Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

Certainly. However, the fact that a phrase has been misused does not mean it is incorrect. The fact that a phrase has sometimes been employed deceptively doesn't mean that every use of it is deceptive.

One of the biggest mistakes we make when debating creationists and/or ID proponents is to assume that all the arguments are alike. They aren't, and it serves no purpose to argue against an argument that no one is actually making at the time.

I'm in complete agreement.
 
The title of my post rebuts your statement. The dean of ID who coined the term “specified complexity”. That is an term of ID. If the third alternative of “specified complexity” is not present, it would not be ID.
Sorry, RevD; specified complexity has never been properly defined:

Wikipedia said:
The concept of specified complexity is widely regarded as mathematically unsound and has not been the basis for further independent work in information theory, complexity theory, or biology.

...

When Dembski's mathematical claims on specific complexity are interpreted to make them meaningful and conform to minimal standards of mathematical usage, they usually turn out to be false. Dembski often sidesteps these criticisms by responding that he is not "in the business of offering a strict mathematical proof for the inability of material mechanisms to generate specified complexity". Yet on page 150 of No Free Lunch he claims he can prove his thesis mathematically: "In this section I will present an in-principle mathematical argument for why natural causes are incapable of generating complex specified information." Others have pointed out that a crucial calculation on page 297 of No Free Lunch is off by a factor of approximately 1065.
I made fun of another poster's argument for a quantum-mechanical cause for consciousness when he was off by a factor of 1013. Dembski is off by a factor of 1065!

The former is equivalent to saying that the US GDP is "about a dollar".

The latter, though, is harder to provide a good analogy for. For example, if we said "The planet Earth consists of a single atom, probably iron or oxygen", we'd still have 15 orders of magnitude of wrongness to make up.

Abiogenesis is weak theory that comes from the ancient Spontaneous generation
Sorry, this complete baloney. Abiogenesis has nothing whatsoever to do with spontaneous generation.

ie living things from dead matter.
What, exactly, do you think is the difference between living things and dead matter?

It has been revived in recent years by reliance on the discredited miller experiment and other questionable research.
Sorry, no. The Miller-Urey experiment has, in recent years, been credited rather than discredited. Not only have the results been confirmed, but re-analysis shows that the original experiment was more successful than first thought.

First evolution etc all dovetail nicely into ID.
Sorry, this is meaningless. ID is no more than an attempt to claim exceptions to evolution. All specific exceptions claimed - the eye, the flagellum, the blood clotting cascade, cilia, the immune system - have been utterly demolished.

Secondly unless the third component/ alternative of “specified complexity” is not evident, it fails the test of ID.
Sorry, this too is meaningless. Specified complexity not being properly defined, it is not evident anywhere, in anything.

Again most of evolution and of science is retained by ID, so your concerns are effectively placated.
Sorry, again, no. This is complete nonsense.

ID is special pleading based on theological concerns. Nothing could be more poisonous to science. ID does not provide an alternative theory, only objections, all of which, in the specific, have been shown to be false.

Again abiogenesis is not much better than wishful thinking at this point, and as I have said, not just here but in other venues, ID relies on evolution and all of science to support its theories albeit with exceptions.
Sorry, still no. ID is not a theory. It makes no predictions. It is not testable. All it is, is a list of ad-hoc exceptions to evolution, all of which exceptions are false. A more dismal failure is hard to imagine.
 
A standard theory of ID.
ID is not a theory. It is not even the groundwork for a sound hypothesis. It's not even logically coherent speculation. It's special pleading, from beginning to end.

No, ID as I have said many, many, many times is nearly identical to evolution
And where it is different, it has been demonstrated to be wrong.

but this thread is about specified complexity, nothing else.
Then it's likely to be quite short, because specified complexity is not even properly defined.
 
What? How do you account for the universe not being 'smooth'?

I hadn't noticed this earlier.

Why should it be "smooth"? What is less probable about lumps?

Quantum mechanical phenomena are, in many cases, probabilistic. While these things operate on the subatomic level, you might expect them not to affect the lumpiness of the universe, which depends on such things as the distribution of galaxy clusters. However, there was a time when the universe fit into the space of an atom, so a quantum mechanical fluctuation (i.e. a random event) would make it very slightly nonunimform in distribution.

Expand that universe by about a trillion trillion times, and suddenly there are vast amounts of empty space, i.e. lumps.
 
Good posting too bad its not like that when I am here.

I know its never all one sided but anyone can look at the posts and figure it out for themselves what happened. I just don't (can't is a more accurate word) tolerate the (very) few jerks that are here with an ax to grind against anything Christian.
Affirming the consequent.

That insults (which I regard as unnecessary) were against Intelligent Design. Not "anything Christian". Specifically, very specifically, against Intelligent Design. And with good reason, since Intelligent Design is a deliberate, planned assault by religion on science education and science in general.

Don't believe me?

Believe the Discovery Institute.
 
Intelligent Design has to meet the means test described in the thread. No need to repeat it here.
Specified complexity does not have a mathematically sound definition, and cannot be applied as a test.

Your posts if any will be answered after DDTs are. Nonsense is such a not nice word.
It's a perfectly cromulent word. If you don't want your posts described thus, don't post nonsense.

No comment needed.
Actually, this is exactly where you need to comment; the sentient puddle goes straight to the heart of all your arguments.

By the way, how are we to empirically tell the difference between Specified Complexity and non-specified complexity ?

How do you know that the Specified form can not possibly be the product of a natural evolutionary process?

It can be.
Well, specified complexity isn't much good as a test, then, is it?

Until the flamable comments cease I will not answer any more replies. My thread stands on its own merits until I decide to reply. Thanks to all the people that had the moral and ethical standards to reply in a civil manner.
I think you mean "collapses in a sobbing heap on its own merits".
 
Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

I'm actually more interested in the Specified Complexity of the human mind. Of how can some human minds bias themselves to believe irrational things, to an extent that they will make sure they reject any possible well explained argument of why their belief is irrational and incoherent and how they will, at all costs, maintain their delusional construct. I find that one truly fascinating. Maybe one day we will manage to fully understand how and why this happens and maybe find a way to work through it in a more successful way.
 
Last edited:
The same one that designed you.:D
Evasion noted. The theory of evolution by natural selection explains how such a creature can evolve. "Intelligent Design", with its implied designer, does not explain why this designer would produce something so horrific.
 
Evasion noted. The theory of evolution by natural selection explains how such a creature can evolve. "Intelligent Design", with its implied designer, does not explain why this designer would produce something so horrific.


That is only a problem if the designer prefers human beings to worms.

If the designer prefers worms...

;)
 
ID is special pleading based on theological concerns. Nothing could be more poisonous to science. ID does not provide an alternative theory, only objections, all of which, in the specific, have been shown to be false.

Quoted for emphasis - this is a really nice, short, elegant summary of ID.
 
In my personal search for truth (God)

Right there, you have just revealed your bias. You aren't looking for the truth. You are looking for stuff that supports your belief in a god.

has led me through two decades of (mild) adventure and travel, most of it spiritual some of it via a jet plane on a flight plan vs. an spirit on an astral plane.

Uhhh...

I agree with much of established ID.

Then my opinion of you has just dropped.

We sorely need a standard theory.

We have one. It's called "evolution." Maybe you should read up on it.

Nevertheless I will attempt to explain my beliefs and why I think ID is a credible idea.

Oh, this should be good. :rolleyes:

How can an infinitesimally improbable event such as a finely-tuned Universe could warrant belief in a God and how about other incomprehensibly improbable events? We can say that in addition to high improbability events and conformity to an independently given pattern should also exist (to lend credence to ID). When these two rudiments/situations are present, we have what ID proponents call “specified complexity” (SC). What is SC you say ? Lets use the example of a poker game. All deals of the cards is equally and highly improbable. Nevertheless if a guy across from you gets a royal flush every time you can bet this is not the result of chance but of design !

In the labors of Intelligent Design theorists we find that none of them appeals to the simple high improbability of an event or thing as a basis for a design inference (conclusions). Our own existence, for example has to do with the exceedingly improbable union of one specific sperm and a one in specific egg. Nevertheless, ID proponents wouldn’t say conception was intelligently designed.

A reader writing in to Dr William Craig (a Christian, ID apologist) used this example: Imagine a likely Universe that is a great deal larger than our own, in which there are only two small space asteroids in existence, but they are located on different ‘edges’ of the Universe. The likelihood of these two small rocks colliding is dreadfully improbable, but if it did theoretically happen, would that warrant a supernatural explanation?

If the two rocks collided, you would deduce it was neither design nor chance as the best explanation. We should look to the third alternative ie physical necessity. Because gravitation acts over infinite distances, it is in fact, unavoidable that those two masses will eventually collide. However the thing that would suggest design would be if the rocks were to smash into pieces which then came together to spell “Welcome to the Milky Way.”

To detect design look for high improbability conjoined with an independently given pattern. Thats all folks...

With the disinformation on the web you could use this criteria to determine if a claim meets ID criteria, such that is. I hope that this clears up a bit of the mystery of ID.

; {>

:drool:

*sighs*

I must say, RevD, that that is the biggest bunch of claptrap I have ever heard spouted by someone who actually believed what they were saying.
Please, read the sentient puddle story that has been posted above. Then do as Pixy and so many others have suggested: prove that this universe is so very improbable. While you're at it, show some specific examples of creator-imposed patterns that can be verified as creator-imposed patterns. And then address the question "who designed the designer?"
 
ID is special pleading based on theological concerns. Nothing could be more poisonous to science. ID does not provide an alternative theory, only objections, all of which, in the specific, have been shown to be false.
Quoted for emphasis - this is a really nice, short, elegant summary of ID.
Agreed. The crack in my wall of belief against evolution was that ID only offered objections. It didn't explain anything or address the facts at all except to say that it was the result of magical powers by an unknown entity.
 
...and anyone who believes that complexity necessitates an intelligent designer is an idiot.

But they're inconsistent on whether complexity is a hallmark of design, or non-complexity is.

Stephen Meyer and Michael Behe seem to think that complexity indicates that it must have been designed.

On the other hand, Bill Dembski says that non-complexity, along with improbability, is how to recognize design. In case this is confusing to you, think of his example of being dealt royal flush poker hands. These hands are significant not only because they're improbable, but also largely because they're low-information content; they have low complexity. Similarly, Dembski uses the example of how SETI is not looking for complex radio signals as indicating alien intelligence, but they're looking for simple signals.

I agree more with Dembski than with the other two. Take the example of a ping-pong ball and a rock of the same size. The rock is way more complex, the ping-pong ball is very simple. But that simplicity is a key to our figuring that it's not natural.

I just wish the ID people would get together and decide which it is, before trying to foist it upon public school students.
 
Numbers! Where are the numbers?!

In their absence, can I offer

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giant's_Causeway

The Giants Causeway in Ireland. It's a roadway of regular hexagonal pillars leading out to sea. They're tessallated in a remarkably tight and cohesive way. Such a complex structure must be the result of an intelligent designer surely? The probability of it happening by chance is miniscule.
The truth is, of course, that it is a perfectly natural phenomena, just a very complex and unusual one.

In my opinion any grown man that believes in the tooth fairy is an idiot, anyone who believes that there is actually a platform 9 3\4 at Kings Cross station is an idiot and anyone who believes that complexity necessitates an intelligent designer is an idiot.

But...but...but...I thought that same formation down around the Caribbean was proof that that's where Atlantis was!
 
But they're inconsistent on whether complexity is a hallmark of design, or non-complexity is.

Stephen Meyer and Michael Behe seem to think that complexity indicates that it must have been designed.

On the other hand, Bill Dembski says that non-complexity, along with improbability, is how to recognize design. In case this is confusing to you, think of his example of being dealt royal flush poker hands. These hands are significant not only because they're improbable, but also largely because they're low-information content; they have low complexity. Similarly, Dembski uses the example of how SETI is not looking for complex radio signals as indicating alien intelligence, but they're looking for simple signals.

I agree more with Dembski than with the other two. Take the example of a ping-pong ball and a rock of the same size. The rock is way more complex, the ping-pong ball is very simple. But that simplicity is a key to our figuring that it's not natural.

I just wish the ID people would get together and decide which it is, before trying to foist it upon public school students.


You're right, I am confused! Why would low complexity but high improbability necesitate a designer? My friend Brad got 2 royal flushes in one game of poker does that mean he's god? Google tells me that the odds of a royal flush are 1 in 2,598,960, but these simple events DO happen, and without design (he's not a cheat).

Also, a table tennis ball may look simple, but it's actually very complex. It's not the fact that it's a simple sphere that gives us the key to it's being designed, but the fact that it's a light, hollow, almost perfect sphere with a carefully calculated degree of roughness on it's surface to impart the right amount of spin. That's less of a disagreement with your argument, than with your example, sorry! :)
 
I've split a number of posts off to Abandon All Hope for bickering, general incivility and off-topic discussions. While group labels are allowed on the boards, use of them to make insults to members is not, for example, you can't say "You are a member of Group X and all members of Group X are idiots," That kind of sophistry is apparent.

So get back to being civil and perhaps we will leave this thread open.
Thank you.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom