The atheists favorite bible verses

It obviously nullifies Joe's prima facie argument, "the text means what it says", if the passage does not say "obey" anywhere. Why is this so difficult to understand?
The verb in question (that I've been translating as "break" or "disobey" in verse 19) in Greek is luo (in transliteration). Strong's Greek dictionary gives this definition:

a primary verb; to "loosen" (literally or figuratively):--break (up), destroy, dissolve, (un-)loose, melt, put off.

The KJV uses "break". (I suspect you'll face an uphill battle if you want to get ACS to accept that other Bibles are equally as valid as the KJV.)
 
Ok. As I see it, the part you have highlighted supports JtJ's case and mine.
I am not arguing your case, but his. Would you please explain why

the thing spoken of IS NOT x

supports Joe's case, which is

the thing spoken of IS x.

Good luck :D
 
(I suspect you'll face an uphill battle if you want to get ACS to accept that other Bibles are equally as valid as the KJV.)

Why would you suspect that when ACS used the NIV in the OP? (Acronymtastic!)
 
Last edited:
I thought I had done that. I will try again :)

First, the passage which says the law is still in force is not here. It is in verse 17. That is for everyone I think, for reasons I set out in post #466. This commentary then disagrees with what I set out in that same post as meaning for verse 19. That is true. It rests on your own point about the use of the word "annul" here, rather than "break". And this makes some sense of ACS's interpretation as he outlined it earlier, for which I am grateful.

So let us look at a bit more of the commentary.

Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary

19. Whosoever therefore shall break-rather, "dissolve," "annul," or "make invalid."

I am ok with any of these words: they do not affect verse 17 and so from my reading the law is still in force. But I accept yours and ACS's point that this part may refer to those with the power to "annul" the law, rather than to the generality of people. Specifically it may be directed at teachers or clerics or disciples and those kind of people.

one of these least commandments-an expression equivalent to "one of the least of these commandments."

No problem here, I trust?

and shall teach men so-referring to the Pharisees and their teaching, as is plain from Mt 5:20, but of course embracing all similar schools and teaching in the Christian Church.

This part of the commentary reiterates that we are talking to and/or about religious leaders of any stripe, I think. I am happy to give you this point, if it pleases you.

he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven-As the thing spoken of is not the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law, but annulling or enervating its obligation by a vicious system of interpretation, and teaching others to do the same;

The meat of the problem is here, I think. But I do not think the commentary supports your interpretation since I do not see how you can get around the word "obligation".

As I understand it everybody will break the Law. We are not perfect and we cannot be perfect. That is the whole point of Jesus, is it not? He redeems the original sin which separates mankind from god and he makes up for the fact we all sin. So far so good. But even in this commentary the law remains in force, as evidenced by the word obligation. We are supposed to obey it, because it is a law.

Our failure does not matter cos jesus sorts that out: it is what he is for, after all. But in this passage, as seen by this particular commentary, there is a sin apart from breaking the law which is addressed. That sin is sophistry, for want of a better word. As the commentary puts it, " annulling { } its obligation by a vicious system of interpretation". What this does is warn those with a position of respect within a religious community against thinking they can cherry pick the laws and teach others that some are not valid.

In some ways this has helped me to understand ACS interpretation (the one he laid out, not the others which he has not shared). And I do think it makes some sense. Problem for me is that it does not in any sense show that the OT law is not still in force:rather it serves to deny religious leaders any power to alter it. The prima facie meaning of the passage is unchanged by this: in fact it is strengthened

You may not agree, but I will be interested to hear how you see it
 
Whatever that "law" legislates, thanks to the long history of the development of democracy from the Magna Carta to the Constitution of these United States, the truly repulsive parts of it have been annulled by popular request, and those few parts that actually make sense have been incorporated in a meaningful manner in the social contracts.
Arguing whether Christians (or anyone) can/should/must obey all those old laws is just wasting bandwidth.
They have lost any significance with the general maturing and education of mankind from the simplicity of the Stone Age to present day's freedom from religion as enjoyed in many progressive countries now.
 
Last edited:
You may not agree, but I will be interested to hear how you see it
I agree to what you say mostly, and I find virtually all you say reasonable.

But even in this commentary the law remains in force, as evidenced by the word obligation. We are supposed to obey it, because it is a law.
I think, here you sense a problem which is not there. Let me try to express myself in a few bullet points.

(1) Yes, God's law is still valid. It will not be abolished, but "fulfilled". Means it has been partially incomplete, unclear etc. and JC has shown up to teach us about it.

(2) JC re-defines the law's obligations, the devine spirit, which is actually behind the concrete letter of the laws. Spirit and letter of law are both important, and not necessarily identical.

(3) A law system does not imply anything about public behaviour. Judges might obey, or not, to a law, I have no idea how Joe Blow might do it.

(4) Because any law simply says "A certain conduct shall be judged in a certain way." Laws don't imply any conduct at all, except for lawmakers, judges etc., they simply list forms of improper conduct and assign certain implications to it. Consequentially, a law is disobeyed when its implications are ignored in a lawsuit, for instance.
 
Last edited:
Why would you suspect that when ACS used the NIV in the OP? (Acronymtastic!)
D'oh! You're right.
:blush:

Guess I was guilty of making an assumption.

At any rate, the NIV version also uses "break".

Back to the larger issue of interpretation--even if you read verse 19 to mean something like "those who would try to destroy or invalidate even the least one of the old commandments by vicious interpretation will be called least in heaven" etc.---it would still have the more obvious meaning by implication.

Unless there is some way that not abolishing the law, and not changing even one part of a letter stroke of it, and this verse 19 reading can somehow mean the the law is to be preserved merely as a historical curiosity and not as laws that are still in effect. Even being very loose in interpreting the passage, I don't see how you could be so loose as to allow that reading.
 
Sorry ACS but that really won't do. In the past you have said that one must read the context and I agree with you. So I cannot see how you can take the view we must see this verse in isolation.

I'm on dial up this weekend so not sure how often or quick I can respond.

We were talking about verse 19 specifically.
Because that was Joe's claim about verse 19 specifically. He said that verse alone was obvious.

But on that verse alone it's how the word and is used in verse 19.

The only part of all those verses that makes it seem that it might mean the law is still binding is the phrase "until heaven and earth pass". I've been trying to look at these verses alone without reference to outside books in the bible - so if we can move on at some point past verse 19 I think I'll have to hold on with elaborating on what I think about that phrase.

I have already explained why I do not think the law in question can be other than the OT law. Perhaps you could say where you disagree?

I'll have to re-read what you wrote - but if I remember right it seemed like it's a possible reading of it.
 
(1) Yes, God's law is still valid. It will not be abolished, but "fulfilled". Means it has been partially incomplete, unclear etc. and JC has shown up to teach us about it.
I agree with this point, but not really the rest. The passage emphasizes that the old laws aren't to be altered even very slightly. Instead, it seems that Jesus says to obey those old laws to the letter, but ADD to that the new law. The new law says that it's not enough to refrain from committing adultery, it's also a sin to (borrowing from Jimmy Carter's famous Playboy interview) lust in your heart.
(2) JC re-defines the law's obligations, the devine spirit, which is actually behind the concrete letter of the laws. Spirit and letter of law are both important, and not necessarily identical.
I see no evidence in this passage or in the whole speech that Jesus is advocating some different interpretation of the old law.

By the way, the Transfiguration is another part of the gospel of Matthew that shows Jesus putting himself in line with the old prophets. Again, the message is that Jesus is for Jews and not some revolutionary character setting out to establish a new religion that rejects the old scriptures.
(3) A law system does not imply anything about public behaviour. Judges might obey, or not, to a law, I have no idea how Joe Blow might do it.
A law system does not imply anything about public behaviour????
(4) Because any law simply says "A certain conduct shall be judged in a certain way." Laws don't imply any conduct at all, except for lawmakers, judges etc., they simply list forms of improper conduct and assign certain implications to it. Consequentially, a law is disobeyed when its implications are ignored in a lawsuit, for instance.
Sounds like you're repeating number 3. I still don't buy it. The whole point of having laws of morality is to codify moral behavior, isn't it? You seem to think the point of having laws it to give lawyers and judges (presumably Pharisees and such?) some guidance. I'm pretty sure the Jewish tradition even at the time was to take them as moral prescriptions for everyone's behaviour.

For example, the one I quoted much earlier in this thread that tells farmers to let their fields lie fallow every 7th year and let the poor take gleanings from the fields at that time. I don't think these fields were farmed by lawyers and judges. Surely that law prescribes the farmer's behavior.
 
I knew we'd be back to this.

If your point isn't how Christians are behaving or should behave or you don't want to try to figure out what it means - what is your purpose for bringing these verses up?

Are you simply telling me your observation of what the words in these Matthew verses are?

Please clarify if you are simply making an observation or something else.
 
The verse says whoever breaks the least one of these commandments and teaches others to shall be called least in heaven, and those who keep them and teach others to do so shall be called greatest in heaven.

Again, I see no way of reading this to mean that he has abolished the old laws and that it doesn't matter whether or not you obey them.

You said it's obvious these verses mean Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and then asked how else Verse 19 could be read. I've showed how else verse 19 could be read and also that it doesn't even talk about Christians having to follow all the laws, but rather contrasts two types of teaching - a lesser one if you will and a better one. I take the better one to mean practice what you preach in essence.

Again - I'm only taking this verse alone - we've never even reached a point where we can move on to the other verses.

Do you still say verse 19 is obvious it means Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws? I'm not talking about any verse right now except verse 19. Is that verse alone obvious it mean Christians must follow all Old Testament Laws?
 
Last edited:
In some ways this has helped me to understand ACS interpretation (the one he laid out, not the others which he has not shared). And I do think it makes some sense. Problem for me is that it does not in any sense show that the OT law is not still in force:rather it serves to deny religious leaders any power to alter it. The prima facie meaning of the passage is unchanged by this: in fact it is strengthened

You may not agree, but I will be interested to hear how you see it

Hi Fiona,

I agree with you here. I currently think, well with the interpretation we're talkin about here, that if the question being wondered is how are religious leaders to act then these verses would be appropriate. For the question on what individual Christians are to do - I think it's not applicable. It doesn't appear that's what it's about. I think I posted something along these lines elsewhere here, but it's been buried. An individual might be able to consider some things from these verse, but it's not clear enough to do much and would probably need to be considered alongside other verses directed at individuals.

By the way everyone reading this, at this point I'm not interested in reading all the verses throughout the bible pertaining to this. So please refrain from jumping in with those at this point.

For this thread I'm wanting to get to the intent of these verses which are used liked in the OP (but not being told to me on how to behave by atheists personally. :) )
 
Last edited:
Instead, it seems that Jesus says to obey those old laws to the letter, but ADD to that the new law.
Bizarre. There is not one single new law by JC in the NT. You lack the most basic understanding.

The new law says ...snip...
Your "new law" does not exist.

I see no evidence in this passage or in the whole speech that Jesus is advocating some different interpretation of the old law.
That doesn't speak for you.

You seem to think the point of having laws it to give lawyers and judges (presumably Pharisees and such?) some guidance.
You seem to confabulate.
 
As I understand it everybody will break the Law. We are not perfect and we cannot be perfect. That is the whole point of Jesus, is it not? He redeems the original sin which separates mankind from god and he makes up for the fact we all sin. So far so good. But even in this commentary the law remains in force, as evidenced by the word obligation. We are supposed to obey it, because it is a law.

Ack, please don't bring up Original Sin. It's a terrible piece of Catholic dogma. It's the most disgusting piece of theological ******** I know of. It has only a passing reference with the Jesus of the gospels (yes, even John), and has no place in the historical context of Roman-occupied Israel.
 
Bizarre. There is not one single new law by JC in the NT. You lack the most basic understanding.


Your "new law" does not exist.

Oh boy! It's time for an episode of everyone's favorite ambiguously referential sports event "Do you know your Bible better than the atheists?" with color commentators, Bible Bill and Jesus Jon!


Bill: Currently the atheists have a commanding lead, but the believers are attempting what looks like a rally. Let's check the source!

Jon: Well, here comes Romans 7 in which Paul declares Christians "are delivered from the law, that being dead wherein we were held; that we should serve in newness of spirit, and not in the oldness of the letter," yet goes on to say that that law they were delivered from is still righteous, holy, and needs to be followed.

Bill: I don't know Jon, that could be ruled a case of biblical contradiction. Yes, our judges refuse to rule on that case and require a clear cut passage.

Jon: Look, they're bringing out Matthew 5:21-22 and I think its going to be a clear decision. Matthew quotes Jesus describing how the old law works in regard to murder and changes as to how anger is now sufficient to cause damnation.

Bill: Yep Jon, that's a clear example of Jesus providing a 'new law' and the judges to score yet another point for the atheists over the Believers.

Jon: Bill, this looks like a slaughter, are the Believers planning to make any sort of shift in strategy?

Bill: No it doesn't look like it, each player seems to be running his own unique interpretation of the plays and ignoring the playbook completely.

Jon: What kind of coaching could let this farce continue?

Bill: Well that's the thing Jon, the owner's been missing since early in the pre-season and never managed to actually appoint a head coach.

Jon: Now Bill, I don't think that's right, I'm sure there's a German bloke running the show there. Gave me the right willies last time I ran into him.

Bill: Yes, that's true but only a fourth of the team respect his authority and even most of them ignore him most of the time.

Jon: But what about the other three fourths?

Bill: It's a fascinating situation, there are almost as many coaches as there are players. Most of them brought in personal trainers to act as coaches and there's also several coaches over there all named Hank.

Jon: Doesn't that cause confusion?

Bill: Oh yes, it cripples team communication. Every player who suggests running Hank's new play does something different because no one can figure out which Hank they're talking about. Oddly enough, most of them don't even realize there's more than one Hank on staff.

Jon: Amazing! Why on Earth do they keep showing up if they have all these problems? I can't remember the last time they won a match.

Bill: Well that's the thing, they think they're the undefeated champions.
 
Last edited:
@ ACS. As I said, I am giving you verse 19 for teachers, though I still think it is a stretch. Verse 17 for everyone. This still means Christians should follow the OT laws if they accept this part of the bible, for that is what the passage means. And I am not going to rise to all this "you are telling me what to do" We have done that to death and it annoys people to no purpose. You know this . You also know I think it means Christians should follow the OT laws; there is no ambiguity in my position. Only you know the implications of that for you own behaviour, since it is possible the passage is plain wrong. There really is nothing more to be said on this subject. We are, at your own recommendation, "moving on"

Do I understand that both ACS and Herzblut are able to agree that verse 19 imposes old testament law on clerics and religious teachers and that sort of person? I would really like an answer to that. particularly in light of
ACS said:
I currently think, well with the interpretation we're talkin about here,

We are in danger of a repeat of the earlier frustration if I make this assumption and later you use this caveat to renege or even to clarify a misunderstanding at this point. I woud like to avoid that if I can
 
Ack, please don't bring up Original Sin. It's a terrible piece of Catholic dogma. It's the most disgusting piece of theological ******** I know of. It has only a passing reference with the Jesus of the gospels (yes, even John), and has no place in the historical context of Roman-occupied Israel.

Sorry to have annoyed you. I do not need that particular doctrine to make the case: whether we are inherently sinful or not, we are certainly not able to keep the law for a lifetime in its entirety.

As an aside, I once heard a very funny radio play about this. The premise of the play was that a very, very good man, who happened to be atheist, suddenly became a saint. This caused him all sorts of problems because he got the full set of biblical miraculous abilities. Most of the play was about the problems this caused him: he could not rest for being called in as a translator, and a healer; couldn't move for folk mobbing him and wanting him to advise them etc. So he wanted to stop being a saint. This man never breached his own moral code but he was advised he must sin if wanted to get out of he situation. So he tried all sorts of things but he couldn't manage it. Prostitutes he tried to sin with immediately took the mary magdalene pledge and stuff like that. So he was perplexed. Catholic friend to the rescue. He advised him to convert on the grounds that he could not be a catholic and not sin, in face of the prescriptive demands of that faith. Bingo! Problem solved. This is much the same :)
 
Jon: Look, they're bringing out Matthew 5:21-22 and I think its going to be a clear decision. Matthew quotes Jesus describing how the old law works in regard to murder and changes as to how anger is now sufficent to cause damnation.

Bill: Yep Jon, that's a clear example of Jesus providing a 'new law' and the judges to score yet another point for the atheists over the Belivers.

But is it a new law? The letter of the old law is: do not murder. But if you're angry, then you commit murder in your heart. And so you break the spirit of the same law.

The "eye for an eye" becoming "turn the other cheek" would be a better example. I don't see how the latter is the spirit of the former.

Also, I don't see how "love your enemies" is in the spirit of "hate your enemies".
 
@ ACS. As I said, I am giving you verse 19 for teachers, though I still think it is a stretch. Verse 17 for everyone.

Why is it for everyone?
If the latter use of "annul" is translated as "break" I could see that there are two different people addressed. It would be Jesus saying "I have not abolished the law. And those that break it -- naughty, naughty!"

But with the word "annul" used, which is pretty much the same as "abolish", the meaning becomes Jesus saying: "There are two kinds of teachers in the world -- I am like one and not the other".

This still means Christians should follow the OT laws if they accept this part of the bible, for that is what the passage means.

It certainly endorses the old laws. Those that wish to say the old laws have been replaced need to look elsewhere.
 
Last edited:
But is it a new law? The letter of the old law is: do not murder. But if you're angry, then you commit murder in your heart. And so you break the spirit of the same law.

The "eye for an eye" becoming "turn the other cheek" would be a better example. I don't see how the latter is the spirit of the former.

Also, I don't see how "love your enemies" is in the spirit of "hate your enemies".


I'd say it is. It used to be "kill your brother and go to hell" now it's "be angry at your brother without cause and go to hell" That's new even if it's similar. You still aren't supposed to kill him of course, but in addition you must not be angry at him.

Your example works too, of course, although I don't believe you were supposed to hate your enemies before, just kill them. Then again, the concept of 'love your enemies' has some interesting semantic meaning when you consider it more deeply. It is not "have no enemies" but "love your enemies". This suggests that having enemies is an acceptable state of affairs, which in turn leads to the possibly of loving your enemies while killing them. Just a thought.

eta:Just realized you might think I'm arguing the old laws were replaced. I'm not, just that there was some stuff added and a few rules may have been relaxed in the dietary restrictions area.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom