The atheists favorite bible verses

You're right - it is clear now. I was hoping Joe and others would understand why I thought they and he meant what he originally wrote.

Moving on then:

OK--for the 5th time: I used the analogy to explain why the statement "according to the text you should do x" is not equivalent to the statement "you should do x".

The analogy was NOT offered as an argument for any particular reading of the Matthew passage.

Without wishing to appear to speak for anyone, and at the risk of annoying everybody, it seems to me that ACS has made it plain that he does now understand what you were saying, JoeTheJuggler. He has tried to show how he made the error because it is not nice to be seen as dishonest, and all the other things he has been accused of. I have to confess if such accusations had been levelled at me I would try to dispel them because it would not be true, and I would be uncomfortable if people thought it of me. Since the misunderstanding has been cleared up he has offered to move on, and now it seems to be you, JtJ, who cannot leave it.

For myself I think I understand both positions. Most other posters have said they do. Can we really not just leave this? :(

ETA:Oops I see this has already happened. My bad for interfering. Apologies to all.
 
Last edited:
No two different texts are equivalent.
OK. So all this nonsense about me saying that you're supposed to obey all the O.T. laws was just a waste of time, right?


Of course not.
WTF? If it's "Of course not" then why did you pretend that my analogy was meant as an argument about the interpretation of the passage?

You have never offered ANY argument to support your particular reading of the passage. You don't expect me to regard your weird writings about public surveys as a valid argument, do you?

You are founding bold accusations ("cherry picking") against a religious group on unsupported propositions. This is discriminative against such group.

I offered the words of the text as prima facie evidence that that is what it means. When it says "I come not to abolish the law" I interpret that to mean that the law is not being abolished. When it says if you disobey the least of these commandments and teach others to do so you will be regarded as least in heaven, I interpret that to mean that (according to the author of Matthew) Jesus is saying that you should still obey every last one of the O.T. laws.

I've yet to see any argument against the prima facie evidence of the plain words of the text.

I also fully agree with Fiona's more detailed explication given earlier that shows that any attempt at reading this to mean that those laws are abolished simply doesn't make sense.

Before you again get carried away with the "and teach" business, I'll repeat an argument offered several times by another astute poster (sorry--I forgot who--but it was such a good argument I felt no need to repeat it myself): if you disobey the law aren't you already teaching others to do so through example? In other words, the reading that if you disobey the law but don't teach others is somehow OK (according to this passage) doesn't make much sense either.

Have you ever seen the musical Godspell? IIRC, their take on this passage has Jesus saying the famous quote "I come not to abolish the law and the prophets but to complete them" and leads to the song "Learn Your Lessons Well".

I believe Jesus' idea (according to the author of Matthew) was that you should obey every last little bit of the old law--make sure all your "i"s are dotted and "t"s are crossed (by the way the meaning of "tittle" in the Luke passage is the little mark that essentially crosses the tau in the Greek, according to my Jesuit friend) so that the established Jewish clergy will have nothing to use against you. In other words, that you need to be at least as good as them. The passage goes on to say that that's not enough. Under the new law, you have to obey every last bit of the old law plus worry about things like intention or desires (as opposed to just the actions).
 
ACS, before I answer any more of your questions, please answer this one:

Do you still stand behind your notion that the passage means "practice what you preach" and has nothing to say about the validity of the old laws?
 
it seems to me that ACS has made it plain that he does now understand what you were saying, JoeTheJuggler.
It seemed that way to me too at several points over the last week or so, but then he went right back to making the assertion about what I had said.

I predict he will do so again at some point.

In fact, I think he started this thread as an attempt to do a "gotcha" and it failed miserably.

I think he thought that the "atheists" position in the argument wherein the Matthew passage was invoked is somehow inconsistent with the wishes of atheists. (As in: why argue that we should obey all the O.T. Laws when you yourselves don't want us to obey all the O.T. Laws?)

It is not.

No more than it would be inconsistent for a meat eater to point out that the dish I'm eating contains meat and that my behavior is inconsistent with what I profess (as a vegetarian).

FWIW, I tried to engage ACS in a discussion of the meaning of the passage waaaaaaay back in post number 30. ACS wasn't interested then:

I could tell you but you'd say I was wrong and then others would jump in saying I was wrong so really - what's the point?

He did relent and gave us a very confused argument about the passage meaning practice what you preach and having no applicability to people who disobey the old laws. Rather than defend this, he went back to the business of asking why we're trying to convince him that he's supposed to obey all the old laws.
 
ACS, before I answer any more of your questions, please answer this one:

Do you still stand behind your notion that the passage means "practice what you preach" and has nothing to say about the validity of the old laws?

We were discussing your claims about verse 19. And verse 19, alone, seems to be directed at people who are teaching commandments. (I'm not sure if that means the commandments that follow in the narrative, some other commandments, or commandments in general) The verse emphasizes the preference for the positive by contrasting the negative of teaching people to break them like you (the teacher) are doing and the positive of teaching people to keep the commandments while also making sure you are practicing them.

Given that there's been at least 6 different interpretations given in this thread and in addition I have a few more it is even less obvious to me that your conclusion is the obvious one.

Your turn. Please answer Herzblut's points.
 
Last edited:
Once you've seen the commercial-- it's the same every time. It's okay to fast forward through them.

He's trying to convince atheists not to quote that bible passage at him-- and he's trying to convince himself they are trying to boss him around when they do. I don't know why you think the message is going to change. His goal is just to get the last word to keep his "story" alive.

And I have no idea what Herzy's goal is, but I suspect no one really does.
 
He's trying to convince atheists not to quote that bible passage at him-- and he's trying to convince himself they are trying to boss him around when they do.

Unless you're trying to make some sort of point towards a Christian or are actually trying to understand what it might mean why would you quote bible verses at a Christian?

To simply make observations of what it says?

Hey - look verse 17 says this.

- Nice observations.

And verse 19 says this.

- It does indeed say that.

And verse 45 means this.

- I think you meant to say 'says' not means. Means isn't simply an observation.

Oh yeah, verse 45 says this.

- Thanks for the observation.

In all the time I've been here everytime someone's quoted a verse at me - it's just been an observation of the words themselves? Really?
 
We were discussing your claims about verse 19. And verse 19, alone, seems to be directed at people who are teaching commandments. (I'm not sure if that means the commandments that follow in the narrative, some other commandments, or commandments in general) The verse emphasizes the preference for the positive by contrasting the negative of teaching people to break them like you (the teacher) are doing and the positive of teaching people to keep the commandments while also making sure you are practicing them.

Given that there's been at least 6 different interpretations given in this thread and in addition I have a few more it is even less obvious to me that your conclusion is the obvious one.

Your turn.

Sorry ACS but that really won't do. In the past you have said that one must read the context and I agree with you. So I cannot see how you can take the view we must see this verse in isolation. But even if I give you that; and even if I accept this is directed solely to the disciples, as Herzblut claims; or at those who are to be teachers of the law, as you can argue; even with all that I cannot see how you get to your conclusion.

I have been looking at some different translations here:

http://bible.cc/matthew/5-19.htm

None of the commentary at the bottom divorces this verse from the context, so far as I can see. I found this interesting, for example:

People's New Testament

5:19 Shall break one of the least of these least commandments. The Pharisees taught that some commands were more important than others, and that it was a trivial matter to break the smallest commands. The papists still divide sin into mortal and venial. Christ shows that the spirit of obedience does not seek to make such distinction.

Shall be called the least. He may get into the kingdom, possibly, but such a spirit will give him a very low spiritual rank.

and also this:

Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary

19. Whosoever therefore shall break-rather, "dissolve," "annul," or "make invalid."

one of these least commandments-an expression equivalent to "one of the least of these commandments."

and shall teach men so-referring to the Pharisees and their teaching, as is plain from Mt 5:20, but of course embracing all similar schools and teaching in the Christian Church.

he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven-As the thing spoken of is not the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law, but annulling or enervating its obligation by a vicious system of interpretation, and teaching others to do the same; so the thing threatened is not exclusion from heaven, and still less the lowest place in it, but a degraded and contemptuous position in the present stage of the kingdom of God. In other words, they shall be reduced by the retributive providence that overtakes them, to the same condition of dishonor to which, by their system and their teaching, they have brought down those eternal principles of God's law.

but whosoever shall do and teach them-whose principles and teaching go to exalt the authority and honor of God's law, in its lowest as well as highest requirements.

the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven-shall, by that providence which watches over the honor of God's moral administration, be raised to the same position of authority and honor to which they exalt the law.

Nothing there to suggest that the passage does not mean one should keep the law in its entirety.

I have already explained why I do not think the law in question can be other than the OT law. Perhaps you could say where you disagree?
 
Oh no...! now ACS is going to accuse you of telling him he's supposed to obey the OT, Fiona.

He already knows where I stand on that, Articulett. It is not as if I haven't been somewhat profligate with my explanations :)
 
I want ACS to follow the law in the OT that demands he thinks shellfish is an abomination.

There - I've done it - I've revealed my terrible atheist scheme to ensure Christians all hate them because that's what I want from Christianity. A terrible hatred of entreé fodder.
 
I offered the words of the text as prima facie evidence that that is what it means.
The obvious danger is that other editions of the text might contain a different wording, no longer supporting your prima facie approach.

I have demonstrated that this is actually the case. German, Spanish, Italian, French, Latin versions of Matt 5,19, together with http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=matthew%205;&version=49; do not even include the word "obey". Please clarify whether you are now restricting the scope of your proposition

From:
According to Matt 5...

To:
According to a particular translation of Matt 5...

Thanks for clarifying.
 
Last edited:
I want ACS to follow the law in the OT that demands he thinks shellfish is an abomination.

There - I've done it - I've revealed my terrible atheist scheme to ensure Christians all hate them because that's what I want from Christianity. A terrible hatred of entreé fodder.

And the mixing of fibers must stop too. God said so. So ACS should do so. Right after he gives all his money to the poor as mandated by his savior.
 
@ Herzblut. I am sorry but I do not see how any of the different translations you have proposed, or which are included in the link I posted,changes the meaning of the passage. It does not matter if you use the word "break" or "annul" or "abrogate" or any of the others, does it? How do you think this changes it significantly?
 
Last edited:
@ Herzblut. I am sorry but I do not see how any of the different translations you have proposed, or which are included in the link I posted,changes the meaning of the passage. It does not matter if you use the word "break" or "annul" or "abrogate" or any of the others, does it? How do you think this changes it significantly?
It obviously nullifies Joe's prima facie argument, "the text means what it says", if the passage does not say "obey" anywhere. Why is this so difficult to understand?

Your links are excellent, again, esp. the Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary. The interpretation presented there more or less corresponds to what I think. Just re-read this passage, please

the thing spoken of is -->**not**<-- the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law, but annulling or enervating its obligation by a vicious system of interpretation, and teaching others to do the same;

and try to explain in how far the part I have highlighted might be not literally and blatantly contradicting Joe's interpretation, claiming that the thing spoken of was exactly this, practical breaking and disobeying of the law. To help you catching it, I pointed to the keyword "not", if you don't mind. If you need further clarification (oh dear!) please let me know.
 
Last edited:
We were discussing your claims about verse 19. And verse 19, alone, seems to be directed at people who are teaching commandments. (I'm not sure if that means the commandments that follow in the narrative, some other commandments, or commandments in general)
It's very obvious that it means the commandments in "the law and the prophets" which means the Jewish scriptures or what we've been calling by shorthand "the Old Testament". The phrase the "least of these commandments" refers back to them.

I see no reason to think that the context of Jesus preaching to a multitude could lead to your reading that this verse alone is suddenly not directed to everyone in earshot.

The verse emphasizes the preference for the positive by contrasting the negative of teaching people to break them like you (the teacher) are doing and the positive of teaching people to keep the commandments while also making sure you are practicing them.
Huhn? I don't follow this at all.

The verse says whoever breaks the least one of these commandments and teaches others to shall be called least in heaven, and those who keep them and teach others to do so shall be called greatest in heaven.

Again, I see no way of reading this to mean that he has abolished the old laws and that it doesn't matter whether or not you obey them.
 
Your links are excellent, again, esp. the Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary. The interpretation presented there more or less corresponds to what I think. Just re-read this passage, please

the thing spoken of is not the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law, but annulling or enervating its obligation by a vicious system of interpretation, and teaching others to do the same;
I'm not sure where they can get that from, but even so, think it through.

Are they saying that it doesn't matter whether or not you break the old commandments as long as you don't misinterpret the old laws to enervate their obligation? So. . . .the point is that the old laws are still in force. The only difference I see is that this reading focuses on not suspending the obligations of the old laws through a "vicious system of interpretation". Either way, the point is (according to Jesus as presented by the author of Matthew) that you can't ignore one jot or tittle of the old law.
 
It obviously nullifies Joe's prima facie argument, "the text means what it says", if the passage does not say "obey" anywhere. Why is this so difficult to understand?

Because I do not think many translations use the word obey. However they all use some version of the idea that the law remains in force, when placed in context. If they remain in force it is very strange to argue that they are not to be obeyed. This point was made earlier by another poster ( I am sorry I cannot remember who exactly said it) and it is unanswerable, so far as I can see.

Your links are excellent, again, esp. the Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary. The interpretation presented there more or less corresponds to what I think. Just re-read this passage, please

the thing spoken of is -->**not**<-- the practical breaking, or disobeying, of the law, but annulling or enervating its obligation by a vicious system of interpretation, and teaching others to do the same;

and try to explain in how far the part I have highlighted might be not literally and blatantly contradicting Joe's interpretation, claiming that the thing spoken of was exactly this, practical breaking and disobeying of the law. To help you catching it, I pointed to the keyword "not", if you don't mind. If you need further clarification, please let me know.

Ok. As I see it, the part you have highlighted supports JtJ's case and mine. What is at stake is not solely the breaking or disobeying of the law; that is perfectly true if the words are taken at face value. Breaking the law is not to be done but ALSO teaching others to do the same. And the teaching of others to do the same is an additional "sin". That is why it uses the word "and", which ACS made to carry so much weight. What we have here is a commentary which points to such teaching through a "vicious system of interpretation" and to say that words do not mean what they say is precisely what is referred to. How do you teach someone to break the law? Well one way is to reinterpret in such a way that the law is no longer in force; or it means something else.

Not sure if that is clear but if not I will try again
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom