Merged Teen Encouraged Friend to Commit Suicide, Convicted of Manslaughter

The Fox bottom feeders have decided she did equivalent of shooting him. Of course they would because more guns are better.
Until you all pull these ethical morons into line you will need a lot more jail space.
 
I'm sure she is foul, but that shouldn't be against the law.



No, she didn't. She behaved in a disgusting manner and any right-minded person would shun her but that's not a legal matter, or shouldn't be. If we go down the road of jailing people for immoral acts then I suggest we start with some of the right-to-life campaigners, who would rather see people suffer beyond words for decades than compromise on their holier-than-thou morality, and who celebrate when a loving husband or wife of 50 years is jailed for compassionately ending the suffering of their spouse. When these dirt bags are in jail get back to me and we can discuss a wider range of cases.
She told him to kill himself and he did. She talked him out of saving himself. If I tell someone to kill someone else and they do, its a crime. She just skipped the middleman.
 
I'm sure she is foul, but that shouldn't be against the law.



No, she didn't. She behaved in a disgusting manner and any right-minded person would shun her but that's not a legal matter, or shouldn't be. If we go down the road of jailing people for immoral acts then I suggest we start with some of the right-to-life campaigners, who would rather see people suffer beyond words for decades than compromise on their holier-than-thou morality, and who celebrate when a loving husband or wife of 50 years is jailed for compassionately ending the suffering of their spouse. When these dirt bags are in jail get back to me and we can discuss a wider range of cases.

:rolleyes:

A for effort!
 
Here's the verdict which includes Juvenile Court Judge Lawrence Moniz explaining what led him to find her guilty:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A4i6bGFfQ9E

The ACLU has spoken out regarding the verdict, saying it imperils free speech. I'm expecting Carter to appeal her verdict. In the meantime she's free on bail until her sentencing hearing on August 3. I'm not sure why that is though since she was found guilty.

It's been reported that Carter has suffered from anorexia, cutting and childhood depression.

http://www.masslive.com/news/index.ssf/2017/06/michelle_carter_trial_controve_1.html

IMO she's a mess psychologically and needs to be removed from the community until she can be properly assessed and treated.
 
An excellent point.

Why are cyberbullies who push kids to suicide not charged?

Some of them probably should be charged with something. But this is an unusual, if not unique, case. This goes way beyond cyberbullying, which itself is terrible enough. It's clear that this guy was actively in the process of trying to kill himself with a CO-spewing generator in his truck, but he changed his mind and got out. She told him to get back in the truck and finish the job. She also knew where he was -- which, according to the judge's account, was a half-mile away from the fire department -- but failed to call for help. If she hadn't said anything he might have saved himself. At some point speech becomes action. That's why we hear the cliche that you can't yell fire in a crowded theater. A spoken threat by itself alone can be charged as assault. Her speech was the direct and immediate cause of his death. She doesn't need to be hanged, but a couple years in prison would be a gift.

As an aside, the defense had a famously, if not notoriously, anti-psychiatry psychiatrist testify that her capacity for empathy was impaired by the antidepressants she was taking. "The pills made me do it."
http://www.masslive.com/news/index.ssf/2017/06/michelle_carter_trial_cross_ex.html
 
I'm worried about this as a precedent because sometimes agreeing with a person's intent to hurt themselves has the opposite effect and makes them realize they don't want to die.

I don't believe that was the intent in this case, but it often is -and sometimes it's more effective than begging someone not to or trying to convince them to seek help.
 
I'm worried about this as a precedent because sometimes agreeing with a person's intent to hurt themselves has the opposite effect and makes them realize they don't want to die.
.....

Who says so? I suspect that's not a standard psychiatric practice. More important, in this particular case the guy had already changed his mind, he had gotten out of the truck where he was being gassed, and she told him to get back in and finish. She was directly responsible for his death. In other cases, a prosecutor and ultimately a judge and jury will get to decide.
 
She was directly responsible for his death. In other cases, a prosecutor and ultimately a judge and jury will get to decide.

I agree with you.

But standard psychiatric practices aside, sometimes calling a person's bluff when they're threatening suicide works.

I'm not fond of the practice, but I've known at least a couple of people who were, and I've personally seen people back off and recognize dying wasn't really what they wanted.

So, I'm concerned about this verdict and the potential liability for people who are trying to help friends or family members.
 
I agree with you.

But standard psychiatric practices aside, sometimes calling a person's bluff when they're threatening suicide works.

I'm not fond of the practice, but I've known at least a couple of people who were, and I've personally seen people back off and recognize dying wasn't really what they wanted.

So, I'm concerned about this verdict and the potential liability for people who are trying to help friends or family members.
DragonLady:
I am glad you are helping the thread with a nuanced approach.
 
....
But standard psychiatric practices aside, sometimes calling a person's bluff when they're threatening suicide works.

I'm not fond of the practice, but I've known at least a couple of people who were, and I've personally seen people back off and recognize dying wasn't really what they wanted.

So, I'm concerned about this verdict and the potential liability for people who are trying to help friends or family members.

What? Trying to help? Refusing to be blackmailed by somebody who's being manipulative ("If you leave me I'll just kill myself!," "If you fire me life just won't be worth living," etc.) is one thing. Telling somebody in crisis to just kill himself and get it over with -- especially when he is obviously leaning the other way -- is something very different. "Free speech" doesn't mean no consequences for bad outcomes. How 'bout this: If you tell somebody to kill himself and he finds a new joy in life, you win; if he's dead the next morning with a note in his hand thanking you for your great counsel, you go to jail. Fair enough?
 
How 'bout this: If you tell somebody to kill himself and he finds a new joy in life, you win; if he's dead the next morning with a note in his hand thanking you for your great counsel, you go to jail. Fair enough?

No. Not fair enough. While people do use threats of suicide to manipulate, there are also those who think they're serious -until they realize they're not. Apparently that happened to the boy at the center of this topic: he changed his mind when faced with the very real specter of dying. Sometimes, that is the ONLY thing that works to prevent someone from going through with the act.

(sigh)

I agree what this woman did was terrible, and she deserved to be prosecuted and punished. In fact, I think she deserves to spend time in prison. Clearly, she wasn't trying to help, but she almost did help despite her intentions.

If she had been a real friend to him, she gained the perfect opportunity to tell him to go home and call for some professional help. But now, the next person who really is trying to help, and finds themselves in that same place may face prosecution because of her actions. That's worrisome.
 
I know about suicide. From the outside looking in regarding friends who took their own lives. Thinking about missed clues, words not spoken.

I've had to face some ugly things in my life and have gone to a place where suicide wasn't out of the question. The folks that love me helped me through those times.

Understanding those emotions, I have a difficult time understanding the actions of the girl involved. Maybe she wasn't mature enough to grasp the gravity of the situation. Maybe it was the idea that if the kid did kill himself she'd be the center of attention.

I can't see where putting her in prison is going to achieve anything.
 
I recall a friend who took his life by the same method by his father's grave. He had been helping us sand and paint an old boat the previous day. He had many devoted friends who attended the funeral of course, no one really understood, but it may have been lost love.
All the lessons from this current tragedy are available to all, including to the then 17 year old girl, by virtue of the publicity and scrutiny.
It seems to me that consequences of crime should flow in a foreseeable fashion. This is quite unlike shooting him in the head. I also do not see how prison will help.
 
.....
I can't see where putting her in prison is going to achieve anything.

You could say that about almost any crime: The murder victim is dead, putting the killer in jail won't bring him back. The money is gone, locking up the embezzler won't get it back. Sending the rapist to jail won't undo the victim's pain. Etc. Conviction and punishment are the community's only way of holding someone responsible for his actions, and of deterring similar conduct by others. She doesn't have to go away forever, but people go to prison every day for much less.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom