Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

Abiogenesis is weak theory that comes from the ancient Spontaneous generation, ie living things from dead matter. It has been revived in recent years by reliance on the discredited miller experiment and other questionable research.
Repeat after me, "asserting something doesn't make it true".

First evolution etc all dovetail nicely into ID.
  • ID is not parsimonious.
  • ID posits unknown forces and entities.
  • ID makes no falsifiable predictions.
  • ID has no explanatory power (other than to say it's complex therefore god did it).
Again most of evolution and of science is retained by ID, so your concerns are effectively placated .
See above.

Again Diogenes's is not much better than wishful thinking at this point...
  • Abiogenesis does not posit unknown forces and entities.
  • Abiogenesis makes falsifiable predictions (many which are being explored as we speak and experimental data confirms them to date).
  • Abiogenesis has explanatory power.
 
Quote:
We sorely need a standard theory.
We have one. It's the Theory of Evolution. But you are going to go to all sorts of places that have nothing to do with ID or evolution. Right? Please don't disappoint us!

A standard theory of ID.

But you are going to go to all sorts of places

No, ID as I have said many, many, many times is nearly identical to evolution, but this thread is about specified complexity, nothing else. If we go off on every tangent possible the only thing that happens is a railroaded thread. I will not respond to off topic or unfriendly replies as per this sites TOS.

; {>
 
Good plan. Can you give us an example of "high improbability" that meets with "an independently given pattern". Of course, I'm talking about in natural phenomena, not royal flushes or mousetraps, which we know are designed.

Can you give us an example of something that most of us on JREF thinks developed by without direction, simply under the influence of natural law and random chance, but which has a very high improbability and an independently given pattern?

The universe being lumpy.

; {>
 
My favorite Youtube videos that detail the facts about abiogenesis:





Here's a hint: The truth is that the science underpinning abiogenesis is far greater than ID proponents would have you believe.
 
The universe being lumpy.
Elegant explanation found in M-Theory and no unkown entitites or forces are needed to as an explanation (a magic man did it). On the contrary, M-Theory is based on a mechanistic hypothesis and not simply speculation and insertion of unkown forces. IOW: It's parsimonious.
 
I don't think that there's a distinct difference between design and chance anyway. If I throw an axe at the wall, and it leaves a dent, did I design the dent? If I spend ten years throwing axes at walls and learn how to produce any type of dent I want, do I design dents? What about damage done to the axe? Do I design that?

Confusion arises from trying to use vague words at the same time as logic.

Intelligent Design has to meet the means test described in the thread. No need to repeat it here.

; {>
 
I could fill a page with spelling mistakes of others.

Could you point out where in a previous post I wrote the word "spelling"? I presume you're alluding to my using of "cdesign proponentsists", and then you're either naive or evading the issue. In case of the former, I advise you to read up on the issue.

Furthermore, you're not answering to the rest I wrote. I expect you're going to do that?

Lastly, I want to advise you that deliberately misquoting someone is reportable.
 
The title of my post rebuts your statement. The dean of ID who coined the term “specified complexity”. That is an term of ID. If the third alternative of “specified complexity” is not present, it would not be ID.
Then, apparently, there are four alternatives:

1. Intelligent Design w/o Specified Complexity
2. Intelligent Design with Specified Complexity (which is what you seem to favor)
3. Random Chance
4. Natural Algorithms, such as Natural Selection, and Catalytic Processes

Science tends to work the most on #4, because it presents the best opportunity for developing empirical models of life, and its formation.



Abiogenesis is weak theory that comes from the ancient Spontaneous generation, ie living things from dead matter.
Modern abiogenesis concepts and theories are backed by empirical evidence.

The early Urey-Miller-type of experiments have shown us how organic compounds can form in various conditions that could exist on Earth. Their findings have not been discredited, and can still be replicated. In fact, there has been a wide variety of other, similar experiments showing us a variety of different ways different compounds could emerge.

Today we have observations about how naturally-occurring PNA molecules could have lead to RNA molecules: http://www.pnas.org/content/97/8/3868

And, how RNA could have been first catalyzed into DNA in certain viruses:
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/summary/312/5775/870

Etc.
( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis ,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RNA_world_hypothesis )

Which of these findings is "questionable"?

It looks like, at the very least, abiogenesis scientists are doing actual scientific research, and making new findings as they do so. I do not see evidence of I.D. doing the same.

Again abiogenesis is not much better than wishful thinking at this point,
Which one of those scientific findings is only "wishful thinking"?

First evolution etc all dovetail nicely into ID.
I am glad you think so. But, what, exactly, does I.D. add to our understanding of biology?

Secondly unless the third component/ alternative of “specified complexity” is not evident, it fails the test of ID.
Can you define what "specified complexity" is? (empirically?) What exactly it prevents it from being the result of an evolutionary process?


and as I have said, not just here but in other venues, ID relies on evolution and all of science to support its theories albeit with exceptions.
Give us some good examples of those exceptions, if you could, please.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom