The atheists favorite bible verses

Quixotecoyote--

Excellent.

You have studied the "wild woo" trying to "blend in" to the skeptical community quite closely, I see. Kudos.
 
This "he said, she said" thing has been going on for far too many posts. I'm embarrassed at having to talk about it.

ACS, even if JtJ wasn't clear in his first sentence, then he certainly was after that. Please move on.
 
I'll give you a mixed review on this one. You can't let clear analogies stand. Analogies are an excellent way to help people comprehend a new issue in terms they already understand and can undo a lot of painstaking obfuscation and misdirection, so your instinct to muddy the waters was good.
To explain or understand an obvious meaning, no analogies should be required. Using analogies contradicts the assertion of obviousness.
 
To explain or understand an obvious meaning, no analogies should be required. Using analogies contradicts the assertion of obviousness.

Correct, which is why Joe was not using the analogy to explain the passage, instead using it to explain the dynamics of describing a discrepancy versus prescribing behavior.

eta: "It is easier for Heaven and Earth to pass away than for the smallest part of the letter of the law to become invalid."

You have to be a fairly committed LfJ to interpret that as saying anything except 'the pre-existing laws are still valid.
 
Last edited:
Correct, which is why Joe was not using the analogy to explain the passage, instead using it to explain the dynamics of describing a discrepancy versus prescribing behavior.
Well, the analogy was used to make somebody understand Joe's interpretation of a text with alleged self-evidence. This is a contradiction.

eta: "It is easier for Heaven and Earth to pass away than for the smallest part of the letter of the law to become invalid."

You have to be a fairly committed LfJ to interpret that as saying anything except 'the pre-existing laws are still valid.
What is "LfJ" and why follows your conclusion?
 
A better one would be me going through your books about vegetarianism, finding a few sentences in one of your books that could be interpretted to mean fish is not meat and should be eaten by vegetarians, and then telling you that your not doing what it says right there in those sentences. I might also tell you an inconsistent vegetarian is one who does not eat fish. And then I could conclude by saying that it is obvious that that sentence means all vegetarians are supposed to be eating fish. I mean, how else could that sentence be read?

OK--fine, let's use a version of your analogy. What if the source says that a vegetarian should NOT eat fish?

Read this next paragraph carefully:

The reason I'm making this change in your analogy is because to parallel our situation what the text says should be the opposite of the critic's opinion. Otherwise the two will line up, and you'll say that the two statements are identical. Just because "the text says you should do x" and "I think you should do x" are both true statements does NOT make them equivalent statements. To avoid that issue, let's use something a non-vegetarian (or you anyway) would not likely be thinking.

If you then say "It's obvious that the sentence means all vegetarians are supposed to refrain from eating fish", is that the same thing as you saying you think all vegetarians should refrain from eating fish?

If you claim it is, I'd find it odd that you, a person who eats fish, is saying that I'm not supposed to eat fish.

ETA: I am assuming you are a person who eats fish.
 
Last edited:
Well, the analogy was used to make somebody understand Joe's interpretation of a text with alleged self-evidence.
No it was not. The analogy, as QC said, was to explain how the statement "the text says you should x" is not equivalent to "you should do x".

I haven't addressed arguments about the meaning of the passage itself since ACS abandoned that discussion a looooong time ago. (Remember, he said the statement means "practice what you preach" and says nothing about the validity of the old laws.)*
What is "LfJ" and why follows your conclusion?
I took that to mean "Liar for Jesus".

*ETA: I think Fiona gave a fine explication of why any other reading of that passage just doesn't make sense.
 
Last edited:
-deleted-

Joe explains it better and I'm a little uncomfortable speaking for him anyway.
 
Last edited:
This "he said, she said" thing has been going on for far too many posts. I'm embarrassed at having to talk about it.

Fair enough - as long as I'm the "he said" :D

ACS, even if JtJ wasn't clear in his first sentence, then he certainly was after that. Please move on.

You're right - it is clear now. I was hoping Joe and others would understand why I thought they and he meant what he originally wrote. Next time, JoeTheJuggler, just quote what you're actually replying to instead of the whole OP. Thanks.

Moving on then:

JoeTheJuggler - do you still stand by your claim that your conclusion is what those verses in Matthew obviously mean? Because I'd like to hear your response to Herzblut's points.
 
No it was not. The analogy, as QC said, was to explain how the statement "the text says you should x" is not equivalent to "you should do x".
If the meaning of the text was so obvious, self-evident, clear, unequivocal there would have been no demand for any dispute using farfetched analogies.

I took that to mean "Liar for Jesus".
Why should atheists do this?
 
JoeTheJuggler - do you still stand by your claim that your conclusion is what those verses in Matthew obviously mean? Because I'd like to hear your response to Herzblut's points.
Heck I would like you to answer the question I have asked on numerous occasions. I even start a thread like you asked. So will you tell me.

Should Christians stick to all, some or none of the laws of the OT ?

Congratulations your resurrection btw.
 
If the meaning of the text was so obvious, self-evident, clear, unequivocal there would have been no demand for any dispute using farfetched analogies.
I agree. That's why, as has been pointed out twice now, I didn't offer the analogy to support the obvious reading of the text of Matthew.

The analogy is there to illustrate why the statements "according to the text you should do x" is not equivalent to "you should do x"/

Why should atheists do this?
It was a follow up to QC's earlier tongue-in-cheek post where he used the conceit of teaching ACS how to be a more skillful liar.

That was in response to the second (or more??) occasion when ACS quoted my words, and proceeded to argue that they mean something different than what they say by flagrantly ignoring words in the quote.
 
Heck I would like you to answer the question I have asked on numerous occasions. I even start a thread like you asked. So will you tell me.

Should Christians stick to all, some or none of the laws of the OT ?

Congratulations your resurrection btw.

Done. I posted in your thread.

Now - JoeTheJuggler - please answer Herzblut's points. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
You're right - it is clear now. I was hoping Joe and others would understand why I thought they and he meant what he originally wrote. Next time, JoeTheJuggler, just quote what you're actually replying to instead of the whole OP. Thanks.
No. . I think a much better idea would be for you to read the words that I have written and not conveniently ignore the ones that don't fit into your preconceived notions.

Moving on then:

JoeTheJuggler - do you still stand by your claim that your conclusion is what those verses in Matthew obviously mean? Because I'd like to hear your response to Herzblut's points.
This is "moving on"?

ACS, and Hertzlut: I used the analogy to explain why the statement "according to the text you should do x" is not equivalent to the statement "you should do x". [Note this is the 4th time that I know of that this has been explained.]

The analogy was NOT offered as an argument for any particular reading of the Matthew passage.

Now, if you want to discuss the Matthew passage, I am happy to.

However, my discussing it would in no way refute my contention that the obvious meaning is the correct one. Your refusal to acknowledge the the text in that passage clearly addresses the question of whether or not the old laws still apply (and answers that question in the affirmative) does not make it any less obvious.

Seriously, show that passage to any disinterested party and give them a multiple choice response for the interpretation that best fits it.

Let one of the choices be something like "Jesus says he is not abolishing the old Jewish scriptures and that you should obey every least one of the commandments in the older scriptures" and let another choice be "that Jesus is saying you should practice what you preach and he is not addressing the validity of the old laws at all".

How do you think such a survey of disinterested people is likely to turn out?

Do you still stand behind your "practice what you preach" interpretation?
 
Now - JoeTheJuggler - please answer Herzblut's points. Thanks.
You're awfully bossy for someone who continues to ignore many of my questions.

OK--for the 5th time: I used the analogy to explain why the statement "according to the text you should do x" is not equivalent to the statement "you should do x".

The analogy was NOT offered as an argument for any particular reading of the Matthew passage.

Now to my questions. First, respond to the vegetarian analogy (yours is fine as long as you use the modification I suggested and explained). Is your saying, "According to this authoritative text on vegetarianism, you should refrain from eating fish" equivalent to your saying, "You should refrain from eating fish"?

The only time you responded to the same question without using the analogy (to whit: Is my statement, "According to the author of Matthew, Jesus says you're supposed to obey all the O.T. laws" equivalent to my statement, "You're supposed to obey all the O.T. laws"), you said that you thought the "according to Matthew" part could be understood and wasn't needed. You then promptly turned around and misread the ambiguous statement to mean that I am trying to convince you that you should obey all the O.T. laws.

So--I have replied to your bossy demands for an answer (4 times myself--and QC answered it once for a total of 5 times). Now you really should be nice and kindly answer my questions. Perhaps then the conversation will in fact "move on" and not just go in the same tired circle.
 
-deleted-

Joe explains it better and I'm a little uncomfortable speaking for him anyway.
Nonsense. Your explanation was perfectly intelligible. I don't know why it wasn't enough.

Also--hop in, after all I piped up in explaining your LfJ thing! :)
 
ACS, even if JtJ wasn't clear in his first sentence, then he certainly was after that. Please move on.
You're right - it is clear now. I was hoping Joe and others would understand why I thought they and he meant what he originally wrote. Next time, JoeTheJuggler, just quote what you're actually replying to instead of the whole OP. Thanks.
ACS, surely you're not willfully misreading FireGarden's statement, are you?

In fact, even if my first post was unclear, my position has been clear pages and pages and pages ago, yet you're still stuck on the problem of equating "According to the author of Matthew, Jesus said you should obey all the laws of the O.T." and my saying that you should obey all the laws of the O.T.

This is not a concession that my first post was unclear. It's just trying to point out how unreasonable it is for you to keep on the same point when you have understood my position quite clearly for days if not weeks by now.
 
He wants you to admit the fault was yours... otherwise he has to admit to either being disingenuous or daft. Clearly, his semantics show the former--not the latter. He's trying to get you to say, "ahh... I can see how you misinterpreted me--my mistake--sorry, chap". Yet person after person has explained it and understood you--as well as his continual refusal to acknowledge your analogy or answer his own question--

I think this makes it obvious that some part of him is very aware of how he's "obfuscating" for Jesus, so to speak.

These sorts give you just enough to keep the conversation going... because as long as they can have the last word-- the win the game in their head. It's not about understanding... it's about distracting himself from that bible passage by making bad guys out of the people who point out the passage.

It's easier to vilify you-- then examine what you are actually saying. And it won't change. There are none so arrogant as those who imagine themselves humble due to their "faith".
 
ACS, and Hertzlut: I used the analogy to explain why the statement "according to the text you should do x" is not equivalent to the statement "you should do x". [Note this is the 4th time that I know of that this has been explained.]
No two different texts are equivalent.

The analogy was NOT offered as an argument for any particular reading of the Matthew passage.
Of course not. You have never offered ANY argument to support your particular reading of the passage. You don't expect me to regard your weird writings about public surveys as a valid argument, do you?

You are founding bold accusations ("cherry picking") against a religious group on unsupported propositions. This is discriminative against such group.
 
Last edited:
JoeTheJuggler,

Please answer these points Herzblut brought up about your claim regarding Matthew 5:19. Your claim was that it is obvious they mean I and other Christians have to follow all the Old Testament Laws. I understand it's not you personally telling me what to do - that is clear now.

Here is your claim:
JoeTheJuggler said:
Well it's obvious that according to the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus said that you still have to obey every last one of the Jewish laws (what Christians call the Old Testament). Is there any other reading of verse 19?

Here was Herzblut's points.
Herzblut said:
His argument is simply wrong. His proposition goes
There is an obvious meaning of Matt 5,19, which (happily) coincides with my privative interpretation. It is clearly obvious, that JC directly demands all Christians to obey all OT laws.

His justification goes
My interpretation is true, because the meaning is obvious.

That proposition is null and void. The meaning is obviously not obvious because atheists in this thread have suggested at least 6 other possible meanings. Not to talk about billions of Christians who do not buy into it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom