Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Faith healing

I would guess that the faith healing clause is intended to forestall claims made after the fact. For instance, somebody might say, "I was kidnapped by organ thieves and drugged insensible, whereupon my kidneys were TORN from my LIVING BODY! But I prayed very earnestly to Our Lady of Notre Dame, and behold my kidneys were miraculously RESTORED to me, and the flesh HEALED UP without a scar, so I get the million, Randi, come on, cough up, what are you, a welsher? Hey, 'm talkin' ta YOU, buddy!" Or some such drivel; the well of human cupidity has no bottom.
 
Actually, I'd guess that it is because of the nature of the human body (perfectly natural recoverys occur that seem amazing and counteract doctor's statements). It's hard to see how you could accurately measure the odds on something like that. This is one that I see as just plain too difficult to test. I dunno, though, I'm just guessing.
 
Maybe the healing would also involve people becoming involved in the testing who had serious medical problems, and in participating in the experiemnt might not be getting the treatent they should be.

By refusing to test for this Randi in no way encourages anyone to persuade others to try their 'miraculous' method of healing instead of seeing an actual doctor.

I think this rule makes perfect sense.
 
Ashles said:
I saw one on another thread claiming that Randi wouldn't pay out because he wants to keep the interest for himself in case he has health issues as he gets older.


You did not. Don't misrepresent me.

I pointed out that not wanting to pay out was a possible motive for a hypothetical refusal to pay. Any time you get into seven-figure numbers, the honesty of all parties in transaction starts to become a significant issue. The exact quote is here :


[T]he damage to anyone's "good name" might well be worth less than the interest on a million dollars a year to him, especially if he gets hit with some serious and unexpected medical bills or something.

Note specifically the use of the words "might," and "anyone's."

I did not say that Randi would not pay out, and in fact would find it extremely surprising if he refused to honor the JREF agreement. On the other hand, with the number of people who have specifically expressed reservations about his honesty and probity, failure to take their concerns seriously make you look, well, naive and credulist.

More pointedly : I've seen the lame excuse "Randi won't pay me the money even after I win!" offered more than once. Saying "Sure he would!" makes you seem a fool. Saying "He'd have to or you could sue for breach of contract and get the money by court order" is a much stronger argument.
 
Maybe not a snappy retort, but I think the JREF should offer a consolation prize of a T-shirt --

"I tried to pass the James Randi Educational Foundation $1,000,000 Challenge and all I got was this lousy T-shirt!"
 
CFLarsen said:
Any more excuses? :)

Surely the excuses can be found on any web browser, yes?

Some I found in about ten minutes of looking....

  • Randi sets the bar too high; the test is impossible (Tanya Barrientos}
  • "[T]he terms enable Randi to draw up specific rules that are unwinnable" (Alternative Science)
  • The challege is just a meaningless PR stunt. (Various skeptics, including Randi himself)
  • The rules of evidence for the challenge are stacked. (E.g 'only eyewitness evidence is allowed, which is fine if the astrologer can do the business while walking on water. There is a reason for the eyewitness stipulation. Since Maskelyne, illusionists investigating the paranormal have always had an ace up their sleeve. They will say that if the effect can be produced by trickery, their stock in trade, then the effect must be trickery.' [astrozero]).
  • Randi will just refuse to accept what I do as paranormal. ('I might be sent a letter along these lines: "Dear Mr Elwell, Congratulations! You have succeeded in your demonstration! You have discovered a hitherto unrecognised phenomenon of nature which, however, as a natural phenomenon cannot by definition be classed as paranormal. We hope you get your Nobel Prize, but regret you do not qualify for ours."' [again, astrozero] )

It seems kind of silly to parody the arguments that people make against JREF when they're so kind as to put their idiocy on-line for all to see themselves.
 
CFLarsen said:
"I can only perform if a skeptic offers me large sums of money."
That's a misquote. I said I could only do it if NO sceptic offers me large sums of money. It inhibits my wild talent.
I don't understand 4.
Well, although Randi doesn't design the tests, conduct the tests, or even be present at the tests, he does want to know how they turn out. This causes the famous "Randi effect" where, by excercising his supernatural powers of emitting sceptical vibrations, every experiment the JREF does turns out not to work. How else do you explain it?

This proves the following propositions

(1) James Randi is a crook
(2) James Randi knows that psi exists
(3) Psi exists
(4) I have psychic powers, but you're all too afraid of the truth to admit it
(5) I should sue (starts foaming at the mouth and raving about lawyers)
 
I've also seen this nonsense:

A true psychic knows that they lose their power if they charge money for using their gift... or agree to perform for a financial reward apparently.

Of course, this was from a fanatic on a forum dedicated to a "psychic" who sold a book about her "gift" and collected money from each copy sold... apparently without harm.

The supposed idea being that "true psychics" just leave out a tip jar for donations that might appear after each session... but strictly voluntarily and with no expectation of payment.

I don't know what kind of snappy response you'd want to give to people this incredibly dense.
 
Sloe_Bohemian said:
I've also seen this nonsense:

A true psychic knows that they lose their power if they charge money for using their gift... or agree to perform for a financial reward apparently.

Of course, this was from a fanatic on a forum dedicated to a "psychic" who sold a book about her "gift" and collected money from each copy sold... apparently without harm.

The supposed idea being that "true psychics" just leave out a tip jar for donations that might appear after each session... but strictly voluntarily and with no expectation of payment.

I don't know what kind of snappy response you'd want to give to people this incredibly dense.

"Then take a big tip jar, perform for JREF and if they like it, they'll stuff a million into it."

"Then apply and ask JREF to guarantee that they will not give you a single cent and only proclaim that you passed."

Carn
 
Dr Adequate said:
That's a misquote. I said I could only do it if NO sceptic offers me large sums of money. It inhibits my wild talent.

Hey, I've heard both! :)
 
Good, good...


"Randi won't pay me the money even after I win!"

Since the result will be self-evident, he would have a very hard time explaining why he would refuse to pay the money.

(I don't think the legal point is of much use)


"Randi sets the bar too high. The test is impossible."

We cannot relax the conditions to an extent where it is possible for you to cheat.


"The terms enable Randi to draw up specific rules that are unwinnable."

Each claim is different. Therefore, each test must be designed differently. You cannot test a dowser the same way as you would test a clairvoyant.


"The challege is just a meaningless PR stunt."

It may be a PR stunt, but the money is there. One million dollars is not exactly "meaningless". Nor is a discovery of such magnitude.


"Randi will say that if the effect can be produced by trickery, then the effect must be trickery."

Since the results are self-evident, this is no reason to refuse to pay. If you can fool Randi, you get the million bucks, too.


"Randi will just refuse to accept what I do as paranormal."

Showing your discovery of a new natural phenomenon will certainly get you the million - and a Nobel prize! But you have to show it first, not merely write to Randi and claim you did.


"I can only perform if no skeptic offers me large sums of money."

Fine! Then do it for the sake of humanity. Let us all share your knowledge, and learn from your skills. Don't be so selfish by keeping it all to yourself.


"I will lose my power if I charge money for using my gift."

How do you know this? You have never earned a penny? If you have, then it is not correct that you lose your power, so you are free to apply for the million dollars.
 
"The JREF doesn't release any readily available results from previous applicants, so I don't know what to expect. He isn't peer reviewed from what I know- so why does that make him at all qualified to know whether or not what I can show is paranormal phenomenon? I would apply if I had the answers to these two. Knock yerselves out."
 
RottingPhoenix said:
The JREF doesn't release any readily available results from previous applicants, so I don't know what to expect.
Well, roughly speaking, you can expect your supposed paranormal power to be tested under conditions where you could oly perform some feat by means of your supposed supernatural powers. Don't know what to expect? Well, chum, chances are YOU WILL FAIL BECAUSE YOU ARE NOT A WIZARD. Try testing yourself under such circumstances. See?
He isn't peer reviewed from what I know- so why does that make him at all qualified to know whether or not what I can show is paranormal phenomenon?
He isn't. Probably nor are the observers involved (Randi does not perform the tests himself). So you can win the prize both by levitating or by fooling the observers into thinking that you're levitating, by reading minds or by foooling the observers into thinking that you're reading minds, by successfully dowsing or by successfully fooling the observers into thinking that you can dowse.

When the JREF accepts your application, they have accepted that what you claim would be, if genuine, a "paranormal phenomenon". What they want to know is CAN YOU DO IT. If you can, you get the cash. Good luck.
 
RottingPhoenix said:
"The JREF doesn't release any readily available results from previous applicants, so I don't know what to expect."

This depends mainly on what you are going to claim.
Somethings JREF does not accept, because its either silly, not testable, dangerous to test or known to be not paranormal, e.g. you control every event in the world by shaking your head, cloud busting, immortality,...

If your claim is about getting some information you could not attain by normal means, e.g. dowsing, astrology, augury, you can expect that the test design will be made, so there is realy absolute no way for your 5 normal senses to get any hint about the sought information. E.g. dowsing for flowing water tests used buried pipes that could be flooded with water independently and randomly.

If you claim to cause any unsual effect, then expect that whatever you want to cause the unusual effect on will be kept seperately from you , if possible and if not, then there will be some requirements for yourself, like washing hands, wearing clothing that was checked to be empty,...

If you claim you have something, that is paranormal or shows paranormal effects under certain conditions, expect some tests with and without your something,so it is certain that not the conditions cause the effect.

With some claim, it is possible that JREF might ask directly for some quick demonstration, so they know its not a joke, e.g. someone claimed to be perfectly able to control meteor impacts and Randi ask him immiediately for a small harmless one in his garden next sunday.

Far more things possible depending on the claim.

And always expect that JREF will look very close for cheating.

Do not expect JREF to listen to any explanation, except those neccesary to satisfy above point(e.g. if you have some big black box, that does something and do not allow them to look into it, then they will ask for explanations and will start checking them, if possible)

Expect that JREF requires you to sooner or later clearly state under what conditions you can perform and which keep you from performing, so try to find out these before conducting tests.

And remember that from their point of view they are dealing daily with deluded individuals and many of them are in need for competent psychatrists, so try to be polite, short and clear with your statements as far as possible. You are trying to make buiseness with them.

Thats all i can come up with now, it would be best if you give some hint what you're claim could be, you can be certain that several people here will make test suggestions, that would give an idea what JREF requires.

Cannot think of any further suggestions.

Carn
 
"The JREF doesn't release any readily available results from previous applicants, so I don't know what to expect."

All the results have been negative: Nobody has won. All has failed. Still, this is irrelevant to your own claim: Can you do it, yes or no?

(It's supposed to be "snappy", Carn ;))
 
RottingPhoenix said:
"He isn't peer reviewed from what I know- so why does that make him at all qualified to know whether or not what I can show is paranormal phenomenon?"

Part of the protocol: he agrees upfront that if you can do what you claim, then it's paranormal. All you need to do is to do it. "Knock yourself out."
 
Carn said:
Why is divine healing not allowed?

I'm reviewing this with Randi today. I would suspect that JREF should accept all healing claims, divine or otherwise.

I will get back to you on this.
 
KRAMER said:
I'm reviewing this with Randi today. I would suspect that JREF should accept all healing claims, divine or otherwise.

I will get back to you on this.

I look forward to hearing the answer.

You know, a JREF poster, 1inChrist says he has divinely healed two other JREF posters, Nyarlathotep and The Cats Venm. Maybe we will have another applicant soon, and thus another excuse as well.
 
Rob Lister said:
How would you test such a claim?

Easily: Applicant demonstrates, investigators observe.

No anecdotal "evidence" is acceptable. Only a demonstration before a team of observers will suffice.

Simple. No endless protocol negotiations, and nothing to waffle over. Just DO IT.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom