Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

That's very true. But for it to be a case for the ID proponents they'd have to define the actual odds of their particular "Royal Flush" and how many "games" are being played.

It's worse than that, though. Because by definition, we'd never know if the cards had not been dealt into a Royal Flush, so you have all the problems of a post-hoc calculation in statistics.

Douglas Adams' parking lot puddle shows the problem here. The odds against a puddle fitting exactly into the hole in the pavement are astronomical. But, of course, if the hole hadn't been in that particular shape, that particular puddle wouldn't have formed.

The only reason you remember this particular fact-oid about Brad is because it's so unusual; you don't remember such stories about any of your other poker-playing friends. Similarly, when you read investment books, you generally only hear from the successful investors -- because the unsuccessful ones don't get invited to write books. So even if Peter Lynch (or whoever) was wildly successful beyond what probability would have dictated, that doesn't prove that he's a god or that he cheated. Unusual events happen -- and only unusual events are worth documenting in trade paperback format.

If the Royal Flush is: Life Begins and it's odds are 40,000 to 1 and the number of games are 10 then there is a god.

Not even then.
 
Did we get a definition of "Specified Complexity" yet?
Since it is William Dembski's neologism, I suppose we should use his defintion and RevDisturba can tell us if he accepts it.

"That which cannot be created through 'undirected' evolution."

Whether or not such a thing exists in organisms is yet another excercise in trying to prove a negative. To prove it "could not exist" requires knowing every single evolutionary possibility. Dembski has already been proved wrong on several of his claims of things that possessed "Specified Complexity", and he has no "right" ones so far. (i.e. they have not been proved to be impossible under evolution.)

So based on this, it seems apparent that Dembski has defined a "unicorn". A hypothetical construct for which there is a perfectly good definition, but no evidence that it exists in reality.
 
Last edited:
Since it is William Dembski's neologism, I suppose we should use his defintion and RevDisturba can tell us if he accepts it.

"That which cannot be created through 'undirected' evolution."

That is not Dembski's definition of specified complexity. That is a claim that Dembski makes about specified complexity. If he defined the concept that way, it would be silly for him to do all the work with probability and information theory that he does in order to show that certain things exhibit the property in question. Dembski may be confused or corrupt but he is not stupid.

Here is a quotation from Dembski's book No Free Lunch that I found in an article at Talkorigins.com:

Something that is specified and complex is highly improbable with respect to all causal mechanisms currently known. Consequently, for a causal mechanism to come along and explain something that previously was regarded as specified and complex means that the item in question is in fact no longer specified and complex with respect to the newly found causal mechanism.

An exposition and critical evaluation of Dembski's concept can also be found here ("Dissecting Dembski's 'Complex Specified Information'" by Thomas D. Schneider).

Edited to add:
Now that I re-read what I quoted, I see that it doesn't explain what specified complexity is either. I don't know what it is, and I have not yet been sufficiently curious to do the reading necessary to find out.
 
Last edited:
Since it is William Dembski's neologism, I suppose we should use his defintion and RevDisturba can tell us if he accepts it.

"That which cannot be created through 'undirected' evolution."

Whether or not such a thing exists in organisms is yet another excercise in trying to prove a negative. To prove it "could not exist" requires knowing every single evolutionary possibility. Dembski has already been proved wrong on several of his claims of things that possessed "Specified Complexity", and he has no "right" ones so far. (i.e. they have not been proved to be impossible under evolution.)

So based on this, it seems apparent that Dembski has defined a "unicorn". A hypothetical construct for which there is a perfectly good definition, but no evidence that it exists in reality.

So, what...he just makes flat statements ("That flagellum couldn't exist without directed evolution," "That eye couldn't exist without directed evolution") without any evidence or authority to back them up? And expects people to say, "Whoa, yeah, you're right"
 
Since it is William Dembski's neologism, I suppose we should use his defintion and RevDisturba can tell us if he accepts it.

"That which cannot be created through 'undirected' evolution."
I thought it was a specific number based on a particular calculation?

As I understand it this calculation is yet to be done - so maybe any discussion on specified complexity should be postponed until we see the results of this calculation.
 
So, what...he just makes flat statements ("That flagellum couldn't exist without directed evolution," "That eye couldn't exist without directed evolution") without any evidence or authority to back them up? And expects people to say, "Whoa, yeah, you're right"
No, he claims that he will able to do a calculation (one day soon we hope) based on the probability of the e-coli flagellum just happening at random and using a plain English language sentence as the pattern and demonstrating that the e-coli got it's flagellum by means of some intelligent agent

And expects people to say, "Whoa, yeah, you're right"
 
Last edited:
Hmm; it looks as though my posts are invisible (since people are replying to Tricky's post and disregarding my correction to it and the further information that I supplied); but I'll try again anyway. Here is a passage from the article at Talk Origins (Richard Wein, "Not a Free Lunch But a Box of Chocolates: A critique of William Dembski's book No Free Lunch," section 6.2), minus the links and formatting:

Dembski devises his own measure of how complex a phenomenon's configuration is, and calls it specified information (which I'll abbreviate to SI). He calculates this measure by choosing a specification (as described in 3.1 above) and then calculating the probability of an outcome matching that specification as if the phenomenon was generated by a process having a uniform probability distribution. A uniform probability distribution is one in which all possible outcomes (i.e. configurations) have the same probability, and Dembski calculates the SI on this basis even if the phenomenon in question is known not to have been generated by such a process. (This will be considered more carefully in the next section.) The probability calculated in this way is then converted into "information" by applying the function I(R) = -log2P(R), i.e. the information is the negation of the logarithm (base 2) of the probability, and he refers to the resulting measure as a number of bits.

If the SI of a phenomenon exceeds a universal complexity bound of 500 bits, then Dembski says that the phenomenon exhibits complex specified information (or CSI).32 The universal complexity bound is obtained directly from Dembski's universal probability bound of 10-150, since -log2(10-150) is approximately 500. Dembski also refers to CSI as specified complexity, using the two terms interchangeably. As noted above, this meaning of specified complexity is different from the one we encountered earlier. I'll call it uniform-probability specified complexity. To be clear: eliminative specified complexity is an inferred attribute of an event, indicating that we believe the event was highly improbable with respect to all known causal mechanisms; uniform-probability specified complexity (or CSI) is an observed attribute of a phenomenon, indicating that the phenomenon has a "complex" configuration, without regard to how it came into existence. We will see that Dembski's notion of "complexity" is very different from our normal understanding of the word.
For my part, I'm not inclined to try to figure out what all that means, but if any of you want to know what Dembski means by specified complexity or complex specified information, I would advise doing some reading at least in materials like this rather than trying to figure it out by speculation.
 
For my part, I'm not inclined to try to figure out what all that means, but if any of you want to know what Dembski means by specified complexity or complex specified information, I would advise doing some reading at least in materials like this rather than trying to figure it out by speculation.
Actually the Wikipedia page Tricky cited explains it pretty well and gives the mathematical definition of specified complexity as well as discussing the proposed implementation of this definition that I referred to before

(My posts are apparently invisible too)
 
Last edited:
One of the long-standing claims of Creationism / Creation Science / Intelligent Design is that evolutionary processes cannot produce new information, but only reshuffle existing information or (worse) lose it.

Unfortunately for the cdesign proponentsists, this is not only untrue in theory for all of the standard definitions of information, but provably false in practice.

So Dembski came up with the idea of Specified Information, which is the type of information that can't be increased by evolutionary processes. Specified Complexity is the amount of Specified Information in a system. If a system has a high Specified Complexity, that means it was designed and could not have been formed by natural processes.

Yes, that's entirely circular. No, Dembski has never produced a mathematically sound definition of either Specified Information or Specified Complexity. Yes, this means the entire argument is worthless. No, no-one is much surprised.
 
Actually the Wikipedia page Tricky cited explains it pretty well and gives the mathematical definition of specified complexity as well as discussing the proposed implementation of this definition that I referred to before

(My posts are apparently invisible too)
Admittedly, I just looked for the most succinct definition I could find with the "definition" section of that Wiki page. My apologies to Kritkos. I didn't want to get into the mathematical ones. Like many, my eyes glaze over when looking at such stuff. Besides, it all boils down to the fact that Dembski sets the probabilities for these things. There is no way to test his defined probabilities, i.e. to say that "these are the only ways this could have occurred" because he would have to know every possible way it could occur. In essence, it is an argument from personal incredulity with a bunch of made-up probabilities thrown in to make it look scientific.
 
Yes, that's entirely circular. No, Dembski has never produced a mathematically sound definition of either Specified Information or Specified Complexity. Yes, this means the entire argument is worthless. No, no-one is much surprised.
...but at least he adds up a lot of book sales. That's the most important kind of math.:D
 
Well I suppose it is mathematically sound in that you could plug some numbers in and you would get some numbers out.

Coming up with these numbers is another matter entirely.

I notice that one of those numbers is "the number of other patterns that may have Kolmogorov complexity no larger than that of T".

Hmmm.... Kolmogorov Complexity is undecidable as far as I remember. So wouldn't that also make Specified Complexity undecidable? Or has Wiki got this wrong?
 
Yes, that's entirely circular. No, Dembski has never produced a mathematically sound definition of either Specified Information or Specified Complexity. Yes, this means the entire argument is worthless. No, no-one is much surprised.

Lol. It is not impossible that one day I shall undertake try to figure out Dembski's sophistries for myself, but until then, I am content with summaries like yours. :p

Besides, it all boils down to the fact that Dembski sets the probabilities for these things. There is no way to test his defined probabilities, i.e. to say that "these are the only ways this could have occurred" because he would have to know every possible way it could occur. In essence, it is an argument from personal incredulity with a bunch of made-up probabilities thrown in to make it look scientific.

Shades of the "fine-tuned universe"!
 
Last edited:
I notice that one of those numbers is "the number of other patterns that may have Kolmogorov complexity no larger than that of T".

Hmmm.... Kolmogorov Complexity is undecidable as far as I remember. So wouldn't that also make Specified Complexity undecidable? Or has Wiki got this wrong?
You can, in theory, quantify Kolmogorov Complexity of any given string S by brute force, i.e. trying all shorter strings in order to find possible representations of S.

Therefore, all Dembski needs to do, is run a couple Universes for a couple billion years and watch what could/could not develop. Since running multiple Universes for billions of years is a rather resource intensive endeavour, this might explain why we haven't heard of him for a while - and he actually still may come up with something ... later.

It has been my point for quite some time already, that who argues with ID proponents along the lines of "X is certainly more complex than Y" already engages in wrestling with a pig, because either side necessarily must have pulled these figures out of thin air.

Then, one could always redefine "complexity" to mean something else entirely. I predict that this is what will happen, eventually.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom