Merged Teen Encouraged Friend to Commit Suicide, Convicted of Manslaughter

12AX7

Banned
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
10,889
Location
Hollywood East

Teen Encouraged Friend to Commit Suicide, Police Say


An 18-year-old girl has been charged with manslaughter for urging her friend to commit suicide.
Carter's attorney, Joseph P. Cataldo, told the Standard-Times of New Bedford on Thursday night that the 18-year-old girl is innocent.

"This is terrible tragedy – a young man taking his own life," he said. The district attorney's office "is trying to pin the blame on someone. I can't understand why they brought the charge."

He added: "They're trying to claim there is manslaughter when they freely admit the boy took his own life. You can't have it both ways."

Interesting story. Not sure I agree with charging her.
 
I . . . uhm . . . hm. Can't really figure out what to make of it. I get the feeling something big is being left out of the story.
 
Strange one. Not much to go on but from the very limited information in the report it seems she did more than simply take no action. You can be charged with "assisted suicide" in the UK but I don't know about encouraging someone to suicide.
 
I . . . uhm . . . hm. Can't really figure out what to make of it. I get the feeling something big is being left out of the story.

Agree.

No one physically forced the kid back into his truck AFAIK. It'll be interesting to see how this plays out.
 
Email evidence perhaps? Something stronger than "go jump in a lake"?
 
This should get bumped up on account of an aggravating circumstance for keeping him in the friendzone all those years.
 
I'm having trouble seeing how making a bad suggestion should make one criminally liable in a case like this. If he were a minor, maybe. Depending on the circumstances. But he was not.

But no, unless there's some huge detail that hasn't been shared yet (and I can't even imagine what that might be), I do not agree with this. The girl might be a dreadful, sick, uncaring person - or this could also be a misunderstanding or case of hyperbole - but I'm struggling to see how she's a criminal.
 
If entrapment is reasonably a crime, then encouraging someone to take their own life is also reasonably a crime.

If somebody is struggling with the choice to end their own life, then I can totally see charging someone with manslaughter if they urge the one option over the other.
 
Where the heck are we? Is an invitation for another to take an unlikely anatomical excursion as in "go <foxtrot> yourself" now somehow incitement to rape? Where exactly does this end?
 
I'm having trouble seeing how making a bad suggestion should make one criminally liable in a case like this. If he were a minor, maybe. Depending on the circumstances. But he was not.

But no, unless there's some huge detail that hasn't been shared yet (and I can't even imagine what that might be), I do not agree with this. The girl might be a dreadful, sick, uncaring person - or this could also be a misunderstanding or case of hyperbole - but I'm struggling to see how she's a criminal.

Incitement to commit a crime has always been a crime. Attempting suicide is a crime. How is her encouragement and cajoling any different than if she had encouraged him to commit robbery, murder, or rape?
 
Where the heck are we? Is an invitation for another to take an unlikely anatomical excursion as in "go <foxtrot> yourself" now somehow incitement to rape? Where exactly does this end?

That's a ridiculous comparison. She wasn't speaking figuratively when she convinced him to kill himself and to get back in the truck and finish the job. She was literally inciting him to commit suicide, which is legally a crime.
 
Email evidence perhaps? Something stronger than "go jump in a lake"?

I'm having trouble seeing how making a bad suggestion should make one criminally liable in a case like this. If he were a minor, maybe. Depending on the circumstances. But he was not.

But no, unless there's some huge detail that hasn't been shared yet (and I can't even imagine what that might be), I do not agree with this. The girl might be a dreadful, sick, uncaring person - or this could also be a misunderstanding or case of hyperbole - but I'm struggling to see how she's a criminal.


Have people not read the article, or was it updated in the past 15 minutes? Because...

In a police report provided to the Chronicle, Fairhaven police Detective Scott Gordon writes: "Not only did Conrad tell Carter in several of his texts prior to his death that he was scared and didn't want to leave his family, she continued to encourage him to take his own life, and when he actually started to carry out the act, he got scared again and exited his truck, but instead of telling him to stay out of the truck … Carter told him to 'get back in.' "


Someone seriously contemplating suicide is already in a pretty vulnerable position. That he had second thoughts and she still allegedly encouraged the taking of his own life and urged him to go through with the actual act...

She very much had a role in his death.
 
Last edited:
Incitement to commit a crime has always been a crime. Attempting suicide is a crime. How is her encouragement and cajoling any different than if she had encouraged him to commit robbery, murder, or rape?

Sorry, what? Attempting suicide is not a crime. Not in the conventional sense.

And I don't agree that encouraging someone to do those other things should be a crime either. People are responsible for their own actions (except, as I said, in certain cases of minors, or dependents, or things like that).

"But he made me do it!" isn't an up-to-snuff defense in my eyes unless true threats of harm are involved to the actor.

I can only speak for myself, of course.
 
I can see charging her with being an accessory to suicide (if it is a crime in Massachusetts -- I do not know), but charging her with manslaughter makes no sense at all. By definition, manslaughter is a death which resulted from unintended action. If she encouraged the boy to commit suicide, the outcome is clearly intended.
 
Have people not read the article, or was it updated in the past 15 minutes? Because...




Someone seriously contemplating suicide is already in a pretty vulnerable position. That he had second thoughts and she still allegedly encouraged the taking of his own life and urged him to go through with the actual act...

She very much had a role in his death.

Indeed, a role. And she's clearly a rotten person if that summary of her statements is accurate.

But I don't think that should be a crime. And why manslaughter? That makes even less sense.
 
Last edited:
Have people not read the article, or was it updated in the past 15 minutes? Because...




Someone seriously contemplating suicide is already in a pretty vulnerable position. That he had second thoughts and she still allegedly encouraged the taking of his own life and urged him to go through with the actual act...

She very much had a role in his death.

He was thinking clearly enough to get out of the truck twice and could have walked away. Did she physically force him to do it? Now we can be criminally charged for "I dare ya!" when someone gets hurt or killed?

I can't see how she's liable. She sounds like a terrible person, but liable?
 
Such a weird case. An attorney who was interviewed had this to say:

“All she did was talk to this guy and he clearly had the propensity to do it,” Duncan said. “Now if he changed his mind and she could have talked him out of it but didn’t, then maybe that should be a crime, but I’m not sure that this is the crime that it is.”

It seems like that's exactly what she did. Some of Carter's texts:

July 11, 2014: Texts Roy: “Let me know when you’re gonna do it.”

Sept. 15, 2014: Carter texts a friend: “...his death is my fault like honestly I could have stopped him I was on the phone with him and he got out of the car because it was working and he got scared and I (expletive) told him to get back in... because I knew he would do it all over again the next day and I couldn’t have him live the way he was living anymore I couldn’t do it I wouldn’t let him...”

http://www.bostonherald.com/news_opinion/local_coverage/2015/02/case_against_teen_faces_steep_climb

I don't know if the charges are going to fly though. Canada has a law against counseling or aiding suicide but the U.S. doesn't as far as I know.

http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/c-46/page-119.html
 
Such a weird case. An attorney who was interviewed had this to say:

“All she did was talk to this guy and he clearly had the propensity to do it,” Duncan said. “Now if he changed his mind and she could have talked him out of it but didn’t, then maybe that should be a crime, but I’m not sure that this is the crime that it is.”

It seems like that's exactly what she did. Some of Carter's texts:

July 11, 2014: Texts Roy: “Let me know when you’re gonna do it.”

Sept. 15, 2014: Carter texts a friend: “...his death is my fault like honestly I could have stopped him I was on the phone with him and he got out of the car because it was working and he got scared and I (expletive) told him to get back in... because I knew he would do it all over again the next day and I couldn’t have him live the way he was living anymore I couldn’t do it I wouldn’t let him...”

http://www.bostonherald.com/news_opinion/local_coverage/2015/02/case_against_teen_faces_steep_climb

I don't know if the charges are going to fly though. Canada has a law against counseling or aiding suicide but the U.S. doesn't as far as I know.

http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/c-46/page-119.html

I'm not even sure I agree with that! Since when is staying out of something a crime? I mean, he's the lawyer, he would know. I'm just giving my personal opinion, which is extreme surprise.

This reminds me of the Seinfeld finale's rather liberal interpretation of so-called "Good Samaritan" laws.

Look, I think this girl's actions are callous and terrible. I can't imagine why someone would behave that way. I'm just uncomfortable with the criminalizing of it based on the limited information we have here. What other forms of "being a dick" should be criminalized?
 
Sorry, what? Attempting suicide is not a crime. Not in the conventional sense.

You are mistaken. It is a crime, in the conventional sense.

And I don't agree that encouraging someone to do those other things should be a crime either. People are responsible for their own actions (except, as I said, in certain cases of minors, or dependents, or things .

So you don't believe Charles Manson should be in prison for his role in encouraging his followers to commit murder?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom