You're right - it is clear now. I was hoping Joe and others would understand why I thought they and he meant what he originally wrote. Next time, JoeTheJuggler, just quote what you're actually replying to instead of the whole OP. Thanks.
No. . I think a much better idea would be for you to read the words that I have written and not conveniently ignore the ones that don't fit into your preconceived notions.
Moving on then:
JoeTheJuggler - do you still stand by your claim that your conclusion is what those verses in Matthew obviously mean? Because I'd like to hear your response to Herzblut's points.
This is "moving on"?
ACS, and Hertzlut: I used the analogy to explain why the statement "according to the text you should do x" is not equivalent to the statement "you should do x". [Note this is the 4th time that I know of that this has been explained.]
The analogy was NOT offered as an argument for any particular reading of the Matthew passage.
Now, if you want to discuss the Matthew passage, I am happy to.
However, my discussing it would in no way refute my contention that the obvious meaning is the correct one. Your refusal to acknowledge the the text in that passage clearly addresses the question of whether or not the old laws still apply (and answers that question in the affirmative) does not make it any less obvious.
Seriously, show that passage to any disinterested party and give them a multiple choice response for the interpretation that best fits it.
Let one of the choices be something like "Jesus says he is not abolishing the old Jewish scriptures and that you should obey every least one of the commandments in the older scriptures" and let another choice be "that Jesus is saying you should practice what you preach and he is not addressing the validity of the old laws at all".
How do you think such a survey of disinterested people is likely to turn out?
Do you still stand behind your "practice what you preach" interpretation?