Merged Teen Encouraged Friend to Commit Suicide, Convicted of Manslaughter

I'm having trouble seeing how making a bad suggestion should make one criminally liable in a case like this. If he were a minor, maybe. Depending on the circumstances. But he was not.

But no, unless there's some huge detail that hasn't been shared yet (and I can't even imagine what that might be), I do not agree with this. The girl might be a dreadful, sick, uncaring person - or this could also be a misunderstanding or case of hyperbole - but I'm struggling to see how she's a criminal.


I have no problem with it what so ever. How the hell could a friend tell a friend to get back into a truck that would kill him?

Slammer for her.
 
I have no problem with it what so ever. How the hell could a friend tell a friend to get back into a truck that would kill him?

Slammer for her.

I'm not entirely sure what the second and final sentence of that mean, but if you read on in the thread, you'll see that I've backed down from my original position in light of further reading about the case.
 
One cannot murder oneself, of course, so neither can someone else be an accessory to a non-existent murder.

Counselling suicide, on the other hand, that seems a reasonable charge if the facts and circumstances warrant it.

Sorry, manslaughter not murder. Also, as a verb, yes one can murder oneself.

The girl took actions which had a reasonable foreseeable outcome of a death. Even more than that, the death seems to have been the goal of the actions.

I'm not completely convinced that this is the correct charge, but I also don't think it's out in left field simply because the death was a suicide. Talking someone into killing someone seems more in line with manslaughter (or with other details, murder) than anything else. That those 'someones' are the same person doesn't seem to change much. While the charge you mention seems like it has solid reasoning, the actions here seem to be more than 'counseling'. Perhaps criminally negligent homicide? But then the actions were not negligent, they were (allegedly, as with all the information given) premeditated to result in the boy's death.

And obviously, the evidence and arguments in a trial will hopefully sort a lot of this out.
 
I'm not entirely sure what the second and final sentence of that mean, but if you read on in the thread, you'll see that I've backed down from my original position in light of further reading about the case.

opps. sorry
 
No, if the summary of her quotes are accurate, that describes what she did all right.

Why aren't more people charged with this? Bullies encourage people to commit suicide all the time, and often, they attempt it. Sometimes they succeed.

Another puzzling thing is, if that is indeed its own law, why are they charging her with manslaughter? :confused: Laws are weird sometimes.

I think the idea is that her behavior with someone who was clearly suicidal was reckless and there for fits into manslaughter.
 
However, section 241(a) of the Criminal Code of Canada was not at issue at all in either the Rodriguez case or in the current case before the SCC, and that sub-section remains fully in force, and that is the section that deals with counselling someone to commit suicide, rather than aiding or abetting. Counselling another to commit suicide remains a criminal offence here in Canada, and that provision has not been challenged so far as I know (but if it has been challenged somewhere at some time, it certainly hasn't been successful so the provision stands in any event).

I do not know if Massachussetts has a similar provision against counselling suicide, but based solely upon the limited (second, third, or fourth hand and therefore presumptively unreliable) reports that have been provided thusfar in this thread about the allegations against the young woman, and assuming for purposes of discussion that they are accurate, it seems to me that a charge of counselling another to commit suicide might be appropriate (if such a charge exists in Massachussetts).

On the other hand, if Massachussetts does not have any prohibition against counselling suicide, it seems to me to be a stretch to try to shoehorn the alleged (second, third, or fourth hand and presumptively unreliable) 'facts' into a charge of manslaughter.

Based on the link Scordatura gave earlier (which I can't access at the moment, as apparently my internet provider thinks I should have to prove I'm over 18 and provide a credit card number to browse pages on assisted suicide laws...) it sounds as if Massachusetts doesn't have any prohibition against counselling suicide. The same page does say:

Of these States, the United States contends that case law in Alabama, Massachusetts, North Carolina and Ohio indicates that assisting suicide may nevertheless be prosecuted.

- the key word there I think being "assisting". The Melchert-Dinkel case linked to by another poster is interesting in that respect, in that the man was originally convicted (in Minnesota) of encouraging and advising suicide, a conviction which was overturned by the Minnesota Supreme Court when it ruled that advising/encouraging suicide is speech protected by the First Amendment. However he could still be found guilty of speech assisting a suicide, which is what he was eventually convicted of on retrial.

It seems a bit of a grey area as to whether the girl in this case actually "assisted" the suicide - she is supposed to have discussed the way he was going to do it, so I guess it's possible. As you say, though, given that there seems to be no appropriate offence to charge her with in Massachusetts, it does look as if the facts have been shoehorned into a manslaughter charge simply because there's nothing else she can be charged with. If counselling suicide were an offence, it would obviously be a lot more straightforward.
 
Last edited:
I haven't seen them on the thread, but they have released a heap of the text exchange

She is an evil little b**** in my opinion

Texts

.........CARTER: Go in your truck and drive in a parking lot somewhere, to a park or something. Do it like early. Do it now, like early.

ROY: Didn't we say this was suspicious?

CARTER: No. I think night is more suspicious, a kid sitting in his car turning on the radio. Just do it. It wouldn't be suspicious and it won't take long............
 
I agree that she's a scumbag, but I don't think that rates a long jail term.

If we start locking up all of that sort of scumbag there won't be any room for the potheads.

I suspect the scumbag will end up some kind of mental health insitution.
 
Apparently she was only 17 at the time. I know people even younger than that have been charged as adults, but I'm not sure that's really right.

Maybe she thought that this is what he really wanted and she was just trying to help?

It's easy to see this as the act of an evil, malevolent person, but what if it was just the act of a confused, immature teenager? Whose brain is not fully mature yet? If a 30-year-old did the same thing I think I would see it differently.

The Terrible Teens

Frances Jensen is a mother, an author, and a neurologist. In “The Teenage Brain: A Neuroscientist’s Survival Guide to Raising Adolescents and Young Adults” (HarperCollins), written with Amy Ellis Nutt, she offers a parenting guide laced with the latest MRI studies. By her account, adolescents suffer from the cerebral equivalent of defective spark plugs.

“When we think of ourselves as civilized, intelligent adults, we really have the frontal and prefrontal parts of the cortex to thank,” she writes. But “teens are not quite firing on all cylinders when it comes to the frontal lobes.” Thus, “we shouldn’t be surprised by the daily stories we hear and read about tragic mistakes.”

. . .

The frontal lobes are the seat of what’s sometimes called the brain’s executive function. They’re responsible for planning, for self-awareness, and for judgment. Optimally, they act as a check on impulses originating in other parts of the brain. But in the teen years, Jensen points out, the brain is still busy building links between its different regions. This process involves adding myelin around the axons, which conduct electrical impulses. (Myelin insulates the axons, allowing impulses to travel faster.) It turns out that the links are built starting in the back of the brain, and the frontal lobes are one of the last regions to get connected. They are not fully myelinated until people are in their twenties, or even thirties.

This is where parents step in. “You need to be your teens’ frontal lobes until their brains are fully wired,” Jensen writes. By this she seems to mean near-constant hectoring. Whenever she hears a story like the one about Dan, she rushes to tell Will and Andrew, and, whenever Will and Andrew screw up, she uses it as an opportunity to remind them that they, too, could wind up floating face down in a pool. (After the unconscious girl has been dropped off at the hospital, Jensen relates, she sits Andrew and his girlfriend down at the kitchen table and lectures them about “blood alcohol levels and the effects on coordination and consciousness.”) As a matter of principle, Jensen has attached a lock to the liquor cabinet in her own home. When her sons are invited to someone else’s house, she calls the kid’s parents to make sure there will be no unsupervised fun.
 
Apparently she was only 17 at the time. I know people even younger than that have been charged as adults, but I'm not sure that's really right.

Maybe she thought that this is what he really wanted and she was just trying to help?

It's easy to see this as the act of an evil, malevolent person, but what if it was just the act of a confused, immature teenager? Whose brain is not fully mature yet? If a 30-year-old did the same thing I think I would see it differently.

The Terrible Teens

On the early teen maybe. At 17 you are already on the side where that starts to fix in as a personality trait. Charging her is probably in the gray zone, but having a PSA to be really wary of her would be good.
 
She sounded a bit power hungry, narcissistic, psycho to me, with a hint of sinister scuminess
 
Last edited:
Do we know if it was his own idea to begin with, or something he had never considered which she talked him into?

Does it matter ? How many people having human empathy do you know would not try to get somebody away from suicidal idea ? Sure if somebody is suffering horribly from a lethal disease , but teen angst ? Who the **** in their right mind does not try to get them away from that ?
 
Does it matter ?
Yes. I think it does.

How many people having human empathy do you know would not try to get somebody away from suicidal idea ? Sure if somebody is suffering horribly from a lethal disease , but teen angst ? Who the **** in their right mind does not try to get them away from that ?

Again, she was a teen too. She was younger than him. You can't expect a teenager to look at something and dismiss it as "teen angst". Only older people have that perspective.

I agree that "she was not in her right mind" and that's sort of the point. It seems possible that in some kind of deranged way, given that she lacks that perspective, she actually thought she was helping him. Maybe he convinced her that he really wanted to die, and just needed a little help, and so she was being "helpful" by encouraging him to do what he told her he wanted to do.

I also agree that the texts themselves look horrible but I think we need to step back and look at the bigger picture. What led up to those texts?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom