Merged Teen Encouraged Friend to Commit Suicide, Convicted of Manslaughter

Seeing as how it is a crime to come across someone badly hurt but then not render any aide I can very well see how having someone on the phone about to kill themselves and you actively talk them into it is also a crime.

And if it isn't it should be.
 
D
this has nothing to do with the right for people to choose to die. I support that right

This is about somebody choosing their right to live and being convinced otherwise

A suicidal state is a very vulnerable one, a bleak place to be. If someone who seems to care about you (see 1000 msgs) is whispering in your ear to finish job when you want to live then they are very culpable for this

Perhaps. I don't know how you reconcile supporting the right to choose life or death and prosecuting people who support or aid someone who has made that choice. Regardless, if she is culpable I don't think it's been shown that she was being malicious and I don't think it's appropriate to treat her as if she were.
 
I'm of two minds of this.

On hand I'm reminded of that scene in that X-Files episode where that guy has the supernatural ability to talk people into doing things, even getting a cop to douse himself in gasoline and light himself on fire...

Mulder: Modell psyched the guy out, he put the Whammy on him!
Scully: Please explain to me the scientific nature of "The Whammy."

So I'm hesitant, not opposed just hesitant, to start assigning blame to people on a legal level (moral is a completely different story) who isn't literally forcing someone to do something. Generally speaking a layperson giving bad advice, regardless of the consequences, isn't a crime.

But I'm neither heartless or stupid and as with everything if we can reasonably assume that said person wouldn't have committed suicide if not given the outside influence then with all things we can apply a blame to that factor.

On a purely pragmatic level I don't see this being an easy court case to decide however.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps. I don't know how you reconcile supporting the right to choose life or death and prosecuting people who support or aid someone who has made that choice. Regardless, if she is culpable I don't think it's been shown that she was being malicious and I don't think it's appropriate to treat her as if she were.
that "choice" can be backed out of at any point the person "Choosing" wants. To push past that does not amount to support or aid.
I do not support prosecuting people who aid a person to go through with a "choice" made freely and sanely
 
Perhaps. I don't know how you reconcile supporting the right to choose life or death and prosecuting people who support or aid someone who has made that choice. Regardless, if she is culpable I don't think it's been shown that she was being malicious and I don't think it's appropriate to treat her as if she were.


Did you read the pdf? It does seem to be a tad malicious. She even texted a friend when she found out the police were about to go through his phone messages and stated when the police find her messages (to him) that she was "done".
 
Encouraging a person who you think has genuine suicidal tendencies to off themselves shouldn't be any more legal than, say, luring a drunk person off of a cliff. I'm surprised that people are surprised that it's illegal.
 
Did you read the pdf? It does seem to be a tad malicious. She even texted a friend when she found out the police were about to go through his phone messages and stated when the police find her messages (to him) that she was "done".

Well the texts are being partially quoted out of context by police to a reporter for a paper. The only ones I've read here in this thread though don't seem to indicate that. Although it's possible, as the pdf claims, that she crafted many of the texts to generate false sympathy for herself in anticipation for their eventual discovery including the ones I have read, I'm not going to default to that.
 
Encouraging a person who you think has genuine suicidal tendencies to off themselves shouldn't be any more legal than, say, luring a drunk person off of a cliff. I'm surprised that people are surprised that it's illegal.

Having read further into what exactly was said, I'm now inclined to agree. This seems like it was indeed malicious.

I wonder what on earth this girl could have gotten out of such actions. :confused:
 
In Canada, neither committing suicide nor attempting to commit suicide are criminal offences. They were once upon a time but I believe that the provisions were officially repealed by about 1972. (And it usually takes quite some time before things go from 'no longer being enforced' to 'officially repealed' (absent a Supreme Court of Canada judgment officially deeming them of no force and effect, of course, which speeds up the process).

However, counselling someone to commit suicide, and aiding or abetting someone to commit suicide are criminal offences in Canada.

That said, section 241(b) of the Criminal Code, which is the aiding or abetting offence, was subject to a constitutional challenge in recent years and just a few weeks ago (~February 6), the Supreme Court of Canada decided unanimously that the provision is unconstitutional at least in certain narrow circumstances (i.e., physician-assisted suicide in cases of severe and irremediable debilitating situations with a whole bunch of provisos) and that particular provision was struck down, with the court essentially reversing itself on its prior decision in the Rodriguez case some 22 years ago. While doing so, the SCC suspended the application of its current decision for a year to give the legislature as well as the relevant medical regulatory organizations the opportunity to re-draft the relevant statutes, rules, and regulations in keeping with the terms of the current SCC judgment.

From the judgment, it appears that it is intended by the court that any right to physician-assisted suicide is to be narrow in scope and the court spelled out certain circumstances in which they expect their decision to be confined, but it is an interesting debate and will, no doubt, be a very heated one over the course of the next 12 months.

However, section 241(a) of the Criminal Code of Canada was not at issue at all in either the Rodriguez case or in the current case before the SCC, and that sub-section remains fully in force, and that is the section that deals with counselling someone to commit suicide, rather than aiding or abetting. Counselling another to commit suicide remains a criminal offence here in Canada, and that provision has not been challenged so far as I know (but if it has been challenged somewhere at some time, it certainly hasn't been successful so the provision stands in any event).

I do not know if Massachussetts has a similar provision against counselling suicide, but based solely upon the limited (second, third, or fourth hand and therefore presumptively unreliable) reports that have been provided thusfar in this thread about the allegations against the young woman, and assuming for purposes of discussion that they are accurate, it seems to me that a charge of counselling another to commit suicide might be appropriate (if such a charge exists in Massachussetts).

On the other hand, if Massachussetts does not have any prohibition against counselling suicide, it seems to me to be a stretch to try to shoehorn the alleged (second, third, or fourth hand and presumptively unreliable) 'facts' into a charge of manslaughter.

It could prove to be an interesting discussion, though.
 
Last edited:
I was mistaken that suicide is still a crime. But assisting (and, arguably, encouraging) someone to commit suicide is.

From Wikipedia:



Manslaughter is an area of the law that is notoriously murky, and dependent on the judgment of judge, jury, and prosecution as to how a particular situation should be interpreted. I have no problems with prosecutors deciding that her actions in this case deserve a charge of manslaughter.

Well, I resign my opinion to the judicial system on this one.
 
Well the texts are being partially quoted out of context by police to a reporter for a paper. The only ones I've read here in this thread though don't seem to indicate that. Although it's possible, as the pdf claims, that she crafted many of the texts to generate false sympathy for herself in anticipation for their eventual discovery including the ones I have read, I'm not going to default to that.

Just a minor nitpick - I believe the Fairhaven reporter was quoting from court documents and not from a police source. Fairhaven is the town where Roy killed himself so she probably got the docs from the Bristol county courthouse.
 
Actively trying to convince someone to kill someone, especially when you have very good reason to believe this will actually result in a death, certainly sounds like at least accessory to murder.

I await the pedantic comments about soldiers, end of life terminal cases, and the prosecutors who argue for the death penalty.
 
Sociopaths, which I can't help but believe she is, generally don't off themselves (although there are rare exceptions, such as Eric Harris. That was in the context of his murderous rampage, though).

I'm currently writing a book that i have been posting in chapters online, and the first three deal with a person who is very much a sociopath doing almost the same thing. It kinda wierds me out that people could sere this as anything other than a malicious act.
 
Actively trying to convince someone to kill someone, especially when you have very good reason to believe this will actually result in a death, certainly sounds like at least accessory to murder.


One cannot murder oneself, of course, so neither can someone else be an accessory to a non-existent murder.

Counselling suicide, on the other hand, that seems a reasonable charge if the facts and circumstances warrant it.
 
Last edited:
If entrapment is reasonably a crime, then encouraging someone to take their own life is also reasonably a crime.

If somebody is struggling with the choice to end their own life, then I can totally see charging someone with manslaughter if they urge the one option over the other.

Yep.

Furthermore, I assert that if the suicide had been a female or a gay male and the other person had been a straight male, then not only would there be no significant objection on this forum to an arrest and charge, but we'd also hear a lot about how it is a hate crime and shows how horrible bullying is.
 
Yep.

Furthermore, I assert that if the suicide had been a female or a gay male and the other person had been a straight male, then not only would there be no significant objection on this forum to an arrest and charge, but we'd also hear a lot about how it is a hate crime and shows how horrible bullying is.

You have any reasoning behind that?
 
Yep.

Furthermore, I assert that if the suicide had been a female or a gay male and the other person had been a straight male, then not only would there be no significant objection on this forum to an arrest and charge, but we'd also hear a lot about how it is a hate crime and shows how horrible bullying is.

Oh, let's not do this.
 
In my personal opinion you would have to prove that the victim was, for whatever reason*, in a very below average state of susceptibility to suggestion.

(Whether it be age, under the influence, mental retardation, etc.)
 
Furthermore, I assert that if the suicide had been a female or a gay male and the other person had been a straight male, then not only would there be no significant objection on this forum to an arrest and charge, but we'd also hear a lot about how it is a hate crime and shows how horrible bullying is.


There is no need to derail this thread like this. If you want to discuss hypothetical (or actual) 'female or gay male' suicides, and some hypothetical (or actual) 'other person' of some other specific sexual orientation, etc., it seems to me that it would be preferable that you start a new thread about that rather than derail this thread, which is about a specific case that actually exists and does not have anything at all to do with your proposed hypotheticals.

ETA: Or, to say it more succinctly,

Oh, let's not do this.


^^
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom