CFLarsen said:
If you can't keep up in the threads you participate in, don't participate, then.
Let's see some evidence of your claims. E.g., dowsing: Where is the evidence that it works?
First of all, congrats for providing the cite. Now repeat for all items on your list.
Other than that, once again, Larsen, you are lying. I have never said that dowsing "works." I have always said that I am sceptical of claims, but I want to see them fairly tested.
Your article is about the reasons dowsers and others give for not taking the test. I quoted some guy's stated reason for not taking the test. I invited you to include that reason on your list.
Now your demand for "evidence" confuses me. See, here's the scenario:
Larsen: I want to erite another fawning article singing the praises of Randi. Please give me examples of excuses the woo-woos use for not taking the test.
Peter: Here's one for your list. A claimed dowser has rejected the test. His reason given was
"it is unacceptable to put a lump of sulfide mineralisation, or a gold ring, or any other substitute for an orebody under a cardboard box and ask me to detect that by dowsing. It won't work. It must be done under real field conditions over real sulfide mineralisation. I have had no response from the Australian Sketpics, other than to invite me to the next round of testing of water dowsers. Presumably, they are going to ask the dowsers to detect bottles of water or pipes of water. It won't work, because that's not how dowsing works. I will contact them again and try to get a better response out of them. I will let you know how I get on.
There, that's a common reason. Put that on your list.
Larsen : Where's the evidence? I need evidence. It only goes on the list when there is evidence. Without evidence it doesn't go on the list. Everything on the list needs evidence.
Dr. Adequate : Sylvia browne says the money is cursed.
Larsen : Oh, that's a good one. That goes on my list. There is enough evidence of that. The evidence is sufficient to include on the list.
You see my dilemma, Larsen? You consider evidence missing when someone complains that Randi's design for a protocol is unfair, yet evidence present when someone says the money is cursed. So I ask again. What evidence would that be? Evidence of what?
If I were a cynic, I might suppose that you are just making excuses, you don't want to include this on your list because:
- its a sensible, reasonable sounding complaint
- you have no answer for it.
But it couldn't possibly be that, cause we all know how honest you are.