Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

If IDiots claim there is a god and ID, then why did he waste so much space in the universe by making Earth pretty much the only place in a HUGE universe that can support us without life support? Also, two things i want to know is why god in his infinite wisdom gave Israel to the jews when it is the only country in the middle east without oil? Why did god rest on the 7th day, did the omnipotent god get tired?
 
The universe being finely tuned was not really improbable. It happened so an after the fact probability is really 100%.

Apologies in advance, but that's about the dumbest thing I've ever read here.
If you're going to be talking about probability in any meaningful way you first have to accept it as a viable notion.
 
Apologies in advance, but that's about the dumbest thing I've ever read here.
Except that he's right.

If you're going to be talking about probability you first have to accept it as a viable notion.
Except that in this case it's not. You can only assign probabilities for the creation of universe with given parameters if you have a model for the creation of universes, and then the probability is only as valid as the model, and you can't test the model. (Or, more precisely, you can test the model against exactly one datapoint. If your model predicts that our Universe can't exist, you have a problem.)
 
Apologies in advance, but that's about the dumbest thing I've ever read here.
If you're going to be talking about probability in any meaningful way you first have to accept it as a viable notion.
I am not accepting probability? You must be kidding. You think applying probability after the fact is a valid way to make an argument?

ETA - Take something like the lottery with a probability of a win being 1 in 5 million. Low odds right? After the drawing we find that you won. After the fact what is the probability that you will win the draw (it ain't 1 in 5 million).
 
Last edited:
By the way, how are we to empirically tell the difference between Specified Complexity and non-specified complexity ?

How do you know that the Specified form can not possibly be the product of a natural evolutionary process?
 
Why do IDiots think that it must be design because it couldn't be chance? Don't they understand evolution is not chance but it is natural selection?
 
I am not accepting probability? You must be kidding. You think applying probability after the fact is a valid way to make an argument?

ETA - Take something like the lottery with a probability of a win being 1 in 5 million. Low odds right? After the drawing we find that you won. After the fact what is the probability that you will win the draw (it ain't 1 in 5 million).

In which case, what you are doing is denying yourself any future ability to judge any completed event as before-the-fact improbable.
Which is a silly position to take, and is done entirely as a mode of worldview protection, due to it being undeniable that reality as it is has the hallmarks of rational design as opposed to mere blind chance + necessity*.
It means that if you come home and find your pet snake spilled a tin of paint and then slithered out the Book of Revelation on your parquet floor, you'd have no right to remark on the before-the-fact improbability of that.
I mean, it happened, right? So it was always going to happen. So it had a probability of 1.

Yeah, right :boggled:

*necessity - in the form of physical laws - also has the hallmarks of rational design
 
By the way, how are we to empirically tell the difference between Specified Complexity and non-specified complexity ?

How do you know that the Specified form can not possibly be the product of a natural evolutionary process?

Regardless if ID has any validity or not, the one thing it does not have is data points. We have the history of life on Earth. From one single time line how can we work out what was planned, unplanned etc etc, because we dont know what the alternative should look like

If we go out and explore the Universe, find man, Christians and stories of Christ on every planet....then we can consider ID, till then it simply has to guess, which as we know sucks as a scientific process
 
Regardless if ID has any validity or not, the one thing it does not have is data points. We have the history of life on Earth. From one single time line how can we work out what was planned, unplanned etc etc, because we dont know what the alternative should look like

If we go out and explore the Universe, find man, Christians and stories of Christ on every planet....then we can consider ID, till then it simply has to guess, which as we know sucks as a scientific process
As I said above, it seems that our life is only supported on Earth or at least in a very small portion of the universe and interstellar travel is extremely unfriendly to our life so we are essentially stuck on Earth. Why was god or the designer so wasteful?
 
Rev, to prove that this Universe is fine-tuned for life you have to show that no other set of fundamental constants could give rise to life.


Good luck with that.
 
In my personal search for truth (God)...
I was an ID proponent but I wasn't in search of god. I had made a commitment to the truth and to accept the truth wherever I found it. I didn't know that the commitment would lead me away from a belief in god but if the commitment for truth is strong enough it is the only possible outcome IMO.

I came to atheism kicking and screaming but giving up my belief in ID was, by comparison easy. The evidence for evolution is simply overwhelling.

ID on the other hand is evidence of nothing. And argument by improbable events is silly once you understand that it is special pleading for any particular imporbable event. The odds for your existence are 1. The chance of your existience however is unfathombly small (If you go back 10 generations (250 years) the chance of you being born at all is at most 1 divided by 6 x 10100)

But you are not going to conclude anything from that.
 
Regardless if ID has any validity or not, the one thing it does not have is data points. We have the history of life on Earth.
That is true.

We also have the means to extrapolate some predictions about the future of life on Earth, at least to some degree of accuracy. ID has none what-so-ever.

Though, I would still like to know exactly what properties Specified Complexity is supposed to have, that would make it impossible to be the product of an evolutionary process.

From one single time line how can we work out what was planned, unplanned etc etc, because we dont know what the alternative should look like
And, I don't know exactly what this is supposed to mean.

If we go out and explore the Universe, find man, Christians and stories of Christ on every planet....then we can consider ID, till then it simply has to guess, which as we know sucks as a scientific process
Heh. We don't even have a single, clear, consistent, and persistent Creation story here, on Earth. What makes you think other planets would be able to sustain one?

If I.D. proponents could develop an empirical way to determine properties of the Designer, that does not rely on going to other planets; and they could make predictions about life forms, that Evolution would not be capable of, then they would have a framework for turning I.D. into a real sciene, sooner than intersteller space travel.

But, so far, there has been no attempt at actual scientific progress from them. So, I won't be holding my breathe.
 
The way to think about the probability question is this.

I have a standard deck of 52 cards, and I deal you one at random. It's the king of clubs, and you say, "Wow, I got the king of clubs, of all the cards in the deck isn't it amazing that I got that one specific card?"

Well, frankly, no, it isn't. You were dealt a card. You would have been amazed at getting that specific card regardless of what it actually was. It could have been the four of spades and you still would have been amazed.

And this is the problem you have with the, "Isn't it amazing that of all the possible people that could have been born after all the generations preceding me, that I should be born", statement is that it's the same as the king of clubs. When your mother got pregnant someone was going to be born. Someone who was a combination of your parents' genetics. It happened to be you, but it could have been a different you. And here's the thing, if it were a different you, you might still be amazed at the improbability of that other you having been born.

You're the four of spades, but you could just as easily have been the king of clubs.

That you're the four of spades would only be amazing if, before you were even conceived, someone had predicted your exact genetic code, down to the last amino acid. But they didn't, so it isn't.
 
...
So, what sort of god do you think it takes to design such a worm?
.
Or as I mentioned in another thread, "designing" the prostate/urethra situation, which kills with a great deal of pain.
All this crap about ID is just a semantic game where words are twisted out of context to suit some irrationalist purpose.
There's a disturbingly large number of posters here with a disturbingly obvious mental "challenge" to reality that has them post page after page of self-congratulation/justification for illogical and irrational beliefs.
 
I admit to using the "IDiot" tag too, but jsfisher is right. It doesn't help to further the argument.

Rev's whole OP hinges on one thing: probabilities. That should be solid mathematics. If he can't back it up with solid calculations, his whole argument tumbles down like a house of cards. Let's hear it from him what the various probabilities are of the things he described. Let's hear it from him at which cutoff point he thinks something should be designed.

I'm waiting with bated breath.
 
Why do IDiots think that it must be design because it couldn't be chance? Don't they understand evolution is not chance but it is natural selection?
.
And natural selection is just a crap shoot.
This works right now, it might not work tomorrow, after the asteroid impact.
 
.
And natural selection is just a crap shoot.
This works right now, it might not work tomorrow, after the asteroid impact.
Natural selection is chance? Care to explain cause that is wrong. If natural selection were chance, that is exactly what it would be called but it appears to be called something else.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom