The atheists favorite bible verses

You're wrong. What Robin said implies NOTHING about the Jamieson-Fausset-Brown commentary, because the J-F-B commentary is not one of the "atheists in this thread".
You're wrong. Because what the JFBBC says corresponds to the interpretation of one of the atheists in this thread. Guess who, Einstein. :D
 
That's the problem. This passage in Matthew says that he's only extending or refining the existing law--and you'd better keep the old law crossing every t and dotting every i.
Right. Your privative interpretation of the passage says

(1) JC does not change God's Law, not even the dotting of an 'i'.

(2) JC does change God's Law.

Pretty weird, isn't it? How might anybody hold this crap without screaming cognitive dissonance?

Edit: Obviously, one can if one also finds that my interpretation, namely
the thing spoken of is not the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law

does not blatanly contradict one's own, namely
the thing spoken of is the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law.
 
Last edited:
Instead of confabulating again answer my questions, please.
No.

And please look up the word confabulate.

If you think the only person who can break a law is a lawmaker or judge, you're simply wrong. If you think the O.T. laws weren't meant for regular Jews (not just lawmakers and judges) to obey, you are wrong.
 
You're wrong. Because what the JFBBC says corresponds to the interpretation of one of the atheists in this thread. Guess who, Einstein. :D
So you're an atheist. Right! OK.

You implied that several atheists on this thread offered other interpretations, and that's not true. I believe you are the only "atheist" who subscribes to a view that this passage means something other than a refutation of the notion that the old laws are null and void and no longer count.

Fiona is willing to give you and ACS the benefit of the doubt for some parts (by admitting that some points of your readings are possible but only at a stretch), but still has not, I believe, accepted that the passage either means that the old laws are abolished or that the passage doesn't say something about the validity of the old laws. (I also don't know if Fiona is an atheist anyway.)
 
Right. Your privative interpretation of the passage says

(1) JC does not change God's Law, not even the dotting of an 'i'.

(2) JC does change God's Law.
Nope. This is a mischaracterization of my position.

Here you are equating "God's Law" and the "law and the prophets" (which we've been referring to by the shorthand "old laws" or "laws of the Old Testament").

If you swap "laws of the Old Testament" for "God's Law" in statement (1) and remember that it is understood that this is "according to the author of Matthew" and not my own opinion, then it's a good enough characterization of my position. I would never use the phrase "God's Law" since that makes a lot of assumptions that I don't accept (aside from the ambiguity you are making use of by having it refer to both the old testament laws and Jesus' teaching). I'd recast statement (2) something like "according to the author of Matthew, Jesus is adding requirements (a "new law" if you will) to the existing and still valid old laws."
 
Really? For example, can we find a cite in the "old law" where it says to "hate your enemies" as Jesus says in verse 27?

[...] It seems to me that Jesus's device of "you have heard it was said" is his way of going after current tradition. If it was actually in the law, then he would say, "It is written..." I think the "Hate your enemies" was something that was assumed, but not actually part of the law.

I read the phrase in the same way as Quixotecoyote.

But looking at Matthew 5 again,
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew+5

Divorce is introduced with "It has been said...." rather than "You have heard that it was said..."

So maybe it isn't just a rhetorical device. He could be correcting misconceptions.

Now, "eye for an eye" is certainly in the Law of Lev and Ex (and Deut, I think)

So there's still an example of an old law being overturned. In spite of the huge endorsement the old law gets from Jesus just a few verses earlier.
 
If you think the only person who can break a law is a lawmaker or judge, you're simply wrong.

I've lost track of that particular conversation, but could Herzblut mean that some laws only apply to judges, etc. That would fit with the examples he gave, which "bind the legislature, the executive, and the judiciary".
 
I've lost track of that particular conversation, but could Herzblut mean that some laws only apply to judges, etc. That would fit with the examples he gave, which "bind the legislature, the executive, and the judiciary".
Laws primarily bind state authority, I think. This is relevant for the special Matthew wording saying "whoever breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do so.." in the context of the Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary. They read breaking as "unbinding" etc. This cearly refers to authorities, not to people on the street.

I was trying to make sense of my interpretation, even when using the verb "break" instead of the more appropriate "annul". If state authority breaks a law, the law itself is annuled, it ceases to exist.
 
Last edited:
Really? For example, can we find a cite in the "old law" where it says to "hate your enemies" as Jesus says in verse 27?

Indeed, Lev 19 is very clear here:

" 'Do not seek revenge or bear a grudge against one of your people, but love your neighbor as yourself. "

But nowhere in the bible can we find the instruction "hate your enemy." In fact, the OT actually tells the exact opposite:


Wonder what happens if they are not one of 'your people'. Are we allowed to seek revenge and/or bear a grudge?

Could this be the part that allows you to hate your enemy (those other people).

;)
 
@Herzblut. I have looked at the examples you have given from German law. What you seem to have there is an interpretive statute. For example, in this country we have incorporated international human rights law into domestic law. Where there are different interpretions of law the judicary is bound to adopt the interpretation which is in line with the human rights legislation if one of those interpretations is not.

We simultaneously have a sovereign state and the legislature of that state can pass any law it likes including laws which violate the incorporated human rights legislation. Since the legislature is able to do this; and since the judiciary cannot overturn it; the legislature is required, where an application is made for it to do so, to consider any new law in light of those human rights provisions. Where it finds the new law conflicts with those it MUST issue a statement of incompatibility.

These are examples of laws which bind the judiciary. Those particular laws are irrelevant to the rest of the population because they are not in a position to violate or comply with them: only the judiciary can be affected. That is the kind of point I am prepared to concede both for the first example you have cited, and for Matthew 19.

In other matters there are laws and rules which govern the conduct of a trial etc and those are also binding on the court system and personnel alone: they are not so relevant but clearly there are laws which apply only to lawmakers and enforcers.

This does not in any way demonstrate that other law does not prescribe behaviour for everyone. The only possible point I can see you might have is that law does not actually have the power to make or prevent people doing whatever they like: it can only impose a penalty where some action in contravention of that law is taken. If that is what you mean then it is true and also trivial. The very fact that a penalty is imposed for non-compliance demonstrates that law is made for the purpose of prescribing the behaviour of the population or community.

Unless you intend something else then I cannot at all see you have a substantive point

@JoeTheJuggler. Yes, I am an atheist. I am quite surprised that was not clear
 
Last edited:
What you say implies that the Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary says
the thing spoken of is not the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law

and that this complies with your case, namely
the thing spoken of is the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law.
Can you point out where I have said this? I have not said this at all.

The thing spoken of is that not a single letter, nor smallest part of a letter will pass away from the law.

The thing that is subsequently spoken of is that the least commandment cannot be annulled, or destroyed, or broken up or loosened.

Again, it would help if you would simply state your interpretation of the passages in question. You seem to be suggesting that he is saying that the laws "a) will never pass away, b) can not be annulled and c) don't have to be obeyed.

You say that statement X has a meaning not significantly different from statement Not-X.
You need to think about that just a little longer. The annulment of a law and the requirement to obey it are dependent concepts, not a mutual exclusion.

You appear to be saying, for example, that if a speeding law is not annulled then motorists are thus freed to exceed the posted limit.

I kindly disagree with you, if you don't mind.
 
Last edited:
This does not in any way demonstrate that other law does not prescribe behaviour for everyone.
I don't have to demonstrate anything. You're the one making a claim, not I. So, what "other law" are you thinking of? Like ... Family Law? It describes my rights and duties in case I'll divorce. Does it hence "prescribe my behaviour" in any way, whether I shall divorce or not?

The only possible point I can see you might have is that law does not actually have the power to make or prevent people doing whatever they like: it can only impose a penalty where some action in contravention of that law is taken. If that is what you mean then it is true and also trivial.
Criminal law does not prescribe any behaviour, because behaviour simply cannot be prescribed. Instead, it prescribes certain values, which have to be respected by anybody. And it binds state authority to protect those values in a certain way.

The very fact that a penalty is imposed for non-compliance demonstrates that law is made for the purpose of prescribing the behaviour of the population or community.
Not at all. German law does not "prescribe my behaviour" at all. For instance, law does not prescribe where I shall spend my vacations, and when. It doesn't tell me to smoke or not to smoke. It doesn't tell me to do sports, or not.
 
Hertzblut, answer my question: do you think the moral commandments of the Jewish scripture are there to direct lawmakers and judges and NOT to prescribe personal conduct?
 
Not at all. German law does not "prescribe my behaviour" at all. For instance, law does not prescribe where I shall spend my vacations, and when. It doesn't tell me to smoke or not to smoke. It doesn't tell me to do sports, or not.
Just because the law doesn't prescribe your every behaviour doesn't mean it doesn't apply to you as an individual. Surely you can disobey or break the law, can't you? Surely it's not just legislators and judges who can break the law.

If the law says you must not do X or must do Y, it is prescribing your behavior. The fact that you can do Z or not do Z is irrelevant.

By the way, did you think the author of Matthew had Jesus addressing issues of modern European law or the old Jewish scriptures?
 
Constitutions primarily bind state authority, they are intended to spell out what the government is and is not allowed to do.

Statutes primarily bind individuals, declaring what is illegal to do, and only bind judges and lawmakers insomuch as they may mandate or limit sentences.

Do you think Jesus was outlining some sort of constitution for judges and lawmakers among his followers? My reading, paraphrased, is that no one is to violate the law, neither are they to teach or encourage others to do so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom