She told him to kill himself and he did. She talked him out of saving himself. If I tell someone to kill someone else and they do, its a crime. She just skipped the middleman.I'm sure she is foul, but that shouldn't be against the law.
No, she didn't. She behaved in a disgusting manner and any right-minded person would shun her but that's not a legal matter, or shouldn't be. If we go down the road of jailing people for immoral acts then I suggest we start with some of the right-to-life campaigners, who would rather see people suffer beyond words for decades than compromise on their holier-than-thou morality, and who celebrate when a loving husband or wife of 50 years is jailed for compassionately ending the suffering of their spouse. When these dirt bags are in jail get back to me and we can discuss a wider range of cases.
I'm sure she is foul, but that shouldn't be against the law.
No, she didn't. She behaved in a disgusting manner and any right-minded person would shun her but that's not a legal matter, or shouldn't be. If we go down the road of jailing people for immoral acts then I suggest we start with some of the right-to-life campaigners, who would rather see people suffer beyond words for decades than compromise on their holier-than-thou morality, and who celebrate when a loving husband or wife of 50 years is jailed for compassionately ending the suffering of their spouse. When these dirt bags are in jail get back to me and we can discuss a wider range of cases.
An excellent point.
Why are cyberbullies who push kids to suicide not charged?
I'm worried about this as a precedent because sometimes agreeing with a person's intent to hurt themselves has the opposite effect and makes them realize they don't want to die.
.....
She was directly responsible for his death. In other cases, a prosecutor and ultimately a judge and jury will get to decide.
DragonLady:I agree with you.
But standard psychiatric practices aside, sometimes calling a person's bluff when they're threatening suicide works.
I'm not fond of the practice, but I've known at least a couple of people who were, and I've personally seen people back off and recognize dying wasn't really what they wanted.
So, I'm concerned about this verdict and the potential liability for people who are trying to help friends or family members.
....
But standard psychiatric practices aside, sometimes calling a person's bluff when they're threatening suicide works.
I'm not fond of the practice, but I've known at least a couple of people who were, and I've personally seen people back off and recognize dying wasn't really what they wanted.
So, I'm concerned about this verdict and the potential liability for people who are trying to help friends or family members.
How 'bout this: If you tell somebody to kill himself and he finds a new joy in life, you win; if he's dead the next morning with a note in his hand thanking you for your great counsel, you go to jail. Fair enough?
The implications of this conviction go far beyond the tragic circumstances of Mr. Roy’s death. If allowed to stand, Ms. Carter’s conviction could chill important and worthwhile end-of-life discussions between loved ones across the Commonwealth.
.....
I can't see where putting her in prison is going to achieve anything.
You could say that about almost any crime
I can't see where putting her in prison is going to achieve anything.
I can't see where letting her walk free is going to achieve anything either.