The atheists favorite bible verses

I have demonstrated that this is actually the case. German, Spanish, Italian, French, Latin versions of Matt 5,19, together with http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=matthew%205;&version=49; do not even include the word "obey".
Err.... you don't think that "law" and "commandment" implies that they should be obeyed????

I really wish you would simply state what you think is a reasonable interpretation.

Are you suggesting that Jesus is saying that the laws can never be annulled, but they don't have to be obeyed?
 
Law implies lots of things. Why your fixation on obedience?

Because that is central to what makes it a law, maybe? It demands certain kinds of behaviour and proscribes others. And if you don't obey it there are penalties. otherwise it is not law it is friendly advice or something :)


OED said:
I Human Law . 1. the body of rules, whether formally enacted or customary, which a state or community recognises as binding on its members or subjects. (in this sense usually the law Also, in early use, a code or system of such rules. 2. One of those rules. 3. gena. Laws as obeyed or enforced; controlling influence of laws; the condition of society in which laws are observed. ba Laws in general, as a human institution b The science of which laws are the subject matter; jurisprudence. c. Rules or injunctions that must be obeyed .......
 
I'd say it is. It used to be "kill your brother and go to hell" now it's "be angry at your brother without cause and go to hell" That's new even if it's similar. You still aren't supposed to kill him of course, but in addition you must not be angry at him.

Your example works too, of course, although I don't believe you were supposed to hate your enemies before, just kill them. Then again, the concept of 'love your enemies' has some interesting semantic meaning when you consider it more deeply. It is not "have no enemies" but "love your enemies". This suggests that having enemies is an acceptable state of affairs, which in turn leads to the possibly of loving your enemies while killing them. Just a thought.

eta:Just realized you might think I'm arguing the old laws were replaced. I'm not, just that there was some stuff added and a few rules may have been relaxed in the dietary restrictions area.


Can "enemy" refer to anything that represents a danger, or potential danger to the self?


M.
 
One thing is obvious, according to ACS, Jesus never said what he meant and talked in riddles disguised as blatantly plain speech. I guess those people he preached to had all kinds of arguments about what he really meant............
 
I'd say it is. It used to be "kill your brother and go to hell" now it's "be angry at your brother without cause and go to hell" That's new even if it's similar. You still aren't supposed to kill him of course, but in addition you must not be angry at him.

"But anyone who says, 'You fool!' will be in danger of the fire of hell."

Being in danger of hell-fire is not the same as being condemned to hell-fire. It could mean that, since you've already committed the murder in your heart, you're in danger of committing it for real -- and thus risk going to hell.

So I can see a sense in which this is not a new law. Which is why I think my examples are better -- I can't see how the new is the spirit of the old in those cases.

Your example works too, of course, although I don't believe you were supposed to hate your enemies before, just kill them.

Jesus says "You have heard that it was said..."
So either he's talking about the old law or misconceptions of the old law. I suppose the latter could let people say he isn't introducing anything new, just correcting misconceptions.
 
To me, he's making the rules tighter--

it isn't just actions that can get you in trouble with the invisible omniscient guy--
thoughts become a crime now too.
 
Bizarre. There is not one single new law by JC in the NT. You lack the most basic understanding.
No, I'm afraid it's you who is clueless. I'm speaking about the verses in Matthew immediately following the passage in question when Jesus addresses murder, adultery, divorce, etc. In each case, (according to the author of Matthew), he says that you must obey the old laws on these topics, but then proceeds to define a much higher standard that is new. See Matthew 5: 21-following.



Your "new law" does not exist.
It's not my new law. As I've pointed out throughout this thread, the concept is invoked by those who claim that the O.T. no longer counts because Jesus replaced it with a new law.
A quick Google on the terms "Jesus" and "New Law" results in a great many hits. The top two that I got even refer to this very passage in Matthew (as do several others on the first page of hits).

I even remember a hymn from my childhood that I think was even titled something like "There's a New Law". The lyric I remember (from some 35 years ago) was:
"A man can kill with a knife of steel, a gun, a bomb or a lance
But there's a new law--there's a new law--
A man can kill with a glance!"

Don't pretend for a moment that I'm the person who invented the idea of Jesus preaching a new law.


You seem to think the point of having laws it to give lawyers and judges (presumably Pharisees and such?) some guidance.
You seem to confabulate.
Do you know what the word confabulate means?

My statement above was in response to your assertions that laws aren't there to prescribe conduct for anyone but lawyers and judges:

(3) A law system does not imply anything about public behaviour. Judges might obey, or not, to a law, I have no idea how Joe Blow might do it.

(4) Because any law simply says "A certain conduct shall be judged in a certain way." Laws don't imply any conduct at all, except for lawmakers, judges etc., they simply list forms of improper conduct and assign certain implications to it. Consequentially, a law is disobeyed when its implications are ignored in a lawsuit, for instance.
Seriously, do you think only "lawmakers and judges" can disobey or break a law?

Do you think the laws in the old Jewish scriptures weren't meant to prescribe conduct for anyone but "lawmakers and judges"?

I'm not "confabulating"--this is what you said in points numbered 3 and 4.
 
But is it a new law? The letter of the old law is: do not murder. But if you're angry, then you commit murder in your heart. And so you break the spirit of the same law.

The "eye for an eye" becoming "turn the other cheek" would be a better example. I don't see how the latter is the spirit of the former.

Also, I don't see how "love your enemies" is in the spirit of "hate your enemies".
I agree with this entirely, FG.

I think the ones who say the old laws no longer count are thinking of other passages of the N.T. than this one. In fact, I think this passage is inconvenient to those who make the argument that you can use the Bible to make some moral judgments but those abominable laws in the O.T. no longer count because Jesus replaced it with a new law.

As I've said for some time, a more reasonable reading of all this is to put these documents of the N.T. in their historical context. The author of Matthew thought Jesus was just for Jews, so on this question he promoted retaining every last detail of the old law. That's certainly NOT the only view presented in the N.T. The gospel of John, for instance, almost treats Jesus himself as a non-Jew.
 
To me, he's making the rules tighter--

it isn't just actions that can get you in trouble with the invisible omniscient guy--
thoughts become a crime now too.
I agree with that interpretation of the Sermon on the Mount section. And it's definitely the Catholic interpretation. Sins of intention and sins of omission play a big role. ( I remember a George Carlin bit on the topic--where he felt up a girl at a party, and in so doing committed something like 5 sins, thought, deed, intention, failing to be contrite, etc.) In other places, though, there's the whole forgiveness thing which makes the new system a lot more liberal.

Heck, you could be a drug-using, alcoholic ne'er-do-well, but then be born again and get a fresh enough moral slate to win the vote of the religious right!
 
"But anyone who says, 'You fool!' will be in danger of the fire of hell."

Being in danger of hell-fire is not the same as being condemned to hell-fire. It could mean that, since you've already committed the murder in your heart, you're in danger of committing it for real -- and thus risk going to hell.

It's set up in a clear parallel, it used to be X that causes you to face judgement, now Y causes you face judgement.

If you're going to -ahem- interpret the verse so that the consequences of Y aren't so bad then that same interpreatation applies to X, and Jesus isn't really upset about murder.




Jesus says "You have heard that it was said..."
So either he's talking about the old law or misconceptions of the old law. I suppose the latter could let people say he isn't introducing anything new, just correcting misconceptions.

"You have heard it said" is a rhetorical device used repeatedly in the sermon on the mount to refer to the old law in order to compare it with new standards:

22 "Again you have heard that it was said to your ancestors, 'Do not take a false oath, but make good to the Lord all that you vow.


25 "You have heard that it was said, 'An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth.'


27 "You have heard that it was said, 'You shall love your neighbor and hate your enemy.' (oops, guess I may have been wrong about the hate your enement stuff)

After each one, Jesus makes some kind of change. The passage I used is part of the same pattern, part of the same purpose as the passage you used. You can't dismiss one without dismissing the other.
 
Whether you call it a "new law" or refinement of the old law, the main point to this thread anyway is that the old law is still in force.

I think of the old law as a subset of the new teaching. Used to be X constituted the sin of murder; now X AND Y constitutes the sin of murder. (In other words the new standard is the old standard PLUS, and not a replacement of the old standard.)
 
Last edited:
If you really believe this is God's law and that following it determines how you'll spend your eternity... then you'd want to give it the strictest and most literally interpretation possible-- right? You wouldn't want to be re-interpreting "god" through your measly mortal viewpoint, right? Why would anyone play fast and loose with interpretation when their ETERNITY is at stake. If the bible is god's rubric for for his big pass/fail life- test--
then why wouldn't people aim to get "extra credit"? It's either not divine or it's of utmost importance to determine what it's saying and follow it as closely as possible-- right?
 
I'm a bit confused as to where you're going with this. Enemies in this sense surely is restricted to people, no?

Making sense of the bible is extremely confusing, to me at least. I read it mainly as esoteric literature, because I simply cannot know what was in the minds of those who wrote it, let alone interpret ancient language into our contemporary English. So it puzzles me that anyone takes any of it literally.

And then you have someone like Meister Eckhart, who spoke in riddles so sublime that reading him led me to look into most of the Eastern religions.


M.
 
It's set up in a clear parallel, it used to be X that causes you to face judgement, now Y causes you face judgement.

If you're going to -ahem- interpret the verse so that the consequences of Y aren't so bad then that same interpreatation applies to X, and Jesus isn't really upset about murder.

But there's still wiggle room.
You've heard that a murderer will face judgement. I tell you that a jay-walker will face judgement.

It doesn't have to mean the same punishment.

No wiggle room with my example. Unless you can explain how loving your enemy is the spirit of hating your enemy. Loving isn't a different way to hate.

"You have heard it said" is a rhetorical device used repeatedly in the sermon on the mount to refer to the old law in order to compare it with new standards:

That's how I read it.
In that case, the old law says to hate your enemy.

The passage I used is part of the same pattern, part of the same purpose as the passage you used. You can't dismiss one without dismissing the other.

I dismiss your example because it doesn't have to be read as a new law. Just directions to lay off the things which can lead to murder. It could be like the old joke:

Q: Why do Methodists disapprove of sex?
A: Because it might lead to dancing.


I don't see how my examples can be taken in the same way. They have to be new laws. Somehow not abolishing the old laws. In which case you have to both love and hate your enemies. Otherwise, Jesus will have removed more than a tittle from the old law.
 
I agree with this entirely, FG.

I think the ones who say the old laws no longer count are thinking of other passages of the N.T. than this one. In fact, I think this passage is inconvenient to those who make the argument that you can use the Bible to make some moral judgments but those abominable laws in the O.T. no longer count because Jesus replaced it with a new law.

I think the examples I gave may contradict the verse from the OP. Unless Jesus says to both hate and love enemies, and to get an eye for an eye while turning the other cheek.

As I've said for some time, a more reasonable reading of all this is to put these documents of the N.T. in their historical context. The author of Matthew thought Jesus was just for Jews, so on this question he promoted retaining every last detail of the old law. That's certainly NOT the only view presented in the N.T.

I can accept that.
But I think Matthew might not have done a good job. I don't see how the above aren't removing some part of the old law.

The gospel of John, for instance, almost treats Jesus himself as a non-Jew.

I can't think of anything along those lines.
A few examples from the gospel of John would be interesting. New thread, maybe.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom