Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

To detect design look for high improbability conjoined with an independently given pattern. Thats all folks...

On those rare occasions when we get a genuine ID proponent on these boards, we just can't resist, can we? 60 responses in just a few hours, and not yet one from the person who made the OP.

Just imagine when he gets back to the thread to see how it's going.

He never meant to "get back to the thread". He just preached once again to save our sorry souls. The OP isn't an invitation to debate. IMHO
 
He never meant to "get back to the thread". He just preached once again to save our sorry souls. The OP isn't an invitation to debate. IMHO
RevD has more staying power than most. He came back to the thread on the "Certainty of God's Existence" repeatedly, despited getting demolished every time. Give him a chance.
 
In non biological events but not in natural selection. To claim otherwise is wrong.
Nonsense.

Changes in variables that drive natural selection are the result of chance.

I really don't know why you are having this obsession but you are wrong. Clearly.
 
I think that the whole argument of chance/not chance is based on differing concepts of determinism in the universe... for instance, if I roll two dice, the resulting number is not technically "chance". It's based on a whole list of variables -- the side the dice were facing before being thrown, how many times they rolled and how they rolled, air pressure, wind, etc. None of this is "chance", yet we recognize it as "chance" mostly as a result of our own ignorance and the changing of the variables in a way that we ourselves are not capable of understanding without a great deal of forethought and controls.

Thus, the "chance" of evolution is no different than the "chance" of rolling two dice and getting a certain result.
 
I think that the whole argument of chance/not chance is based on differing concepts of determinism in the universe... for instance, if I roll two dice, the resulting number is not technically "chance". It's based on a whole list of variables -- the side the dice were facing before being thrown, how many times they rolled and how they rolled, air pressure, wind, etc. None of this is "chance", yet we recognize it as "chance" mostly as a result of our own ignorance and the changing of the variables in a way that we ourselves are not capable of understanding without a great deal of forethought and controls.

Thus, the "chance" of evolution is no different than the "chance" of rolling two dice and getting a certain result.
Exactly. Claiming chance for evolution is an argument based on personal incredulity which is usually based on ignorance.
 
Exactly. Claiming chance for evolution is an argument based on personal incredulity which is usually based on ignorance.

The people claiming chance are thinking of "chance" in the same way as casting the dice, however. So it's not exactly helpful to tear into each other about it when it's mostly based on definition.
 
The role of chance in Evolution. (pdf)

Chance is one of the most misunderstood aspects of evolution. On one
hand you have those who want to dismiss evolution by claiming falsely that all its mechanisms are dependent entirely on chance and therefore they are totally undirected and could not possibly produce the complexity and organization we see in nature. The other group totally dismisses chance and views evolution as operating entirely to produce adaptations. Neither of these groups is correct.​

Evolution and Chance (talk origins)

Dawkins both accepts the role of chance in evolution through mutations and denies, as this FAQ does, that evolution thereby involves deep improbability. The 'quality' he speaks of is what gets selected by natural selection sorting processes.
(emphasis mine) A great read. I highly recommend it.

Pay particular attention to Gould and his differentiating "senses" of the word chance. You are fanatically hung up on the wrong sense.

We should not fear ID rhetoric that we dogmaticaly deny any use of the word "chance".
 
Last edited:
RevD has more staying power than most. He came back to the thread on the "Certainty of God's Existence" repeatedly, despited getting demolished every time. Give him a chance.

Yes, I know that. I'm just pointing out that this time, in my opinion, there was no call for debate.
 
Nonsense.

Changes in variables that drive natural selection are the result of chance.

I really don't know why you are having this obsession but you are wrong. Clearly.


I've been through this discussion about "chance" many times, and I'm amazed how much intense emotion it generates. For reasons I cannot fathom, people refuse to see the other side, and not only do they get pretty intense, they end up accusing each other of some very weird things.

First, a little bit of technical stuff. The words "random", "probabilistic", and "stochastic" are well defined terms with specific meanings, as are the phrases "random process" and "random variable". There is no doubt that evolution is a random process, and there is also no doubt that the outcome of an evolutionary process (i.e. which species emerge from an evolutionary process at any given time) is also random. As I said, I've been through this debate enough times that I'm not really willing to engage in it again. There's a right answer, and a wrong answer, and I know the right one.

When I hear the word "chance" or the phrase "by chance", I always equate it in my mine with randomness. Because I do so, I have absolutely no problem with anyone saying that evolution operates by chance, or that life arose by chance, or any of those other things that people say about "chance". It's not a word you will find in a probability textbook, like all those other words, but I always thought I knew what it meant.

What surprises me is the vehemence with which some people insist that it actually means something else. Not only that, some people will insist that somehow, saying life arose "by chance", puts the speaker in the camp of the ID proponents. I don't get that, but I've seen it often enough that I know that it's pointless to discuss it. It's as if that word has become "their word", and rather than stick with actually trying to understand what a speaker means, there is a knee jerk reaction to say that anyone who says "chance" is on "their side". I find it alternately irritating and amusing, but I know it will happen, and the people who are opposed to that word will absolutely insist that anyone who disagrees with them is horribly wrong, has probably been suckered by the ID proponents, and may even be an ID proponent sneaking about trying to infiltrate JREF.

I don't get what it is about that word that gets people so emotional, but it does. As for me, I'm going to say that chance=random, and I'm going to stick by the definitions I learned in graduate school for that word and and various related words. And if revdisturba is willing to debate the subject with me, I will have no problem at all saying that life and/or human beings arose by chance.
 
I don't get what it is about that word that gets people so emotional, but it does. As for me, I'm going to say that chance=random, and I'm going to stick by the definitions I learned in graduate school for that word and and various related words. And if revdisturba is willing to debate the subject with me, I will have no problem at all saying that life and/or human beings arose by chance.


I have a minor quibble with your conclusion in that it seems to assume that mutation and natural selection are the only factors at work in the evolution of human beings. I would suggest that sexual selection has also left its mark on our species, and that is not a random influence.
 
First, a little bit of technical stuff. The words "random", "probabilistic", and "stochastic" are well defined terms with specific meanings, as are the phrases "random process" and "random variable". There is no doubt that evolution is a random process, and there is also no doubt that the outcome of an evolutionary process (i.e. which species emerge from an evolutionary process at any given time) is also random. As I said, I've been through this debate enough times that I'm not really willing to engage in it again. There's a right answer, and a wrong answer, and I know the right one.
Thank you, agreed.

I don't actually have a problem with a debate about chance so long as those involved understand the limits of such a discussion and the logical consistency one would need to take in light of one's position.

If ~enigma~ wanted to have a discussion I think it fair to confront what is meant by "random" and "chance". I think the article referenced at Talk Origins a good start. I also think that an understanding of chaos theory/butterfly effect (sensitive dependence on initial conditions) could be helpful.

BTW: If anyone wants to assert that chance plays no role (and I accept that one could make such an argument) one would have to throw out the word "chance" as meaningless in any context.

The problem I have with ~enigma~ is his dogmatic instances that the word cannot by any means be used in conjunction with evolution. However, if you accept that a meteor striking the earth was a "chance" event then there is no argument. Logic has consequences.
 
I have a minor quibble with your conclusion in that it seems to assume that mutation and natural selection are the only factors at work in the evolution of human beings. I would suggest that sexual selection has also left its mark on our species, and that is not a random influence.
Also genetic drift but I think most would charactherize that more as random. Of course it depends on one's initial premises including whether or not "chance" has any actual meaning.

I'd ask ~enigma~ if he accepts the concept of chance but he has me on ignore.
 
Saying life arose by chance and not saying the opposite is chance also is very dishonest, wouldn't you agree?

I don't understand the question. I don't know what you mean by "not saying the opposite".

Could you rephrase the question?
 
I don't understand the question. I don't know what you mean by "not saying the opposite".

Could you rephrase the question?
If life arose by chance what were any of the other conditions of no life. Each one was just as improbable wasn't it?
 
If life arose by chance what were any of the other conditions of no life.
Are we discussing evolution or abiogenesis?

Each one was just as improbable wasn't it?
What does improbability have to do with the discussion of chance in this context?

Given that initial conditions of a complex system are too great and the interdependancy of all of the variables not known and unlikely to be known then a chance event is one where the probability or improbability is one that can't be sufficently determined beyond a certain marging of error.

If we were struck by a meteor in the near future then that would be a chance event.
 
Last edited:
That is exactly right! Most I.D. proponents would like people to think that there is no third alternative: It must be either designed or random chance.

The title of my post rebuts your statement. The dean of ID who coined the term “specified complexity”. That is an term of ID. If the third alternative of “specified complexity” is not present, it would not be ID.

But, the very nature of the sciences of abiogenesis,

Abiogenesis is weak theory that comes from the ancient Spontaneous generation, ie living things from dead matter. It has been revived in recent years by reliance on the discredited miller experiment and other questionable research.

[quote evolution, and cosmology, etc. belie that false dichonomy: These are teams of scientists devoted to the empirical, physical behavior of things. It would not be very helpful to anyone if all they did was declare "Oh, well that's just all random chance.", would it? [/quote]

First evolution etc all dovetail nicely into ID. Secondly unless the third component/ alternative of “specified complexity” is not evident, it fails the test of ID.

ETA: And, of course, it wouldn't be helpful to anyone if the scientists declared "Oh, well it was all designed that way.", either.

Again most of evolution and of science is retained by ID, so your concerns are effectively placated .

What is more helpful is understand how and why things work the way they do, as precisely as possible. And, sciences such as evolution and abiogenesis are able to do that for biological life forms.

Again abiogenesis is not much better than wishful thinking at this point, and as I have said, not just here but in other venues, ID relies on evolution and all of science to support its theories albeit with exceptions.

; {>
 
There is also the "inconceivable" angle. If I can't conceive of a natural explanation, then it must be the handiwork of my choice of magical sky daddy. This is the entirety of the argument proffered by the OP.

Wrong conclusion. See reply to wowbagger. However I agree and do not promote a magical sky daddy. I am not familiar with that religion.


: {>
 
Also genetic drift but I think most would charactherize that more as random. Of course it depends on one's initial premises including whether or not "chance" has any actual meaning.

I'd ask ~enigma~ if he accepts the concept of chance but he has me on ignore.
.
Let's find out. :)
 
I'm not sure you're quite correct about what a pattern is, and how what we think of as patterns can emerge without a plan.

Can you point to the rocks which have split apart to spell "Welcome to the Milky Way?" I have not yet seen them.

That was an Allegory.

; }>
 
RevDisturba said:
Abiogenesis is weak theory that comes from the ancient Spontaneous generation, ie living things from dead matter. It has been revived in recent years by reliance on the discredited miller experiment and other questionable research.

Explain how the Miller-Urey experiment was discredited, and why abiogenesis could not have occurred.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom