Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

You're right, I am confused! Why would low complexity but high improbability necesitate a designer? My friend Brad got 2 royal flushes in one game of poker does that mean he's god? Google tells me that the odds of a royal flush are 1 in 2,598,960, but these simple events DO happen, and without design (he's not a cheat).
We would live in a very strange world if such events didn't happen. --John Allen Paulos.
 
Sorry, no. The Miller-Urey experiment has, in recent years, been credited rather than discredited. Not only have the results been confirmed, but re-analysis shows that the original experiment was more successful than first thought.
I didn't know that. Thanks!

wiki said:
In 2008[6], a re-analysis of Miller's archived solutions from the original experiments showed 22 amino acids rather than 5 were actually created in one of the apparatus used.[7]
 
I agree more with Dembski than with the other two. Take the example of a ping-pong ball and a rock of the same size. The rock is way more complex, the ping-pong ball is very simple.
How does one determine that (maths and all?)

What mathematical model did you use to calculate the complexity of a rock (in order to be able to compare it to the complexity of a ping-pong ball?)

"It surely looks complicated" certainly cannot be it.
 
How does one determine that (maths and all?)

What mathematical model did you use to calculate the complexity of a rock (in order to be able to compare it to the complexity of a ping-pong ball?)

"It surely looks complicated" certainly cannot be it.
.
A ping-pong ball is much more complex, it must be constructed from an artificial material using complex equipment.
Rocks are just cooled lava, or compressed sand.
 
You're right, I am confused! Why would low complexity but high improbability necesitate a designer?

It is a case of using a specific definition of "complexity". The designed objects typically have a simpler description than natural objects.

Consider a deck of cards that is in the order that it came from the factory. I want you to recreate the arrangement of the deck of cards. I can tell you to put the hears, spades, clubs, and diamonds together, and arrange each suit as 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,J,Q,K,A.

Now, shuffle the same deck of cards. I want you to recreate the new arrangement of cards exactly. I have to tell you, Jack of spades, then 2 of diamonds, then 3 of diamonds, etc..... It takes a more complex desciption for you to recreate the "designed" arrangement (sorted) than the "natural" arrangement. We can say that the sorted arrangement is simpler, because it takes less information to describe.

Dembski's specialty is information theory, and he doesn't suck at it, but he makes a couple of really huge errors in some of his papers. Not surprisingly, those huge errors are the ones that are used to "demonstrate" the need for a designer.
 
.
A ping-pong ball is much more complex, it must be constructed from an artificial material using complex equipment.
Rocks are just cooled lava, or compressed sand.

Carrying on the thought from my last post, I can describe a ping pong ball by saying it is a hollow sphere of plastic (or something. What are those things made of anyway?) approximately one millimeter thick.

To describe a rock, I have to describe an irregular shape, and a composition that varies somewhat in different portions of the rock.

In that sense, the rock is more complex.
 
RevD has more staying power than most. He came back to the thread on the "Certainty of God's Existence" repeatedly, despited getting demolished every time. Give him a chance.

He never knows when he's demolished though,does he?
 
What mathematical model did you use to calculate the complexity of a rock (in order to be able to compare it to the complexity of a ping-pong ball?)

"It surely looks complicated" certainly cannot be it.

Well, I thought it was patently obvious that a rock, with its irregular shape and myriad minerals, is more complex than a regular shape of a very small number of chemicals. The complexity here gets down to what it takes to describe each, and the ping-pong ball can be accurately described in a very short amount of space.


A ping-pong ball is much more complex, it must be constructed from an artificial material using complex equipment.
Rocks are just cooled lava, or compressed sand.
The complexity of an object doesn't depend on how it was created, the complexity is inherent in the object itself. Doing it your way, the human brain is simple - just take a huge amount of energy and wait 13.7 billion years, and it formed by itself! But that's not the way to describe complexity.
 
.
A ping-pong ball is much more complex, it must be constructed from an artificial material using complex equipment.
Rocks are just cooled lava, or compressed sand.
But as far as complexity, one cannot prove either way.
What looks complicated is not necessarily complex.
 
Well, I thought it was patently obvious that a rock, with its irregular shape and myriad minerals, is more complex than a regular shape of a very small number of chemicals. The complexity here gets down to what it takes to describe each, and the ping-pong ball can be accurately described in a very short amount of space.
Prove that the rock cannot!
 
Carrying on the thought from my last post, I can describe a ping pong ball by saying it is a hollow sphere of plastic (or something. What are those things made of anyway?) approximately one millimeter thick.

To describe a rock, I have to describe an irregular shape, and a composition that varies somewhat in different portions of the rock.

In that sense, the rock is more complex.
.
It's the "what are those things made of anyway" and the rigamarole of making them that is what makes the ball more "complex" than the rock, which is a natural construction of random processes.
 
But as far as complexity, one cannot prove either way.
What looks complicated is not necessarily complex.

"Complex" is another one of those terms that has a very specific mathematical meaning, which does not always coincide with the common usage of the word in standard English. When using the term as defined in information theory, there is no doubt that the ping pong ball is less complex than the rock.

When using ordinary English, it's a different story. I would call a ping pong ball more complex than a rock when speaking colloquially.

As an aside, I'm going to put in a plug for the book that I read that made me finally "get" the information theoretic aspect of the second law of thermodynamics, along with the nature of mathematical complexity. It's called "The Recursive Universe", by William (?) Poundstone.
 
"Complex" is another one of those terms that has a very specific mathematical meaning, which does not always coincide with the common usage of the word in standard English. When using the term as defined in information theory, there is no doubt that the ping pong ball is less complex than the rock.
Especially in information theory, it has been shown that for non-trivial cases it is virtually impossible - by means other than brute force - to quantify complexity. Look up Kolmogorov Complexity and why the claim to be able to quantify the complexity of a rock in that context is necessarily false!
 
Last edited:
Especially in information theory, it has been shown that for non-trivial cases it is virtually impossible - by means other than brute force - to quantify complexity. Look up Kolmogorv Complexity and why the claim to be able to quantify the complexity of a rock in that context is necessarily false!

Actually, I stand corrected, at least partially I was focusing on a particular statement, trying to explain Dembski's assertion of simple objects being a hallmark of design, but I overused the term "complex" in that context. The overall topic of complexity is way too....er...complex....for me to understand, explain, and get it right. I'll quit while I'm at least not falling too far behind.

So, the ping pong ball is neither "more complex" nor "less complex" than the rock, even in information theory. Dembski was focusing on the fact that designed objects tend to have simpler descriptions than naturally occurring objects, and therefore were less complex, but only using one of the many possible definitions of that word, technical or otherwise.
 
So, the ping pong ball is neither "more complex" nor "less complex" than the rock, even in information theory.
Strictly speaking, for a given representation of the Universe inside a Turing Machine, it could very well be decided whether one is more complex than the other - in finite time. Just do not hold your breath ;-)

What all of this really means - and that seems to be the more interesting aspect - is that evolution could not possibly have equipped us mere mortals with a way to accurately quantify complexity, no matter how hard we might try. At the same time, our survival depends on our ability for pattern recognition.

I assert that this alone explains exactly 83.482% of all irrational beliefs that humans can hold!
 
To detect design look for high improbability conjoined with an independently given pattern. Thats all folks...
I used to have the impression that there was some intellectual sophistication to the idea of "specified complexity." But if your exposition is any guide, then I was wrong, and arguments for intelligent design rest on exactly the same fallacious method as the "Bible code," the prophecies of Nostradamus, and similar quackeries. That method is: look through some extremely large body of data for a combination that conforms to any of the innumerable patterns that are "independently given" in your mind, and when you find one, pronounce the conformity to be strong evidence that the data was produced by a being that had that very pattern in mind.

In fact, given that the body of data on the one hand and the store of patterns in your mind on the other hand are both extremely vast, and that no determinate criteria of pattern-conformity were specified in advance, the probability that you will find something that seems to you to match some previously given pattern in your mind will be quite high.
 
I assert that this alone explains exactly 83.482% of all irrational beliefs that humans can hold!
And, I assert that roughly 88.861149% of all statistics are just made up.

In fact, given that the body of data on the one hand and the store of patterns in your mind on the other hand are both extremely vast, and that no determinate criteria of pattern-conformity were specified in advance, the probability that you will find something that seems to you to match some previously given pattern in your mind will be quite high.
I think this is a more accurate assessment.

I also suspect some of this pattern matching might be something similar to a paredolia effect. Sometimes, they "swear" clear patterns are there, even when they are not.
 
Oh, my post has been moved! How am I going to get the Giant Font of condemnation now?? ok ok, you're right, I was out of order. I apologise.

Now that you've chewed the definition of complexity into a tasteless grey paste, how does an absence of it, however defined, coupled with a high improbability mean that an intelligent designer is required?

Can you give an example from nature? I’ve been trying to think of something simple but improbable, but all I can come up with is my brother...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom