Merged Teen Encouraged Friend to Commit Suicide, Convicted of Manslaughter

I'm imagining a couple drunk frat guys. One wants to jump off a second-floor balcony at a beach hotel into the pool below. Another says "Go ahead! I dare ya!" Dude jumps, misses, dies.

Is this chargeable then?

There's also a diminished capacity element which can serve as mitigating circumstance.
 
Perhaps her state lacks the law against aiding or persuading, so man slaughter is it?
 
It turns out that some states do have laws prohibiting aiding, abetting, assisting or counseling suicide. Massachusetts isn't one of them.

I don't know exactly what this means:

Of these States, the United States contends that case law in Alabama, Massachusetts, North Carolina and Ohio indicates that assisting suicide may nevertheless be prosecuted.

...but it kind of sounds like there have been cases that were successfully prosecuted under other laws, maybe including manslaughter?

http://www.finalexit.org/assisted_suicide_laws_united_states.html

The link is related to "death with dignity" information but it does list the laws of each state and many clearly prohibit encouraging someone to take their own life.

Conrad Roy was in a mentally vulnerable state and Carter took advantage of it for whatever personal reason. Exchanging over a thousand texts with him is obsessive. I'm not sure exactly where the legal line should be drawn between casual remarks and actively encouraging a person to kill themself but the info released so far in this case implies that she may have crossed it.
 
"Historically, various states listed the act of suicide as a felony, but these policies were sparsely enforced. In the late 1960s, eighteen U.S. states had no laws against suicide.[29] By the late 1980s, thirty of the fifty states had no laws against suicide or suicide attempts but every state had laws declaring it to be a felony to aid, advise or encourage another person to commit suicide."

Emphasis mine.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_legislation

Scroll down to united state.

It is unclear if it is still the case, but law tend to stay unless striken.
 
This must be a rough time for her. She's facing a trial and possible imprisonment. The rest of her life might be ruined.

I hope she has a trusted friend to talk to who will explain the options and encourage her...
 
It is a crime to "aid, advise or encourage another person to commit suicide..."

Do you disagree that she did this? If not, why do you feel she should not be charged?

Is that a MA statute? If so, it seems like she could be charged under that statute, for sure.

I could see an accessory/conspiracy charge. Manslaughter... hmm. Possible. It's definitely possible to get a manslaughter conviction against someone who urges a dangerous act that results in death. "Try riding this horse, greenhorn!"

I know a case where a guy gave his prescription meds to a girl he had a crush on, without intending to harm her, but she died from an OD, and he was charged with murder. The charge was pending last I discussed it with my friend who knows about it. I wonder how it was handled.

To me it seems like this girl's role was more passive, more that of an accessory.
 
I suspect this is a bit of irrelevant information in that not all of those thousand texts are likely related to his suicide. The sheer number can be explained in one word: teenagers.

Point taken. The arrest warrant isn't online so I went by what msm is reporting - that Carter sent about a thousand texts during the days prior to Roy's suicide. The only other quote is from a detective stating in the warrant that a "slew" of texts were sent. So yes, the number of texts directly relating to Roy's suicide is unknown.

I found an article that had a little more information about some that she sent:

Court records state that after police gained access to Mr. Roy’s phone they found “that a string of text messages stretched all the way back to early last week [before his death], and throughout the entire sequence of messages from early last week till the Saturday before Conrad’s body and truck were located, Michelle Carter not only encouraged Conrad to take his own life, she questioned him repeatedly as to when and why he hadn’t done it yet, right up to the point of when his final text was sent to her on Saturday evening, July 12, 2014 at 6:26 p.m.

So maybe not all of the texts were directly related to suicide but it seems that there were a lot.

And:

In other text messages, Ms. Carter tells her friends that Mr. Roy is missing and she is worried about him, but, at the same time, she is texting
him. Police say those texts show that she helped him choose his method of carbon monoxide poisoning.

Plus, Carter sent long, rambling texts to Roy's 13-year-old sister detailing what he said about his depression and why he wanted to kill himself.

What's really chilling:

“And I just got off the phone with Conrad’s mom about 20 mins ago and she told me that detectives had to come and go thru his things and stuff. Its [sic] something they have to do with suicides and homicides. And she said they have to go thru his phone and see if anyone encouraged him to do it in texts and stuff...they read my messages with him I’m done. His family will hate me and I could go to jail.”

Ugh. Even if the thousand texts included mundane stuff the ones that involve suicide still seem obsessive and weird. I don't know if the charges will stick or not but either way she seems to have severe mental issues.

http://fairhavenneighborhoodnews.com/ARCHIVES/2015 ISSUES/02-26-15 Surrender.pdf (pp. 7. 19)
 
This must be a rough time for her. She's facing a trial and possible imprisonment. The rest of her life might be ruined.

I hope she has a trusted friend to talk to who will explain the options and encourage her...

That was the first thing I thought of! The DA is playing a dangerous game if this girl is at all prone to suicide.
 
I found an article that had a little more information about some that she sent:



So maybe not all of the texts were directly related to suicide but it seems that there were a lot.

Death by nagging. A woman's ultimate weapon.
 
"Instead of attempting to assist him or notify his family or school officials, Ms. Carter is alleged to have strongly influenced his decision to take his own life, encouraged him to commit suicide and guided him in his engagement of activities which led to his death."

...

In a police report provided to the Chronicle, Fairhaven police Detective Scott Gordon writes: "Not only did Conrad tell Carter in several of his texts prior to his death that he was scared and didn't want to leave his family, she continued to encourage him to take his own life, and when he actually started to carry out the act, he got scared again and exited his truck, but instead of telling him to stay out of the truck … Carter told him to 'get back in.'


I had my text messages used as evidence in a trial in which I testified. Only two of the texts were used by the plaintiffs attorney and they were taken completely out of context. The defendants lawyer made sure the jury knew this upon cross examination, in fact the remaining texts from my phone - maybe 50 or so - were the best evidence against the plaintiff. The defendant had a poor attorney and it was almost embarrassing watching him.

My point is that a few selected texts in a news article is not nearly enough evidence to determine the entirety of the situation and the relationship between these two people.

She was 17 at the time. Perhaps, in some teenaged "melodramatic fantasy" way (I'm not sure how to phrase this) she thought she was "helping" him end his pain. Perhaps she also suffers from depression and is suicidal as well, and perhaps they both talked about ending their lives. Perhaps she's just evil.

Without more information, "perhaps" is all we have. We've only heard one side of the story and, as I've already said, prosecutors can make a story sound a lot different than it actually is.
 
From the text quoted in this thread it was either a misguided or legitimate attempt to help a friend, depending on whether or not you agree that people have the right to choose to live or die. Framing and prosecuting this as a malicious act deserving of the highest penalties allowed, including making up charges that don't really make sense, is pretty dishonest IMO.
 
That was the first thing I thought of! The DA is playing a dangerous game if this girl is at all prone to suicide.

Sociopaths, which I can't help but believe she is, generally don't off themselves (although there are rare exceptions, such as Eric Harris. That was in the context of his murderous rampage, though).
 
Last edited:
To elaborate, she seems to have wanted to use his suicide for validation and attention for herself. She's posted numerous Twitter messages about how much she misses him, and how she knows he's looking down on us, and how important it is to raise awareness of suicide and the warning signs, etc.
She's even held a fund raiser called "Homers for Conrad".

So, I think she's a total sociopath.
 
Incitement to commit a crime has always been a crime. Attempting suicide is a crime. How is her encouragement and cajoling any different than if she had encouraged him to commit robbery, murder, or rape?
Is attempting suicide still a crime in your jurisdiction?
 
D
From the text quoted in this thread it was either a misguided or legitimate attempt to help a friend, depending on whether or not you agree that people have the right to choose to live or die.
this has nothing to do with the right for people to choose to die. I support that right

This is about somebody choosing their right to live and being convinced otherwise

A suicidal state is a very vulnerable one, a bleak place to be. If someone who seems to care about you (see 1000 msgs) is whispering in your ear to finish job when you want to live then they are very culpable for this
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom