You're right - it is clear now. I was hoping Joe and others would understand why I thought they and he meant what he originally wrote.
Moving on then:
OK--for the 5th time: I used the analogy to explain why the statement "according to the text you should do x" is not equivalent to the statement "you should do x".
The analogy was NOT offered as an argument for any particular reading of the Matthew passage.
Without wishing to appear to speak for anyone, and at the risk of annoying everybody, it seems to me that ACS has made it plain that he does now understand what you were saying, JoeTheJuggler. He has tried to show how he made the error because it is not nice to be seen as dishonest, and all the other things he has been accused of. I have to confess if such accusations had been levelled at me I would try to dispel them because it would not be true, and I would be uncomfortable if people thought it of me. Since the misunderstanding has been cleared up he has offered to move on, and now it seems to be you, JtJ, who cannot leave it.
For myself I think I understand both positions. Most other posters have said they do. Can we really not just leave this?
ETA:Oops I see this has already happened. My bad for interfering. Apologies to all.
Last edited: