Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Here's the answer...

Randi agrees that "divine healing" must be accepted as a paranormal claim.

We have asked our webmaster to remove the words "divine healing" from the note at the end of the Challenge application stating what types of claims JREF would decline to test. He'll get to it at his earliest convenience. Hopefully, that will be soon.
 
Stars, Struck?

It says that Randi won't test those that can supposedly move stars, though I heard in a archived broadcast that he is going to test a claimant in Germany that purports to have this power.
 
CFLarsen said:
"The JREF doesn't release any readily available results from previous applicants, so I don't know what to expect."

All the results have been negative: Nobody has won. All has failed. Still, this is irrelevant to your own claim: Can you do it, yes or no?

(It's supposed to be "snappy", Carn ;))

How do you know that? I'm looking for files here. What happened during the tests, what the claimant offered, how this was tested and why it wasn't accepted.
 
If a 'psychic' really does believe that the million is all the money Randi has, then why not take the test, claim the cash, bankrupt him, and go around doing the "Ha! Ha! I beat James Randi at his own game!" dance?

Whoops, I forgot..they aren't allowed to take the nasty, naughty, wicked, evil money, as their own powers will short out like a radio in a bathtub, and their head might well explode.
( SCANNERS comes to mind...)

Hey! That's why they don't try! Their heads would explode! Ah, now it all makes sense..:D
 
Didn't see this one, but heard it today:

CIA, Mossad, Secret Service or someone else will harrass, threaten, employ, misuse, abuse or kill me, if i demonstrate my power.

I do not know a good answer and as JREF gets all data, applicant would have to trust them, that they keep his identity hidden.

And this excuse could actually be serious, just think how much money CIA and KGB were willing to waste on not working psychic powers, on working useful(for them) psychic powers they would be ready to spend billions and would be even ready to kill to keep it out of the wrong hands.

Carn
 
I've seen that kind of claim... I've even made it myself, back in my old woo-woo days.

Something along the lines of "I don't wanna be a LAB RAT the rest of my life!"


I haven't really found any comeback for that. I mean, it's coming from paranoia, but in the end something like that could really happen to a person, if they gave real evidence to PSI etc. ... :con2:
 
How about: 'I don't know if this is true, but I have read that Randi has said "I always have an out." in relation to the challenge, so it seems by definition unwinnable, so why even try?'
 
Re: Stars, Struck?

Yeah_Right said:
It says that Randi won't test those that can supposedly move stars, though I heard in a archived broadcast that he is going to test a claimant in Germany that purports to have this power.

An applicant named HILFIGER was tested early this year for this power, and failed. This was prior to the addition of the new rules regarding which claims JREF will decline to test.
 
Re: Re: Stars, Struck?

KRAMER said:
An applicant named HILFIGER was tested early this year for this power, and failed. This was prior to the addition of the new rules regarding which claims JREF will decline to test.

Hey, I can move stars!! I can give Sean Penn a well-deserved push.... :D
 
Re: Re: Re: Stars, Struck?

CFLarsen said:
Hey, I can move stars!! I can give Sean Penn a well-deserved push.... :D

I find that claim to be dubious at best, as it is almost a certaintly he would have "pushed" back... ;)
 
Nex said:
I've seen that kind of claim... I've even made it myself, back in my old woo-woo days.

Something along the lines of "I don't wanna be a LAB RAT the rest of my life!"
I'm interested in your story. Would you add it to this thread?
 
Re: Re: Stars, Struck?

Originally posted by Yeah_Right
It says that Randi won't test those that can supposedly move stars, though I heard in a archived broadcast that he is going to test a claimant in Germany that purports to have this power.
KRAMER said:
An applicant named HILFIGER was tested early this year for this power, and failed. This was prior to the addition of the new rules regarding which claims JREF will decline to test.
I'm intrigued. Surely any test of such a claim must take at least four years..?
 
Zamzara said:
Because it would take four years for the newly moved light to reach us.

Ah, OK. Got it.

It would be easy to test: Just ask the person if the change would be immediate (without giving away this clue). If he answered "yes", then you can dismiss his claim immediately.

No matter what he answered, it could easily be tested by asking him what stars he had moved in the past. I am sure that there would be a few astronomers who had wondered just what the heck happened to that star....

The claim is ridiculous, OK?
 
CFLarsen said:

It would be easy to test: Just ask the person if the change would be immediate (without giving away this clue). If he answered "yes", then you can dismiss his claim immediately.


Don't be so closed-minded. If I can move stars, I can almost certainly move photons-in-flight. After all, they weigh much less, right?
 
new drkitten said:
Don't be so closed-minded. If I can move stars, I can almost certainly move photons-in-flight. After all, they weigh much less, right?

If that is the case, then we can test it simply by having the guy redirect a beam of light coming from a torch. No need for stars, no need to wait for 4 years.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom