I am back from breakfast which the good wife will not brook any delay when she calls, otherwise she will pick up everything and get herself ready to leave the house for work.
And during breakfast I had an enlightenment. I remember suddenly that in college with the class in what we might call psychology 101, there was mention of the phenomenon of human thinking and behaving which is called denial syndrome.
So, that is the explanation for why Buddhists and also starting with Buddha the master himself could not and would not accept the existence of the self, when everyone else from the lowly street sweeper to the richest man on earth (Bill Gates?), to the mightiest man on earth (George Bush?), accept it and live with it, and exert their utmost efforts to cope with it -- because Buddhists find the self too painful to accept.
In the nation in which I live, the vast majority of people believe in god and a created earth.
Should I chose to believe in them because they do?
I suggest that you take the time to answer the following question:
Where is the self and what it is composed of?
again,
What is the self and what is it compsoed of.
The fact that most children in the US believe in Santa Claus does not make him exist. Nor does the fact that a suprising number of people believe in the after life make it so.
That is the fallacy of populism, you are in denial of the fact that the self does not exist.
And it could not be otherwise for them, seeing that the only insight to life they entertain, and thereby their fundamental principle declares categorically, that all life is suffering; when everyone else knows that all life is not suffering but there are also a lot of joys and pleasures to life, and life is getting better and better as we face it and work to make it better -- in any way you care to understand better so that life is better for you -- i.e.,to keep alive better and to get on in life better, and maybe one day to live indefinitely, or to be able to come back from death -- which is not impossible, if we would define life as we must in order to know what kind of life we want to live for indefinite duration, or to restore when it is extinguished.
You can believe in all those things and do all those things and not believe that there is a transcendant self.
------------------
"...but that it may be that our perseption of a self as the overarching connection between the things does not exist."
That may be indicates the psychological hesitation, or reluctance, or even resistance to accept the existence of the self, and be liberated from all kinds of difficulties with the fact of admission on the one hand, but edging it with reservation and qualification, on the other.
Actualy it was an attempt to use polite speech, which I will continue to do, I have extended you the coutesy of reading your words and thinking upon them, I believe that you have not extended me the same courtesy.
In all things sceptical:
It is the burden of the one who believes in the existance of something to provide proof!
You have not proven that a self exist.
The burden is on you.
One very radical axiom of skeptical criticism is KISS, meaning in the present context, keep it simple and short, in dealing with a philosophy of life.
And the self is extraneous, there is a body, thoughts, emotions,perceptions and habits. No need for the self, if you wish to keep it simple.
Why don't you just say, I mean the Buddhists here, that there is a self and we love to keep it lasting as long as we can succeed in keeping it around and functional; and that sometimes we are weary of the self for it is a limited entity in terms of what we desire of it and life, but we will not let the frustration of unrealistic desires overcome us so that we give up on life, or indulge in a self-defeatist attitude.
If you had read the previous posts you would already know that the interpretation of annatta is un-needed in following the eightfold path. I see no reason compelling or otherwise to believe that a self that transcends the five skanhas exists. I am open to learning, so what exists beyond the five skandhas ?
Our determination should be: We will simply take of the good in the self and in life and bear with the ills that come along with the limitations and deficiencies of self and life, instead of denying the existence of the self altogether, but futilely and to no purpose whatsoever except to feel so what? transcendental?
You are free to choose your beliefs as I am, if you show your self open to understanding, then I might explain to you the reasons I find the principle of annatta to be useful. However so far I see that it would be pointless.
For myself the doctors are referring to the body when they use the word self in the question,"How did you shoot yourself?" Suppose you tell me if you had accidentally shot yourself and gone to the hospital, and the doctors asked you, "How did you shoot yourself?"
The body is one of the five skandhas.
By law you mean law as in the law against infringement of copyright and patent?
The way I see it, there is no law as understood in the example above where there are no human interactions. What do you think?
So perhaps there may be no self beyond the five skandhas?
An organization as for example a sports club is an entity created by convention of the members forming it, and given legal existence by the government for the purpose of safeguarding and enforcing all transactions, entered into by the members acting as a collectivity with other human entities like human individuals or other such similar collectivities.
Does such an organization continue to exist when the members do not engage in interactions among themselves and with outsiders, or even when all the members should cease to exist as when they should all die the biological death of the self?
We have to consult legal experts in corporations law, but I seem to know of a general principle in corporate law or similar such laws governing similar or analogous collectivities, that such an entity does not cease automatically unless the government gives it a certificate of dissolution or termination, what we might see as some sort of certificate of death. (Correct me legal experts here if I am mistaken.)
Such an organization is a moral self as distinct from a natural self, but it has real existence in the sense that it can transact acts with other moral or natural selves with binding force like transactions between purely natural selves.
And the self which is the focus of annatta is the 'moral' self, the five skanhas comprise the 'natural' self.
Annata states that there is no self that is beyond the body, thoughts, feelings, perceptions and habits.
We are talking about the body as the self in regard to the human body, one with a head and limbs and organs functioning, a natural body. This kind of a self-body is not a creation of humans getting together to create a moral body like the sports club or even a huge collectivity like a country or a political state.
A human body is a self for all purposes of self until it is bereft of life signs and such signs can't no longer be restored with today's science and technology; it is still a self even should only the brain of such a natural self/body alone remains and survives in some nourishing fluids if brain waves can still be detected.
No, there is no essential identity between a natural human body and a country.
Well I suggest that most people confuse the self and conflate it with transcendant principles.
The self that does not exist is the one that surpasses the five skandhas.
[/quote]
I think both you and I can prove the existence of a self, a human natural self that is, by the pinching test, pinch whoever is beside you and ask him to pinch you in return.
[/quote]
And so again do all those actions fall within the five skandhas, there is no self beyond them in the examples.
Do you agrre that there might only be bodies, thoughts, feelings, perceptions and habits in that example?
An orchestra is a moral self but it is already present even before the arrival of the concert goers and after their departure it is still present, as long as the natural selves making up the orchestra remain in the hall; and even when they leave the hall, as long as the members thereof are related together by their convention or agreement and specially when the government grants it a legal existence.
-------------
I suggest most heartily that Buddhists dwell most intensely and with the maximum of concentration on the topic of denial syndrome and apply the fruits of their meditation to Buddhist non-self.
I think that you should look in a mirror and say the same to yourself. So far all you have done is misquote all buddhist principles and ignore all the explanations that have been given, Mr Kettle meet Mr. Pot.
Yes, I agree with you completely and unreservedly in those lines from you which I put in bold.
Yrreg
Then you should apply those lines to your belief that there is a self that extends beyond the five skandhas!
PS You are misquoting and misinterpreting the buddha, where did the buddha teach that all life is suffering, your ignorance becomes you.