Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Carn said:
CIA, Mossad, Secret Service or someone else will harrass, threaten, employ, misuse, abuse or kill me, if i demonstrate my power.

"I don't wanna be a LAB RAT the rest of my life!"

Basically the same as "If I do this in public, they will lock me up in the Pentagon or in a nuthouse."

Carn said:
'I don't know if this is true, but I have read that Randi has said "I always have an out." in relation to the challenge, so it seems by definition unwinnable, so why even try?'

Basically the same as "James Randi judges the outcome/I want an independent judge."
 
TheBoyPaj said:
"If I pass the prelim, they'll just move the goalposts to make sure I fail the next test."

Basically the same as "James Randi judges the outcome/I want an independent judge."
 
Peter Morris said:
Don't worry, Larsen. You'll be a wit one day. You're half way there already.

Are you sure you focus on the evidence and not the persons?
 
Peter Morris said:
Larsen, do you know what a straw man argument is?

It's when someone chooses to invent his opponents words and makes the claim "here is what my opponent says"

You are claiming that these are the excuses used by people that refuse Randi's test. Are they really? I do hope that you are going to provide cites for every one of these excuses. That is, you will cite specific people that have used these excuses, and cite the exact words they use.

I'm sure you will find it easy to do so. After all these are the top excuses for not taking the test. You wouldn't include any fictional examples on the list, would you. When you have "If I do this in public, someone will steal my discovery" on the list, it is because many paranormalists have actually said those words. And you are of course willing and able to identify them.

Yes, they really are. They are not taken verbatim, as you would know, had you read the article.
 
Peter Morris said:
If you cannot find a specific instance of someone saying it, then it cannot be a top argument, and must be removed.

In other words, if an example is not to your liking, it should be censored.
 
CFLarsen said:
Basically the same as "If I do this in public, they will lock me up in the Pentagon or in a nuthouse."


Yes, its the same, but i do not think your answer will satisfy(public outcry), those who have that excuse, because as i said above some intell agencies and gov't do realy give a damn about public opinion and human rights.

Carn
 
Carn said:
Yes, its the same, but i do not think your answer will satisfy(public outcry), those who have that excuse, because as i said above some intell agencies and gov't do realy give a damn about public opinion and human rights.

Carn

The point is that people will disappear. That will create a mega stir.
 
Peter Morris said:
Larsen, do you know what a straw man argument is?

It's when someone chooses to invent his opponents words and makes the claim "here is what my opponent says"

You are claiming that these are the excuses used by people that refuse Randi's test. Are they really? I do hope that you are going to provide cites for every one of these excuses. That is, you will cite specific people that have used these excuses, and cite the exact words they use.
I think he does know what a straw man is. It's when you pretend that someone holds an opinion which he doesn't hold, and then argue with that, as you are doing here.
 
Carn said:
I can do that for the one i added, the CIA excuse.

Last saturday i met a friend of mine ... i suggested to her, to go for the JREF prize, if she still thinks she can do something of the above. Her response was, as far as i remeber:
"One million is not worth the trouble intelligence agencies will cause one, who passes this test. Also the public interest would be annoying."

I did not press her further on the issue ...

So, Peter Morris, you realy want everybody to post something like this for every excuse mentioned?


Oh no. I want you to do a lot better than that. For all I know, you might be making up the story. It could be a work of fiction. Or you might be misquoting your friend. You could be quoting her words out of context. You might have missed something from what she said. You might have added something.

For each one that you list, give a verifiable cite from a primary source. Somebody posting under a pseudonym, claiming that an unnamed friend has said something similar to this, doesn't count.
 
Peter Morris said:
Oh no. I want you to do a lot better than that. For all I know, you might be making up the story. It could be a work of fiction. Or you might be misquoting your friend. You could be quoting her words out of context. You might have missed something from what she said. You might have added something.

For each one that you list, give a verifiable cite from a primary source. Somebody posting under a pseudonym, claiming that an unnamed friend has said something similar to this, doesn't count.

So, why should anyone pay any attention to what you post?

Nobody knows if you are really "Peter Morris".
 
Peter Morris said:
Oh no. I want you to do a lot better than that. For all I know, you might be making up the story. It could be a work of fiction. Or you might be misquoting your friend. You could be quoting her words out of context. You might have missed something from what she said. You might have added something.
Yes we're all involved in a vast conspiracy of lies against you. You rumbled us.
 
Peter, when you see people talking on street corners and on buses...

We're talking about you.
 
Nex said:
Peter Morris--

I belong to a few "woo" internet message boards, and these are definetly the top excuses for not taking the test. If they were not, I would have said so.

*edit* And to go further, I made these excuses myself. They are very common excuses for not wanting to take the challenge.


So untwist your panties. :p

Fine.

Since these are so common, yiu will have no trouble at all citing them, will you.

Name specific people that have said them. Quote the precise words used. Give a reference that can be actually checked. That way, we don't have to take your word for it.

Should be easy, since they say these things all the time.
 
Peter, Peter...

Who are you? Why should we attach any significance to what you say?
 
Peter Morris said:
Oh no. I want you to do a lot better than that. For all I know, you might be making up the story. It could be a work of fiction. Or you might be misquoting your friend. You could be quoting her words out of context. You might have missed something from what she said. You might have added something.

For each one that you list, give a verifiable cite from a primary source. Somebody posting under a pseudonym, claiming that an unnamed friend has said something similar to this, doesn't count.

Ok, so help me a bit, imagine you were in my position and would try to support the quote you brought here in a way that would satisfy "Peter Morris" and that you realy met a friend last saturday, who said something very close to that quote.

I have no idea how to do it, except get her and me sign a notarified protocol of what we talked about last saturday and post a copy here and send anyone interested a real copy.

Anything that would be easier and cheaper?

Carn

BTW, i'm fairly certain, that i quoted her correctly(at least the meaning, conversation was in german, so a translation error is possible), because i knew i was going to meet her and intended to ask her about it and was interested what she say about it and if and how she would argue for not applying.
I do not no much about the working of brain, but as far as i know any healthy person should be able to correctly recall what somebody said 5 days ago, if it was about the topic the person was aiming for in the conversation and was interested to hear what the other one had to say about the topic.

So said shortly, if i'm grossly misquoting my friend i'm either intenly lying or my brain is seriously malfunctioning and i should visit a doctor immiediately(probably neurology or something like that).
 
CFLarsen said:
Yes, they really are. They are not taken verbatim, as you would know, had you read the article.

I read the article, Larsen. The point of the article was to say : hey aren't the paranormalists stupid, lets list the things they say and have a good laugh at how ridiculous they are.

That is a common debating tactic. I see it in any debate on any subject, from both sides. List things that are supposed to be the sort of things your opponents say, then attack your own list. It's called a straw man. This is always dishonest. Whatever the subject being discussed, whatecver side you take, this sort of thing is dishonest. Unless you provide specific references, it might not be a fair representation of what they say. Even with references its a bit dodgy. You might be cherry-picking the ones you can answer, and ignoring the ones you can't.
 
Carn said:
Ok, so help me a bit, imagine you were in my position and would try to support the quote you brought here in a way that would satisfy "Peter Morris" and that you realy met a friend last saturday, who said something very close to that quote.

I have no idea how to do it, except get her and me sign a notarified protocol of what we talked about last saturday and post a copy here and send anyone interested a real copy.

Anything that would be easier and cheaper?

Yes. Stick to actual published sources. Don't expect people to accept hearsay.

For example, earlier in the thread, Dr. Adequate said:
My favorite one is Sylvia Browne's stuff about the JREF money being tainted and evil. She can't even give it to charity, you see, because it would carry with it the Curse Of Randi.

Fine. Lets go with that. When did she say that? In print? what publication? On TV or radio? Name the show and date of broadcast. You will understand that I personally have never read or watched any of her stuff. I'm no fan of hers. But I'm not going to just take your word for it that she ever said such a silly thing.

repeat for every one on the list.
 
CFLarsen said:
In other words, if an example is not to your liking, it should be censored.

Actually, if you cannot find even one single instance of a person saying this, then including it on the list of "common" arguments would be a lie.

If it's a common argument, you will be able to cite specific people saying it, and give a verifiable cite that can be checked.

If you can't provide any cite whatsoever, then it's not a common argument.
 
Peter Morris said:
Actually, if you cannot find even one single instance of a person saying this, then including it on the list of "common" arguments would be a lie.

If it's a common argument, you will be able to cite specific people saying it, and give a verifiable cite that can be checked.

If you can't provide any cite whatsoever, then it's not a common argument.

Who are you, Peter Morris? Why should we pay any attention to you? Are you a real person?
 
So, Larsen, you demand that I provide cites for my claims, but find it unneccessary to provide cites for your claims?

Once again, a Randi-fan displays skill at hypocritacal thinking.

Can anyone provide a cite for the Sylvia one, for instance?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom