Merged Teen Encouraged Friend to Commit Suicide, Convicted of Manslaughter

Incitement to commit a crime has always been a crime. Attempting suicide is a crime. How is her encouragement and cajoling any different than if she had encouraged him to commit robbery, murder, or rape?

Last I checked, nobody's gone to jail for committing suicide. If the punishment for inciting a crime is less than or equal to actually committing that crime, then the punishment here is . . . ?
 
You are mistaken. It is a crime, in the conventional sense.

Okay, then why aren't I in jail? Or charged with anything?



So you don't believe Charles Manson should be in prison for his role in encouraging his followers to commit murder?


If he'd just emailed them and said "go kill those people," no, I would not agree. There was a bit more going on in that case.
 
There are a few people here claiming that this is a slippery slope to criminazlizing saying "Go jump in a lake".

Incitement has been a crime for a long time. As Doghouse pointed out. Charles Manso didn't kill anyone, he just told people to do it.

Our justice system is fully capable of distinguishing between petty taunts and real calls to action. If someone has a reasonable belief that their words will result in criminal actions, I don't see how that has ANYTHING in common with colloquial taunts and insults.

For starters, there's a massive difference in mens rea, which is absolutely crucial in this kind of case.
 
Last I checked, nobody's gone to jail for committing suicide. If the punishment for inciting a crime is less than or equal to actually committing that crime, then the punishment here is . . . ?

I was mistaken that suicide is still a crime. But assisting (and, arguably, encouraging) someone to commit suicide is.

From Wikipedia:

By the late 1980s, thirty of the fifty states had no laws against suicide or suicide attempts but every state had laws declaring it to be a felony to aid, advise or encourage another person to commit suicide.[30] By the early 1990s only two states still listed suicide as a crime, and these have since removed that classification.

Manslaughter is an area of the law that is notoriously murky, and dependent on the judgment of judge, jury, and prosecution as to how a particular situation should be interpreted. I have no problems with prosecutors deciding that her actions in this case deserve a charge of manslaughter.
 
There are a few people here claiming that this is a slippery slope to criminazlizing saying "Go jump in a lake".

Incitement has been a crime for a long time. As Doghouse pointed out. Charles Manso didn't kill anyone, he just told people to do it.

Our justice system is fully capable of distinguishing between petty taunts and real calls to action. If someone has a reasonable belief that their words will result in criminal actions, I don't see how that has ANYTHING in common with colloquial taunts and insults.

For starters, there's a massive difference in mens rea, which is absolutely crucial in this kind of case.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Failed_suicide_attempt#Criminalization_of_attempted_suicide

In America, attempted suicide is not a criminal act. Therefore, encouraging someone to do it is not encouraging someone to commit a crime. It's more akin to bullying.

Like I said, the lawyer would know better than me about the specifics. I'm just surprised. I'm clearly not the only one.
 
Okay, then why aren't I in jail? Or charged with anything?






If he'd just emailed them and said "go kill those people," no, I would not agree. There was a bit more going on in that case.

I think the prosecutors have decided there was a bit more going on in this case, too.
 
I certainly agree that assisting someone in suicide should be. It seems a bit murkier when you get into the encouraging part. Open to a lot of interpretation.

Which in this case must have been determined to be criminal on the girl's part. It still surprises me, whatever I may think of her actions ethically.
 
Last edited:
Manslaughter in English law

Involuntary manslaughter arises where the accused did not intend to cause death or serious injury but caused the death of another through recklessness or criminal negligence. For these purposes, recklessness is defined as a blatant disregard for the dangers of a particular situation.

I'd say that insisting that someone complete their suicide while that are in the act and have tried to stop once constitutes "a blatant disregard for the dangers of a particular situation".
 
It is a crime to "aid, advise or encourage another person to commit suicide..."

Do you disagree that she did this? If not, why do you feel she should not be charged?
 
Manslaughter in English law



I'd say that insisting that someone complete their suicide while that are in the act and have tried to stop once constitutes "a blatant disregard for the dangers of a particular situation".

It seems a bit of a stretch, only because the boy was no doubt aware of those dangers as well. But legal applications have certainly been stretched further and stuck.

We shall see.
 
I was confused by the citation of a Daily Mail article, but, if I recall correctly, "reckless disregard" is an element of manslaughter in US law as well.
 
It is a crime to "aid, advise or encourage another person to commit suicide..."

Do you disagree that she did this? If not, why do you feel she should not be charged?

No, if the summary of her quotes are accurate, that describes what she did all right.

Why aren't more people charged with this? Bullies encourage people to commit suicide all the time, and often, they attempt it. Sometimes they succeed.

Another puzzling thing is, if that is indeed its own law, why are they charging her with manslaughter? :confused: Laws are weird sometimes.
 
Last edited:
No, if the summary of her quotes are accurate, that describes what she did all right.

Why aren't more people charged with this? Bullies encourage people to commit suicide all the time, and often, they attempt it. Sometimes they succeed.

My guess is that is has to do with the fact that usually bullies are more just encouraging suicide as a general suggestion, rather than in the context of a clear and specific suicide attempt actually being planned and carried out.

But it's a good question and I don't know the actual answer as to why such laws aren't applied more frequently.
 
Last edited:
Cases like these are exactly why our jurisprudence progresses top a jury trial. However, sometimes the assertion of "no crime" appears to question the validity of the charge in the first place.
 
Involuntary manslaughter arises where the accused did not intend to cause death or serious injury but caused the death of another through recklessness or criminal negligence. For these purposes, recklessness is defined as a blatant disregard for the dangers of a particular situation.

I'm imagining a couple drunk frat guys. One wants to jump off a second-floor balcony at a beach hotel into the pool below. Another says "Go ahead! I dare ya!" Dude jumps, misses, dies.

Is this chargeable then?
 
No, if the summary of her quotes are accurate, that describes what she did all right.

Why aren't more people charged with this? Bullies encourage people to commit suicide all the time, and often, they attempt it. Sometimes they succeed.

Another puzzling thing is, if that is indeed its own law, why are they charging her with manslaughter? :confused: Laws are weird sometimes.

An excellent point.

Why are cyberbullies who push kids to suicide not charged?
 
An excellent point.

Why are cyberbullies who push kids to suicide not charged?

Perhaps this case will be the setting of a new precedent in that regard. For cases where the bullies can be identified, anyway. (And there are plenty such cases!)

I guess my initial objections to all this may have been wrong, uninformed, irrational, etc. I'll be interested in seeing how it all plays out now.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom