Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

"If you meet the Buddha, kill him!" - Zen Saying, meaning that once you have understood the Dharma, the Buddha is no longer needed and should be discarded. Once you've reached your destination, the guide and the map is of no further use.

Hello, all. I've been lurking on this thread the whole time and this reminded me of something I've heard. Ryokan can probably answer this.

An expression I've heard before, and really like is "Kill your parents, kill your god, kill your teacher." Basically, a rather violent way of saying "think for yourself." I guess it also goes along with how you (Ryokan) define "enlightenment."

Just wondering, is this expression from Buddhism and/or Zen? Just curious.

I'll go back to lurking now.:)
 
Speaking from reference works.

What pseudoscience is there in Buddhism? What is the supernatural elements of Buddhism? -- Ryokan

My information about Buddhism is essentially from reference works, and I prefer works which are succinct, which give me views or reports in broad strokes.

It might not do justice to Buddhism or any system but it is reliable, just as if you look down on the earth from a satellite you see lands and seas, although when you get down to the earth's surface not all seas are wet and not all lands are dry.

That is why for specific points I have to depend as I said several times already, on Buddhists who are deep into Buddhism: the texts, the literature, their own reflections and convictions, and their own attempts to express Buddhist thoughts and practices in words common to speakers and inquirers, like English (for English we must admit does possess a wealth more than sufficient to convey whatever of concepts and theories Buddhism holds however deep in its bosom).

So, what do I say about this question from Ryokan, on my opinion:

What pseudoscience is there in Buddhism? What is the supernatural elements of Buddhism? -- Ryokan​


Oops, the wife calls for lunch; so time to go, but I will be back. I love so much to discuss in message boards such matters as Buddhist self and rebirths and Nirvana, I should have become a Buddhist monk in a Buddhist monastery, then I would have all the time to be absorbed in message boards when the community acts are done and over with.

Not that simple and easy, brother. No?


Yrreg
 
I am engaged in an exercise of skeptical criticism.


Buddhism the religion and the Buddhism the philosophy is an disingenuous distinction. The way I see it, when someone calls himself by another man's name, like calling oneself Buddhist or Randian, there is already the element of religion in the worship of a human who has some speculated insight into life and knowledge not derived from the senses and logic, but from meditation and similar esoteric ways and means, like flash of enlightenment or revelation.

This is more assertion if you read the teachings of the buddha, you might understand that his teachings and the 'religion' which started later are not the same thing.


Buddhism the religion and the Buddhism the philosophy is an disingenuous distinction.


Oh, I see you make assertions that we don't agree with and you offer no proof or evidenca and we are just to agree with you I think not. The teachings of Jeshuah and his followers differ in many places , as do the teachings of Bohr and Einstien.

And again:
The buddha repeatedly taught that his teachings were to be examined by the individual, and if they were found to have merit then used.


there is already the element of religion in the worship of a human who has some speculated insight into life and knowledge not derived from the senses and logic, but from meditation and similar esoteric ways and means, like flash of enlightenment or revelation

The buddha did not teach that his enlightenment was derived from something beyond the senses and logic, buddhist meditation is not esoteric at all, it is a means of learning to be mindful.

Buddhist do not worship the buddha, no more than any one worships a teacher.
Call yourself an idealist, a solipsist, a dreamer, an empiricist, a skeptic, but not Buddhist, or Einsteinian, or Popperist, or Randian.

To quote a wise child:

Are you the boss of me?
I see that now you claim some sort of title to tell us what words we may use and not use.

Who and what supernatural power gave you that authority?

Feel free to say what you please, I will free to disagree.
The distinction between phiolosophic Buddhism and religious Buddhism is not known to Buddha; and it would do him discredit to introduce the distinction to his system of thought and behavior, accepting the one and rejecting the other.

Cite an authority and source, you claim that you are here to learn from buddhists and that you refuse to learn from the actual sources. Then you claim to use logic, reason and scepticism!

I suspect even more that you are some religous and philosophical fanatic here only to prattle on about your own misguided beliefs and how they are superior.

I hope that I am wrong.
There is literature in my messages, modesty aside, that is to say that I might give the impression of being against the person instead of his ideas.

mainly your posts seem to follow this pattern:
1. Bold assertions about buddhism.
2. Inability to support any statements that you make regarding the buddha and budddhism.
3. Further foolish assertions.
4. Statements that you do not need to study buddhism to make bogus assertions concerning it.
5. Continued assertion without merit , proof or evidence.
Ryokan is a very softspoken and mild poster here, and I have not yet said so, but I do admire his demeanor all throughout this thread so far, except on one occasion when he told someone to get out.

So, notwithstanding my impression to you that I tend to as you put it, "You ignore his answers and offer insults," I want to put it on record here that I do really hold his person in good esteem.

But if he is the softspoken and mild person that he is or has become, in this thread, it must be the practice of the eightfold paths and not the belief in the four noble truths.
It is not ever asserted that the noble truths are needed to follow the eightfold path, however so far you have misrepresented every aspect of the buddha's teaching , including the four truths.

The eightfold paths are nothing new in the history of wisdom thinking from mankind since the start of civilized settlement, they antedate Buddha and are universal with all peoples. The only hitch here is how people define what is right and what is wrong.

More assertion, do you have any proof!

1. That they pre-exist the buddha?
2. That the buddha ever claimed that he was the sole authority?

They were not taught by Zoroaster, nor the Greeks, nor the Taoists, nor were they taught by the Hinduva.

J'accuse: you just make things up.
About what I expect to get from skeptics in JREF and from CSICOP in the way of criticism on Buddhism the religion and Buddhism the philosophy, I am still very convinced that they are obviously treating Buddhism with kid's gloves; and if these skeptics behind both societies have solid high carat self-knowledge, I am sure they can come to the same self-enlightenment that they are not exercising their critical skepticism on Buddhism, as they have done so in regard to claims of paranormal powers by gifted people or pseudoscientists or proponents of supernatural system.

Then you have not read the post correctly, if the buddhists here claimed that the buddha taught reincarnation, then the sceptics would argue, if the buddhists here said that they could preform miracles then the sceptics would critique.

You are making this argument
1. Claim that all buddhists hold a belief.
2. Assertion that this belief is false.
3. When countered that it is not the teachin of the buddha, you merely switch to:
1.a. Claim that all buddhists hold another belief.
2.a. Assertions that this belief is false.

In summary:

When told that buddhism is a syncretic and diverse set of beliefs and practises you merely assert that it is monolithic.
When told that the teachings of the buddha do not agree with your statement about buddhism, you state that the teachings of the buddha do not matter.
When told that the teachings of the buddha and the practise of buddhism is diverse and varying, and that there are buddhists who practise irrational and nonsensical beliefs, you ignore the statements.
When asked to furnish proof of any statements you just ignore them.

Again you appear to be a religous zealot on a mission, I have had many a debate here on the teachings of the buddha, and many sceptics have participated in them

You are a religous apologist, looking to find your secret agenda.
My inclination is to suspect that Buddhism is a paranormal religion and a paranormal philosophy, as I have described these phrases earlier.

And if we who study the teachings of the buddha say other wise then you are the expert.

I bow to your Supreme Knowledge and Authority.

Where is your proof,where is your evidence?
Is Buddhism also a pseudoscience and is Buddhism also founded upon supernaturalism? I tend to suspect that there are elements of both in Buddhism.

yes there are, but they are not the teachings of the buddha, I suspect that you don'y know what buddhits believe at all, or what meditation is to a buddhist.
Why do I have such an interest in Buddhism? Well, it is embraced by many Westerners of the so-called intellectual type, but to my knowledge, it is being abandoned by peoples in the lands where Buddhism is the traditional religion -- but for the folk or national culture into which Buddhism is embedded inseparably.

And that is a phenomenon worthy of my curiosity; so I start with questions focusing on the intrinsic merits of Buddhism -- what's so hot in Buddhism or so cool in Buddhism?


Anyway, let's just all have a hahaha, okay?

And when you are told why some westerners are drawn to the teachings of the buddha what have you done, ignore them!

I am not laughing at you!
Yrreg

PS When I can come across more people who are of the same curiosity as I entertain, then I might come out with the psychological grounds why I am critical with Buddhism; for I am not into criticising Scientology even though Scientology must have also a lot of followers among Americans and Westerners, and Scientology has only a history of less than sixty years, but Scientology is to all appearances reeking of paranormality, pseudoscience and supernaturalism.

And when you care to discuss the paranormal aspects of the teachings of the buddha, then we will all be sceptical.

Are you critical of geology, yet refuse to read the texts of geology?
 
What pseudoscience is there in Buddhism? What is the supernatural elements of Buddhism? -- Ryokan

My information about Buddhism is essentially from reference works, and I prefer works which are succinct, which give me views or reports in broad strokes.

It might not do justice to Buddhism or any system but it is reliable, just as if you look down on the earth from a satellite you see lands and seas, although when you get down to the earth's surface not all seas are wet and not all lands are dry.

That is why for specific points I have to depend as I said several times already, on Buddhists who are deep into Buddhism: the texts, the literature, their own reflections and convictions, and their own attempts to express Buddhist thoughts and practices in words common to speakers and inquirers, like English (for English we must admit does possess a wealth more than sufficient to convey whatever of concepts and theories Buddhism holds however deep in its bosom).

So, what do I say about this question from Ryokan, on my opinion:

What pseudoscience is there in Buddhism? What is the supernatural elements of Buddhism? -- Ryokan​


Oops, the wife calls for lunch; so time to go, but I will be back. I love so much to discuss in message boards such matters as Buddhist self and rebirths and Nirvana, I should have become a Buddhist monk in a Buddhist monastery, then I would have all the time to be absorbed in message boards when the community acts are done and over with.

Not that simple and easy, brother. No?


Yrreg

And what are the sources you use and who wrote them, it would appear that you can't read the titles and type them into the computer, are you afraid?

Do you just study the sources that agree with your beliefs.

I am calling you out, an un-buddhist trait, what are your sources,
give citations and quote, do tell us where you get the wealth of misinformation you spout so readily.

I believe that you are a poseur, a religous zealot posing in the guise of a sceptic, you claim to be a sceptic but you act like a fundamentalist of some sort.

Prove me wrong, and I will rejoice in my learning!

What are your sources, who wrote them, when were they published, give us quotes and authors.

Show us!
 
How Buddhism could be pseudoscience and packed with supernaturalism.

Ryokan_#99 said:
Originally Posted by yrreg :
Buddhism also a pseudoscience and is Buddhism also founded upon supernaturalism? I tend to suspect that there are elements of both in Buddhism.​

What pseudoscience is there in Buddhism? What is the supernatural elements of Buddhism?

I'm a Buddhist, and I do not engage in pseudoscience, and I do not believe in the supernatural.

The complete quotation from me is the following:

Is Buddhism also a pseudoscience and is Buddhism also founded upon supernaturalism? I tend to suspect that there are elements of both in Buddhism. -- Yrreg in post #97​


Ryokan missed the first word of the quotation, Is; but it's all right, nothing disastrous to my thought.

Why do I suspect that Buddhism is a pseudoscience? Because from my reading about Buddhism from Buddhist enthusiasts I have come across their assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion. What is the experience of others who read accounts of Buddhism published in the web by Buddhist enthusiasts? have you come across such an assertion?

I can't find anything scientific in Buddhism, understanding scientific as referring to science in 2005. So, I think Buddhist enthusiasts who tell us that Buddhism is a scientific religion is making of Buddhism a pseudoscience.

Of course Buddhists here might ask me to produce instances in the web, of such an assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion from Buddhist enthusiasts; in which event I have to back off.

If they have never come across such an assertion, and I am not inclined to invest time and labor to look up such instances in the web; then I will just take back that statement that I encountered such an assertion in my reading about Buddhism in the web from Buddhist enthusiasts.

Let me however explain why I can't see anything scientific in Buddhism.

First, because it is a system of thought and behavior founded some 2500 years back in time, and there was then no such thing as science as we know it today. Is there a word in ancient Buddhist texts synonymous to science as we know science today?

Second, examining the four noble truths and the eight noble paths which are common to all Buddhists, I cannot see any science in them either. Here are the four noble truths and the eight noble paths of Buddhism:

From Columbia Encyclopedia:

Basic Beliefs and Practices [of Buddhism]

The basic doctrines of early Buddhism, which remain common to all Buddhism, include the "four noble truths": existence is suffering (dukhka); suffering has a cause, namely craving and attachment (trishna); there is a cessation of suffering, which is nirvana; and there is a path to the cessation of suffering, the "eightfold path" of right views, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration.
​


The way I see these truths and paths of Buddhism, they are ideas and counsels or even injunctions which I can't seriously call scientific, but moralistic and spiritualistic.

"Existence is suffering," that is not a scientific statement; maybe the following is a scientific statement: "Human existence is life."

Suffering is a moralistic concept, the scientific concept is pain: physical, emotional, or mental pain. Desire or "craving and attachment" is not the cause of suffering, frustration is the cause of suffering. Nirvana is not the cessation of suffering or pain; it's not scientific, what is scientific is anesthetics.

Let's not continue in this analysis for science in the four noble truths, because the concepts come from 2500 years back and they belong to a world still bereft of what we know as psychology today -- even though psychology is supposed to be a soft science as compared to physics and chemistry and biology, yet it is incomparably more scientific than the world pictured in the four noble truths. The four noble truths are purely moralistic and spiritualistic concepts, nothing scientific in them.

As regards the eight noble paths, here is where I can see the supernaturalism in Buddhism. How is that? Because what is right and what is wrong as observed among diverse peoples are what we call ethical prescriptions and proscriptions.

From a naturalistic examination they differ from people to people and change with the times, from considerations of social necessity, practicality, and concession to the liberty of individual person. In pre-scientific and pre-technological societies ethical prescriptions and proscriptions are also dictated by superstitious fears of unknown agents.

I can see that in the eight noble paths of Buddhism there is the unspoken but clearly discernible premise that these injunctions are not derived from human formulation, not from as I said considerations of social necessity and practicality, but from an agent above and beyond man's mind and heart.

Maybe the Buddhists here can tell me who or what is the author or cause or origin of these noble right paths? Perhaps they will say that it’s Gautama, the Buddha himself; but the alleged founder is believed to have told his disciples not to take him seriously, instead to use their own reason to find out for themselves what is true, implicitly what is right also.

No, Buddha to Buddha himself and to his disciples was just like any human, subject to errors and imperfections; so those injunctions about what is right could not have come from him unless he and his disciples would admit that they are not exactly flawless, not warranted to be completely trustworthy as the right paths to what is right.

The Buddhists here might tell me that these right paths have always been there in the cosmic universe, just as the cycle of rebirths for humans has always been there since from eternity but of course until all mankind reaches Nirvana.

But there is a big difficulty in this construct, namely, we know now that mankind has not been in the cosmos except only in this late late split second of the present time in cosmic history. Even ancient thinkers not into esoteric speculations know that man has not been in the cosmos since from whenever in distant past the cosmos started if ever it had a beginning.

However, granting but not conceding that human existence has been present from the very foundation of the cosmos that is the physical universe, and all Buddhists believe in the eternal cycle of rebirths for each individual (I don’t know for a certainty about Ryokan, because someone here says that Ryokan is a philosophic Buddhist and not a religious Buddhist) until he reaches Nirvana, by adhering to the four noble truths and practicing the eight noble paths; my question is who or what is operating this system or rebirths and determining who among humans have already filled up his quota of right thoughts and activities as to merit entrance to or arrival in Nirvana.

Whoever or whatever is keeping records and checking them twice must be above the cosmos and be in charge of it; and that I would consider to be a supernatural aspect of Buddhism.

The Buddhists here will tell me that on the contrary there is no need to postulate an agent above nature in charge of the cycle of rebirths and keeping records of who is still unfit for Nirvana, and who is ripe and thereby to be liberated from the cycle of rebirths; because recurring rebirths and the final transit to Nirvana are all parts and parcels of the whole system of a process which is the whole cosmos.

Now, that I cannot accept because I for one maintain that the scenario for that kind of a process cosmos does not account for what I will insist is the distinction between the physical order and the moral order; that kind of a scenario would mix the two orders into some kind of an amalgam. Let me explain.

The physical order is that of stars, planets, matter, energy, elements, molecules, while the moral order has to do with human persons bound by themselves and among themselves to do what is right in dealing with fellow human persons. Human persons can all disappear in a nuclear holocaust suddenly and quickly, or in time ultimately end up as an extinct species as other life species have ended up; but the physical universe would continue to go on and on without so much as any infinitely brief disruption in its course.

I think that is the supernatural in Buddhism, the mixture of the physical and the moral orders with the unspoken but clearly deductible superordinaton of the moral over the physical –- owing to the doctrine in brief that all universe will end up in Nirvana.


Summing up: Yes, I do suspect very seriously that first Buddhism has its facet of a pseudoscience, and second that Buddhism has elements of the supernatural.


Yrreg
 
Well, you're absolutely right, Buddhists are just like everyone else, including all their faults.

Then, therefore, claims in Buddhism are just as amenable to skeptical examination as anyone else's.
 
Why do I suspect that Buddhism is a pseudoscience? Because from my reading about Buddhism from Buddhist enthusiasts I have come across their assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion. What is the experience of others who read accounts of Buddhism published in the web by Buddhist enthusiasts? have you come across such an assertion?

Apart from the massive amount of Newagey bulltreacle attempting to link Buddhism to Quantum Mechanics or some such (which I would not blame on Buddhists any more [or any less] than I would blame newspaper horoscopes on astrologers), I don't think I've ever seen a flat-out claim that it is a scientific religion.

I've seen claims that it isn't a religion but rather a philosophy, but I don't think that's right. The claim is often made on the basis that it doesn't necessarily have gods, but to me, the prime characteristic of a religion is a strong emphasis on something that is ineffable, that is, cannot be described directly and is also not easily experienced. The ineffability itself is not sufficient; there must also be a strong emphasis on the ineffable as important. Buddhism does this in spades; some Buddhists put high value on the ineffability itself.

I have seen some statements by Buddhists that are pseudoscientific, such as that karma and dharma are descriptions of a scientific law of cause and effect. The trouble with this is that, while cause-and-effect might have been a basic assumption in the 19th century, it isn't now. In fact, some of the most exciting work up until about 1970 is in what can only be described as acausality. That claim, at least, is pseudoscientific.

Of course, at this point, we'll usually get into a NARB phenomenon ("Not A Real Buddhist").
 
Why do I suspect that Buddhism is a pseudoscience? Because from my reading about Buddhism from Buddhist enthusiasts I have come across their assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion. What is the experience of others who read accounts of Buddhism published in the web by Buddhist enthusiasts? have you come across such an assertion?

I've come across discussions of Buddhism and science on a number of occassions. I haven't seen anyone explicitly claim that Buddhism and science are synonymous. I have seen people claim that Buddhism has central tenants that are open to testing and falsification, thus making it more compatible with science than other religions.

Suffering is a moralistic concept, the scientific concept is pain: physical, emotional, or mental pain. Desire or "craving and attachment" is not the cause of suffering, frustration is the cause of suffering. Nirvana is not the cessation of suffering or pain; it's not scientific, what is scientific is anesthetics.

We suffer because what we desire cannot be accommodated by reality: the two jar and so we experience suffering. For instance when I am in pain I want that pain to go away and I suffer because it will not. Pain is neutral, it is neither good or bad, it is simply sensory input.

Frustration is suffering (it is dukkha) and it occurs because my desire for something cannot be fulfilled. In the end all suffering comes back to the conflict between what I want and what in reality I can actually have.

Nirvana is a state of being free from dukkha, it is not absence of sensation. Once someone has attained nirvana their actions are no longer driven by the desire to avoid suffering. They have achieved that and so are free to act in a way that those of us still bound to the wheel are not.

I can see that in the eight noble paths of Buddhism there is the unspoken but clearly discernible premise that these injunctions are not derived from human formulation, not from as I said considerations of social necessity and practicality, but from an agent above and beyond man's mind and heart.

Maybe the Buddhists here can tell me who or what is the author or cause or origin of these noble right paths? Perhaps they will say that it’s Gautama, the Buddha himself; but the alleged founder is believed to have told his disciples not to take him seriously, instead to use their own reason to find out for themselves what is true, implicitly what is right also.

I don't think the Buddha ever told his followers not to take him seriously. He did tell them to treat what he said with scepticism and to test it for themselves rather than accepting it as true simply because he said so.

The Four Noble Truths are part of the Dharma, the description of the way underlying operation of the universe interacts with human experience. They have always existed but someone had to have the right experiences and ask the right questions for them to be discovered. They were not revealed to the Buddha, he uncovered them.

However, granting but not conceding that human existence has been present from the very foundation of the cosmos that is the physical universe, and all Buddhists believe in the eternal cycle of rebirths for each individual (I don’t know for a certainty about Ryokan, because someone here says that Ryokan is a philosophic Buddhist and not a religious Buddhist) until he reaches Nirvana, by adhering to the four noble truths and practicing the eight noble paths; my question is who or what is operating this system or rebirths and determining who among humans have already filled up his quota of right thoughts and activities as to merit entrance to or arrival in Nirvana.

Whoever or whatever is keeping records and checking them twice must be above the cosmos and be in charge of it; and that I would consider to be a supernatural aspect of Buddhism.

The Buddhists here will tell me that on the contrary there is no need to postulate an agent above nature in charge of the cycle of rebirths and keeping records of who is still unfit for Nirvana, and who is ripe and thereby to be liberated from the cycle of rebirths; because recurring rebirths and the final transit to Nirvana are all parts and parcels of the whole system of a process which is the whole cosmos.

Now, that I cannot accept because I for one maintain that the scenario for that kind of a process cosmos does not account for what I will insist is the distinction between the physical order and the moral order; that kind of a scenario would mix the two orders into some kind of an amalgam. Let me explain.

The physical order is that of stars, planets, matter, energy, elements, molecules, while the moral order has to do with human persons bound by themselves and among themselves to do what is right in dealing with fellow human persons. Human persons can all disappear in a nuclear holocaust suddenly and quickly, or in time ultimately end up as an extinct species as other life species have ended up; but the physical universe would continue to go on and on without so much as any infinitely brief disruption in its course.

I think that is the supernatural in Buddhism, the mixture of the physical and the moral orders with the unspoken but clearly deductible superordinaton of the moral over the physical –- owing to the doctrine in brief that all universe will end up in Nirvana.


Summing up: Yes, I do suspect very seriously that first Buddhism has its facet of a pseudoscience, and second that Buddhism has elements of the supernatural.


Yrreg

I don't think many of the Buddhists here believe in a literal cycle of birth and rebirth over a number of lifetimes. I suspect most of us are philosophical Buddhists rather than religious ones. I'm sure most of us would agree that a lot of the religious accretions around Buddhist practice and belief are superstitious mumbo-jumbo.

Buddhism is atheistic; it requires no gods or supernatural forces. It contends that karma, which drives all human existence, is a natural law. Karma does not keep records it simply reflects the way our actions and omissions play out over time.

Buddhism is only relevant to sentient beings. While there are schools of Buddhism that believe that eventually all living things will attain nirvana this is not a universal belief.

If the thrust of your argument was that some Buddhists have silly beliefs that cannot stand up to examination then I suspect most of the Buddhists here would agree with you. Your weakness is that you are attacking the fundemental aspects of Buddhism and I think all you've demonstrated so far is a lack of understanding of the subject.
 
Why do I suspect that Buddhism is a pseudoscience? Because from my reading about Buddhism from Buddhist enthusiasts I have come across their assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion. What is the experience of others who read accounts of Buddhism published in the web by Buddhist enthusiasts? have you come across such an assertion?

Where did you read this? Who haw claimed this? Actually, I have never come across tge claim that Buddhism is a 'scientific' religion.

I can't find anything scientific in Buddhism, understanding scientific as referring to science in 2005. So, I think Buddhist enthusiasts who tell us that Buddhism is a scientific religion is making of Buddhism a pseudoscience.

Maybe it's not about hard science, but what about the soft sciences, like psychology? Gautama Buddha's contemporaries called him a doctor of the mind.

Of course Buddhists here might ask me to produce instances in the web, of such an assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion from Buddhist enthusiasts; in which event I have to back off.

How nice of you to admit that you can't reference your claims. Does that mean you withdraw them?

If they have never come across such an assertion, and I am not inclined to invest time and labor to look up such instances in the web; then I will just take back that statement that I encountered such an assertion in my reading about Buddhism in the web from Buddhist enthusiasts.

How nice of you. I have never come across anyone claiming that Buddhism is a scientific religion. If anyone did, I would ask them what they mean by that. So I guess this claim is laid to rest now?

Let me however explain why I can't see anything scientific in Buddhism.

I guess not, then. So you have no evidence for your claims, but you're going ahead with them anyway? What kind of sceptic are you?

First, because it is a system of thought and behavior founded some 2500 years back in time, and there was then no such thing as science as we know it today. Is there a word in ancient Buddhist texts synonymous to science as we know science today?

Was Pythagoras science? Was Archimedes? How long ago did they live? The age alone does not mean that there's no scientific value in it.

I have not come across the word 'science' in any Buddhist text. The closest would have to be 'knowledge'. But Buddhism makes no claims about science, except an understanding of the human mind when it comes to suffering and attachments. The human mind has not changed in 2500 years.

Second, examining the four noble truths and the eight noble paths which are common to all Buddhists, I cannot see any science in them either. Here are the four noble truths and the eight noble paths of Buddhism:

From Columbia Encyclopedia:

Basic Beliefs and Practices [of Buddhism]

The basic doctrines of early Buddhism, which remain common to all Buddhism, include the "four noble truths": existence is suffering (dukhka); suffering has a cause, namely craving and attachment (trishna); there is a cessation of suffering, which is nirvana; and there is a path to the cessation of suffering, the "eightfold path" of right views, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration.
​

No there's no hard science in them, we agree on that. Buddhism does not explain how the universe works, how life began, or anything like that. That has got nothing to do with Buddhism.

The way I see these truths and paths of Buddhism, they are ideas and counsels or even injunctions which I can't seriously call scientific, but moralistic and spiritualistic.

Why would you call them moralistic or spiritual?

"Existence is suffering," that is not a scientific statement; maybe the following is a scientific statement: "Human existence is life."

A more correct translation of the first Noble Truth would be 'there is suffering'. And there is suffering, isn't there? The entire goal of the first Noble Truth is to make you aware that there is suffering. It lays the foundation for the rest of the truths.

If it's a scientific statement would really depend on your definition of a scientific statement.

Suffering is a moralistic concept, the scientific concept is pain: physical, emotional, or mental pain. Desire or "craving and attachment" is not the cause of suffering, frustration is the cause of suffering. Nirvana is not the cessation of suffering or pain; it's not scientific, what is scientific is anesthetics.

Suffering is a moralistic concept? You really have to explain that one to me. And I hope you do.

You say frustration is the cause of suffering, and the Four Noble Truths agree. However, frustration comes from craving and attachment, without those there would be no frustration. That's what the Four Noble Truths are all about!

Let's not continue in this analysis for science in the four noble truths, because the concepts come from 2500 years back and they belong to a world still bereft of what we know as psychology today -- even though psychology is supposed to be a soft science as compared to physics and chemistry and biology, yet it is incomparably more scientific than the world pictured in the four noble truths. The four noble truths are purely moralistic and spiritualistic concepts, nothing scientific in them.

Yes, let's cease this attack upon the poor strawman.

But again I ask, what do you mean by moralistic and spiritual? I'm sorry, but I just don't get it.

As regards the eight noble paths, here is where I can see the supernaturalism in Buddhism. How is that? Because what is right and what is wrong as observed among diverse peoples are what we call ethical prescriptions and proscriptions.

They are supernatural because they are ethical prescriptions and proscriptions? I'm sorry, this definition of supernatural is new to me.

Please explain how the eightfold path is supernatural. Please explain how they are 'ethical prescriptiond and proscriptions'. I just don't get it.

From a naturalistic examination they differ from people to people and change with the times, from considerations of social necessity, practicality, and concession to the liberty of individual person. In pre-scientific and pre-technological societies ethical prescriptions and proscriptions are also dictated by superstitious fears of unknown agents.

I agree with half of this section, as does Buddhism.

But the other half? Evidence?

If Buddha gave us some advice on how to live, that's supernatural because he lived 2500 years ago? But if someone today gave the same advice, they wouldn't be? Maybe I misunderstand, and that's not what you're saying. In that case, please correct me and tell me what you mean.

I can see that in the eight noble paths of Buddhism there is the unspoken but clearly discernible premise that these injunctions are not derived from human formulation, not from as I said considerations of social necessity and practicality, but from an agent above and beyond man's mind and heart.

Surely you are joking? Would you care to point out where in the eightfold path you see this?

Maybe the Buddhists here can tell me who or what is the author or cause or origin of these noble right paths? Perhaps they will say that it’s Gautama, the Buddha himself; but the alleged founder is believed to have told his disciples not to take him seriously, instead to use their own reason to find out for themselves what is true, implicitly what is right also.

The origin of the eightfold path is Siddharta Gautama, also called the Buddha.

The Buddha asked us to be sceptical of all things, including his own teachings. The Buddha did not want sheep who followed him out of blind faith. Buddhism is not a faith religion.

No, Buddha to Buddha himself and to his disciples was just like any human, subject to errors and imperfections; so those injunctions about what is right could not have come from him unless he and his disciples would admit that they are not exactly flawless, not warranted to be completely trustworthy as the right paths to what is right.

Yes, the Buddha was just a man of flesh and blood, just like you and me.

But you use this as evidence for him not coming up with the Four Noble Truths, and thus they are supernatural? Because the Buddha was human, his ideas are therefore by definition flawed?

The Buddhists here might tell me that these right paths have always been there in the cosmic universe, just as the cycle of rebirths for humans has always been there since from eternity but of course until all mankind reaches Nirvana.

The Buddhists here might tell you? Are you a psychic now? Are you going to apply for the million?

But there is a big difficulty in this construct, namely, we know now that mankind has not been in the cosmos except only in this late late split second of the present time in cosmic history. Even ancient thinkers not into esoteric speculations know that man has not been in the cosmos since from whenever in distant past the cosmos started if ever it had a beginning.

Has the Buddha claimed otherwise?

However, granting but not conceding that human existence has been present from the very foundation of the cosmos that is the physical universe, and all Buddhists believe in the eternal cycle of rebirths for each individual (I don’t know for a certainty about Ryokan, because someone here says that Ryokan is a philosophic Buddhist and not a religious Buddhist) until he reaches Nirvana, by adhering to the four noble truths and practicing the eight noble paths; my question is who or what is operating this system or rebirths and determining who among humans have already filled up his quota of right thoughts and activities as to merit entrance to or arrival in Nirvana.

Sigh. Right back at where we started.

Buddhists does no not acknowledge or believe in a 'self' or a soul, so what is it that is reborn? Yrreg will cease to exist when he dies. So will Ryokan. And so did the Buddha.

It's not a literal rebirth of self, nothing is passed on of Yrreg from this life to the next. You're dead.

However, it's your actions that live on, your karma. What Yrreg does in this life will have repercussions in the future. What this generation plants, the next generation will harvest.

If there's one thing the Four Noble Truths, the core of Buddhism, teaches, it's the impermanence of everything.

No one is 'operating' this system, it just is.

Whoever or whatever is keeping records and checking them twice must be above the cosmos and be in charge of it; and that I would consider to be a supernatural aspect of Buddhism.

You have yet to show evicence that Buddhism believes any such thing.

The Buddhists here will tell me that on the contrary there is no need to postulate an agent above nature in charge of the cycle of rebirths and keeping records of who is still unfit for Nirvana, and who is ripe and thereby to be liberated from the cycle of rebirths; because recurring rebirths and the final transit to Nirvana are all parts and parcels of the whole system of a process which is the whole cosmos.

Psychic once again?

All I can say is that you don't understand the concept of Buddhist rebirth. There's nothing supernatural about it.

Now, that I cannot accept because I for one maintain that the scenario for that kind of a process cosmos does not account for what I will insist is the distinction between the physical order and the moral order; that kind of a scenario would mix the two orders into some kind of an amalgam. Let me explain.

You don't accept it, and that's not a problem because that's not what Buddhism claims.

Buddhists don't talk much about rebirth, it's simply not an important concept in Buddhism. Buddhism is all about the here and now, and how to rid yourself of suffering and reach enlightenment in this life.

The physical order is that of stars, planets, matter, energy, elements, molecules, while the moral order has to do with human persons bound by themselves and among themselves to do what is right in dealing with fellow human persons. Human persons can all disappear in a nuclear holocaust suddenly and quickly, or in time ultimately end up as an extinct species as other life species have ended up; but the physical universe would continue to go on and on without so much as any infinitely brief disruption in its course.

I totally agree with this part. It's very Buddhist, nothing is permanent.

I think that is the supernatural in Buddhism, the mixture of the physical and the moral orders with the unspoken but clearly deductible superordinaton of the moral over the physical –- owing to the doctrine in brief that all universe will end up in Nirvana.

Of course you think that's the supernatural in Buddhis, you just invented it!

The universe will not 'end up' in Nirvana, unless it suddenly becomes sentient. Actually, no-one will end up there as it's not a place, but a state of mind.


Summing up: Yes, I do suspect very seriously that first Buddhism has its facet of a pseudoscience, and second that Buddhism has elements of the supernatural.


Yrreg

You have shown neither.
 
If the thrust of your argument was that some Buddhists have silly beliefs that cannot stand up to examination then I suspect most of the Buddhists here would agree with you. Your weakness is that you are attacking the fundemental aspects of Buddhism and I think all you've demonstrated so far is a lack of understanding of the subject.

Indeed.
 
The claim Buddhists make concerning science is not that Buddhism is scientific, but that Buddhism does not conflict with science. An example that comes to mind is an interview Carl Sagan recounts in 'The Demon Haunted World':
Carl Sagan's 'The Demon Haunted World'
pg 278

...In theological discussion with religious leaders ,I often ask what their response would be if a central tenet of their faith were disproved by science. When I put the question to the Fourteenth, Dalai Lama, he unhesitatingly replied as no conservative or fundamentalist religious leaders do: In such a case, he said, Tibetan Buddhism would have to change.

Even, I asked, if it's a really central tenet, like (I searched for an example) reincarnation?
Even then, he answered.
However-he added with a twinkle-it's going to be hard to disprove reincarnation.
Plainly the Dalai Lama is right. Religious doctrine that is insulated from disproof has little reason to worry about the advance of science...

...many religions-devoted to reverence, awe, ethics, ritual, community, family, charity, and political and economic justice - are in no way challenged, but rather uplifted, by the findings of science. There is no necessary conflict between science and religion... - Carl Sagan ibid pg 277

Buddhism is wide like most major religions, and runs a gamut from very religious to 'not'. There is a tenet that allows for belief in supernatural gods as a kind of temporary understanding, perhaps similar to a child who needs an imaginary friend.

That seems like a philosophical stance worth discussion, and might come back to sacrifice vs benefit.
 
Three kinds of Buddhists and a fourth.

I said that in my reading of Buddhism from Buddhist enthusiasts in the web I have the impression among other impressions, that they or some of them make the assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion.

Of course they don't say it verbatim that way, but in so many words, as we would say in effect.

This does not sit well from the reactions here with the Buddhists participating in the thread -- again it seems to me.

In which case they mean then that Buddhism is not a scientific religion, in other words or in effect Buddhism is unscientific or non-scientific, i.e., all the way from being irrelevant to science to being contradictory to science?

Just being funny, please; so don't feel so annoyed. Anyway, there is often truth in humor, yes?


The way I am seeing it now from reading the posts in this thread from participants, the Buddhists in this thread are what I might call, first to use a term introduced by one poster here, philosophic Buddhists; then there are religious Buddhists not in this thread but outside -- and these run the risk of missing the genuine Buddhism as preached by the Gautama, according to our Buddhists here like Ryokan and Dancing David.

What is the third kind of Buddhists? What about the scientific Buddhists, which I seem to meet in my reading in the web of writings from Buddhist enthusiasts extolling the scientific grounds of Buddhism.

But there is a fourth kind of Buddhists, also I may presume are participating in this thread, the skeptical sort.

Sad to say for myself, I want to meet with skeptics who will do skeptical criticism of Buddhism; but the skeptical Buddhists I am meeting here are uniformly singing hosannas to Buddhism, while I being of a more demanding mind want to hear from them observations of how Buddhism has aspects or elements which at least hint of the, what? how about the irrational?


In regard to my understanding of the supernatural, I have to look up a good glossary of skeptics terms to find out whether my understanding coincides with that of the most recognized skeptics.

What is my understanding of the supernatural? By the supernatural I mean any entity that is not subject to the laws of nature as nature can be observed with our senses, or discerned from dependable reason, that depended upon namely by scientists.

I have to consult however a good glossary of skeptics terms, and I will report back here.


Yrreg
 
And what are the sources you use and who wrote them, it would appear that you can't read the titles and type them into the computer, are you afraid?

Do you just study the sources that agree with your beliefs.

I am calling you out, an un-buddhist trait, what are your sources,
give citations and quote, do tell us where you get the wealth of misinformation you spout so readily.

I believe that you are a poseur, a religous zealot posing in the guise of a sceptic, you claim to be a sceptic but you act like a fundamentalist of some sort.

Prove me wrong, and I will rejoice in my learning!

What are your sources, who wrote them, when were they published, give us quotes and authors.

Show us!

All you did was post one citation of your mistaken beliefs about budhhism, rather poor defense of your mistaken beliefs.

I would say that so far you have a rate of one citation per 500 assertions.

So I will ask one pertinet question;

Which I assume that you are incapable of answering:

What proof do you have that the eightfold path is predated by other teachers than the named buddha, Sidartha Gautama Shakyamuni?

You are a poseur yyreg, you can't provide evidence because it is just the deluded product of you ego.

You are not a sceptic, you are some sort of fundamentalist.

I give you one more chance, but from the past track record it is apparent to me you are no sceptic, you are a died in the wool believer of the first water and a fundamentalist to boot. What joy you must get telling your other findie friends how you have challenged the teachings of the buddha and found them wanting, I am sure that it feeds your ego to see the rapt faces of the children in your sunday school class as you tell them that "I HAVE THE ONE TRUE PATH!".

J'accuse: you are no sceptic.
J'accuse: you are a poseur>
J'accuse: you have less comprehension than a good Turing Program.
J'accuse: Your father was a hamster and your mother smelled of elder berry!
 
Sad to say for myself, I want to meet with skeptics who will do skeptical criticism of Buddhism; but the skeptical Buddhists I am meeting here are uniformly singing hosannas to Buddhism, while I being of a more demanding mind want to hear from them observations of how Buddhism has aspects or elements which at least hint of the, what? how about the irrational?


Yrreg


If you were capable of using the Internet you could have already googled
Mahayana and Magic

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=mahayana+magic&btnG=Google+Search

or perhaps Tantric Buddhism

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=tantric+buddhism&btnG=Search


or Red tibetan buddhism

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=tibetan+buddhism+"red"&btnG=Search

or Buddhism and miracles

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=buddhism+miracles&btnG=Search

or buddhism and supernatural

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=supernatural+buddhism&btnG=Search

But I feel that the only way you can think for yourself is if others do it for you , have at it tiger!

These are areas that people after the death of the buddha went and made upu, just like all the stuff you make up.
 
Ah yes the Lazer YoYO, it is up there with the butterfly cave and the more recent one of the dog 'Waiting for You". Engrish maybe rude but it makes me laugh.

Do you have any good vegetarian recipres or pictures of kittens?
;)
 
Buddhism the religion and the Buddhism the philosophy is an disingenuous distinction. The way I see it, when someone calls himself by another man's name, like calling oneself Buddhist or Randian, there is already the element of religion in the worship of a human who has some speculated insight into life and knowledge not derived from the senses and logic, but from meditation and similar esoteric ways and means, like flash of enlightenment or revelation.

True. The religious/philosophical distinction is a red herring.

There is no reason why philosophies are or should be exempt from skeptical inquiry.

If a Kantian, for example, says that matter only changes when one monad changes another monad's internal state by means of its vis activa, it's reasonable to ask if these concepts really have any actual meaning with respect to what I laughingly call the real world, or if it just reduces to mysticism or intellectual masturbation, or maybe something else, such as metaphor or myth, which can be valuable without being strictly accurate.

Same thing with Buddhism. There are all sorts of concepts, usually with jargon words, that merit looking into. Karma, Dharma, enlightenment, Mind, and so forth and so on, as well as claimed interrelationships.

It's also quite reasonable to have skeptical inquiry in another sense into Buddhism, its effectiveness when implemented in and by a person. Even if something lacks a scientific basis, the use of it can have an effect. "Good golly Miss Molly, you sure like to ball" is not a scientific statement about human metabolism, but a hypothetical claim such as that people lose weight faster when they do aerobics while listening to Little Richard.

Same thing with Buddhism. There are all sorts of practices that are claimed to result in something-or-other. It's possible to examine them and see if they do at a rate better than can be explained by chance. It's one thing to say that you want to eliminate suffering, but when I had pancreatitis, they gave me morphine, which at least took the edge off.

If this weren't enough, I do get the impression that Buddhism gets an uncritical free ride amongst intellectuals.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom