Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

Or, to make a long story short:

It's like shooting an arrow at a blank wall, then drawing the target around where it happens to land.


Then saying: "Wow! Isn't it amazing I hit the target so accurately!"
Hmm...I used to shoot like that when I lived in Texas....
 
BTW, to those that think arguing that life was an extremely improbable event is a valid pursuit:

Wouldn't any other specific condition of "no life" be just as improbable?
 
Rev, to prove that this Universe is fine-tuned for life you have to show that no other set of fundamental constants could give rise to life.


Good luck with that.

Or indeed, that any other set of fundamental constants is possible.
 
Natural selection is chance? Care to explain cause that is wrong. If natural selection were chance, that is exactly what it would be called but it appears to be called something else.
.
Natural selection is the process by which organisms which can survive the environment they get born into, survive, and pass on their characteristics to the next generation.
An organism which is unsuited for the environment won't survive.
The environment can change overnight.
If the organism can cope with the change, it does. We have birds and crocodiles.
If it can't, it dies. We don't have dinosaurs. Birds and crocs co-existed with them.
There's no direction or purpose to what occurs, it's all chance.
 
.
Natural selection is the process by which organisms which can survive the environment they get born into, survive, and pass on their characteristics to the next generation.
An organism which is unsuited for the environment won't survive.
The environment can change overnight.
If the organism can cope with the change, it does. We have birds and crocodiles.
If it can't, it dies. We don't have dinosaurs. Birds and crocs co-existed with them.
There's no direction or purpose to what occurs, it's all chance.
Your post is correct but your conclusion is wrong. Chance would be my taking the entirety of chemical elements in your body, throwing them in the air and resulting in you. What you wrote above is entirely different and not chance.
 
"You know, the most amazing thing happened to me tonight. I was coming here, on the way to the lecture, and I came in through the parking lot. And you won't believe what happened. I saw a car with the license plate ARW 357. Can you imagine? Of all the millions of license plates in the state, what was the chance that I would see that particular one tonight? Amazing!" - Richard Feynman
 
The following thread didn't last terribly long, but I think it addresses some of the issues:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=144212

I would like to think that thread makes it easier for I.D. proponents to digest. But, I could be wrong.

Basically, it argues how abiogenesis is a "hunt" for increasing the probability of life emerging, based on what we know about physics, and more specifically, catalytic processes.

And, so far, this "hunt" has yielded some real elements of success. There are always new things to discover, and improvements to models to be made. But, I don't think the concept of "specified complexity", nor anything else in I.D. even comes close.
 
Last edited:
Your post is correct but your conclusion is wrong. Chance would be my taking the entirety of chemical elements in your body, throwing them in the air and resulting in you. What you wrote above is entirely different and not chance.
But it was chance that the environment change didn't adversely effect birds and crocks. It was chance that it did adversly effect the dinosaurs.
 
On those rare occasions when we get a genuine ID proponent on these boards, we just can't resist, can we? 60 responses in just a few hours, and not yet one from the person who made the OP.

Just imagine when he gets back to the thread to see how it's going.
 
Your post is correct but your conclusion is wrong. Chance would be my taking the entirety of chemical elements in your body, throwing them in the air and resulting in you. What you wrote above is entirely different and not chance.
.
No, you're spreading "chance" too widely.
My way is a lot like luck, which is preparation meeting opportunity.
The beasties mentioned which passed or failed the K-T event did so by chance.
 
.
No, you're spreading "chance" too widely.
My way is a lot like luck, which is preparation meeting opportunity.
The beasties mentioned which passed or failed the K-T event did so by chance.
RandFan is just stirring the pot. You, on the other hand, are redefining chance to fit what IDiots are claiming.
 
RandFan is just stirring the pot. You, on the other hand, are redefining chance to fit what IDiots are claiming.
.
Shurely, you're not serious.
Natural selection takes those which can survive the environment due to their constitution, which by -chance- enables them to survive, while discarding those who aren't adaptable and capable of handling a change.
The IDers shoehorn selection into a directed purpose, and direction for "progress" towards humanity, which is merely a single branch on the bush of the primate, which has many more longer lived species than humanity.
 
.
Natural selection takes those which can survive the environment due to their constitution, which by -chance- enables them to survive, while discarding those who aren't adaptable and capable of handling a change.
You are describing natural selection, not chance. One more post claiming it is and the only result will be my putting you on ignore cause there is no other way to stop your inanity.

ETA - Seriously, how inane is it for someone to compare a random event of non-biological origins to be the same as natural selection of a biological object?
 
Last edited:
You are describing natural selection, not chance. One more post claiming it is and the only result will be my putting you on ignore cause there is no other way to stop your inanity.


By imposing an Ignore condition, you will not have created an environment that reduces the chance that I Ratant will survive as a viable poster in this thread.
 
RandFan is just stirring the pot.
??? What? The word fits. If I by chance get hit by a bus today then it was chance. If by chance the ever changing envioronment favored crocs and not dino's then that is chance. End of story. I hate to be tautological but what's with the nonsennse?

Going from a single celled organism to a mamal isn't simply the result of chance.
 
As I said above, it seems that our life is only supported on Earth or at least in a very small portion of the universe and interstellar travel is extremely unfriendly to our life so we are essentially stuck on Earth. Why was god or the designer so wasteful?

Thats only in your opinion though. Science has exactly the same problem ID does, lack of data points. Even a very small portion of the universe presents an enormous number of oppotunities
 
Thats only in your opinion though. Science has exactly the same problem ID does, lack of data points. Even a very small portion of the universe presents an enormous number of oppotunities
No. It is an opinion shared with many scientists. Tell me, how is our life possible on a world without oxygen unless we have life support? Tell me, how is our life possible on a world where the temperature is either to hot or cold for liquid water to exist? Tell me, how is interstellar travel with the exposure to cosmic radiation compatible with our life? Note that I restricted my statement to our type of life yet I said nothing about any other types.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom