The atheists favorite bible verses

I don't see how my examples can be taken in the same way. They have to be new laws. Somehow not abolishing the old laws. In which case you have to both love and hate your enemies. Otherwise, Jesus will have removed more than a tittle from the old law.

That's the problem. This passage in Matthew says that he's only extending or refining the existing law--and you'd better keep the old law crossing every t and dotting every i.

Other parts of the N.T. are in direct conflict with this.

If the Bible itself is your only moral guide, you're screwed.
 
We were talking about verse 19 specifically.
Because that was Joe's claim about verse 19 specifically. He said that verse alone was obvious.

But on that verse alone it's how the word and is used in verse 19.
We were also talking about YOUR interpretation of the passage that it means "practice what you preach" and has nothing to say about the validity of the old laws.

Is that still your position? (This is at least the third time I've asked this. Why don't you read and respond to what I write until I've written it over and over and over?)
 
I find it weird that the moral absolutist christians will point to the bible as their source of morality while denouncing moral relativism. I guess moral relativism is only good if you're the god that they worship, who seems to have changed morality from OT to NT to today.
 
If you really believe this is God's law and that following it determines how you'll spend your eternity... then you'd want to give it the strictest and most literally interpretation possible-- right? You wouldn't want to be re-interpreting "god" through your measly mortal viewpoint, right? Why would anyone play fast and loose with interpretation when their ETERNITY is at stake. If the bible is god's rubric for for his big pass/fail life- test--
then why wouldn't people aim to get "extra credit"? It's either not divine or it's of utmost importance to determine what it's saying and follow it as closely as possible-- right?

Except that's looking at it rationally. The self delusion required to believe in an imaginary super-tyrant also causes one to become glassy-eyed and vacant when attempting to think about said super-tyrant. Also, it would undue all the hard, hard work done by apologists in making their respective religions palatable to modern norms.
 
The real question behind all this rhetoric is why would a divine entity inspire a text that is so prone to interpretation that it can mean anything you want it to mean? Why would anyone choose to follow such a book or imagine it as "divine" in origin? Why would someone imagine themselves moral for following a book which they've clearly not read and/or interpreted very differently than others reading the same words.

Theist inanity and apologetics never ceases to baffle me. You have to be really good at lying to yourself and others to be a Christian it seems. Either that, or not think about it at all and spend all your time demonizing those who try to get you to do so.
 
Another thing I never did get--tangential to this discussion--is why someone who believed this stuff was the actual words of a deity wouldn't want to learn the languages it was originally written in. I know there are some few who do so, but not the vast majority of believers.

There are also believers who think that God perversely put errors in the original (and who knows how many intermediate versions) such that their preferred translation is the only correct one. Even if you believed that, I'd still think you'd want to be able to read the original--if for nothing else but for a greater emotional connection.

I have less trouble with believers who don't think the text is such a direct revelation, but appreciate that you should take into account human error, biases, historical and linguistic context, etc.
 
That proposition is null and void. The meaning is obviously not obvious because atheists in this thread have suggested at least 6 other possible meanings.
I am not aware that anybody has produced a significantly different possible meaning.
 
I think he's a "significantly different" atheist.

I suspect the meaning may be as different to him as his varied biblical interpretations.
 
The only other one I've heard is ACS' reading that the passage means "practice what you preach" and has nothing to say about the validity of the old laws.

The slight spin that Hertzblut has been trying to read into this still seems to be saying that the old laws are still in force. He's just saying they're not rules for personal conduct or some such. Like that business about being circumcised or eating a kosher diet--that's not there for normal people to follow, but only for the sake of judges and lawmakers.
 
Isn't this the sort of debate that is won by audience acclaim only. I mean, if you debate for the sheer pleasure of debating, then that is fine but if you debate to 'actually' prove something in these books, then I think you are pushing ◊◊◊◊ up hill.

I mean unless either side is 100% sure of their interpretive argument, then both sides are wrong! I don't think you are allowed to be 83.5% right when it comes to god's words. It causes problems at the main gate. ;)

Both original testaments say what they say and nothing anyone here can put forward, will interpret correctly, what the authors (not the translators) wanted to say.
Note: They also show how dumb a god could be when he/she would allow a bunch of semi-literate, superstitious old men to write such obtuse nonsense and then call it his/her words.

Because of the basic un-believability of most things found in this 'holey' book(s), I very rarely use any of it to argue a point. I must admit though, I do use it as barbed humour when a theist starts to bad-mouth us poor innocent atheists.

To me, both books are a load of dog's vomit, to others they are their life's rules. If they are right when we 'kick off this mortal coil', then good luck to them. If I'm right, we will never know. My vote is worm-food.

:)
 
Seriously, do you think only "lawmakers and judges" can disobey or break a law?
Yes, in general this is the case. Let's take some samples from German law (since I know it best):

German Constitution:
I. Basic Rights

Article 1 [Human dignity]

(1) Human dignity shall be inviolable. To respect and protect it shall be the duty of all state authority.
(2) The German people therefore acknowledge inviolable and inalienable human rights as the basis of every community, of peace and of justice in the world.
(3) The following basic rights shall bind the legislature, the executive, and the judiciary as directly applicable law.
So, article 1.1 et al. of our Constitution is binding for whom?

German Criminal Code:
Sections dealing with particular crimes:


Whoever <conducts in the described way> shall be punished with <the described punishment>.
So, who shall do what, according to all those sections of our criminal law?
 
Last edited:
I am not aware that anybody has produced a significantly different possible meaning.
What you say implies that the Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary says
the thing spoken of is not the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law

and that this complies with your case, namely
the thing spoken of is the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law.

You say that statement X has a meaning not significantly different from statement Not-X.

I kindly disagree with you, if you don't mind.
 
Last edited:
"You have heard it said" is a rhetorical device used repeatedly in the sermon on the mount to refer to the old law in order to compare it with new standards:

Really? For example, can we find a cite in the "old law" where it says to "hate your enemies" as Jesus says in verse 27?

A search for "hate your enemy" finds only Matt 5:43 and Ex 23:5. Now, a great thing about www.bible.com is that it has the passages cross-referenced. Indeed, for the Matt passage, it actually cites the source of the "love thy neighbor"

"You have heard that it was said, 'Love your neighbor [ Lev. 19:18] and hate your enemy.' "

Indeed, Lev 19 is very clear here:
" 'Do not seek revenge or bear a grudge against one of your people, but love your neighbor as yourself. "

But nowhere in the bible can we find the instruction "hate your enemy." In fact, the OT actually tells the exact opposite:

Exodus 23:5 (Whole Chapter)
If you see the donkey of someone who hates you fallen down under its load, do not leave it there; be sure you help your enemy with it.

It seems to me that Jesus's device of "you have heard it was said" is his way of going after current tradition. If it was actually in the law, then he would say, "It is written..." I think the "Hate your enemies" was something that was assumed, but not actually part of the law.

Now, "eye for an eye" is certainly in the Law of Lev and Ex (and Deut, I think)
 
Yes, in general this is the case. Let's take some samples from German law (since I know it best):

So, article 1.1 et al. of our Constitution is binding for whom?

So, who shall do what, according to all those sections of our criminal law?
So you think a criminal doesn't break or disobey the law? Such a thing only happens when a lawmaker or judge does something wrong?

A murderer is NOT a law breaker? A speeder hasn't violated an ordinance (or disobeyed the law)? What about DWI? For a while the ad campaign trying to encourage less drunk driving was based on the slogan, "It's the LAW!"

You really think laws don't prescribe personal conduct? You really think laws--especially the ones in question which are the O.T. laws and not the German Constitution, by the way--are only instructions to judges and lawmakers?

So who is supposed to follow a kosher diet?

Who is supposed to leave his fields fallow every 7th year?

Who is supposed to not commit adultery?

Sorry, but your position is completely untenable. If your position was true, then no one except lawmakers and judges was "supposed to" obey the old laws to begin with. Surely that's not the approach that the Bible has taken.

In fact, according to the story of Moses and the Commandments in Exodus, the only lawmaker was God. The laws were prescription for personal behavior. When the people broke the law (for instance about not worshipping other Gods when they made the golden calf), there were no judges, just immediate and swift slaughter. Sure sounds like they were "supposed to" obey the law (which, in this case, they didn't even know about yet). Again, there were no judges or lawmakers (other than God), so your notion that the laws are only for them doesn't hold up.
 
The meaning is obviously not obvious because atheists in this thread have suggested at least 6 other possible meanings.


I am not aware that anybody has produced a significantly different possible meaning.
What you say implies that the Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary says<snip>
You're wrong. What Robin said implies NOTHING about the Jamieson-Fausset-Brown commentary, because the J-F-B commentary is not one of the "atheists in this thread".

It's plain that when Robin said "anybody" it was understood by context to mean "anybody on this thread".

The only alternative interpretations I've seen have been ACS' theory that the passage means "practice what you preach" and has nothing to say about the validity of the old laws, and the various things you've said that seem now to hang on the notion that laws can't be broken or disobeyed by anyone except lawmakers and judges.

Merriam Webster defines the term "lawbreaker" thusly:

MW said:
noun
Date: 15th century

: a person who violates the law

Nothing about it being only lawmakers or judges.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom