Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Peter Morris said:
Thank you for that. I had a quick look through that. Nobody expressing fear of the CIA that I saw. Nor expressing fear that the money is cursed. Perhaps they aren't top excuses after all.

The common theme in the reasons given were :

1) Randi doesn't test these thinks fairly or properly.

2) I know it's true and have no need to prove it to anyone else.

Those aseem to be the actual top reasons.

Your quick look wasn't enough then.

Of course, the CIA et al. were not mentioned yet, but I suggest watching that thread. It will come up-- the subject's been debated there many times before, and it always goes the same way.

Also, you missed "if you take the money your powers will disappear" and "skeptics ruin the vibrations."

But like I said, looks like that thread just started a few days ago. I predict it will go on for another week or so, and all top excuses will be given.

I'm not psychic, I just know the pattern. I've only seen it a hundred times before. ;)
 
Peter Morris said:
Yes. Stick to actual published sources. Don't expect people to accept hearsay.


Sorry, Peter Morris, but from your point of view, if you are objective, my word is as good as a post in the thread, that Nex provided.

Why?

Because if i'm dishonest, i would register there under a different name, post that excuse and viola, would have something to cite to you.

As much of this conversations about JREF challenge and paranormal happen on forums and message groups, where practially anyone can jump in and post what he likes, for most of that quotes it will be impossible to cite a reliable source.

Exceptions are of cours, are the direct quote from Silvia Brown and those things you found in the challenge application section,
though that would only satisfy, if you would think KRAMER to be honest.

So when you're asking to quote reliable sources for those excuses, sorry that's nearly as impossible as finding reliable prove of psi abilities.

Carn
 
Peter Morris said:
Evidence of what, Larsen?

If you can't keep up in the threads you participate in, don't participate, then.

Peter Morris said:
However, and this is the point that confuses me, your list already contains the claim that some people refuse the test because the money is cursed.

So, I presume that you already have evidence of that? Since you need evidence before you include an item on your list.

Here you go:

Re the "dirty money" that Danish numerologist Annet Kofoed says, on that same Boesen site, that she doesn't want from the JREF, reader William Rentfrow suggests:

If the physical money is somehow "cursed," couldn't she just exchange it? "Hello, I'd like to exchange this for some non-cursed money, please." It's a practical approach.

Or give it away to an enemy...?
Source

She was asked, "Couldn't you just give the money away?" She answered:

I cannot give anything away which has bad energy. If I did give the money to the poor kids in Africa, they would simply receive bad energies, and I do not want to expose them to that.
Source

Let's see some evidence of your claims. E.g., dowsing: Where is the evidence that it works?
 
Peter Morris said:
(ONE of the reasons why test negotiations fell through.
Ah... all is clear. I thought that was it (chalk up another point for Dr Adequate's Psychic Powers). This is why I never see you posting about the paranormal, and always see you posting about your frothing hatred of sceptics. Unlike everyone else here, you're not interested in the paranormal, just in your own insane grudge.

Yes, you've failed as a dowser. Yes, you've failed as a human being. Now go away.
 
CFLarsen said:
If you can't keep up in the threads you participate in, don't participate, then.

Let's see some evidence of your claims. E.g., dowsing: Where is the evidence that it works?

First of all, congrats for providing the cite. Now repeat for all items on your list.

Other than that, once again, Larsen, you are lying. I have never said that dowsing "works." I have always said that I am sceptical of claims, but I want to see them fairly tested.

Your article is about the reasons dowsers and others give for not taking the test. I quoted some guy's stated reason for not taking the test. I invited you to include that reason on your list.

Now your demand for "evidence" confuses me. See, here's the scenario:

Larsen: I want to erite another fawning article singing the praises of Randi. Please give me examples of excuses the woo-woos use for not taking the test.

Peter: Here's one for your list. A claimed dowser has rejected the test. His reason given was

"it is unacceptable to put a lump of sulfide mineralisation, or a gold ring, or any other substitute for an orebody under a cardboard box and ask me to detect that by dowsing. It won't work. It must be done under real field conditions over real sulfide mineralisation. I have had no response from the Australian Sketpics, other than to invite me to the next round of testing of water dowsers. Presumably, they are going to ask the dowsers to detect bottles of water or pipes of water. It won't work, because that's not how dowsing works. I will contact them again and try to get a better response out of them. I will let you know how I get on.

There, that's a common reason. Put that on your list.

Larsen : Where's the evidence? I need evidence. It only goes on the list when there is evidence. Without evidence it doesn't go on the list. Everything on the list needs evidence.

Dr. Adequate : Sylvia browne says the money is cursed.

Larsen : Oh, that's a good one. That goes on my list. There is enough evidence of that. The evidence is sufficient to include on the list.


You see my dilemma, Larsen? You consider evidence missing when someone complains that Randi's design for a protocol is unfair, yet evidence present when someone says the money is cursed. So I ask again. What evidence would that be? Evidence of what?


If I were a cynic, I might suppose that you are just making excuses, you don't want to include this on your list because:

- its a sensible, reasonable sounding complaint
- you have no answer for it.

But it couldn't possibly be that, cause we all know how honest you are.
 
Peter Morris said:
Larsen: I want to erite another fawning article singing the praises of Randi.

Liar. Larsen did not write that.

Peter Morris said:
Larsen : Where's the evidence? I need evidence. It only goes on the list when there is evidence. Without evidence it doesn't go on the list. Everything on the list needs evidence.

Liar. Larsen did not write that.

Peter Morris said:
Larsen : Oh, that's a good one. That goes on my list. There is enough evidence of that. The evidence is sufficient to include on the list.

Liar. Larsen did not write that.
 
Peter Morris said:
First of all, congrats for providing the cite. Now repeat for all items on your list.

Whoa....just a second. Do you admit that there was evidence? Yes or no?

Peter Morris said:
Other than that, once again, Larsen, you are lying. I have never said that dowsing "works." I have always said that I am sceptical of claims, but I want to see them fairly tested.

Here you point to the evidence of dowsing:

Peter Morris said:
This is not an open minded man, willing to see evidence of dowsing. This is a closed-minded individual who will attack dowsing any way he can. He spouts a load of information designed to discredit them, and not care much whether the information is accurate or not.
Source

Now, what is this evidence of dowsing, please?

Peter Morris said:
Larsen: I want to erite another fawning article singing the praises of Randi. Please give me examples of excuses the woo-woos use for not taking the test.

Larsen : Where's the evidence? I need evidence. It only goes on the list when there is evidence. Without evidence it doesn't go on the list. Everything on the list needs evidence.

Dr. Adequate : Sylvia browne says the money is cursed.

Larsen : Oh, that's a good one. That goes on my list. There is enough evidence of that. The evidence is sufficient to include on the list.

I have said none of the above things.

Peter Morris said:
You see my dilemma, Larsen? You consider evidence missing when someone complains that Randi's design for a protocol is unfair, yet evidence present when someone says the money is cursed. So I ask again. What evidence would that be? Evidence of what?

Evasion noted. You don't fool me for one second. You are perfectly aware of what I am talking about.
 
CFLarsen said:
Whoa....just a second. Do you admit that there was evidence? Yes or no?

Here you point to the evidence of dowsing:

Now, what is this evidence of dowsing, please?

I have said none of the above things.

Evasion noted. You don't fool me for one second. You are perfectly aware of what I am talking about.

What evasion, Larsen? I have been direct in my statements.

Why wont you include genuine comments from actual claimants in your list?

What is the "evidence" that you want. Some evidence that
- is missing from the dowsers statement
- yet present in the claim that the money is cursed.

You refuse to include the dowsers statement because you say there is no evidence.

You include the cursed money because there IS evidence.

Where is the evidence of the cursed money, Larsen?


And of course, you continue with the same lies. You accuse me of believing in dowsing, which is a lie.

In your delusional state, a comment that Randi is closed minded becomes a statement that dowsing exists.

Show me where I said that dowsing works, you liar.
 
Peter Morris said:
Ah, so you have trouble understanding sarcasm, then.

Again, the tactics you employ are far worse than the things you accuse Randi of doing.
 
Peter Morris said:
Where is the evidence of the cursed money, Larsen?

It's in my post. "Annet Kofoed".

Now, where is the evidence of dowsing you spoke of?
 
Peter Morris said:
And of course, you continue with the same lies. You accuse me of believing in dowsing, which is a lie.

In your delusional state, a comment that Randi is closed minded becomes a statement that dowsing exists.

Show me where I said that dowsing works, you liar.

This is what you posted:

Peter Morris said:
This is not an open minded man, willing to see evidence of dowsing. This is a closed-minded individual who will attack dowsing any way he can. He spouts a load of information designed to discredit them, and not care much whether the information is accurate or not.
Source

Now, what evidence of dowsing is it that Randi is not willing to see?

If you are saying that none exist, then what is your complaint about Randi?
 
CFLarsen said:
This is what you posted:



Now, what evidence of dowsing is it that Randi is not willing to see?

If you are saying that none exist, then what is your complaint about Randi?

Larsen, you liar, this is very simple.

Someone comes forward claiming that they can dowse for groundwater. That is natural water flowing underground in huige quantities.

Randi tries to press them into a test dowsing for a small bottle of water in a box.

Dowser does not accept this test. Presses for test dowsing for groundwater.

Randi refuses to perform that test.

That, Larsen, is an example of Randi refusing to look at the evidence. It is a proven fact that someone claimed to have evidence, offered to show it to Randi, and Randi refused to look. Randi refused to look at the evidence. That does not mean I believe the evidence is true. Only that Randi is a proven liar, just like you.


Now, tell me what evidence you have to support the excuse that the money is cursed.
 
Peter Morris said:
Larsen, you liar, this is very simple.

Someone comes forward claiming that they can dowse for groundwater. That is natural water flowing underground in huige quantities.

Randi tries to press them into a test dowsing for a small bottle of water in a box.

Dowser does not accept this test. Presses for test dowsing for groundwater.

Randi refuses to perform that test.

That, Larsen, is an example of Randi refusing to look at the evidence. That does not mean I believe the evidence is true.

You are lying when you claim I believe in dowsing. but then lies come natural to you.

O.....K. So, you don't believe in dowsing. Then, no such evidence can exist. Then, you cannot have any complaints about Randi.

Peter Morris said:
Now, tell me what evidence you have supporting the excuse that the money is cursed.

Have you seen the Kofoed quote?
 
By the way, Larsen.

I said that Randi is closed-minded and unwilling to look at the evidence.

You took that to mean that evidence exists.

But what of the original comment, which YOUI posted

"When we say we are "skeptical", we mean that we must see compelling evidence before we believe. "

So, what is the evidence that you are willing to see?

After all, you quoted this, so, you must believe that evidence exists.
 
Peter Morris said:
By the way, Larsen.

I said that Randi is closed-minded and unwilling to look at the evidence.

You took that to mean that evidence exists.

But what of the original comment, which YOUI posted

"When we say we are "skeptical", we mean that we must see compelling evidence before we believe. "

So, what is the evidence that you are willing to see?

After all, you quoted this, so, you must believe that evidence exists.

You are either deliberately obtuse or slightly short of a few bricks.

Have you seen the Kofoed quote?
 
CFLarsen said:
O.....K. So, you don't believe in dowsing. Then, no such evidence can exist. Then, you cannot have any complaints about Randi.

Try to understand this concept, Larsen.

From the quote YOU supplied:

" Ideally, skeptics do not go into an investigation closed to the possibility that a phenomenon might be real or that a claim might be true. When we say we are "skeptical", we mean that we must see compelling evidence before we believe. "

That is what I feel. I want to see compelling evidence of dowsing before I believe in it.

Randi however does not. He just KNOWS that dowsing is wrong, and attacks and invents lies to discredit dowsers. He makes a big sham of being willing to see evidence, but when someone comes forward offering to demonstrate he refuses to even look.

This idea that I cannot have any complaints about Randi. If I don't believe in dowsing, then I should forgive all of Randi's lies. I ought to ignore the stupid things he says, and justify the frauds he commits. If I don't belive in dowsing, why should I care when claimants aren't tested fairly.

It may be a peculiar concept to you, Larsen, but I object to dishonesty. You just object to the paranormal. You are perfectly happy with lies told by Randi to attack the paranormal.

Have you seen the Kofoed quote?

What is your evidence, Larsen? You say that there is some evidence you have that is :
- missing from the dowsers quote
- present in the claim that the money is cursed.

I'm still wondering what that evidence might be.
 
CFLarsen said:
You are either deliberately obtuse or slightly short of a few bricks.

Have you seen the Kofoed quote?

And your personal abuse does not change the fact that you are refusing to include things you have no answer for.

What is your evidence for the cursed money claim?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom