terrorism if the "good guys" do it. Then it's just "collateral damage".
 
Last edited:
Terrorism is when Hamas kills civilians, but not when Israel does it, of course! Everybody knows it's not terrorism if the "good guys" do it. Then it's just "collateral damage".

terrorism is a direct and purposeful act of violence or intimidation against a civilian population, in order to achieve a political or military aim.

so when Israel uses Arab human shields, that is terrorism.

when Israel blockades fuel, food, and medicine, to force the Palestinians in Gaza to rise up against Hamas, that is terrorism.
 
terrorism is a direct and purposeful act of violence or intimidation against a civilian population, in order to achieve a political or military aim.

so when Israel uses Arab human shields, that is terrorism.

when Israel blockades fuel, food, and medicine, to force the Palestinians in Gaza to rise up against Hamas, that is terrorism.

Were you even watching the last war, just a few months ago? White phosphorus ring any bells? Do you think the IDF really gives two craps about the people they're continually stealing land from? Why would they care about the civilians that elected Hamas, anymore than they care about Hamas themselves? They don't.
 
So Hamas not allowed to have rockets. Check.

Israel allowed to have rockets, even though they also kill civilians with their rockets. Check.
Last I checked, Israel does not chuck their rockets randomly at population centers as a means of their stated goal of genocide.

Do you really think a group of genocidal fanatics should be allowed to possess rockets?
 
Hamas would be allowed to have rockets, if they only targeted Israeli military.
I'm pretty sure that Israel would still target the rockets in that case. It's SOP to destroy the weapons of your enemy in wartime parky.
 
Were you even watching the last war, just a few months ago? White phosphorus ring any bells?
Tell me, what bells should this ring? If you're going to claim it violates "international law" please cite the relevant law. So far, everyone has faiuled at this for some reason, maybe you'll be the first one Gangularis!

Do you think the IDF really gives two craps about the people they're continually stealing land from? Why would they care about the civilians that elected Hamas, anymore than they care about Hamas themselves? They don't.
And yet an assault in an urban environment involving many tons of high explosives resulted in only 1400 deaths. How do you explain that?

Compare/contrast to Syria's assault on the PLO in Hama in 1982.
 
Tell me, what bells should this ring? If you're going to claim it violates "international law" please cite the relevant law. So far, everyone has faiuled at this for some reason, maybe you'll be the first one Gangularis!


And yet an assault in an urban environment involving many tons of high explosives resulted in only 1400 deaths. How do you explain that?

Compare/contrast to Syria's assault on the PLO in Hama in 1982.

The PLO wasn't in Hama. The assault was against Muslim Brotherhood and other Islamist insurgents, who had conducted a number of deadly terrorist attacks against the Assad regime as well as an assassination attempt on Hafez himself. Amnesty International estimated 10,000-25,000 people were killed, including about 1000 Syrian soldiers. That's out of an estimated population of 350,000 in the city at the time. The Gaza strip has a population of about 1.5 million.
 
And yet an assault in an urban environment involving many tons of high explosives resulted in only 1400 deaths. How do you explain that?

Compare/contrast to Syria's assault on the PLO in Hama in 1982.

Actually, the better comparison might be the Russians in their separate assaults on Grozny.
 
Last I checked, Israel does not chuck their rockets randomly at population centers as a means of their stated goal of genocide.

No, instead they steal land, and bulldoze homes, sometimes with families in them. Get some perspective.

Tell me, what bells should this ring? If you're going to claim it violates "international law" please cite the relevant law. So far, everyone has faiuled at this for some reason, maybe you'll be the first one Gangularis!
.

Oh please, don't try to impose Tin Foil Timmy's failed argument, on me. This notion of whether it's a law or not, is strawman, in order to hide behind the reality of the matter. Face it. Israel engages in some pretty brutal, indiscriminate, killing, too. You can't admit that, though, can you? It's amazing to me that we can find more moderates when it comes to dems versus republicans, on this forum.. but when it comes to the issue of Israel/Palestian, there is an overwhelming lack of moderates, or people that are willing to speak for the other side..

And yet an assault in an urban environment involving many tons of high explosives resulted in only 1400 deaths. How do you explain that?

Only??? ONLY??!! Are you ****ing joking?? .. :jaw-dropp

Compare/contrast to Syria's assault on the PLO in Hama in 1982.

Why do I need to compare/contrast to a different situation of your cherry picking? Does that somehow negate your stated 1400 civilian palestinian deaths? Does that negate the thousands more civilian deaths that Israel's armed forces are responsible for, every single year?

Last I checked, Israel does not chuck their rockets randomly at population centers as a means of their stated goal of genocide.

Why state that goal? They actively pursue it on a regular basis.

Do you really think a group of genocidal fanatics should be allowed to possess rockets?

Absolutely not. Lets bomb Israel's rocket cache (oxygen tanks), too..They shouldn't have it. They're genocidal fanatics. God, this is why I try to avoid any threads that have to do with Israel, on this forum.. The Zionist vein, sickeningly, runs strong, through the JREF.
 
Last edited:
How many times do we have to say this, slayhamlet? When these "human rights activists" can't blame the Jews or Americans (justly or not) for the death of Arabs , they don't care about them.

At first sight this is antisemtism or anti-Americanism. Well, I'm not that sure.

Remember the red shirts in the old Star Trek series? Red shirts guys' deaths only matter, leading to deep discussions of morality and guilt or innocence, when their death can be attributed to Spock or Captain Kirk or one of the other leading actors: was Kirk right to leave behind the poor red shirt guy on the evil planet to save the Enterprise or not? Was Spock right to say it's the logical thing to do? Etc. THAT is an entire episode. But when 100 red shirts are killed by an accident to the shield's capacitators... feh, who cares? They're expendable.

True, the Jews and Americans, for the "human right activists", might be the villans (as irrational as that is in itself). But at least they've got a speaking part. The Arabs are mere walk-on extras, whose sole purpose is to die violently so that the Americans or Jews can be blamed for it. When THAT happens, why, it's an entire episode (or entire set of threads.) But if the Arabs die violently in some other way, having nothing to do with Jews or Americans -- in much larger numbers of course -- the "human rights activists" ignore it. Arabs killing Arabs? Who cares if extras kill other extras?

So I don't know. I am more and more convinced that this double standard is not so much anti-semitism or anti-Americanism, but anti-Arabism.
 
Only??? ONLY??!! Are you ****ing joking?? .. :jaw-dropp
Go ahead Gangularis, find any large military operation in an urban area in the history of the world that has fewer casualties.

You won't be doing so, of course. Because Israel is simply not allowed to defend itself or its people in your ewyes, and therefore you will shreik and cry about every casualty suffered by an enemy that has vowed to destroy it and slaughter all Jews.

Why do I need to compare/contrast to a different situation of your cherry picking? Does that somehow negate your stated 1400 civilian palestinian deaths? Does that negate the thousands more civilian deaths that Israel's armed forces are responsible for, every single year?
Because it shows what an assault looks like where the party doing the assaulting really doesn't care about keeping casualties to a minimum. Of course, you don't give a damn about that because there were no Jews involved, and that's what it's really all about, isn't it?
 
Last edited:
Sorry, folks.

No apologies.

When you are ruled by terrorists whose stated goal is Israel's destruction; when they lob rockets at Israeli cities for eight years; when they deliberately put their bases inside mosques, schools, hospitals, and other heavily populated areas to use them as human shields; then, when at long last Israel fights back, if mosques and schools are hurt and human shields killed, well, that's just too damn bad.

We in Israel are just sick and tired of the hypocritical "human rights" folks who side with the likes of Hamas, Hizbullah, etc. -- or with the UN, which (due to the automatic majority of the Israel-hating dictators), is de facto the same thing.

Say anything you want. But don't expect us to give a damn. When YOUR house is bombed for eight years and you STILL refuse to act so as to not "violate UN resolutions" or "hurt human shields", well, THEN your words might mean something. But, please, not before that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom