Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

I also suspect some of this pattern matching might be something similar to a paredolia effect. Sometimes, they "swear" clear patterns are there, even when they are not.

Thanks for the term, though I found out that the spelling is "pareidolia" when I Googled it. A term that seems to me more germane (which I found through a link in the Wikipedia article "Pareidolia"), is "apophenia":
Apophenia is the experience of seeing patterns or connections in random or meaningless data. The term was coined in 1958 by Klaus Conrad, who defined it as the "unmotivated seeing of connections" accompanied by a "specific experience of an abnormal meaningfulness". . . .

In statistics, apophenia would be classed as a Type I error (false positive, false alarm, caused by an excess in sensitivity). Apophenia is often used as an explanation of paranormal and religious claims, and can also explain a belief in pseudoscience. . . .

Pareidolia is a type of apophenia involving the finding of images or sounds in random stimuli.
 
Thanks for the term, though I found out that the spelling is "pareidolia" when I Googled it.
Aarrgh! I should have known better. I got it on my list of favorite vocabulary words, too!

A term that seems to me more germane (which I found through a link in the Wikipedia article "Pareidolia"), is "apophenia":
That works.

A good question to ask ID proponents might be: If someone was to claim that Specified Complexity was nothing more than an apophenia effect, how can you demonstrate otherwise?
 
Carrying on the thought from my last post, I can describe a ping pong ball by saying it is a hollow sphere of plastic (or something. What are those things made of anyway?) approximately one millimeter thick.

To describe a rock, I have to describe an irregular shape, and a composition that varies somewhat in different portions of the rock.

In that sense, the rock is more complex.

That depends on what you mean by "describe a rock" -- and this is where the problem with Dembski's formulation comes in.

To describe a specific rock requires all that detail. To describe a generic rock, you don't need to describe the irregular shape or the way the composition varies -- if you took a specific rock, and then adjusted its shape somehow (perhaps with a file), it would probably remain "a rock." It takes tremendous skill and effort to take a rock and adjust its shape to something we would describe as "a statue of an eagle."
 
Especially in information theory, it has been shown that for non-trivial cases it is virtually impossible - by means other than brute force - to quantify complexity. Look up Kolmogorov Complexity and why the claim to be able to quantify the complexity of a rock in that context is necessarily false!

Actually, that's wrong. It's quite easy to quantify complexity. What do you think file compressors do? The problem is that you can't quantify Kolmogorov complexity with perfect accuracy. That would bother me a lot more if I could do anything else with perfect accuracy.

And that's one easy way to show that an object is "less complex" than another. Represent them both and run gzip on them.

The problem comes in when you are looking not at individual objects, but at object classes. The concept "brick" is much more complex than the concept "rock" because there's so much less variation in what constitutes a brick, and therefore higher degree of specification.
 
Can you give an example from nature? I’ve been trying to think of something simple but improbable, but all I can come up with is my brother...

A cubical soap bubble. Simple, but improbable.

Alternatively, a spherical crystal.

We can turn it around. A cubical crystal is in theory just as simple as a cubical soap bubble, but those aren't especially improbable. And ditto for a spherical soap bubble.
 
A cubical soap bubble. Simple, but improbable.

Alternatively, a spherical crystal.

We can turn it around. A cubical crystal is in theory just as simple as a cubical soap bubble, but those aren't especially improbable. And ditto for a spherical soap bubble.
Sorry but........



There is no free standing cubical soap bubble.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
That depends on what you mean by "describe a rock" -- and this is where the problem with Dembski's formulation comes in.

To describe a specific rock requires all that detail. To describe a generic rock, you don't need to describe the irregular shape...."

Yeah, I realized that after I wrote my response yesterday. That's about the time I decided that to give a really good response, I would have to dig out the reference books and brush up, and, there were probably people who could do it much better with fewer mistakes.

The real point of my initial comment is that Dembski wasn't making some bizarre, weird, point that was the exact opposite of what other ID proponents were saying. He was just using the terms in a very specific sense, which may have the opposite sense of our ordinary speech.
 
Well, at least for now, revdisturba seems to have abandoned the thread. I, for one, am disappointed.

There are certain questions I would like to ask a real, honest to goodness, ID proponent, and I had hoped for an opportunity to do so here.

Of course, it's a bit rough trying to do that in a place like JREF. If an ID proponent dares to actually post here, he's going to be set upon pretty fiercely. Even after the mods remove the nasty comments, there's going to be a lot of flack flying his way, and even the stuff that doesn't include personal attacks is going to be a bit harsh.

Revdisturba,
If you decide to come back to this thread, I for one would welcome your presence, out of curiousity of how you would defend your position. I, for one, would go out of my way to make sure that I didn't make any nasty comments, and try to subdue some of the others that would inevitably come up. For what it's worth, I'm not the most popular guy around here on the subject of ID. I'm on the record as saying ID is "wrong, but not stupid". You can imagine even that minor concession to ID doesn't exactly make a lot of JREF denizens happy.
 
Actually, that's wrong. It's quite easy to quantify complexity. What do you think file compressors do?
A compressor can establish an upper bound on complexity. It can, however, not provide a definite measure for it. Check your AIT!
 
He never knows when he's demolished though,does he?

In another thread he admitted his mistake in believing the deathbed conversion legend of Darwin. He also reversed his stance on apologizing to RandFan for a certain remark. This may be a case of the Rev not knowing he's been demolished, but 'never' is mistaken.

Perhaps we just haven't explained it in a way that makes sense to him. He is probably not familiar with many of the objections to ID and a large number of posts merely state them without going into much detail.

Maybe the Rev would do better in a moderated debate without having to address more than one person at a time.
 
You're right, I am confused! Why would low complexity but high improbability necesitate a designer? My friend Brad got 2 royal flushes in one game of poker does that mean he's god? Google tells me that the odds of a royal flush are 1 in 2,598,960, but these simple events DO happen, and without design (he's not a cheat).
snip.
This is the chance of a dealed RF for a given suit (e.g. RF in spades).
The actual odds depend on the game and in live poker on the number of players.
In video draw poker the odds for any RF are about 1 out of 40,000 (depending on pay table and playing strategy).
 
Last edited:
My friend Brad got 2 royal flushes in one game of poker does that mean he's god?

That's a good example, and I think highlights the best case that the ID proponents have.

In your example, no one would suggest that Brad is a god, but that he cheated; that the cards may have been placed that way intentionally by someone (possibly Brad, but naming the someone doesn't matter). At what point would you think the more reasonable conclusion is that someone purposefully did this? After three royal flushes in one game? Four?

Now I haven't "flushed" this out for myself, and obviously Dembski hasn't either. He's trying to calculate the odds, but is making some blunders for one thing. Also, in the poker example, we have as a given intelligent agents who are capable of cheating, so thinking they may have done it is already fairly reasonable. With a god, we don't know of its existence, that's the thing that some are trying to prove. So they have to get the probabilities right, even given the size of the universe and the weak anthropic principle.

I could see a scenario where someone did these calculations correctly, and subjected them to the scrutiny of other experts, and maybe that would suggest that our being here is best explained by purposeful intent. Maybe. Dembski is a long long long way from there though, and those guys are taking the very rudimentary concepts that they have of going down this path, and declaring that it's over, that a god is proved, and they want to teach this to public school kids. That's where they deserve to be fought.

I fully support Dembski continuing his quest, but he needs to publish the results in the proper journals, and they need to not make claims about being finished, when they have just barely started to define the concept of where they would like to go.
 
That's a good example, and I think highlights the best case that the ID proponents have.

In your example, no one would suggest that Brad is a god, but that he cheated; that the cards may have been placed that way intentionally by someone (possibly Brad, but naming the someone doesn't matter). At what point would you think the more reasonable conclusion is that someone purposefully did this? After three royal flushes in one game? Four?

If there were no wild cards, I would say that someone cheated. If it's seven card stud with deuces and one eyed jacks wild, then it's lucky.

Overall, excellent post, Curt.

ETA: The probability that 5 cards dealt at random will be a royal flush is 1 in 649740. If that happened twice in one night, I would say it was a "designed" event.
 
Last edited:
This is the chance of a dealed RF for a given suit (e.g. RF in spades).
The actual odds depend on the game and in live poker on the number of players.
In video draw poker the odds for any RF are about 1 out of 40,000 (depending on pay table and playing strategy).

Curse you Google!!!!!!
 
That's a good example, and I think highlights the best case that the ID proponents have.

In your example, no one would suggest that Brad is a god, but that he cheated; that the cards may have been placed that way intentionally by someone (possibly Brad, but naming the someone doesn't matter). At what point would you think the more reasonable conclusion is that someone purposefully did this? After three royal flushes in one game? Four?

That's very true. But for it to be a case for the ID proponents they'd have to define the actual odds of their particular "Royal Flush" and how many "games" are being played.

If the Royal Flush is: Life Begins and it's odds are 40,000 to 1 and the number of games are 10 then there is a god.

If the number of games is 100 billion then there is no god.

I'm pretty certain though that No-One knows *any* of these numbers?

That's why I always thought that the ID argument would always be about maximising the numbers. The most complex and least probable being the best candidate for proving ID. Where's the sense in making an argument for the least complex candidate?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom