How Buddhism could be pseudoscience and packed with supernaturalism.
Ryokan_#99 said:
Originally Posted by yrreg :
Buddhism also a pseudoscience and is Buddhism also founded upon supernaturalism? I tend to suspect that there are elements of both in Buddhism.
What pseudoscience is there in Buddhism? What is the supernatural elements of Buddhism?
I'm a Buddhist, and I do not engage in pseudoscience, and I do not believe in the supernatural.
The complete quotation from me is the following:
Is Buddhism also a pseudoscience and is Buddhism also founded upon supernaturalism? I tend to suspect that there are elements of both in Buddhism. -- Yrreg in post #97
Ryokan missed the first word of the quotation,
Is; but it's all right, nothing disastrous to my thought.
Why do I suspect that Buddhism is a pseudoscience? Because from my reading about Buddhism from Buddhist enthusiasts I have come across their assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion. What is the experience of others who read accounts of Buddhism published in the web by Buddhist enthusiasts? have you come across such an assertion?
I can't find anything scientific in Buddhism, understanding scientific as referring to science in 2005. So, I think Buddhist enthusiasts who tell us that Buddhism is a scientific religion is making of Buddhism a pseudoscience.
Of course Buddhists here might ask me to produce instances in the web, of such an assertion that Buddhism is a scientific religion from Buddhist enthusiasts; in which event I have to back off.
If they have never come across such an assertion, and I am not inclined to invest time and labor to look up such instances in the web; then I will just take back that statement that I encountered such an assertion in my reading about Buddhism in the web from Buddhist enthusiasts.
Let me however explain why I can't see anything scientific in Buddhism.
First, because it is a system of thought and behavior founded some 2500 years back in time, and there was then no such thing as science as we know it today. Is there a word in ancient Buddhist texts synonymous to science as we know science today?
Second, examining the four noble truths and the eight noble paths which are common to all Buddhists, I cannot see any science in them either. Here are the four noble truths and the eight noble paths of Buddhism:
From Columbia Encyclopedia:
Basic Beliefs and Practices [of Buddhism]
The basic doctrines of early Buddhism, which remain common to all Buddhism, include the "four noble truths": existence is suffering (dukhka); suffering has a cause, namely craving and attachment (trishna); there is a cessation of suffering, which is nirvana; and there is a path to the cessation of suffering, the "eightfold path" of right views, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration.
The way I see these truths and paths of Buddhism, they are ideas and counsels or even injunctions which I can't seriously call scientific, but moralistic and spiritualistic.
"Existence is suffering," that is not a scientific statement; maybe the following is a scientific statement: "Human existence is life."
Suffering is a moralistic concept, the scientific concept is pain: physical, emotional, or mental pain. Desire or "craving and attachment" is not the cause of suffering, frustration is the cause of suffering. Nirvana is not the cessation of suffering or pain; it's not scientific, what is scientific is anesthetics.
Let's not continue in this analysis for science in the four noble truths, because the concepts come from 2500 years back and they belong to a world still bereft of what we know as psychology today -- even though psychology is supposed to be a soft science as compared to physics and chemistry and biology, yet it is incomparably more scientific than the world pictured in the four noble truths. The four noble truths are purely moralistic and spiritualistic concepts, nothing scientific in them.
As regards the eight noble paths, here is where I can see the supernaturalism in Buddhism. How is that? Because what is right and what is wrong as observed among diverse peoples are what we call ethical prescriptions and proscriptions.
From a naturalistic examination they differ from people to people and change with the times, from considerations of social necessity, practicality, and concession to the liberty of individual person. In pre-scientific and pre-technological societies ethical prescriptions and proscriptions are also dictated by superstitious fears of unknown agents.
I can see that in the eight noble paths of Buddhism there is the unspoken but clearly discernible premise that these injunctions are not derived from human formulation, not from as I said considerations of social necessity and practicality, but from an agent above and beyond man's mind and heart.
Maybe the Buddhists here can tell me who or what is the author or cause or origin of these noble right paths? Perhaps they will say that it’s Gautama, the Buddha himself; but the alleged founder is believed to have told his disciples not to take him seriously, instead to use their own reason to find out for themselves what is true, implicitly what is right also.
No, Buddha to Buddha himself and to his disciples was just like any human, subject to errors and imperfections; so those injunctions about what is right could not have come from him unless he and his disciples would admit that they are not exactly flawless, not warranted to be completely trustworthy as the right paths to what is right.
The Buddhists here might tell me that these right paths have always been there in the cosmic universe, just as the cycle of rebirths for humans has always been there since from eternity but of course until all mankind reaches Nirvana.
But there is a big difficulty in this construct, namely, we know now that mankind has not been in the cosmos except only in this late late split second of the present time in cosmic history. Even ancient thinkers not into esoteric speculations know that man has not been in the cosmos since from whenever in distant past the cosmos started if ever it had a beginning.
However, granting but not conceding that human existence has been present from the very foundation of the cosmos that is the physical universe, and all Buddhists believe in the eternal cycle of rebirths for each individual (I don’t know for a certainty about Ryokan, because someone here says that Ryokan is a philosophic Buddhist and not a religious Buddhist) until he reaches Nirvana, by adhering to the four noble truths and practicing the eight noble paths; my question is who or what is operating this system or rebirths and determining who among humans have already filled up his quota of right thoughts and activities as to merit entrance to or arrival in Nirvana.
Whoever or whatever is keeping records and checking them twice must be above the cosmos and be in charge of it; and that I would consider to be a supernatural aspect of Buddhism.
The Buddhists here will tell me that on the contrary there is no need to postulate an agent above nature in charge of the cycle of rebirths and keeping records of who is still unfit for Nirvana, and who is ripe and thereby to be liberated from the cycle of rebirths; because recurring rebirths and the final transit to Nirvana are all parts and parcels of the whole system of a process which is the whole cosmos.
Now, that I cannot accept because I for one maintain that the scenario for that kind of a process cosmos does not account for what I will insist is the distinction between the physical order and the moral order; that kind of a scenario would mix the two orders into some kind of an amalgam. Let me explain.
The physical order is that of stars, planets, matter, energy, elements, molecules, while the moral order has to do with human persons bound by themselves and among themselves to do what is right in dealing with fellow human persons. Human persons can all disappear in a nuclear holocaust suddenly and quickly, or in time ultimately end up as an extinct species as other life species have ended up; but the physical universe would continue to go on and on without so much as any infinitely brief disruption in its course.
I think that is the supernatural in Buddhism, the mixture of the physical and the moral orders with the unspoken but clearly deductible superordinaton of the moral over the physical –- owing to the doctrine in brief that all universe will end up in Nirvana.
Summing up: Yes, I do suspect very seriously that first Buddhism has its facet of a pseudoscience, and second that Buddhism has elements of the supernatural.
Yrreg