Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Peter Morris said:
So, Larsen, you demand that I provide cites for my claims, but find it unneccessary to provide cites for your claims?

Once again, a Randi-fan displays skill at hypocritacal thinking.

No, I demand that you live up to the same demands you have for others. You don't trust what people have said, why should anyone attach any significance to what you post?

Nobody knows if you are really "Peter Morris". Prove it.

Peter Morris said:
Can anyone provide a cite for the Sylvia one, for instance?

That has nothing to do with the article.
 
Peter Morris said:
I read the article, Larsen. The point of the article was to say : hey aren't the paranormalists stupid, lets list the things they say and have a good laugh at how ridiculous they are.
No, it's a sort of FAQ list.
That is a common debating tactic. I see it in any debate on any subject, from both sides. List things that are supposed to be the sort of things your opponents say, then attack your own list. It's called a straw man. This is always dishonest. Whatever the subject being discussed, whatecver side you take, this sort of thing is dishonest.
You know, that's just what I was thinking!
Unless you provide specific references, it might not be a fair representation of what they say. Even with references its a bit dodgy. You might be cherry-picking the ones you can answer, and ignoring the ones you can't.
:dl:
This is a public thread, so what you have just fantasised would not be possible. No-one can prevent you, for example, posting up something which you consider a good excuse. I notice you have not done so... unless... unless... perhaps you, too are in the conspiracy against you. You never know how powerful we Evil Sceptics are. WE CAN CONTROL YOUR THOUGHTS.

You are without a doubt the most boring poster on these boards. I have, to my recollection, never, ever, seen you actually posting about the paranormal, but I have often seen you posting about your delusions concerning sceptics. If you have nothing interesting to reveal except that you are a fantasist, then, my dear Mr Morris, we know that already.
 
Peter Morris said:
List things that are supposed to be the sort of things your opponents say, then attack your own list. It's called a straw man. This is always dishonest. Whatever the subject being discussed, whatecver side you take, this sort of thing is dishonest. Unless you provide specific references, it might not be a fair representation of what they say. Even with references its a bit dodgy. You might be cherry-picking the ones you can answer, and ignoring the ones you can't.

I think the informal SkepticReport article is a very powerful article, because it is representative and comprehensive.

I do believe that it would be even more powerful if there were actual quotes with sources (something which I believe there are many examples to be found). These real quotes could be listed under the 'motif' quote.
 
Dr Adequate said:
No, it's a sort of FAQ list.

You know, that's just what I was thinking!

:dl:
This is a public thread, so what you have just fantasised would not be possible.


Why is it impossible to provide proof for your claims?

You attributed words to Sylvia Browne. Why is it impossible to provide a cite for them?

Did you make the quote up?

Did you just take someone else's word for it?

Do you have a shred of evidence that Browne - or anyone - has ever said such a thing?

You are without a doubt the most boring poster on these boards blah blah your delusions blah blah nothing interesting waffle you are a fantasist.

Ah, abuse. How very predictable.
 
jzs said:
I think the informal SkepticReport article is a very powerful article, because it is representative and comprehensive.

I do believe that it would be even more powerful if there were actual quotes with sources (something which I believe there are many examples to be found). These real quotes could be listed under the 'motif' quote.

Like I said:

CFLarsen said:
If you want clarity, you have to boil it down. It also helps you remembering it. Simplify, clarify, cut through the crap.
 
Peter Morris said:
Ah, abuse. How very predictable.
Entirely. You are a boring fantasist, and you should not be at all surprised that people keep letting you know this. I'm afraid that this doesn't count as a psychic power, though, because, yes, people will state the bleeding obvious.
 
kookbreaker said:
What Peter completely fails to realise is that Claus is actually doing the world a favor and only sticking to the coherant complaints.

The incoherent complaints would be in the "Funnies" section. ;)
 
kookbreaker said:
What Peter completely fails to realise is that Claus is actually doing the world a favor and only sticking to the coherant complaints.

What the Kook fails to realise is that the complaints he produces do not match the majority of Larsen's list.

From the Kook's link:

"But in our experience, even with proof in hand, collecting the million appears to be impossible. To us it's been like a rigged carney game.

As serious applicants asking for a fair trial of our claim we are instead subjected to running a gauntlet of ad hominem abuse. "

This genuinely does seem to be a common complaint against Randi, which in general terms goes like this:

I tried to negotiate a test with him, and received a load of abuse in reply. He is an appallingly-behaved, childish and aggressive man with no sense of professionalism. He cannot be trusted to carry out a test either fairly or competently.


Put that one in your list, Larsen. You've even got a specific reference that you can cite.
 
Peter Morris said:
What the Kook fails to realise is that the complaints he produces do not match the majority of Larsen's list.

From the Kook's link:

"But in our experience, even with proof in hand, collecting the million appears to be impossible. To us it's been like a rigged carney game.

As serious applicants asking for a fair trial of our claim we are instead subjected to running a gauntlet of ad hominem abuse. "

This genuinely does seem to be a common complaint against Randi, which in general terms goes like this:

I tried to negotiate a test with him, and received a load of abuse in reply. He is an appallingly-behaved, childish and aggressive man with no sense of professionalism. He cannot be trusted to carry out a test either fairly or competently.


Put that one in your list, Larsen. You've even got a specific reference that you can cite.

Wow, Peter, that is some evidence, isn't it? I mean, fully documented and everything, eh? Compelling, very compelling. That is a fine citation, suitable for birdcage lining. Got any I can toss in my wood furnace? It looks like a long winter.
 
Come on then Peter, if this list was made up, what are the REAL arguments people use for not taking the test? (Also, where did Claus say the arguments have to be top arguments. I though he said they have to be lame arguments.)
 
Peter Morris said:
Fine.

Since these are so common, yiu will have no trouble at all citing them, will you.

Name specific people that have said them. Quote the precise words used. Give a reference that can be actually checked. That way, we don't have to take your word for it.

Should be easy, since they say these things all the time.

I'll rise to that challenge, and one-up you.

Here's a whole message board thread, complete with excuses, excuses, excuses.

Enjoy.
 
Zamzara said:
Come on then Peter, if this list was made up, what are the REAL arguments people use for not taking the test? (Also, where did Claus say the arguments have to be top arguments. I though he said they have to be lame arguments.)

Well, Kookbreaker provided us with one of the actual common excuses : I tried negotiating a test protocol with him, I only received abusive language in response to my attempts, Randi's childish misbehaviour made it impossible to continue.

The person may or may not be telling the truth, but that is about the most common reason given that I've seen.

Or then there's : I don't trust Randi. I consider him dishonest. I'm willing to be tested independently, but I will not be tested by that particular man, or his close assosiates. Randi has refused an independant tester.
example

Or then there's : I don't like the test Randi is offereing me. My dowsing skill enables me to find minerals or water in large quantities in the ground. Randi's test design insists that I find small quantities underneath a cup. That's a different thing, which I can't do.
example (ONE of the reasons why test negotiations fell through.


Put those in your list, Larsen.
 
Carn said:
I think the excuse is more about, that real proven psychic powers could be so useful to intelligence agencies (having long distance telepathy telepathy or long distance killing in mind)

... snipped for space...

BTW, you forgot, that the public opinion is perfectly controlled by the secret ruling circles, which also decide, who is the next idiot to be the puppet, that is called "President".

Ah, yes. My bad. Apologies.

However, it was brought up in a woo message board (linked above) about Randi's challenge rule #7. Apparently, someone's reading that to say that Randi and/or JREF can pick and choose what information to use, or to just suppress all of it.

I don't see how they could do that, though. I mean, Randi's got quite a bit invested in the JREF, but if he found true evidence of psi, breaking the laws of physics, I'd think even that old crotchety codger would want the world to know about it.

*shrugs*
 
Peter Morris said:
Well, Kookbreaker provided us with one of the actual common excuses : I tried negotiating a test protocol with him, I only received abusive language in response to my attempts, Randi's childish misbehaviour made it impossible to continue.

Then try us. What is it you can do? Open a thread, and let's investigate. Hm?

Peter Morris said:
Or then there's : I don't trust Randi. I consider him dishonest. I'm willing to be tested independently, but I will not be tested by that particular man, or his close assosiates. Randi has refused an independant tester.
example

If you don't want Randi to test you, go elsewhere.

Peter Morris said:
Or then there's : I don't like the test Randi is offereing me. My dowsing skill enables me to find minerals or water in large quantities in the ground. Randi's test design insists that I find small quantities underneath a cup. That's a different thing, which I can't do.
example (ONE of the reasons why test negotiations fell through.

Why can't you do this? Have you ever been tested for finding small quantities underneath a cup? If you have, please present the study. If you haven't, how do you know?

Peter Morris said:
Put those in your list, Larsen.

I'm most willing to. All I need is evidence.
 
Nex said:

However, it was brought up in a woo message board (linked above) about Randi's challenge rule #7. Apparently, someone's reading that to say that Randi and/or JREF can pick and choose what information to use, or to just suppress all of it.

Yeah. It would strengthen their case if that's what rule #7 actually said.

Of course, what rule 7 really says is that the JREF can use any of the data however it likes. It's doesn't say that ONLY the JREF can use the data, or that the JREF can tell you how to use the data.

If I give you a copy of a picture, then you can do with it whatever you'd like. That doesn't mean that I can't do as I like with the original.
 
Nex said:

Thank you for that. I had a quick look through that. Nobody expressing fear of the CIA that I saw. Nor expressing fear that the money is cursed. Perhaps they aren't top excuses after all.

The common theme in the reasons given were :

1) Randi doesn't test these thinks fairly or properly.

2) I know it's true and have no need to prove it to anyone else.

Those aseem to be the actual top reasons.
 
CFLarsen said:
I'm most willing to. All I need is evidence.

Evidence of what, Larsen?

You present this list as being the most common excuses for not taking the test.

I show you direct quotes from specific individuals, expressing THEIR reasons for not taking the test.

I have given you evidence that these ARE the top reasons given. You are welcome to disagree with those reasons if you want. Put them in your list, tell us why they are not valid excuses if you can find an answer.


Larsen, here's the point.
somebody has given their reasons gfor not taking the test thusly: "I have had no response from the Australian Sketpics, other than to invite me to the next round of testing of water dowsers. Presumably, they are going to ask the dowsers to detect bottles of water or pipes of water. It won't work, because that's not how dowsing works. I will contact them again and try to get a better response out of them. I will let you know how I get on. "

You say that you want "evidence" before you include that on your list, and answer it.

However, and this is the point that confuses me, your list already contains the claim that some people refuse the test because the money is cursed.

So, I presume that you already have evidence of that? Since you need evidence before you include an item on your list.
 
new drkitten said:

...
If I give you a copy of a picture, then you can do with it whatever you'd like. That doesn't mean that I can't do as I like with the original.

Well, not exactly. There may be copyright issues involved. However, if a proper release is signed (as would be expected with the JREF Challenge), then sure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom