Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

CFLarsen

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Aug 3, 2001
Messages
42,371
All too often, we get people complaining about the challenge. I thought it would be a good idea to compose this short list of snappy retorts. :)

I've paraphrased the excuses that I've seen people use.

<hr>

"James Randi makes a lot of money from this."

Completely irrelevant to your claim. Can you do it, yes or no?

"I was tested by X and that proves it."

Read the terms of the challenge. It specifically states that:
"Only an actual performance of the stated nature and scope, within the agreed-upon limits, will be accepted. Anecdotal accounts of previous events are not accepted or considered."

"James Randi judges the outcome/I want an independent judge."

Read the terms of the challenge. It specifically states that:
"Applicant must state clearly in advance, and applicant and JREF will agree upon, what powers or abilities will be demonstrated, the limits of the proposed demonstration (so far as time, location and other variables are concerned) and what will constitute both a positive and a negative result."
"All tests are designed with the participation and approval of the applicant."
and
"No part of the testing procedure may be changed in any way without the agreement of all parties concerned."

"James Randi won't let me take the challenge."

It would depend on the reason, but these are the ones I can think of right now:
  • The person does not have an ability, but a videotape, picture, or the like.
    "Only an actual performance of the stated nature and scope, within the agreed-upon limits, will be accepted. Anecdotal accounts of previous events are not accepted or considered."
  • The person will endanger himself or others.
    "JREF will also NOT test claims that are likely to cause injury of any sort, such as those involving the withholding of air, food or water, or the use of illicit materials, drugs, or dangerous devices."
  • The person hasn't filled out a notarized application.
    "Only complete agreement with these rules will allow the "applicant" to become a "claimant." Applicant, by signing, notarizing and submitting this form, signifies agreement with all of the above rules."
  • It is a phenomenon that JREF simply doesn't test for.
    "JREF will NOT accept claims of the existence of deities or demons/angels, the validity of exorcism, religious claims, divine healing, cloudbusting, causing the Sun to rise or the stars to move, etc."

<hr>

Others?
 
"JREF will NOT accept claims of the existence of deities or demons/angels, the validity of exorcism, religious claims, divine healing, cloudbusting, causing the Sun to rise or the stars to move, etc."



Why is divine healing not allowed?

Wouldn't be all sorts of extraordinary healing be a valid claim, as long as the performing of the healing is not dangerous according to known medical science?

Especially the explanation behind whatever is irrelevant, so divine healing is as valid as healing through aura massage.

Maybe you took this quote a bit out of context and its refering to some special and foolish healing claim.

Carn
 
Carn said:
"JREF will NOT accept claims of the existence of deities or demons/angels, the validity of exorcism, religious claims, divine healing, cloudbusting, causing the Sun to rise or the stars to move, etc."



Why is divine healing not allowed?

Wouldn't be all sorts of extraordinary healing be a valid claim, as long as the performing of the healing is not dangerous according to known medical science?

Especially the explanation behind whatever is irrelevant, so divine healing is as valid as healing through aura massage.

Maybe you took this quote a bit out of context and its refering to some special and foolish healing claim.

Carn

I don't know why divine healing is not accepted. You'll have to ask Randi.

All I am attempting here is giving a quick way of answering the most common excuses. If you think I quoted out of context, look at the rules yourself and explain how it can be done better.
 
Do we really want to encourage formulaic responses? There's a whole bunch of people out there that already assume we're just a bunch of Randi apologists. I think the last thing we want is the appearance of JREF talking points.
 
I'm surprised you missed:

"He doesn't have the money"

"I don't do this for personal gain"

"Some things just can't be quantified by your limited scientific methods"
 
Dogwood said:
Do we really want to encourage formulaic responses? There's a whole bunch of people out there that already assume we're just a bunch of Randi apologists. I think the last thing we want is the appearance of JREF talking points.

There is nothing apologistic about it, quite contrary. You will notice that the bulk of the snappy retorts consists of direct quotes from the stated terms. That way, there are no interpretations. And no wiggling from those complaining.

If you want clarity, you have to boil it down. It also helps you remembering it. Simplify, clarify, cut through the crap.
 
My favorite one is Sylvia Browne's stuff about the JREF money being tainted and evil. She can't even give it to charity, you see, because it would carry with it the Curse Of Randi. But why can't she give it to someone she really dislikes? There must be some way for her to funnel the evil money to al Qaida. She offers them a million dollars, they take it, they shrivel up and die. What holds her back? Alternatively, in my capacity as witch doctor, I could de-curse the money for her. I'll take ten percent, I'm not greedy.
 
Dr Adequate,

Good one! That excuse has been used by Danish clairvoyant Gitte Walther as well.

<hr>

"The money is tainted. It will only bring misery and pain."

That is ludicrous: You don't get a million dollars in cash, the sum is transferred electronically from one account to another, precisely as is being done millions of times each day all over the world.

How do you know that the money you get for your services hasn't been in touch with a skeptic? (If the answer is: "I can feel it", then we have a testable claim! :))

<hr>
 
Originally posted by CFLarsen
How do you know that the money you get for your services hasn't been in touch with a skeptic?
URRRGH!!! It almost certainly has. And this is what's wrong with the world: everyone is using evil money. We shall have to switch to a cashless economy, except that, as any fundie will tell you, this will bring about the reign of the Antichrist. There's always a snag, eh?
 
Damn! I was really hoping for something along the lines of Mad Magazines "Snappy answers to stupid questions"

They were witty, and often sarcastic. More along the lines of:

"James Randi makes a lot of money from this."

No he doesn't! He doesn't even have enough money to replace all the cutlery Uri Geller keeps bending.

or:

"James Randi won't let me take the challenge."

Not until you take a bath.


OK, so these aren't too great, but do you really call:

Read the terms of the challenge. It specifically states that:

quote:"Applicant must state clearly in advance, and applicant and JREF will agree upon, what powers or abilities will be demonstrated, the limits of the proposed demonstration (so far as time, location and other variables are concerned) and what will constitute both a positive and a negative result."


quote:"All tests are designed with the participation and approval of the applicant."


and

quote:"No part of the testing procedure may be changed in any way without the agreement of all parties concerned."

snappy?
 
Tesserat said:
Damn! I was really hoping for something along the lines of Mad Magazines "Snappy answers to stupid questions"

Sorry, but I don't have the wit of A. E. Neuman! :)

Tesserat said:
"James Randi makes a lot of money from this."

No he doesn't! He doesn't even have enough money to replace all the cutlery Uri Geller keeps bending.

or:

"James Randi won't let me take the challenge."

Not until you take a bath.

I see your point, but hardly ones that could be called serious! :)

Tesserat said:

"Thorough", then. "Read the challenge" comes first, and then, the longer explanation.
 
Patricio Elicer said:
- Randi is just a magician, what does he know?

- Spiritual powers and money don't mix

Good ones!

"Randi is just a magician, what does he know?"

That's the perfect occupation to reveal possible trickery - which the paranormal world is full of. And he calls in scientists and statisticians, too.

"Spiritual powers and money don't mix."

Then, why do psychics, dowsers, etc. charge often exorbitant amounts of money?
Why do they sell books and go on lectures?
If they are only doing it to cover the basic expenses, why not give the money to charity?
 
TheBoyPaj said:
I'm surprised you missed:

"He doesn't have the money"

"I don't do this for personal gain"

"Some things just can't be quantified by your limited scientific methods"

Sorry, didn't see these.

<hr>

"He doesn't have the money."

The Foundation has: http://www.skepticreport.com/images/investmentaccount.gif

If you want a copy yourself, contact JREF.

"I don't do this for personal gain"

Then give the money to charity. There are literally billions who could use the money, and you can do so much with a million dollars! The Red Cross will be kissing your feet!

"Some things just can't be quantified by your limited scientific methods"

1. Then how do you distinguish between a real phenomenon and one that is not?

2. We don't even need scientific methods. If it can be shown to exist, then you win the money.

<hr>
 
"I can only perform when no sceptic is

1 Involved in the experimental design
2 Offering me large sums of money
3 In any way involved in the testing process
4 Interested in the outcome
5 Anywhere on the face of the earth

because their Evil Vibrations negate my powers."

(By the way, if it is, in fact, our scepticism alone which prevents people from being psychic, we should get sponsorship from casinos.)

If only someone would offer me a million dollars to demonstrate, for half an hour, that I have the abilities which I claim to have and am paid for having. Why is it only psychics who find this offer offensive?
 
I saw one on another thread claiming that Randi wouldn't pay out because he wants to keep the interest for himself in case he has health issues as he gets older.

Snappy response:

If you flat out disbelieve that Randi will just refuse ever to pay out the money then I guess you'd better apply, and get rejected.

Then get repeatedly tested by other scientists in repeatable observable peer-reviewed experiments.
Display your ability clearly and obviously over and over.
Make millions and millions in media appearances.
Then you will have the satisfaction of having dramatically increased our knowledge of the universe, and have made Randi and the JREF look silly.

Because, lest we forget, James Randi isn't teh only person in the world who would be interested in testing for paranormal powers. He just pays the best for two sessions, which is why he gets all the claims.




Okay, not that snappy, I admit.
 
"I can only perform if no sceptic is in any way involved in the experimental design/testing process"

That will rule out any controls: That is not a test, that is a stamp of approval from your friends or people who don't know how to detect trickery. Completely unacceptable.

"I can only perform if a skeptic offers me large sums of money."

One million dollars, from a huge skeptic: Randi. Get on with it, then.

"I can only perform when no sceptic is present because their Evil Vibrations negate my powers."

That's a claim unto itself: If you can detect whether there's a skeptic in a room, then you win a million dollars.




Dr Adequate said:
4 Interested in the outcome

I don't understand 4.
 
Ashles said:
Okay, not that snappy, I admit.

<hr>

"Randi will never pay, because he depends on the income."

All you need to do is do what you claim you can do. If you get rejected, offer to be tested by everyone else, under controlled conditions, at any time, anywhere. Then, you will not only have dramatically increased our knowledge of the universe, you will also have made Randi look silly.

<hr>

A little better... ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom