Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

To detect design look for high improbability conjoined with an independently given pattern.
Begging the question. How do you determine what is an "independently given pattern". Independently given is simply what you assign as significant.
 
By the way, how are we to empirically tell the difference between Specified Complexity and non-specified complexity ?

How do you know that the Specified form can not possibly be the product of a natural evolutionary process?

It can be.

; {>
 
TOS violation. Third post reported.

; }>

You might want to lay off the report function.

Intelligent Design is an idea promoted by people who are uneducated or ignorant (quite often, incorrectly educated). Those who possess proper education and knowledge do not support intelligent design. Most of those who foolishly support intelligent design are laypersons, i.e. not professionals (and certainly not professionals in biology, chemistry, etc.). Hence, by both the old Latin (unprofessional, layperson) and the newer Middle English (uneducated, ignorant), those who are proponents of Intelligent Design are idiots (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiot_(usage)). Adding the capital letters to make it IDiot is simply a local specific version of the term to denote one particular type of idiot.

Generally, since there is no such thing as 'intelligent design science' (and, thus, no way a person could become 'educated' in intelligent design), then there can be no proponent of intelligent design who is not an idiot. Perhaps, one day, if intelligent design proponents can come up with a coherent theory (which, of course, also does not embrace Creationism), they can cease being IDiots; but in the meantime, it is a most fitting nomenclature for ID proponents, unlike the term twoofer, which is clearly and purely derogatory and has no such clean and certain origin; yet the term 'twoofer' has not been actioned here and probably never will be; so I doubt 'IDiot' will be either.

Just sayin'...
 
My thread stands on its own merits until...
Then it has failed and stands as irredeemable until you do respond.

I don't know how you are going to get around the facts though:
  • ID is unparsimonious (it posits unkown forces and unknown entities).
  • ID makes no falsifiable predictions.
  • ID has no explanatory power.
Perhaps it's best that you don't respond.
 
I'm still hoping for a concise operational definition for specified complexity.
 
Intelligent Design has to meet the means test described in the thread. No need to repeat it here.

; {>

My point was that trying to decide whether something is designed or not based on its intrinsic characteristics when dealing with cosmological matters is utterly futile, since either side could come up with a complex explanation that supported their view, no matter what appearance the object in question had.

If we look at the whole picture, we can see signs of adaptation among species, and transitional fossils, supporting evolution.

What evidence would support intelligent design? None, a being like YHVH could create a species in whatever way it chose. Thus, there's no point in pursuing it.
 
If life arose by chance what were any of the other conditions of no life. Each one was just as improbable wasn't it?


I still am not sure I understand the question. I don't understand what you mean by "other conditions of no life". However, I'll take a stab at it. I might be completely missing the point of your question. If I am, please let me know.

I think what you are asking is whether saying "life arose by chance" implies that it would be possible for life to have not arisen at all, and wouldn't each possible outcome be equally probable? Is that it?

First of all, we could say "evolution is random" or "abiogenesis is random" or "life arose by chance" or any of a number of more or less synonymous things. All those things are getting at the same point, despite slight differences in meaning. In none of those cases is it implied in any way that all the possible outcomes are equally likely. It may be that the origin of life was incredibly likely given the appropriate conditions (proper combination of planetary mass, temperature, etc.) or it might be that the development of life is incredibly rare. We simply don't know the answer to that, but when we say "life arose by chance" we aren't asserting any particular answer.

In other words, if I say, "life arose by chance", I am not saying, "It is equally likely that life could have arisen, or not arisen, on Earth." I'm not saying anything about the relative likelihood of life or non-life. I suppose I must be saying that there is at least some probability, perhaps incredibly small, that life would not have arisen. However, that level of probability might indeed be so incredibly small that it would reasonably be said that the development of life was inevitable. In other words, even if the development of life was a nearly mathematical certainty, it would still make sense to say it arose "by chance".

Time for an analogy. If I flip a fair coin 1,000,000 times, and I wonder whether I will get at least one head, it would make sense to say that heads came up at least once "by chance". I suppose that some people might try to take that "by chance" and run with it and make all sorts of assumptions based on that, neglecting the original circumstances, but that's their problem.

So, nobody is being deceptive or inaccurate when they say that "life arose by chance", or any variant thereof. It is possible that someone might incorporate that phrase into a deceptive argument, but the description itself is neither deceptive nor inaccurate.
 
Incidentally, this is in the "Religion and Philosophy" sub-forum. If Rev wants to claim that I.D. is true on religious or philosophical grounds, he (or she?) can do so.

It seems to be the direction this thread is going, anyway. I do not see any real scientific claims being made.

Since "specified complexity" can be the result of an evolutionary process, then it might only take some kind of philosophy to determine its existence.
 
That was an Allegory.

; }>
No kidding?

To use an example of something which clearly, demonstrably has not happened as an allegory for what you believe has happened is a very poor start. To suggest that what exists is improbable because something else improbable has never occurred is....well, I hate to say the word, folks, but it's stupid.
 
In my personal search for truth (God) has led me through two decades of (mild) adventure and travel, most of it spiritual some of it via a jet plane on a flight plan vs. an spirit on an astral plane. I agree with much of established ID. We sorely need a standard theory. Nevertheless I will attempt to explain my beliefs and why I think ID is a credible idea.

How can an infinitesimally improbable event such as a finely-tuned Universe could warrant belief in a God and how about other incomprehensibly improbable events? We can say that in addition to high improbability events and conformity to an independently given pattern should also exist (to lend credence to ID). When these two rudiments/situations are present, we have what ID proponents call “specified complexity” (SC). What is SC you say ? Lets use the example of a poker game. All deals of the cards is equally and highly improbable. Nevertheless if a guy across from you gets a royal flush every time you can bet this is not the result of chance but of design !

In the labors of Intelligent Design theorists we find that none of them appeals to the simple high improbability of an event or thing as a basis for a design inference (conclusions). Our own existence, for example has to do with the exceedingly improbable union of one specific sperm and a one in specific egg. Nevertheless, ID proponents wouldn’t say conception was intelligently designed.

A reader writing in to Dr William Craig (a Christian, ID apologist) used this example: Imagine a likely Universe that is a great deal larger than our own, in which there are only two small space asteroids in existence, but they are located on different ‘edges’ of the Universe. The likelihood of these two small rocks colliding is dreadfully improbable, but if it did theoretically happen, would that warrant a supernatural explanation?

If the two rocks collided, you would deduce it was neither design nor chance as the best explanation. We should look to the third alternative ie physical necessity. Because gravitation acts over infinite distances, it is in fact, unavoidable that those two masses will eventually collide. However the thing that would suggest design would be if the rocks were to smash into pieces which then came together to spell “Welcome to the Milky Way.”

To detect design look for high improbability conjoined with an independently given pattern. Thats all folks...

With the disinformation on the web you could use this criteria to determine if a claim meets ID criteria, such that is. I hope that this clears up a bit of the mystery of ID.

; {>
But we all understood this much a long time ago. This stuff has been debated over and over again in this forum.

There is not need to keep re-defining these terms, but to present the argument itself.
 
The universe being lumpy.

; {>


That's improbable? Not according to my understanding of quantum mechanics. It seems pretty much inevitable.

I must admit it isn't the sort of answer I expected. Can you explain why you think a lumpy universe is improbable? Ideally, you could provide us some sort of calculation, or at least a mathematically substantiated estimate, of the probability.
 
The problem with specification is finding the specification.

I seem to remember that Dembski claimed to have some sort of a mathematical expression involving the tail of a certain bacterium and an outboard motor which would show that the bacterium's tail was intelligently designed.

I don't think we have seen this expression yet, but correct me if I am wrong.
 
Last edited:
If revdisturba wishes to wishes to debate the subject, I will accept his characterisation that modern mainstream biology says that life arose and evolved by chance, and will not accuse him of being deceptive or innaccurate. From experience, I expect that will draw some emotional replies, for reasons which esacape me, but I can't help that.

I think the emotion arises from witnessing the practice of dishonestly and/or ignorantly characterizing evolutionary mechanisms in a manner exemplified by the "Boeing 747 assembled by a tornado" analogy. I understand where you're coming from and I agree. But I think we'd both also agree that the accumulation of genetic complexity via natural, stochastic processes is hardly equivalent to random jumbling of atoms and molecules into a functional eukaryote, as is often the portrayal from creationist apologists.
 
I think the emotion arises from witnessing the practice of dishonestly and/or ignorantly characterizing evolutionary mechanisms in a manner exemplified by the "Boeing 747 assembled by a tornado" analogy. I understand where you're coming from and I agree. But I think we'd both also agree that the accumulation of genetic complexity via natural, stochastic processes is hardly equivalent to random jumbling of atoms and molecules into a functional eukaryote, as is often the portrayal from creationist apologists.


Certainly. However, the fact that a phrase has been misused does not mean it is incorrect. The fact that a phrase has sometimes been employed deceptively doesn't mean that every use of it is deceptive.

One of the biggest mistakes we make when debating creationists and/or ID proponents is to assume that all the arguments are alike. They aren't, and it serves no purpose to argue against an argument that no one is actually making at the time.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom