Merged Teen Encouraged Friend to Commit Suicide, Convicted of Manslaughter

It is cases like this where I have a stupid and un-warranted hatred of defence lawyers.

They are just doing their job but this chick will get off lighter than she deserves IMHO
 
Apparently she was only 17 at the time. I know people even younger than that have been charged as adults, but I'm not sure that's really right.
Two twelve year old girls are being tried as adults in Wisconsin atm.
 
Apparently she was only 17 at the time. I know people even younger than that have been charged as adults, but I'm not sure that's really right.

Maybe she thought that this is what he really wanted and she was just trying to help?

I don't think so. Whenever he'd have doubts she'd push him to do it. She's either psycho or she thought she was playing a game. In both cases I'd have her evaluated.
 
A bit late to the party here, but I'll chime in and say that the girl should definitely be charged with a crime, though I'm not sure manslaughter is the right one.

People in the thread have made the comment that the guy was capable of making his own decisions (which some have backed down from, rightfully). I strongly disagree. Not just because this was a teen (incomplete development of the ability to make long-term judgements); but because suicidal ideation is typically the result of mental illness. When it's not, its most often the result of intolerable life circumstances causing damage to the ability to judge rationally (there is plenty of science showing the effects of severe chronic stress on the brain). There are obviously exceptions, such as terminal or severe chronic illness; but these are only a very small percentage of cases.

In both cases, the person is not capable of fully reasoned judgement. They are on the level of children or the developmentally disabled in this respect. And pushing someone in this state to suicide is little different from a pushing a small child into doing something to harm themselves. These are people who are highly vulnerable, with what the law refers to as "diminished capacity", and are in need of protection from a more stable third party.

This girl is not only deplorable; but is quite possibly a sociopath as well. There is definitely an element of culpability on her part, every much as if she had done the same thing to a young child, or an adult with Down's Syndrome or schizophrenia.
 
A bit late to the party here, but I'll chime in and say that the girl should definitely be charged with a crime, though I'm not sure manslaughter is the right one.


What would be?

And how long do you think an appropriate prison term should be for this seventeen yr. old girl?

<snip>

This girl is not only deplorable; but is quite possibly a sociopath as well. There is definitely an element of culpability on her part, every much as if she had done the same thing to a young child, or an adult with Down's Syndrome or schizophrenia.


Judging from my six decades of life experience I believe one could say with some accuracy that many teenage girls show some degree of sociopathy.

Some even seem to revel in it. It certainly surfaces a lot as a theme in depictions of teens in school cliques, and I've seen enough of it in real life to know that it isn't wholly fabricated, or even that much of an exaggeration.

Most manage to largely grow out of that phase.

I hope. At least they manage to stifle the outward expression of it as they grow older.
 
What would be?

And how long do you think an appropriate prison term should be for this seventeen yr. old girl?


I'd treat her no different than anyone else who takes advantage of a vulnerable person. There are typically laws already in place for that sort of thing. However, a prison term would be effectively useless without some sort of mandatory therapy included.

Judging from my six decades of life experience I believe one could say with some accuracy that many teenage girls show some degree of sociopathy.


No. Lack of empathy, yes, which is typical of most children and teens; empathy being something that needs to be developed, like everything else. But not full-out sociopathy. There is a big difference, and her actions afterwards point to the latter IMO; though obviously I'm not a professional, and my experiences with sociopathy -- properly called Anti-Social Personality Disorder -- are in a different context.

In the case of teens, including teen girls, a very lot of it is simply peer reinforcement of anti-social behaviours; things they would not normally do on their own without the group approval. Groupthink is a big problem with many different anti-social behaviours, and engaging in it isn't necessarily indicative of anti-social disorders (though if you look at the groups, you can sometimes find a ringleader who does qualify as pathologically anti-social).
 
I am a more simple thinker than most on here.

I think that could have been anyone. Her brother. Grandmother.

She got her jollies out of the power trip of having someone's life in her hands. I'm probably wrong but I don't think that is something that can be switched off.

I think she should get treatment but be locked up in an appropriate institution for a very long time.
 
She got her jollies out of the power trip of having someone's life in her hands. I'm probably wrong but I don't think that is something that can be switched off.


That's part of the description of ASPD (sociopathy), and no, it can't be "switched off". However, it can be treated; though the effectiveness of the treatment varies considerably (as it does for all personality disorders). The biggest barrier to treatment is simply the person's willingness to see their behaviour as problematic. Typically, they don't see anything wrong with, and some never do despite attempts at treatment. The younger treatment starts, the more likely it is to be effective; but there are still no guarantees.
 
The problem is even after treatment do you truly know it won't happen again?

It is a bit like pedophiles.

Personally (I am probably over cautious), I wouldn't never leave her alone in a room with a young relative no matter how much she has apparently progressed
 
Last edited:
I'd treat her no different than anyone else who takes advantage of a vulnerable person. There are typically laws already in place for that sort of thing.


What sort of laws? Could you point out a statute she might be charged under as an example?

However, a prison term would be effectively useless without some sort of mandatory therapy included.
<snip>


Do you think a prison experience would be an asset to the therapy?
 
Woman convicted of inciting suicide....

Surprisingly, there doesn't seem to be a thread about this. A young woman who was a high school girl at the time has been convicted of involuntary manslaughter for tweeting to another student that she knew was suicidal and was actually committing suicide at that moment that he should go ahead and do it, even when he expressed second thoughts. Sounds to me like a just verdict, but apparently it's a legal first.
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/16/us/suicide-texting-trial-michelle-carter-conrad-roy.html
 
Surprisingly, there doesn't seem to be a thread about this. A young woman who was a high school girl at the time has been convicted of involuntary manslaughter for tweeting to another student that she knew was suicidal and was actually committing suicide at that moment that he should go ahead and do it, even when he expressed second thoughts. Sounds to me like a just verdict, but apparently it's a legal first.
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/16/us/suicide-texting-trial-michelle-carter-conrad-roy.html
I am glad you started one Bob001.
Unquestionably she influenced his decision to take his life. What I find despicable are the hang em highers looking for 20 years. Fox of course is quick out of the blocks.
This mentally ill young woman needs anything but jail.
 
And yet when some lost soul stands atop a multistory car park, the idiots below shouting 'jump' are simply moved on by the police. Ridiculous and inconsistent verdict, another example of how the concept of personal responsibility is circling the pan.
 
And yet when some lost soul stands atop a multistory car park, the idiots below shouting 'jump' are simply moved on by the police. Ridiculous and inconsistent verdict, another example of how the concept of personal responsibility is circling the pan.
She could have had the personal responsibility of trying to discourage him and contacting help. Not admonishing him for not following through previously, and telling him to get back in the car. She gets no sympathy from me. She sounds like a callous attention seeking bitch. Well mission accomplished.
 
And yet when some lost soul stands atop a multistory car park, the idiots below shouting 'jump' are simply moved on by the police. Ridiculous and inconsistent verdict, another example of how the concept of personal responsibility is circling the pan.

Personal responsibility was upheld she had a personal responsibility not to incite this young man to kill himself
 
She could have had the personal responsibility of trying to discourage him and contacting help. Not admonishing him for not following through previously, and telling him to get back in the car. She gets no sympathy from me. She sounds like a callous attention seeking bitch. Well mission accomplished.

I'm sure she is foul, but that shouldn't be against the law.

Personal responsibility was upheld she had a personal responsibility not to incite this young man to kill himself

No, she didn't. She behaved in a disgusting manner and any right-minded person would shun her but that's not a legal matter, or shouldn't be. If we go down the road of jailing people for immoral acts then I suggest we start with some of the right-to-life campaigners, who would rather see people suffer beyond words for decades than compromise on their holier-than-thou morality, and who celebrate when a loving husband or wife of 50 years is jailed for compassionately ending the suffering of their spouse. When these dirt bags are in jail get back to me and we can discuss a wider range of cases.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom