The atheists favorite bible verses

Statutes primarily bind individuals, declaring what is illegal to do, and only bind judges and lawmakers insomuch as they may mandate or limit sentences.
What you mean by only in "..and only bind judges.."?

Do you think Jesus was outlining some sort of constitution for judges and lawmakers among his followers? My reading, paraphrased, is that no one is to violate the law, neither are they to teach or encourage others to do so.
That's fine. Just that there's a better reading, I think. Look at the source, please:

Disciples and the World
13'...
...
19' Whoever then annuls one of the least of these commandments, and teaches others to do the same, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven; but whoever keeps and teaches them, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.

This passage is addressed to his disciples and says that one is not to annul the law, but rather to keep it in place. The aspect of personal conduct is not of primary importance for exactly this passage.

Instead, personal conduct within society becomes the dominating aspect in the following Antitheses where it says couple of times:

Personal Relationships
You have heard you were told <THIS>...
But I say to you <THAT>...


http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=matthew%205;&version=49;

Please see the two subtitles, which are also supporting this reading.
 
Last edited:
I don't have to demonstrate anything. You're the one making a claim, not I.

I don't think so, Herzblut. You are claiming that law does not prescribe behaviour and this is a distortion of ordinary language. It is tortured and it seems like sophistry. I think the burden of proof lies with you in this instance and I think you are wriggling. :)

So, what "other law" are you thinking of? Like ... Family Law? It describes my rights and duties in case I'll divorce. Does it hence "prescribe my behaviour" in any way, whether I shall divorce or not?

Law has nothing to say on many issues. JoeTheJuggler has already pointed this out. Where it applies it prescribes behaviour and you are fudging when you say it describes your rights and duties on divorce, for example. Those rights and dutes which it outlines do in fact prescribe your behaviour. For example it might provide that you make a payment for the support of your children. You are going to have a hard time meeting that duty if you do not, by your behaviour, arrange to send the money. It does not apply if you do not divorce? so what? Laws about speeding on the highway do not apply if you do not drive, nor when you are not driving? so what?


Criminal law does not prescribe any behaviour, because behaviour simply cannot be prescribed. Instead, it prescribes certain values, which have to be respected by anybody. And it binds state authority to protect those values in a certain way.

And there you go again. Criminal law does, arguably, try to reflect the values of a society. It does so by prescribing and proscribing certain behaviour. It is in fact one of the important principles of law that it does not penalise thought crime: it penalises certain kinds of behaviour, fortunately for all of us. You want to lock people up for holding different values if they don't do anything illegal based on those values? Remind me not to put you in charge of the dominoes club :)


Not at all. German law does not "prescribe my behaviour" at all. For instance, law does not prescribe where I shall spend my vacations, and when. It doesn't tell me to smoke or not to smoke. It doesn't tell me to do sports, or not.

As already stated: it applies where it applies. The default position in western secular democracies is that you are free except where the law says you are not. You are arguing that there is no law except when "everything not forbidden is compulsory"
 
I don't think so, Herzblut. You are claiming that law does not prescribe behaviour and this is a distortion of ordinary language.
No, it isn't. Why don't you provide evidence by citing subject matter experts who support your proposition?

And there you go again. Criminal law does, arguably, try to reflect the values of a society. It does so by prescribing and proscribing certain behaviour.
No, it doesn't. It does so by threatening a punishment which corresponds to the social ranking of the breached value. Punishment shall correspond to guilt. Even if such punishment does not alter any "behaviour", it will be imposed upon culprits nevertheless.

It is in fact one of the important principles of law that it does not penalise thought crime:
Thought crime? What are you talking about?

As already stated: it applies where it applies. The default position in western secular democracies is that you are free except where the law says you are not. You are arguing that there is no law except when "everything not forbidden is compulsory"
No, I'm not. You should quit trying to explain my own arguments to me.
 
Last edited:
What you mean by only in "..and only bind judges.."?


That's fine. Just that there's a better reading, I think. Look at the source, please:

Disciples and the World
13'...
...
19' Whoever then annuls one of the least of these commandments, and teaches others to do the same, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven; but whoever keeps and teaches them, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.

This passage is addressed to his disciples and says that one is not to annul the law, but rather to keep it in place. The aspect of personal conduct is not of primary importance for exactly this passage.

Instead, personal conduct within society becomes the dominating aspect in the following Antitheses where it says couple of times:

Personal Relationships
You have heard you were told <THIS>...
But I say to you <THAT>...


http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=matthew%205;&version=49;

Please see the two subtitles, which are also supporting this reading.
Your link has a commentary on Matty 5.

This passage seems to suggest that an uncommitted Christian is not a Christian at all (see 5:20). Like other Jewish teachers, Jesus demanded whole obedience to the Scriptures (5:18-19)....

God has not given us the right to pick and choose among his commandments....

Jesus concurs: God does not allow us the right to say, "I will obey his teaching about murder but not his teaching about adultery or fornication"; or, "I will obey his teaching about theft but not about divorce." To refuse his right to rule any of our ethics or behavior is to deny his lordship.

The commentary refers to ‘Christian’, 'our' and ‘us’, perhaps the writer of this commentary was one of the disciples and only considers other disciples Christians.

Or perhaps your source thinks you are wrong.
 
Last edited:
Thanks!

The commentary refers to ‘Christian’, 'our' and ‘us’, perhaps the writer of this commentary was one of the disciples and only considers other disciples Christians.
Hmm, I don't know, to be honest. The author speaks of disciples here: Jesus essentially says, "Look, if you thought the law was tough, wait till you see this. If you really want to be my disciples, give me your hearts without reservation"

and here: It is possible to agree with everything Jesus taught in this sermon yet fail to live accordingly ... Nothing short of a radical transformation, what other early Christian writers called a new birth (Jn 3:3-6; 1 Pet 1:23), can enable one to live as a disciple (compare Mt 18:3).

To "live as a disciple" does not sound to me like a livestyle to be imposed on every christian. I might be wrong, though.

Or perhaps your source thinks you are wrong.
I can live with that:

God has not given us the right to pick and choose among his commandments. As some teachers put it, one should be as "careful with regard to a light commandment as you would be with a heavy one, since you do not know the allotment of the reward" (m. 'Abot 2:1). The sages were not suggesting that they never broke commandments (see Moore 1971:1:467-68), but rather believed that one who cast off any commandment or principle of the law was discarding the authority of the law as a whole.

This illustrates again that's it's mainly about not casting anything off of the law. Not so much about never breaking any commandment.
 
Last edited:
God has not given us the right to pick and choose among his commandments. As some teachers put it, one should be as "careful with regard to a light commandment as you would be with a heavy one, since you do not know the allotment of the reward" (m. 'Abot 2:1). The sages were not suggesting that they never broke commandments (see Moore 1971:1:467-68), but rather believed that one who cast off any commandment or principle of the law was discarding the authority of the law as a whole.

This illustrates again that's it's mainly about not casting anything off of the law. Not so much about never breaking any commandment.
I read it as:-
You shouldn’t do it, but we all make mistakes. However don’t think that because you have broken a commandment once it means that you can carry on breaking it. If you do you are effectively throwing it out of the book which is the same as throwing the whole book away.
 
I read it as:-
You shouldn’t do it, but we all make mistakes. However don’t think that because you have broken a commandment once it means that you can carry on breaking it. If you do you are effectively throwing it out of the book which is the same as throwing the whole book away.
Does make sense.
 
In a word - Hypocrite!

Never said there weren't. In fact, I said this is the only place I've heard these verses used that way. I'd love to read some Christians teachings using these verses that way and I figured since so many here insist that's the way to interpret these verses they might know of some.


That's what all Faithers are - hypocrites - since you are obviously one of the biggest, what's the point of this whole pathetic thread.

Oh, I get it. It 'proves' Faithers, especially xians, are all hypocrites. Thanks for that!
 
To "live as a disciple" does not sound to me like a livestyle to be imposed on every christian. I might be wrong, though.
I always learned that every Christian was a disciple of Christ.
 
This passage is addressed to his disciples and says that one is not to annul the law, but rather to keep it in place. The aspect of personal conduct is not of primary importance for exactly this passage.
If the law in question concerns personal conduct then annulling it or keeping it in place is about personal conduct and nothing else besides.

What else would it be about?
 
By the way, Hertzblut, you never responded to my post about the 10 Commandments. When they were issued (according to Exodus, directly from God), there were no other lawmakers (that is, other than God via Moses) or judges. So who was bound by them?

This is a case in point because I'm directly talking about the sort of law referred to in the Matthew passage. The German Constitution was definitely NOT the law referred to.
 
If your point isn't how Christians are behaving or should behave or you don't want to try to figure out what it means - what is your purpose for bringing these verses up?

ACS, I have answered this point several times, so please read the next paragraph very slowly and carefully. You don't seem to "hear" me unless I've written something over and over again.

I am not arguing that Christians should obey the O.T. law (or not). The argument points out an INCONSISTENCY in an argument made by SOME CHRISTIANS. These are the ones who use cherry-picked Bible passages to justify things like gay-bashing. When it is pointed out that there are other Bible passages that condone horrible moral positions (slavery, rape, murder, etc.), this group of SOME CHRISTIANS, say that those passages don't count because Jesus abolished the old laws with his new law. I am arguing the obvious meaning of the Matthew passage to point out that the argument I just mentioned put forth by some Christians is not valid.

I have also used your version of my vegetarian analogy to make the point. Let's say I'm a vegetarian who professes to follow the vegetarian diet as published in Dr. X's book. You point out that according to Dr. X, I should refrain from eating fish, but you know that I eat fish. What you are doing is point out an inconsistency. You are not telling me you think I should refrain from eating fish.

Now, quit the BS. Stop pretending you don't understand this. You have said that you are ready to "move on" but here you are as I predicted back to the issue where you think an atheist making the argument about the Matthew passage must be telling you that should obey the O.T. laws.

You absolutely 100% must know by now that this is not so. I have said so explicitly some 75 times.

You are being dishonest and insincere if you continue to pretend that you think I (or anyone else in this thread) is offering advice on how you should behave vis a vis the O.T. laws.

Are you simply telling me your observation of what the words in these Matthew verses are?
No. I'm arguing that the argument made by some Christians that the Old Testament laws are abolished isn't valid.

Please clarify if you are simply making an observation or something else.
I have made my position abundantly clear. You keep pretending not to understand. It is an extremely dishonest way of engaging in a discussion.
 
You said it's obvious these verses mean Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and then asked how else Verse 19 could be read. I've showed how else verse 19 could be read and also that it doesn't even talk about Christians having to follow all the laws, but rather contrasts two types of teaching - a lesser one if you will and a better one. I take the better one to mean practice what you preach in essence.
And how do you defend this reading?

This passage clearly mentions the old laws. In verse 17 the phrase "the Law and the Prophets" refers to the Jewish scriptures. According to the author of Matthew in that verse, Jesus says he is not here to abolish that. Verse 18 mentions "the Law" again, and says not one tiny little bit of it is altered. In 19, "the least of these commandments" refers back to the same Law.

How can you claim that the passage says nothing about the validity of the old laws?

Your argument of "practice what you preach" doesn't even follow even allowing for your strange reading. If the lesser teaching is to break the laws and teach others to do so, then it should follow that it's OK to break the law as long as you DON"T teach others to do the same (i.e. by NOT practicing what you preach). If the passage doesn't mean it's OK to break the law as long as you don't teach others to do the same, then we're back to "my" reading that, in fact, according to the author of Matthew, Jesus is saying you're supposed to obey every last one of the laws.

So either way, your "practice what you preach" reading doesn't do what you want it to.

ACS said:
Again - I'm only taking this verse alone - we've never even reached a point where we can move on to the other verses.
Says who?

I think it's absurd to read a sentence and willfully ignore the context. To what does the demonstrative pronoun "these" refer in verse 19? Obviously it refers either to "the law" in verse 18 or "the law and the prophets" in verse 17.
 
Last edited:
I would hate to be Jesus. Think about it. You're Jesus and you're hungry. You say to Matthew "Hey Matt, can you go get me a burger and fries?" At this point, Matt and the other disciples start to debate about what you really mean.

"By burger, he means life and fries is love, he wants me to bring him life and love."
"No, he is asking if you'd kill for him and grow potatoes for him."
"Really, I think he's just hungry for life."

Then you'd have a bunch of apologists "interpreting" your words for a couple of millenia to make it seem as if you said something they believe. "He's condemning homosexuals because gay people don't eat meat" or some such nonsense.

Yep, it would suck to be Jesus as the only people who would actually get him a burger and fries would be the non-believers, who he hated.
 
Last edited:
Speaking of burgers....

Lolcat bible: Matthew 5 said:
17 dont break law. im in ur urfs fulfillin ur prophecy

18 iz all true. srsly. law iz not deleted

19 if u break law, no can has cheezburger. if u teach law, can has lotz cookiez

I think that settles it :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom