Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Hey, I can redirect the light from a torch.

But I don't think a mirror will win the million.
 
CIA, Mossad, Secret Service or someone else will harrass, threaten, employ, misuse, abuse or kill me, if i demonstrate my power.

"I don't wanna be a LAB RAT the rest of my life!"

'I don't know if this is true, but I have read that Randi has said "I always have an out." in relation to the challenge, so it seems by definition unwinnable, so why even try?'

We still have those 3 unanswered.

Carn
 
"If I pass the prelim, they'll just move the goalposts to make sure I fail the next test."
 
CIA, Mossad, Secret Service or someone else will harrass, threaten, employ, misuse, abuse or kill me, if i demonstrate my power.

Not if you wear this useful and stylish tinfoil hat.

"I don't wanna be a LAB RAT the rest of my life!"

Wait 'til you hear about our breeding program!
 
CFLarsen said:
If that is the case, then we can test it simply by having the guy redirect a beam of light coming from a torch. No need for stars, no need to wait for 4 years.

Ah, but you see, photons from stars are natural and haven't been contaminated by the skepticdebunkermilitaryindustrialpatriarchaltechnopenis[tm].

And before you suggest using the Sun instead, that's obviously too large. I mean, look at how big it is compared to all those itty-bitty stars. It's almost the same size as the Moon!
 
new drkitten said:
It's almost the same size as the Moon!

It is exactly the same size as the Moon (well, from our POV). Otherwise, we wouldn't have eclipses! ;)
 
CFLarsen said:
It is exactly the same size as the Moon (well, from our POV). Otherwise, we wouldn't have eclipses! ;)
We would if the moon looked BIGGER than the sun...

Using our own star cuts down the time to eight minutes, I think, but it's not responsible. I like the Sun where it is.

Using someone else's star might have its dangers too. A couple of centuries pass, and suddenly there's a huge interstellar warfleet of irate aliens complaining that we've commited the cosmic equivalent of Spilling Their Pint. Then where are you?
 
Dr Adequate said:
A couple of centuries pass, and suddenly there's a huge interstellar warfleet of irate aliens complaining that we've commited the cosmic equivalent of Spilling Their Pint. Then where are you?

Skeee-roooooed. I'd hate to be the guy who pissed off a warfleet of Klingons or what-have-you...
 
"I don't wanna be a LAB RAT the rest of my life!"

Then stop advertising your abilities on Oprah, which probably has a lot more people watching than the JREF web site (sorry Randi).
 
Zamzara said:
"I don't wanna be a LAB RAT the rest of my life!"

Then stop advertising your abilities on Oprah, which probably has a lot more people watching than the JREF web site (sorry Randi).

That is also good for the CIA excuse, except that it only applies to prominent woo-woos and i think this excuse is more used by the ones, who keep a low profile.

Carn
 
Zamzara said:
"I don't wanna be a LAB RAT the rest of my life!"

Then stop advertising your abilities on Oprah, which probably has a lot more people watching than the JREF web site (sorry Randi).

I've just had a burst of inspiration on this one.

Anyway, I don't see how the World's First Proven Psychicâ„¢, whose name and face would most likely be known to the world, could just *poof* disappear. How could a government or corporation manage to make a well-known celeb disappear? People would notice, and raise a big stink. I mean, the US gov't can be a little slow, but they're not stupid.

Dubya excepted, of course.
 
CFLarsen said:
Let me know when you have changed it. I need to update this article. :)

Larsen, do you know what a straw man argument is?

It's when someone chooses to invent his opponents words and makes the claim "here is what my opponent says"

You are claiming that these are the excuses used by people that refuse Randi's test. Are they really? I do hope that you are going to provide cites for every one of these excuses. That is, you will cite specific people that have used these excuses, and cite the exact words they use.

I'm sure you will find it easy to do so. After all these are the top excuses for not taking the test. You wouldn't include any fictional examples on the list, would you. When you have "If I do this in public, someone will steal my discovery" on the list, it is because many paranormalists have actually said those words. And you are of course willing and able to identify them.
 
Larsen, do you know what a straw man argument is?

These are not straw man arguments as they are not being used to refute a claim.

They are exactly what the title of the thread proposes.
 
apoger said:
They are exactly what the title of the thread proposes.

Are they? These are real true examples of the TOP reasons cited for refusing the test? You're sure about that?

For example, reason #1 given as: "James Randi makes a lot of money from this."

This is a genuine example? really?

Has anybody, ever, actually said " I refuse to take this test because James Randi makes a lot of money from this"

People say this on a regular basis, do they? Have you heard them say this? Who has said this, ever?

Please name any person that has actually said this, or something reasonably similar. Quote the precise words used. Provide a verifiable reference from a primary source.

Repeat for every item on the list. If you cannot find a specific instance of someone saying it, then it cannot be a top argument, and must be removed.
 
Peter Morris--

I belong to a few "woo" internet message boards, and these are definetly the top excuses for not taking the test. If they were not, I would have said so.

*edit* And to go further, I made these excuses myself. They are very common excuses for not wanting to take the challenge.


So untwist your panties. :p
 
My entry wasn't addressed, so I'll repeat it:

How about: 'I don't know if this is true, but I have read that Randi has said "I always have an out." in relation to the challenge, so it seems by definition unwinnable, so why even try?'
 
Peter Morris said:




Repeat for every item on the list. If you cannot find a specific instance of someone saying it, then it cannot be a top argument, and must be removed.

I can do that for the one i added, the CIA excuse.

Last saturday i met a friend of mine, who i haven't seen for roughly 3 years. She was last time i saw her rather convinced, that under the right circumstances(never was able to have some definite answers on this) she is able to commune telepathically and also under other circumstance she is able to summon some sort of supernatural being, she mentioned Spirits, Ghosts and Demons(don't ask me for definitions).

As since i last met her, i became aware of the JREF challenge, i suggested to her, to go for the JREF prize, if she still thinks she can do something of the above. Her response was, as far as i remeber:
"One million is not worth the trouble intelligence agencies will cause one, who passes this test. Also the public interest would be annoying."

I did not press her further on the issue, it would have not been fruitfull, except she might have specified, what sort of trouble she expects. Since i do not exactly know what she meant with "trouble" , i tried instead to name several things, which fit the word trouble and which intelligence agencies might realy do, if someone shows a paranormal ability, that would be useful to them.

So, Peter Morris, you realy want everybody to post something like this for every excuse mentioned?

BTW, i remember now the excuse she offered, when she first told me that she is able to summon supernatural entities.

When she first told me this, i immiediately answered something like: "Where and when? What about this evening, i have nothing to do? I'm ready to buy candles, chalk and whatever you need, and i can do some chanting, if neccessary."

Her reply was: "These entities are to dangerous to meddle with without good reasons."

So i'm suggesting a further excuse, a bit generalized version of the above:
"One million is not worth the danger, that come with my abilities."

Snappy response: "Make sure only close minded evil sceptics are endangered by you're demonstration, then you would do the world a favor, if something goes wrong."

Carn
 
Nex said:
How could a government or corporation manage to make a well-known celeb disappear? People would notice, and raise a big stink. I mean, the US gov't can be a little slow, but they're not stupid.


I think the excuse is more about, that real proven psychic powers could be so useful to intelligence agencies (having long distance telepathy telepathy or long distance killing in mind), that they give a damn, what the public thinks about their actions.

Of course, you could argue, that the CIA and the US gov't would not ignore moral standards and voters opinion, that much, but take one look at Amnesty International reports and you know there are governments and intelligence agency, that give a damn about moral standards and public opinion.
So one could end up pleading the CIA for protection against the evil ones, which is not neccesarily a nice way to live.

BTW, you forgot, that the public opinion is perfectly controlled by the secret ruling circles, which also decide, who is the next idiot to be the puppet, that is called "President".

Carn
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom